UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. -- See spot. See no review. See Joe Paterno run.

Well, at least that's the basic story, following a linear progression of officiating decisions yesterday that left the Nittany Lions' coach steamed and reaffirmed plenty of questions about the aptitude of the Big Ten's instant-replay system.

Two plays in the first half in the Lions' 33-15 victory against Purdue stirred the confusion.

In the second quarter, facing a third-and-6, Purdue quarterback Curtis Painter completed a short out pattern to Dorien Bryant for 6 yards ... or was it 5 yards? Or perhaps 4 yards? Much to Penn State's dismay, officials elected not to review the play, immediately spotted as a first down.

Advertise with us

After the completion, the Boilermakers hurried to the line of scrimmage, hoping to begin the next play before refs could stop play for a review. Penn State called a timeout, buying time for the decision. But, as both teams waited, no signal every came from the press box, and a minute later, as boos rained from the 109,467 in the stands, play resumed.

Later in the quarter, Penn State quarterback Michael Robinson fumbled, while beginning a designed running play, when tackled in the backfield by Purdue lineman Brandon Villarreal. Originally, officials ruled that Robinson did not fumble, that he'd hit the ground before letting go of the ball.

Penn State, knowing its fortune, hurried to punt on fourth down. Still, officials asked center E.Z. Smith not to snap the ball.

About 30 seconds later, officials elected to review the play -- easily overturned with a second look; Robinson fumbled before his knees touched the grass -- and Paterno stormed onto the field, sticking his finger into the first official he could find.

Paterno, after the game, was asked if referees ever explained their rulings.

Advertise with us

"I still haven't gotten an explanation on some things that happened three weeks ago," Paterno said, referencing his earlier problems with officiating in Penn State's Oct. 15 loss to Michigan. "So no, I didn't get one."

Losing returns

Calvin Lowry swears he's comfortable as Penn State's punt-returner. Problem is, he rarely looks it, and yesterday, when rushing to the sideline to grab a punt, the scene that followed underscored Penn State's largest special teams problem.

In the first quarter, Lowry dashed across the field, hurrying to snag the low punt, but, before he could catch it, the ball bounced off his chest, straight into the hands of Purdue's Jerod Void. "I think he didn't know where the ball was, and he panicked," Paterno said.

One play later, from Penn State's 24, Purdue coaches called for a quarterback draw -- starting with a fake handoff to the right -- and Painter sprinted into the end zone for a Purdue touchdown.

Advertise with us

Down and out

The Boilermakers already have taken their share of hits this season. Doesn't help, then, when they start hitting one another.

Two Purdue starters -- senior wide receiver Kevin Noel and sophomore linebacker Stanford Keglar -- did not travel with their teammates for the game yesterday after a practical locker-room joke escalated Thursday into an incident that left Noel unconscious.

According to an account in the Journal and Courier, in Lafayette, Ind., the two players were jokingly hiding one another's clothing, when Keglar tackled Noel.

Noel's head hit the locker-room floor, and he briefly lost consciousness -- resulting in a 911 call.

Advertise with us

This 'n' that

Ethan Kilmer's candidacy as Penn State's top special-teams player received another boost when the senior sparkplug forced a fumble while tackling Purdue's Lance Melvin on a first-quarter punt return. ... Neither Painter nor fellow Purdue quarterback Brandon Kirsch stole the up-for-grabs Boilermakers starting job with their performances yesterday. "We'll get to the practice field and see who we like best," Purdue coach Joe Tiller said.

John Belae, Post-Gazette

Penn State coach Joe Paterno screams at a referee over a fumble call in the second quarter yesterday at Beaver Stadium.

Click photo for larger image.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.