Confusion displaced certainty this week. Consternation yielded to celebration. Before Saturday, Florida State's football season fit tidily into one condemning definition: The three-month escapade of injuries, controversy and losing prompted folks in Tallahassee, Fla., to mourn the decline of their favored program, one that previously seemed immune to losing streaks.

But Saturday, one game muddled the easy definition for Florida State's season. The reeling Seminoles defeated 14-point favorite Virginia Tech in the Atlantic Coast Conference championship game, and the Florida State funeral procession took a detour. Florida State (8-4), with that one upset, earned a BCS appearance and a Jan. 3 Orange Bowl matchup against Penn State. And, it capped one of its most tumultuous regular seasons with a victory that left fans, players and coaches wondering what to make of everything that came beforehand.

"I can't even hardly believe what's happening," Florida State coach Bobby Bowden said.

Florida State can use the next month of preparation to sort through the mixed messages. Does one victory -- an important one, to be sure -- overwrite the concern wrought by a three-game losing streak and an accelerated fall from the national rankings? Or, does that one victory count as a fluke, an interruption in the downward course some suggest the Seminoles have now charted for five years?

Advertise with us

Criticism advances like a wave. It surges, it crests and then, always, it subsides -- sometimes because of wins, sometimes because of changes, sometimes because of surrender. But criticism at Florida State roars at a different volume, because the most recent generation of success has lifted expectations into the stratosphere. Football season in Tallahassee ends in one of two ways: Perfection. Or disappointment.

Between 1987 and 2000, Bowden never finished a season with more than two losses. His winning percentage in the '90s (109-13-1) almost scraped 90 percent. But this season -- and to an extent, several before this -- has been different. In the past five years, counting this one, Bowden's teams have lost four, five, three, three and four games.

Problems flooded Florida State even before the 2005 season began. The school battled the NCAA over the decency of its nickname, which was originally cited as "hostile and abusive." Two crystal national championship trophies were stolen from a locked case outside Bowden's office. (They were recovered last month.) Wyatt Sexton, the starting quarterback for seven games in 2004, was diagnosed with Lyme disease during the summer and forced to miss the season.

Though the Seminoles raced off toward a 5-0 start -- stimulating whispers of another national title run -- what happened in November planted the season firmly into tailspin mode. They lost three consecutive games for the first time since 1983. After the last of those losses, a banner reading "Fire Jeff Bowden" -- Bobby's son and often-assailed offensive coordinator -- was hung near Doak Campbell Stadium.

Before the game against Virginia Tech, Bowden passionately defended his son. Friday night when he privately addressed his team, Bowden spoke with more anger and determination than any of his players had ever seen, some said after the upset.

Advertise with us

"After us losing our last three ballgames and falling from grace and falling out of the polls," Bowden said, "and then the next night, here we are going to a BCS bowl, and about 20 teams ahead of us, they aren't going to get to a BCS bowl -- I feel very happy for us. Naturally, I feel very lucky about it."

Phil Coale, Associated Press

Florida State coach Bobby Bowden talks with quarterback Drew Weatherford in the third quarter of the ACC championship game against Virginia Tech Saturday at Alltel Stadium in Jacksonville, Fla.

Click photo for larger image.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.