MRob4Heisman:
Chico, it looks like an Orange Bowl date with Va Tech, what do you think of the matchup of Mrob against the Vtech defense and Vick vs the PSU D? Who do you like in this matchup?
Chico Harlan: Well, it's a bit premature to assume the PSU-VaTech match-up, but I'll oblige your hypothetical here. In this game, were it to happen, I'd like both of the defenses. Though MRob and MVick are both pretty impressive talents, I would imagine this one taking the shape of a low-scoring game. Especially following that 1 1/2-month lay-off, the defenses will automatically have an advantage. Plus, VT has a fairly exceptional secondary... good speed... the kind of dominance that has shown itself all season. (Well, except for one game.) Penn State fares well against traditional offenses, and they've shown the ability to stop even mobile quarterbacks. Granted, Penn State has yet to see a QB the caliber of Vick, but I'd like the chances of the Lions' D to handle him.
kevlar: Chico, superb work covering Penn State the last so many years. Did you happen to see the All Big Ten team selections today and are there any surprises/disappointments in your mind?
Chico Harlan: Thanks, first, for the kind words. I did have a chance to take a look at the teams, and I can come up with at least one surprise. Calvin Lowry was named to the first team... (no, not as a punt returner.) But heck, maybe I owe him a Christmas card. I (and others) have been on him so hard this season for his returning deficiencies that I think we forget he's developed into a very reliable safety. This award really hammered it home for me. I never would have expected it. But good for him, I supposed. He deserves credit for a very solid season.
Lion_in_Buckeye_Country: Chico, Correct if I'm wrong but it seems to me that the loss to Michigan really didn't hurt Penn State, as least as of now. Even if they were undefeated, they still wouldn't be ranked any higher in the BCS than 3. Having said that, I can see a team passing them before it's all said and done.
Chico Harlan: Well, I tend to agree. A few people I've talked to swear PSU would be ahead of Texas were they still undefeated (meaning they'd beaten Michigan)... but I simply don't buy it. I think they'd still be No. 3 -- 11-0, and in the agonizing position of waiting for USC and/or Texas to lose. Here's my rationale for thinking that even an undefeated PSU team would be No. 3: generally, it takes a lot for a team in the top 2 to be dropped when continually winning. I don't think either Texas or USC has had enough close calls that they would have been bumped down in either the Harris or USA Today polls by an undefeated Penn State team. And yeah, I can see LSU jumped ahead of them w/in the next two weeks. I can also see USC losing (a longshot in itself) and remaining ahead of PSU.
jr2004: Chico, any chance that Alan Zemaitis and Tamba Hali are first round draft picks this year?
Chico Harlan: Yes, both have a chance, though of course those much-important combine workouts will probably have as much bearing on their NFL value as anything they've done this season. (Nonsense, I know.) I'd give Hali, for now, the better chance, especially because in some games this season he's proven downright unblockable. He doesn't fit into the perfect D-end role -- he doesn't have Courtney Brown's size, nor does he have Dwight Freeney's speed -- but he has a respectable combination of both. He could be a mid-first round guy if things break well for him. Zemaitis will have it a bit harder. I worry that he doesn't have the top-flight speed some want in a first-round corner. His technique is pretty sound, but I think he'll need a flashy 40 time to jump into the first or second round.
Dan: If PSU gets into the NC game, who do they match up better with, USC or Texas?
Chico Harlan: I don't think they match up well with either team. This is not meant as a slight to Penn State -- I have much admiration for the qualities that team has shown this season. But both Texas and USC are on another plane. Sorry, but Penn State hasn't faced a player anywhere near the level of Reggie Bush or Vince Young this season. Maroney? Calhoun? ... maybe Troy Smith? No way. Basically, what I'm saying is this: USC and Texas are undefeated for a reason -- they are college football's dominant teams. Penn State is exceptional, but not dominant. I'm not gonna say the Lions would have no chance in the Rose Bowl, but they would be serious, serious underdogs.
DrDon: Any thoughts on next year's (2006) team, especially at QB?
Chico Harlan: Yeah, Morelli will be the man, and I think he'll be in a great position. First, he'll be surrounded by one of the best receiving groups in school history. I don't think that's an overstatement -- he'll have Williams, Butler and Norwood, just in the top three. Throw in Sargeant or Bell, and that's a potent mix. He'll also be able to rely on Tony Hunt, who should be the same workhorse he was this season. That's an ideal situation for a young QB. The one thing that worries me is the O-line. It will lose four seniors, and perhaps Levi Brown if he bolts for the NFL. And Morelli obviously lacks MRob's mobility. To translate: He won't be able to hide the deficiencies of a poor O-line with his scramble. He'll need the line to be at least adequate if the PSU offense to gonna truly fire on all cylinders.
BPLion: Looking ahead to next year, with the depth at WR and the losses in the secondary, do you expect Justin King to play mostly at corner?
