Lando:

Granted PSU is a 17-point dog, its on the road, and they have no experience compared to Ohio St. But finish this sentence, Penn State can win, if ... (and no smart answers like the Buckeye's all get food poisoning!)

Ray Fittipaldo: Penn State can win if, it does not turn the ball over, forces two Ohio State turnovers and gets two big plays from the offense. Oh, and the special teams can't self-destruct like they have been.

rathskeller: I couldn't see the game this week on TV -- were there any further problems in the kicking game?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, there were many. Kevin Kelly missed three field goals. I believe they were from 30, 38 and 38 yards. The kickoff return team still struggles and the punt return unit had a long return by Derrick Williams negated by a block in the back. Other than that, the special teams are doing just fine.

ghostofzackmills: Ray -- its Zack Mills speaking to you from the grave ... why is Joe lining Morelli up in the slot? doesn't he know that unlike me, this kid is immobile and will not take a hit? and that the whole set is stupid and not fooling anyone?

Ray Fittipaldo: Well, correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think they ran that set last week against YSU. I view that as a sign of progress. I think the coaches are smart enough not to run the option again with Morelli, but they very well could split him out wide when Williams is at quarterback. I agree that it's not fooling anyone, but they want to keep the appearance that regular offensive personnel remains in the game.

mls233: Do you see the line starting to jell as a unit -- inexperience aside -- I guess what I mean is that 2003 unit looked like they had no ability to play with each other, regardless of experience levels.

Ray Fittipaldo: I think the offensive line is a pleasant surprise. As I wrote earlier in the week, the offense is completely different from what everyone thought it would be. Everyone assumed because of the strong stable of WRs and Morelli at QB that the passing game would lead this team. Well, the young offensive line, with four new starters, has done a good job of paving the way for the RBs. They'll get a stiff test this week against Ohio State, but yes, they appear to be gelling.

Advertise with us

ODB: Given the special teams problems you've mentioned, why does it seem that special teams have always been an afterthought to Joe? What is the philosophy? Va. Tech went from a nothing program to a nationally known one, largely because of their emphasis on special teams?

Ray Fittipaldo: I wouldn't say it's an afterthought. Joe just has a different approach than most coaches. Most programs today have a special teams coach who specializes in working with all specials teams units. Penn State does not have a special teams coach. Joe has one position coach handle the punt return, another coach the kickoff return, etc. Penn State has had good special teams units in the past. This year's team is severely lacking in that area, and Joe is taking some heat for it again. But don't think for a minute that he will go out and hire a special teams coach. He won't do that. He just doesn't believe there is a need for one.

Lando: Who stands out among those young lineman? Shipley? Cadogan?

Ray Fittipaldo: I would say Shipley has been the best of the bunch so far. I've been impressed with the leadership role has has taken as a sophomore, and Joe said this week that he is coming along well as the center, the anchor of that unit. Cadogan was expected to be a good player, but he has not particularly stood out to me. It's hard to evaluate linemen from the press box because I watch the ball on most plays. I can say this: Other than that bad clipping penalty in the Notre Dame game on Shipley, these guys have done a good job of remaining anonymous. That's good if you're an O-lineman.

CraigJ: Nice article about Derrick Williams -- given his lack of production, do you see him slipping into the realm of Eric McCoo/Austin Scott -- huge recruits that just fizzle?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: No. He has so much more talent than McCoo and he hasn't been injury-prone or a head case like Scott. I just think they need to find better ways of getting him in position to make big plays. I'm not necessarily of the opinion that it's from the tailback or quarterback position, but that seems to be what the coaches are thinking.

jamesp: This Lion team seems to be like that Springsteen song -- One Step Up and Two Steps back -- I expect that from a young team, though. But what areas are you seeing any consistent improvement?

Ray Fittipaldo: Other than the O-line, I think the secondary is coming along. The Ohio State game will be a good test for them, too, especially after what happened in the Notre Dame game. I think the running back situation is good with Hunt. The linebackers will be fine with time. I'd say the biggest concern is the passing game. They have to get that on track.

ghostofzackmills: what other dangers are lurking for the Lions in the Big 10, besides the obvious (Michigan)?

