we_are: Is it me, or does D. Williams look a little unsteady out there. He's remarkably talented, but maybe its just my perception, but Norwood and Butler seem more consistent. Maybe he's still shaking off rust from the injury?

Ray Fittipaldo: You're not the first person to ask about Williams. He was electric last season. Every time he touched the ball, it seemed like he was capable of scoring a touchdown. I don't know if teams are more aware of him this season or what, but he has only one big play in the first two games. That was a touchdown catch versus Akron. He has not made anything happen in the open field yet. He only has six catches. Perhaps it's the way the coaches are using him this season. He is being lined up at quarterback some and it doesn't seem like they are intent on getting him the ball from his receiver position. Whatever the case, he needs to be a big-play threat in this offense, or it's going to be a long season for the Lions.

ddg119: Owing to the fact that there are NO JUMBOTRONS at Notre Dame Stadium, I missed what happened on the missed FG -- not that it mattered in the end -- but, was that a holder thing or did Kelly shank it? And if so, is this cause for concern after the Orange Bowl fiasco?

Ray Fittipaldo: It was a bad hold. The snap from Jay Alford was a little high, but Ganter should have been able to get it down. It was the third botched field goal attempt of the year. Ganter mishandled a snap from Alford against Akron and he tripped and fell on a fake attempt against the Zips. If he doesn't get himself straightened out soon, the coaches are going to have to make a change.

Advertise with us

mls233: Why the option? Why oh why?

Ray Fittipaldo: I was asking the same question Saturday. Joe Paterno defended Galen Hall's play call. He said Anthony Morelli only needed two yards for a first down and that he should have turned it up instead of pitching it. My argument is that Morelli should not be running the option in any circumstance. The guy has the best arm in college football and was playing well to that point. Why put him in a position where he is less than comfortable? Morelli was diplomatic after the game and took the blame for the fumble, but reading between the lines of his quote and his body language, he was miffed at the call as well. If you're going to run the ball there, why not Tony Hunt?

mountnittany: Who was the guy that backed up Morelli at the end? Not that I think there should be a QB controversy, I just don't know anything about him

Ray Fittipaldo: Darrly Clark is a redshirt freshman from Youngstown. He came in and played well, but there is no way there should be any quarterback controversy. Clark was playing in mop-up duty against Notre Dame's second and third stringers. Yes, it looks like he might be a player, but you don't play him in place of Morelli in any circumstance. There has been some ill-informed talk of a QB controversy. It's ridiculous to even write about at this point.

mountnittany: Who is starting at TE this year? PSU always seems to come up w/ a decent TE but I know nothing about the position this year

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: For now, the starting tight end is senior Kevin Darling. The starter was supposed to be senior Patrick Hall, but he is in Paterno's doghouse for unspecified reasons. Hall did not play in the first two games, but Paterno said he is doing some work with the first-team offense this week, so you might see him some Saturday against Youngstown State.

mountnittany: No I don't think there should be one either. I just didn't know anything about the kid. Is Devlin redshirting then?

Ray Fittipaldo: It appears as if Devlin is going to redshirt. He had mononucleosis during preseason camp and was not able to get many reps, so a redshirt is likely, yes.

mls233: What about the goofy set where Morelli lines up wide? Does Galen realize this isn't fooling anyone?

Ray Fittipaldo: They've done that in the past with Zack Mills. I guess they don't want to have the starting QB running off the field in a change of personnel, an obvious sign that a gadget play is going to be run. By lining him out wide, they keep their regular personnel on the field, which forces the defense to make an adjustment at the line.

Advertise with us

mountnittany: What about Austin Scott? Also a redshirt?

Ray Fittipaldo: It is looking more and more likely that Scott will redshirt. Paterno keeps hinting to that, but he has not come out and said it definitively. I guess he doesn't want to say for sure in case Hunt gets injured.

peachypaterno: Realizing the Youngstown St. is a 1-AA program, they're still pretty good. What do you know about them and what should Penn St. do so they don't end up being embarrassed like New Hampshire did to Syracuse this past weekend?

