Roughly one year ago, the same players and coaches positioned tomorrow for a Big Ten championship sunk to their sorriest point, one that was also their most important. Only the passing season of perspective provided the definitive evidence, but now, Penn State's football players credit their opportunity tomorrow -- they'll play Michigan State, knowing a victory will deliver them to a BCS bowl -- to a series of forgotten games in November 2004. Forgotten to everybody but those who played in them.

Matt Freed, Post-Gazette

Penn State's Calvin Lowry runs for a big gain as he eludes Wisconsin's Aubrey Pleasant in the second quarter Nov. 5.

Click photo for larger image.

Advertise with us

"Everybody knew, for some reason, this year was going to be special," senior cornerback Alan Zemaitis said. "We just needed to jump-start it somehow."

So go ahead. Try finding a more inglorious genesis for a football season so memorable. After Penn State's loss Nov. 6, 2004, to Northwestern, observers -- at least those who could bear to watch -- criticized the Nittany Lions as too weak, too slow, so far from their winning tradition that only a wholesale makeover, likely involving years of patience, could provide a remedy.

After that Northwestern loss, Penn State dropped to 0-6 in the Big Ten -- last place. Some players admitted their hesitation to walk around in public, because the criticism hit them like an unstoppable tide. Zemaitis, walking through Beaver Stadium that day, thought about throwing his fist into the concrete walls. He later issued his agitated assessment of the team: "I'm not optimistic until I see something different on the other side of the ball," he said, referencing an offense that generally triggered nothing more than boos and punts.

A locker room of alpha personalities had been reduced into a mass of sullen self-doubters. Fans booed them. Former players questioned them. Quarterback Zack Mills, when speaking by phone on his weekly conference calls, wondered aloud what became of his career's erstwhile promise. He spoke as if lying across his apartment couch, shades drawn, looking for answers. At the same time, a rumor started by hosts of a Pittsburgh radio morning show flooded across the state, suggesting that Joe Paterno would leave his job before 2005.

Reality was, most Penn State fans wished the rumor were true.

Advertise with us

Around that time, the Nittany Lions started talking about playing for pride, something sports teams usually resort to only when they have no pride left. Only now, though, on the cusp of a 10-1 season, can Penn State peel back the events of the past 12 months and call November 2004 their pivotal point: That's when the Lions were most forgotten, most alone ... and, as it turned out, most resilient.

When it happened -- when Penn State won its final two games, against Indiana and Michigan State, before greeting the offseason -- few placed much emphasis on the outcomes. What's the difference, in the end, between a 2-9 season and a 4-7 season? Well, one would have loomed like a dead end. The other, it turned out, bridged 2004 and 2005. It allowed the Lions to convince themselves that their goals could actually match their results, and not simply yield disappointment.

And that realization, defensive end Matthew Rice said this week, "has shone through with our kind of play this season."

Fortune, more than anything, ignited Penn State's turnaround. On Nov. 13, the Lions still floundered, inching within the narrowest margin of another low-point -- a loss, before 24,092, at hapless Indiana. With less than two minutes remaining, the Hoosiers needed to gain only a yard for the go-ahead touchdown. They had four chances.

For a moment, defensive coordinator Tom Bradley thought about ordering his defenders to allow a touchdown, thereby providing Penn State's offense one more chance. He squashed the idea. How, he wondered, could the players believe in themselves if he didn't believe in them first?

Advertise with us

So Bradley, instead, watched four plays, his team ahead 22-18. First down: A run, no gain. Second down: A run for a 1-yard loss. Third down: A quarterback keeper, stuffed again. And on fourth down, to cap a suddenly and surprising rapturous game, Indiana stacked three running backs in I-formation. Running back Chris Taylor was hit at once by three players, and with that, the Lions, for the first time in months, ended a game in celebration.

"Twenty years from now," quarterbacks coach Jay Paterno said later, "we might look at that goal-line stand and say those were the four most important plays in the history of Penn State football."

They gained importance as weeks, and later months, sustained the momentum. The following week, in the season finale against Michigan State, the Lions played their most complete game of the year, winning 37-13 and celebrating with a majestic output of emotions. As the game's final minutes evaporated, fans chanted "Joe Pa-ter-no!" Mills, cheered earlier in the season for leaving a game with an injury, was hit with a rush of honest appreciation. Students screamed for him as he left the field one final time.

When Paterno entered the media room for his postgame comments, he received a stirring applause from onlookers -- school officials, dignitaries and recruits -- watching from the room's balcony. "Holy smokes!" Paterno yelped, smiling. "Two wins, and I get that?"

No, two wins and he got this:

Advertise with us

An offseason buoyed by high spirits and confidence.

A team that taught itself, irreversibly, to expect good instead of disaster.

A program that grew the roots for its 9-1 season, one that attracted the attention of college football fans nationwide, at a time when nobody even noticed.

"It gave us a boost of confidence," quarterback Michael Robinson said. "To end the season by winning, it leaves a good taste in your mouth. We went into the offseason with some momentum, and I think that motivated us to work hard throughout the offseason."

Last season, and in the dreadful one in 2003, former players returned to Beaver Stadium for games and saw a shell of the program they remembered. The Lions lacked a swagger, and their losing perpetuated that.

Advertise with us

Then, with two games left in the 2004 season, Penn State's players talked about playing for pride. People assumed they were trying to save it. They were trying to gain it back.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.