Ray Fittipaldo: Well, they miss Iowa this year and the Hawkeyes are top 15. They do have to go to Wisconsin, which is on the verge of the top 25, and Purdue, which is still undefeated. People should not assume that Penn State will beat everybody besides Ohio State and Michigan. After, the top three teams in the league it looks like there is a lot of parity.

Advertise with us

steelersPSU: Harder to play in -- Horseshoe, or Big House? (though in recent years for PSU, I guess its been both)

Ray Fittipaldo: From what Joe said this week, it's the Horseshoe. He had a veiled reference during his news conference that Ohio Stadium is loud unlike some other places that have a reputation for being loud. I think he was talking about Michigan, although I am not 100 percent sure. The fans are extremely loud at Ohio Stadium. But at Michigan, you have to deal with the officials, too. Lloyd Carr seems to have a spell over those guys once they enter his stadium.

stephen_scott: How do you see things playing out on Sat.? Ugly?

Ray Fittipaldo: It could get ugly. Penn State has to make some plays to even stay close in this game. If they don't make any plays, it's going to be a very, very long day. My prediction is 35-10, but it could be worse than that.

stephen_scott: Could it be better?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: It could be better if Ohio State plays a bad game. But honestly, for Penn State to win, it would take an extremely bad game on Ohio State's part and an extremely good game on Penn State's part. Like Joe said, 'do you have a prayer for St. Jude and hopeless causes or something?'

penn_towers: Ray: Who is emerging as the leader on the offensive side of the ball? Tony Hunt certainly does by example, but he's quiet as a field mouse. Is Morelli showing more leadership on the field?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think Morelli will do fine as a leader once he has some success. But I don't care how much you talk or pat people on the back, no one is going to follow you until you prove you can make some plays and win games. Believe me, Morelli will be fine once he makes a few plays. He has too much talent to fail.

stephen_scott: I heard that. That was actually pretty funny. Old man hasn't lost his wit.

Ray Fittipaldo: No, he's still as sharp as a tack. He said that to motivate his players as well, I am sure. He wants to create an us against the world mentality going into that game.

Advertise with us

Lando: "Too much talent to fail" -- not like Tony Sacca I hope!

Ray Fittipaldo: He is far more talented than Tony Sacca. Let's just hope he figures things out and the coaches put him in position to succeed.

ODB: See, its that kind of stuff that draws Joe heat. He's still sharp as a tack and has forgotten more about football than the rest of D-1 coaches will ever know. But that old stubbornness just kills him.

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know if it's stubbornness or not. He just does not believe there is a need for a special teams coach in college football. Based on the success Virginia Tech has enjoyed over the years, you have to wonder, though.

Lando: Speaking of that -- what has been the offensive play calling hierarchy this season, re: Galen & JayPa?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I assume it's the same as previous years. Galen Hall has last say-so, but Jay makes suggestions in the passing game.

Lando: Thanks for telling me this. This is very encouraging. What about the interior line on the other side of the ball? Anyone emerging in particular?

Ray Fittipaldo: The D-line is thin, but it seems to be performing fine. Jay Alford is a very good player and Ed Johnson seems to be back to where he was two years ago. Jim Shaw has been injured and Tim Shaw is getting used to his new position. After them, you have a lot of young guys like Maurice Evans and Jared Odrick who are getting their feet wet.

ODB: Do you think Jay is getting better? That guy got crucified for a number of years ...

Ray Fittipaldo: Jay received some positive publicity for the way Robinson played last year. And it was deserved. He needs to do a good job with Morelli, though. If Morelli never pans out, Jay will get the blame. That's how it works.

Advertise with us

stephen_scott: Tell me a little more about Wallace, if you can?

Ray Fittipaldo: Wallace is a true freshman who is playing on offense and defense. He is a WR/RB on offense and a DB on defense. He is an explosive athlete the coaches are looking to get on the field, including special teams. He has had some nice kick returns. He should continue to blossom before your eyes. Maybe he is one of the guys who can produce a big play this week against OSU.

Ray Fittipaldo: Guys, thanks for the great questions this week. Catch my Q&A tomorrow on the Post-Gazette web site. Same time, same place next week.