FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. -- First, he had belief without reason. This was long before he had the great games, or a cameo appearance on "ESPN GameDay," or a coach pitching him for the Heisman Trophy. This was before Michael Robinson had the title he always wanted -- Penn State's quarterback. This was before he had teammates who gravitated to him, knowing he was The Man, and before the Big Ten championship, and before the NFL scouts called.
Even when Robinson had none of this, he clung to belief.
"A fourth-and-15," Robinson remembered yesterday, at a news conference leading to the Nittany Lions' Tuesday Orange Bowl against Florida State. "The odds were against us."
No, the odds were against him. On Sept. 24, Robinson's desperate career collided with a desperate moment. The scoreboard read like a premature eulogy to Penn State's season. His team trailed Northwestern by 2. One minute, 39 seconds remained. On the previous play, Robinson's screen pass led to a quick pile-up and a 2-yard loss, and Penn State was moving backward, right along with its hopes for the year.
Fourth-and-15.
"I don't know why," Robinson said, "but there was no doubt we were going to get it."
Failure on that play, and the walls of hope would crash. One incomplete pass, it would be cinched: Robinson's senior year -- his first as a starting quarterback -- would never develop into what he wanted.
He knew what he wanted because he'd thought about it for so long. He thought about it until he admitted that, yeah, falling short of greatness would have forced him "to question a lot of things about faith."
Following his redshirt freshman season, he debated a transfer, but stayed at Penn State mostly on the faith that things would improve. He sat one day before a table of business cards -- coaches across the country wanted him, including those at Virginia Tech, in his home state -- but Robinson decided he'd already chosen his path, Lord help him.
So he spent two more seasons waiting, watching Zack Mills start, and often struggle, at quarterback. Robinson played but elsewhere in the backfield or at wideout. He was a leader being led, and he questioned what to do.
At times, he sought perspective. He thought about his old high school teammate, Craig Lobrano, a blue-chip recruit who'd died of heat stroke before he could become anything more. "Whenever I thought about giving up, whenever I thought about giving in, I thought about Craig," Robinson said. "Craig would have loved to have been in my situation."
He also spoke often to his roommate and best friend, Matthew Rice. The two had met as freshmen at a frat party. They didn't know one another as teammates because the Lions had not opened summer practice. Both danced with girls, and, when Rice caught grief from another guy, Robinson rushed over to defend him. Just happened, he couldn't explain why, but he felt it the right thing to do.
And then, after waiting, it was the summer of 2005; Robinson was 22 and unproven at quarterback. He threw for 90 yards in the first game. He threw interceptions in the next two. Nasty e-mails, sometimes toned with racial hate, filled his inbox. During the first half against Northwestern, he tossed three interceptions and lost one fumble. "If you turn the ball over one more time," Paterno told him at halftime, "I'll kill you."
Points, he knew, would counteract Paterno's wrath. Robinson longed to learn what a victory would do for his team. Defeat Northwestern, and the Lions would waltz into the thickest part of their conference schedule with a 4-0 record; he was sure of that much. Of course, he knew nothing of the specifics: that he'd later grow into Penn State's best quarterback in a decade. That he'd shed his turnover problem and refine his accuracy. That he would lead Penn State into the red zone on all seven two-minute drives, or convert all six fourth-down plays, or finish with 16 touchdowns, 2,097 passing yards and a Big Ten offensive player of the year award.
"He stepped in the huddle and people believed in him," Penn State offensive coordinator Galen Hall said.
"The kind of guy who comes around every 20 years," quarterback coach Jay Paterno said.
"He makes plays that are out of this world," Bobby Bowden said.
Robinson, facing that fourth-and-15, had planted a labyrinth of improbabilities between himself and the praise that would come. The Nittany Lions needed 85 yards for a touchdown, maybe 55, minimum, for a go-ahead field goal. He eyed Northwestern's defense and immediately liked his chances. The Wildcats' safeties backed up, guarding the deep passes.
Penn State's outside receivers, fast and explosive, commanded the safeties' attention, and only fractions of a second after receiving the snap, Robinson already knew what to do. His tight end, Isaac Smolko, pulled on a slight angle across the middle of the field, straight toward a spot where the linebackers parted. Robinson darted the pass low, whistling the ball through the arms that threatened to bat it down and end the game.
Smolko crouched low, snagged the pass, and officials signaled for a first down.
"For some reason, it seemed like practice," Robinson said.
Everything afterward was a parade. Robinson took his team the final 65 yards -- ending with a 36-yard touchdown pass to Derrick Williams. Then, he took his team through the Big Ten schedule, down the field in the final minutes against Michigan, down the field again and again against Illinois, down the field in the fourth quarter against Michigan State.
Following the defeat of the Spartans, Robinson led his team again: into Rec Hall, where he held the conference title trophy in his left arm, and where hundreds of students had gathered to roar for what they saw.
"But if we'd lost that game," Robinson said of the Northwestern contest, "who knows what would have happened?"
In 2004, Penn State's defense had become one of the best in the country, never allowing more than 21 points. The offense never reciprocated. Even entering the game against the Wildcats, defensive players wondered if 2005 would drag them through more of the same frustrations.
"Tamba Hali came up to me [after Northwestern] and said, 'Man, I really believe. I really believe we're gonna have a great season,' " Robinson recalled. "They felt all we needed was an offense ... After that Northwestern game, a lot of people looked at me in a totally different way. I'm telling you, that was when we got around the corner."
That day, as Robinson walked toward the locker room, Jay Paterno put his arm around him, still smiling, and said the words he'd long waited to hear.
"Hey," Paterno told Robinson. "You're a quarterback now."
Matt Freed, Post-Gazette
Penn State quarterback Michael Robinson tries to get around Wisconsin's Joe Stellmacher.
Click photo for larger image.
More Coverage:
Orange Bowl Insider: Two friends, two coaches and the big game
Cook: It's not Garbo, it's Galen Hall
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.