Chico Harlan: Yes, Justin King will be a cornerback next year. Penn State will desperately need him there, b/c it loses both Anwar Phillips and Zemaitis. That will be a young secondary next season, and King will be counted on to lead it.
CollinPSU: Hi Chico... this might be a bit off topic, but what kind of NFL future do you think M-Rob has?
Chico Harlan: Somebody will find a place for him. I see him as a wideout-running back hybrid, almost like an Eric Metcalf (to harken good memories among all you old Tecmo players)... Difference is, Robinson is a sturdy player -- as demonstrated by his hit on Minny's Brandon Owens. I like Robinson's combination of athleticism and balance. He won't be a QB -- he's simply too inaccurate, but he will be drafted somewhere between and third and sixth rounds, I feel. Not bad. He'll make the most of it.
doud: What are the chances of Levi brown staying another year and providing experience for the offensive line?
Chico Harlan: I'm not sure what his personal thoughts are on leaving, because I haven't had the chance to talk about it with him yet. Certainly he'd have reason to leave, at least for personal reasons. He's coming off an impressive season, and he has the size to play tackle in the NFL. But coaches will probably beg him to come back, knowing that they'll need his leadership for an O-line that, other than Brown, will be entirely inexperienced in 2006. If Brown departs, Penn State will be starting over -- replacing all five guys. That will be tough to overcome.
slr: Why do you think Penn State was able to rebound so well after last year's disappointing season?
Chico Harlan: You could write a novella about this, I'll give you a few quick reasons. - the believe of Penn State's senior captains, particularly Michael Robinson - the influx of speed at WR - the unlikely development of this year's offensive line - Robinson's ability, particularly in the second half of the season, to hang on to the football - a veteran defense that routinely reduced top-flight running backs into slouches - Kevin Kelly, reliable as a kicker - Tony Hunt, turning into a very powerful runner, somebody who could be counted on for 90-plus yards even against top defenses - this team's ability to execute in pressure situations, most notably on the final drive against N'Western
Duke: With the resurgence of PSU, I've noticed a positive trend in the number of 4+ star recruits at least verbally committing. Do you see this continuing? Should I go ahead and book my hotel in Miami?
Chico Harlan: Well, I'm always hesitant to draw too much of a correlation between winning and recruiting. After all, if winning attracted recruits by itself, how can you explain the class Penn State drew after its 4-7 season. That said, the winning can't hurt, and it might make it easier for PSU to seal the deal with top recruits. It's too early to evaluate this year's class, but the Lions already have some big names roped in. Their time now in the national spotlight will only keep that recruiting momentum going. As for your travel plans, don't assume too much just yet. Don't discount some sort of backroom deal sending Penn State to Tempe so it can play Notre Dame. I'm dead certain that the ABC execs wouldn't be complaining if they received such a match-up
hailtopitt: Why does the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette give Penn State such great coverage when the school is 3 hours away from Pittsburgh. I don't think you would find this anywhere else in the country. And please don't tell me about how many Penn alumni are in the Pittsburgh area.
Chico Harlan: Well, I was actually hoping the Post-Gazette would boycott Penn State this season, but this chat has changed my mind. When people complain about what we're covering, it generally shows there's interest in it:-) Oh, and did I mention that Pittsburgh has a lot of Penn State alums?
panther_fan: will Joe Pa coach next season if Penn State wins its bowl game?
Chico Harlan: Yes, he'll be back. He's not ready to leave coaching -- I think the simple truth is, he loves his family and he loves football, and he's afraid to give up coaching, which amounts to half of his very essence. I think he'll keep coaching so long as he's physically capable. My answer to this question, which I receive quite often, has changed drastically in the two seasons I've covered this team. I used to feel certain '05 would be his last season. Now, I think JoePa will coach 'til 2007 -- at the least. Possibly longer. He is the septuagenarian Energizer mascot of coaching.
Mrob4Heisman: Chico, will the Post-Gazette send you to the bowl to cover the game or will you have to watch it at home?
Chico Harlan: Yeah, I'll be going down there, probably arriving a week before the game starts. "Down" is the key word in the previous sentence. "Up" would mean the Motor City Bowl.
CollinPSU: Do you see Austin Scott leaving PSU or taking a redshirt? Also, I think that Lydell Mitchell may end up getting buried behind other wide receivers after a wasted year of eligibility
Chico Harlan: I don't see him redshirting next season. But I wouldn't rule out the possibility of a transfer. Last time I spoke to Scott, he sounded fairly miserable about the direction his career has taken. He wasn't outwardly complaining, but he sure as heck didn't rule out the idea of a transfer. If he wants carries -- and by extension, if he wants to somehow showcase himself for NFL scouts -- he needs to be a feature back. That will either require a Hunt injury or a new location. I'd bet on the latter.
RowdyRoddyPiper: Do you have any idea regarding the origins of the hideous song that is in the Penn State commercial played during Big 10 games? It truly stinks.