Ray Fittipaldo: Don't get caught up in how good Youngstown State is. Paterno made them out to be USC at his news conference this week, but the Penguins compete in Division I-AA. There is a reason their players are not playing at a higher level. Penn State should run them out of Beaver Stadium Saturday. I don't know the circumstances under which New Hampshire beat Northwestern (not Syracuse), but Northwestern was coming off an emotional win at Miami, Ohio in the first game without Randy Walker, the coach who died suddenly in the summer. Upsets happen, but don't expect one this week in State College, especially after the Lions got embarrassed at Notre Dame.

JasonD: Having read your nice reporting on P. Poz today, what is your opinion as to the "slow" start?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I did not cover the team last season, so it's hard for me to speak with authority on how we played last season. I saw him on TV a lot and he was dominant at times. He has not displayed that dominance so far. But it's early and there are other circumstances other than his knee. He is learning a new position and you read what Tim Shaw said about playing in the middle. It's a tougher position because of all the traffic and the added mental responsibilities. If the knee is healthy -- he says it is but we don't really know for sure -- I would expect Paul's play to pick up in the next few weeks, after he sheds the knee brace and once he gets more comfortable in his new position.

mountnittany: If Scott did redshirt who is the back behind Hunt?

Ray Fittipaldo: Probably Rodney Kinlaw. Kinlaw has some talent, but he has had some injury problems like Scott. Everyone ought to just pray that Hunt stays healthy the whole year.

mls233: But when MRob ran that, it really did keep you guessing. But not with an immobile QB like Morelli or Mills. Also, can Williams pass? Would he ever pass out of that set?

Ray Fittipaldo: I assume Williams can throw some. They tried to have him attempt a pass against Notre Dame, but he got creamed by a blindside defender. Here's an idea, line up Morelli at QB and let him win you the game with his arm.

Advertise with us

steelersPSU: Has Knowledge Timmons learned the rules of football sufficiently that a live ball should be fielded? I know the guy is a track star, but c'mon!

Ray Fittipaldo: That was one of the oddest plays I have seen. It appeared live and I am told on television replays that he stared at the ball on the ground. I can't say for sure what he was thinking because I have not spoken with Timmons since the game, but I would hope he knows the rules. My six-year old nephew knows enough to jump on that ball.

mls233: Yeah, but gadgets can work. Ask the Steelers ...

Ray Fittipaldo: No doubt. But you have to have the right personnel handling the ball. The Steelers don't run gadget plays with Roehtlisberger running down the line on an option play. They did it with Randle El, an experienced option quarterback who has a great arm.

we_are: What is the status on Mark Rubin?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Rubin is out for a few more weeks, I believe. He sustained an injury during camp. I don't know if he gets on the field much once he comes back, though. I think they like their secondary.

JasonD: I am of the opinion, that egregious mistakes aside, a young Penn State made some forward strides against a very talented, very experienced ND. Am I sane?

Ray Fittipaldo: No, you're not sane. The offensive line looked 100 percent better than it did against Akron. Morelli played well in my opinion against a top-five team on the road. The defense was exposed a little, but Brady Quinn is a great QB and will be a top-five pick in next year's NFL draft. Yes, there are reasons to be hopeful, but the Lions have to cut down on the mistakes or they're going to lose a lot more games.

mountnittany: Prediction for this week?

Ray Fittipaldo: 56-10 Penn State. It should be over at halftime.

Advertise with us

JasonD: You mean I am sane. Or I'm not insane. Or something!

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, you are sane, Jason. There is hope for the Nits.

lavar_11: can your 6 year old nephew also run the option?

Ray Fittipaldo: I project him as more of a dropback QB. He doesn't have the wheels.

Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for the questions this week. See you same time next week. It should be great with No. 1 Ohio State on the slate.