Sports Illustrated

Surprising Penn State earned a Sports Illustrated cover for the first time since 1999.

Click photo for larger image.

Everyone has holiday shopping lists to go through. But here's our top-five lists on surprises and disappointments as college football's regular season nears an end.

Advertise with us

Top five surprises

1. Penn State: Out of modest preseason goals (winning season, bowl bid), the Nittany Lions (10-1) silenced Joe Pa's critics with a Big Ten title and were one play away from a perfect season. This after going 1-13 in the Big Ten against anyone other than Indiana the last two years.

It's great to see such good things happen to players and coaches who persevere.

2. Central Florida: From a 17-game losing streak to a stunning 8-3 finish, Golden Knights coach George O'Leary is the 21st century's Bill Snyder. Now the fun part comes as the Sunshine State's Big Three (Florida, Florida State and Miami) duck scheduling UCF.

3. Notre Dame: Did Charlie Weis and Co. really beat anybody? Only Michigan, Navy and mediocre BYU had winning records among ND's victims. Nonetheless, losses to most of these same foes brought down Bob Davie and Tyrone Willingham.

Advertise with us

The BCS bowl should bring some evidence of where the Irish (9-2) really stand.

4. TCU: The Horned Frogs (10-1) won a share of their third different conference title (WAC, Conference USA and now Mountain West) in the last five years -- a record unlikely to ever be matched.

TCU coach Gary Patterson does it the old-fashioned way. No, the Frogs don't always look pretty, but no team plays closer to the edge of its talent than this group.

5. Oregon: The Ducks had quacked their way to a mediocre 20-17 mark from 2002-04. A 10-1 season was achieved despite star quarterback Kellen Clemens going down Oct. 22. If only Mike Bellotti and Co. could get a mulligan for the second half of that 45-13 loss to USC.

Top five disappointments

Advertise with us

1. Tennessee: Forget the preseason No. 3 ranking. Remember that the Vols were 3-1 and eighth in the nation playing Georgia Oct. 8. That loss triggered the 2-5 collapse and general sense of chaos that left UT home for the holidays for the first time since 1988. Now Phillip Fulmer has axed three assistants. But Vols fans are sadly mistaken if they believe all UT needs is some more discipline. Tennessee is simply a program on the decline.

2. Purdue: Preseason Big Ten favorites, Purdue also sputtered to a 5-6 finish -- despite not playing Ohio State or Michigan. The sense of gloom and underachievement that has hovered over this program for a generation may now be getting to coach Joe Tiller and Co.

3. Syracuse: Granted dismal recruiting in the final years of Paul Pasqualoni didn't exactly hand new Orange coach Greg Robinson a stacked hand. But the first 10-loss season in 110 years of SU football? And in a lousy league to boot. Syracuse will need a lot of help to get back to respectability.

4. Texas A&M: Two losing seasons and a 16-19 mark in the last three years is hardly what Aggie fans had in mind when they emptied their bank accounts for Dennis Franchione three years ago. Some young talent showed in last Friday's tough 40-29 loss to Texas. But didn't we hear the same thing about A&M last year?

5. Oklahoma: Bob Stoops held it together enough for the Sooners to finish 7-4. But that's more a reflection on how weak the Big 12 is than how good OU, ranked seventh in the nation in the preseason, is.

Advertise with us

Top five surprising players

1. Penn State quarterback Michael Robinson: The heart and soul of Penn State's turnaround. Shuffled all over the field earlier in his career, the senior settled in at quarterback and made the Lions winners again through talent and leadership.

2. Louisville defensive end Elvis Dumervil: A 6-0, 256-pound pass-rushing machine, Dumervil led the nation with 20 sacks leaving NFL scouts drooling.

3. UCLA quarterback Drew Olson: Wasn't he supposed to be replaced by BYU transfer Ben Olson? Instead the older Olson leads the nation in passing efficiency with a staggering 30 touchdowns vs. three interceptions. He could add to his legacy in Saturday's showdown with No. 1 USC.

4. Washington State running back Jerome Harrison: The former JUCO-star went from just another 900-yard rusher to leading the nation 1,900 yards rushing. Now watch stupid NFL scouts downgrade his 5-9, 192-pound body.

Advertise with us

5. Vanderbilt wide receiver Earl Bennett: The freshman was sensational with 79 catches, but none will be remembered more fondly than his game-winner vs. Tennessee, Vandy's first win over the Vols since 1982.

Top five to watch next season

1. Notre Dame quarterback Brady Quinn: If Notre Dame is really good, this guy wins next year's Heisman easy. Owner of multiple Irish passing records, he's already ND's best quarterback since Joe Montana.

2. Northwestern running back Tyrell Sutton: It's hard to figure what kind of encore the freshman Sutton has in store as he stands fifth in the nation with 1,390 yards rushing and eighth with 18 touchdowns. We can't wait to find out.

3. N.C. State defensive end Mario Williams: This 6-7, 285-pound physical specimen was fourth in the nation with 13 sacks. Let's hope the lure of the NFL doesn't cost the Wolfpack his senior season.

Advertise with us

4. Indiana wide receiver James Hardy: The gifted 6-7, 185-pound freshman is now off to play hoops for Mike Davis' Hoosiers after snaring 61 balls for 10 touchdowns. This guy is a future NFL star.

5. Central Michigan defensive end Dan Bazuin: The 6-3, 257-pound junior led the nation with 28 tackles for loss and was fourth with five forced fumbles in helping the Chippewas to a 6-5 finish, UCM's first winning season since 1998.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.