Michigan quarterback Chad Henne and Penn State quarterback Anthony Morelli will face each other for the first time on the football field Saturday night at Beaver Stadium. But this will not be the first time they have competed.
As Pennsylvania high school stars, they competed for scholarships and later for playing time in the Big 33 All-Star Game. In a battle of East vs. West, Wyomissing's Henne always had the edge over Penn Hills' Morelli.
Everyone wanted Henne more than Morelli, including Penn State. Nittany Lions coaches made Henne their No. 1 quarterback target in the recruiting process and Morelli their second choice.
Coaches in the Big 33 liked Henne more, too. Harrisburg coach George Chaump, who served as Pennsylvania's coach in the Big 33 game in 2004, started Henne over Morelli. Henne played the first and third quarters and Morelli the second and fourth. Morelli posted better numbers, but when Pennsylvania needed a drive to win the game late in the fourth quarter, Henne was under center instead of Morelli.
Those events are ancient history as far as Morelli is concerned, and he said he has no special incentive going into the game.
"It's not me vs. Chad Henne," Morelli said. "It's me vs. the Michigan defense and Chad vs. the Penn State defense. I'm not looking at it as me vs. Chad. He's had a great career at Michigan. I'm just looking to go out there, have fun and win a football game."
Morelli was not the only one asked to recount the recruiting saga this week. Henne and Penn State coach Joe Paterno recalled Henne's controversial decision, too. Paterno maintains Henne gave Penn State a verbal commitment and then reneged on it. Henne's story differed: "It was Michigan number one and Penn State two."
When he was asked if the rumors of Paterno's retirement had an impact on his decision, he pulled no punches.
"I just felt a lot more comfortable here with [quarterbacks coach] Scot Loeffler and him developing me as a quarterback than [Penn State quarterbacks coach] Jay Paterno. I have nothing against them. I've always liked Penn State and enjoyed going up there. I just felt a lot more comfortable here."
Since 2004, their careers have taken divergent paths. Henne started for Michigan as a true freshman and is in his third year as a starter. He led Michigan to a 9-3 record and a share of the Big Ten championship in 2004, but he slumped last season along with the Wolverines, who fell to 7-5. Six Big Ten quarterbacks had better passer efficiency ratings than Henne last season.
But Henne has rediscovered his touch. In the first six games of the season, he has completed 62 percent of his passes for 1,304 yards with 13 touchdowns and four interceptions. Only Ohio State's Troy Smith has a better passer efficiency rating in the conference.
"Chad has made tremendous strides," Michigan receiver Steve Breaston said. "He has progressed every year. The game is slowing down for him. He's putting it all together. He has a great arm and he handles our offense well. He's doing a great job with it."
Morelli, meanwhile, sat on the bench behind established starters Zack Mills and Michael Robinson his first two seasons. He is in his first year as a starter and taking his lumps along the way. He is eighth in the Big Ten in passer efficiency rating.
"He just happened to walk into a situation where he could start right away," Morelli said. "He didn't have a Michael Robinson or a Zack Mills who had been established as the starter. If I walked into a situation like his I could have done that, too. But I waited my time and I'm happy the way things have worked out."
The question everyone was trying to figure out three years ago still lingers.
Who's better?
The principles in the matter have taken a stance of who cares?
And perhaps with good reason. Neither program has suffered as a result of Henne's decision to go to Michigan. Both teams have won a Big Ten championship. And both have aspirations of doing the same this season. Michigan, undefeated and highly ranked, has national championship hopes.
"I think Anthony competes against himself, first off," Penn State center A.Q. Shipley said. "With Anthony and Henne, there was a lot of hype and people tried to measure them against each other because they are both from Pennsylvania, were both great in high school and played in the Big 33 together. There was that pressure before and they probably each tried to outdo the other guy. Now, though, I know Anthony has moved on from that and is worried about playing his game more than competing against another quarterback."
Michigan's Chad Henne and Penn State's Anthony Morelli have passed for more than 1,000 yards this season.
HenneCategoryMorelli80Completions103129Attempts1841,103Passing Yards1,22462.0Comp. %56.08.55Yards/pass6.6513Touchdown passes64Interceptions5160.9Rating117.2
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.