Chico Harlan: No, I wish I did. But I never watch the games on TV, so I'm not certain. But if another person in this forum sees this response, they are welcome to submit it to me, and I'll relay it back to everybody.
kenb: Mr. Harlan- given the loss of key seniors, especially on defense, how does next season look in light of a tougher schedule out of the Big 10?
Chico Harlan: It will be tougher. The start of the season is brutal in '06... away games against ND and OSU within the first four games. Considering Penn State will be extremely young and several key positions, that's a tough welcome. I think Penn State will certainly contend for a bowl, but I think the Lions will take a step back from the success this season. Maybe a 8-4 season, 7-5. 2007 will be their next really strong team, most likely.
BPLion: Chico, do you expect AQ Shipley to play on the OL next year?
Chico Harlan: I know the team really likes AQ as a defensive tackle, and for good reason... the guy is built like a bowling ball. But I think Penn State would be nuts to keep Shipley at defensive tackle, especially if Ed Johnson returns to the team. (And I suspect he will.) With Alford and Johnson in the middle at DT, Shipley would only be a back-up. And while depth is an important thing, starters at O-line should be held at a premium. Put Shipley at offensive guard, and that's at least one position Penn State won't have to worry about. The Lions are still undecided about what to do with him, but I think the smart money is on a return to offense.
CollinPSU: The talk of Poz leaving at after this season has been increasing, have you heard anything specifically?
Chico Harlan: He originally said he'd think about leaving, and days later, he basically withdrew those comments. As of right now, it looks like Poz will be back in '06.
cary_guy: What odds do you give PSU on going to the national championship bowl game? 100-1? 1,000-1?
Chico Harlan: I'm answering this question because you've set me up to actually portray myself as an optimist. I'll say 50-1.
dwetz4387: Chico, How would you evaluate the PSU punting game this year?
Chico Harlan: Inconsistent. Kapinos still has a booming leg, but he shanks way too many punts right now. He's slow getting the ball off, and it's only a matter of time before he has one blocked. When he see his average -- something a bit north of 40 -- that's an unusual amalgam of 26-yard shanks and 57-yard booms. Once he irons out the wrinkles in his game, Kapinos will be a strong punter.
Mrob4Heisman: DO you think Poz can beat Hawk for the LB award? Also who do you see as the better NFL player?
Chico Harlan: I haven't see Hawk enough to provide a fair evaluation, but a few experts I've spoken with swear the Poz is the more complete player. That said, I think the two players are neck-and-neck... and those postseason awards always seem to give a tie-breaking edge to the senior player -- Hawk, in this case. I bet you Hawk takes home the Butkus, but that's just one fool's guess.
Lion_in_Buckeye_Country: Chico, I'm just curious. What happened to the Penn State D in the MIchigan game? I didn't get to see Penn State much this year but when I did, they were tough to score on and played pretty sound.
Chico Harlan: That was the PSU defense's worst drive of the season -- a semi-tragic string of close calls and chaotic defense. That last play was simply a basic cover 4 defense that Michigan had the perfect play for. It was uncharacteristic, too, because this Penn State unit has essentially been together for two seasons, and the end of that game in Ann Arbor was the only moment, in all that time, that PSU's defense faltered when it couldn't afford to do so.
kevlar: What are your thoughts on Jay Paterno this year as co-whatever he is? This is not Jay Paterno asking the question.
Chico Harlan: What do you mean, co-whatever he is? I'm not sure I understand your question. But just to comment on Jay, I'll have to admit that I've always been a Jay supporter. I think he's unfairly maligned, and now he's owed some credit -- even if it's just a sliver -- for Robinson's development this season. Besides, those who play for him, Robinson especially, are extremely loyal to him, which makes me believe that he does a lot for their mental development. I know the basic rules of engagement for sports fans allows that coaches take blame for failure and players get credit for success, but I don't necessarily think that works. If you're gonna pan Jay for Zack Mills, then you have to applaud him for Mike Robinson
jetscrazy: I live on Long Island but read Mr. Harlan's columns on-line; am a PSU graduate ('69); is this team good enough to win a national championship assuming they get to the Rose Bowl?
Chico Harlan: Another question that begs for speculation. I think Penn State CAN do it, but it's an enormous longshot. In this horse race, the Lions are Birdstone. Then again, Birdstone won, didn't he? So who knows. I think the Lions will be lucky, extremely lucky, to push into the Rose Bowl. If they can, they'll still face a whale of a challenge. USC and Texas are both significantly stronger teams.
Chico Harlan: Ok, thanks guys. Sorry I wasn't able to get to all of the questions. Hopefully this forum was somewhat informative and entertaining... I had to type quickly, so I apologize for the brief answers and the inartful prose. Maybe one of these days I'll become a bit more polished. You know, maybe with some coaching help from JayPa.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.