Steve Manuel & Phil Coale, Associated PressPenn State quarterback coach Jay Paterno was hired by his father, Joe. And Florida State offensive coordinator Jeff Bowden works for his father, Bobby.

By Chico Harlan, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. -- The road, the one that would later lead him to relentless verbal abuse, began in fourth grade, not that Jeff Bowden had a clue at the time. His gym teacher planned a dodgeball tournament and asked Bowden if he could coach one of the teams. And that's basically how it happened: Bowden learned that he made one heck of a coach, just like his father, Bobby.

More Coverage:

Advertise with us

Orange Bowl Insider: Butler stranded at sea

Cook: When it comes to character, Paterno easy choice

"We won the dodgeball championship," Jeff Bowden said. "I had the feeling then."

He grew older. He still loved coaching -- he became a football coach -- but not everybody loved him. In fact, some people hated him. In 2005, when he coached Florida State's offense, the Seminoles struggled to score and fans, fuming with disgust, blamed it on him. He was a coach like his dad, they said. But he was nothing like his dad.

He had been at Florida State since 1994, coaching wide receivers for the first few seasons, but then ascending into the offensive coordinator role when Mark Richt left to coach Georgia. College football observers didn't believe Jeff Bowden was quite ready for a coordinator job. Most coaches, excluding the few fast-rising prodigies of the industry, needed another decade of experience before landing such a responsibility. But Bobby Bowden, the head coach at Florida State since 1976, believed his son was ready and designed a loophole to avoid the school's nepotism policy. Jeff Bowden would report officially to defensive coordinator Mickey Andrews, not his father.

Advertise with us

People never forgot that in Tallahassee. They didn't see an act of love; they saw a plot of corruption. They didn't see a young coach; they saw a coach's son. Worse, Jeff offense's sputtered. The Seminoles' offense ranked first in Division I in 2000, Richt's final season. But during the regular season in '05, Florida State averaged fewer than 30 points per game, scoring only 14 against Clemson and seven against Florida. Radio shows swung at Jeff, pinata-style. One regional newspaper published a column headlined "Step down, son -- at least for your old man." At the nadir of Florida State's season, after a loss to Florida, somebody living in an apartment across from the Seminoles' football complex hung a massive sign across the balcony.

"Joe and i have talked about this in the past, by oh, my goodness, as soon as I hired my son here, what was the first thing that jumped out? Nepotism."

-- Bobby Bowden, Florida State coach

It read, "Fire Jeff Bowden."

The young coach faced options, none promising. He could defend himself and risk issuing more ammunition against him. He could remain quiet and pretend the criticism never reached him. He could seek advice.

Advertise with us

Others, too, had faced his situation. The things you love often pass through genes, which explains why many of the greatest coaches -- Bowden, Joe Paterno Lou Holtz, Steve Spurrier -- raised sons who followed them straight into their shadows. Jay Paterno, Penn State's quarterback coach and the son of head coach Joe Paterno, grew into his job the same year Jeff Bowden was named coordinator. Jay Paterno, too, was blindsided by criticism. His quarterbacks often struggled, and fans wondered if he had gotten his job too soon -- and worse, for the wrong reasons.

"He's going through the same thing I went through last year," said Jay Paterno, whose development of Michael Robinson in 2005 subdued many of the loudest attacks. "I can empathize with him."

"Inside, [hearing the criticism] really does bother you," said Jay Paterno's mother, Sue.

Coaches, when viewed by the fans and media members who appraise them, are still subject to the vagaries of uncertainty. After all, how does one determine the worth of a coach, especially in football, where all components of a team stack together like Jenga blocks, each piece dependent on the next? One can ask for quotes from players who have worked for him. One can measure his hours on the job, or count the pro players he has developed. But mostly, the value of individual coaches, especially assistants, is open to liberal interpretation. Which is why one strike -- bloodlines, for instance -- can be so crippling.

"Bottom line," Jeff Bowden said. "There are always going to be people who don't like you."

Advertise with us

Standing near a fence Friday morning before practice, Jeff spoke with a reporter, performing the one part of his job he least likes -- talking about why he has it in the first place.

"Why would I pay attention to it?" he asked, referring to the criticism.

Because it's unavoidable, he was told. It's on TV. It's on the radio. It touches family members.

"You're leading me down some places I don't want to get into," he said. "This is the stuff y'all write. I don't pay attention to it. Listen, you've got to love what you do. It doesn't matter what it is. And I love this. If you're going to be in this type of profession, it's like politics: you're out there to take the good with the bad.

"It's human nature you have to find a reason why something is going good or something is going bad. Doesn't matter what it is -- stock market, football, politics, war. It's 'why?' So you've got to answer that why."

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, those closest to him have tried to explain why he's not to blame. Bobby Bowden and Joe Paterno, at their back-to-back news conferences Thursday leading to the Orange Bowl Tuesday, complimented the job performances of each son. Both head coaches wished to diffuse criticism. Both, though, lent critics another means for highlighting an agenda.

"Joe and I have talked about this in the past, by oh, my goodness, as soon as I hired my son here, what was the first thing that jumped out? Nepotism," Bobby Bowden said. "And everything comes back to that. I really didn't expect it that much. Nothing was really said about Jeff until I made him offensive coordinator."

"I know my kid is a good coach," Joe Paterno said, who was later asked about his hopes for Jay's career.

"Well, I would hope that whatever happens when I get out of it, there will be somebody on staff that would get the job. I don't mean necessarily Jay, because I think there are other people with more experience, but I would hope if he wants to stay that would be available to him."

Neither Bowden nor Paterno pushed their sons into coaching. But once the sons began their careers, the fathers helped. Joe Paterno's connections allowed Jay his first position, a graduate assistant spot with Virginia in 1990. Jeff Bowden, after a stop at Salem College from 1983-85, worked the next season as a grad assistant at Florida State.

Advertise with us

And that's how the road continued, leading him to several smaller stops, then back to Florida State in less than a decade later. The father loved his son and wanted to help him. But all along, that might have been the problem.

"Boy, it is tough," Bobby Bowden said, asked about the son working for him. "It might even be unfair."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.