All three of them, during the past months, were reckless. Stupid, they've admitted. One placed numerous crank calls to a senior citizen. One fired arrows at his friends' apartment wall. One drank too much only hours after a football game.

John Beale, Post-Gazette

In April, linebacker Dan Connor made a series of crank calls to a retired Penn State assistant coach. He rejoined the team in October.

Three of them, all Penn State football players. And here, there are only two stories of second chances and healing reputations.

Advertise with us

Said Dan Connor: "Overall, I'm hoping the experience made me a better person in the long run."

Said E.Z. Smith: "I couldn't ask for anything more than the spot I'm in right now."

Said Paul Cronin: "At this point, I really don't have anything to say."

A few similarities united these three, because they've all played for the same team, the same coach, the same goals. They've all messed up and witnessed the resulting wrath. But they've faced different consequences. Tomorrow, when No. 12 Penn State (6-1) meets Illinois, Connor will start at outside linebacker. Smith will see the majority of snaps at center. Cronin will watch them do both, from wherever he chooses, if he chooses -- so long as it's not the Memorial Stadium sideline.

Cronin, Smith and Connor all knew it, even before the first of them ever fell into trouble. Play for Penn State, and you knowingly place yourself under one variable -- a head coach who can be equal parts forgiving and severe, depending on the case, depending on the player.

Advertise with us

Smith, a senior center, was the first to fall in trouble. On Jan. 29, he used a bow and arrow belonging to fellow lineman Tyler Reed to damage the wall of an apartment Reed shared with Andrew Richardson and Scott Paxson. More than two months later, after a convoluted investigation, the university's judicial affairs office decided to prohibit Smith from extracurricular participation until the end of the summer. He was forced into football exile, and worse, sentenced to uncertainty. He remained in State College during the summer, working at a miniature golf course, running and lifting, and hoping that Paterno, at summer's end, might grant him one more season of football.

In April, as the judicial affairs office decided Smith's case, Connor, a sophomore linebacker, participated in a series of harassing crank calls directed at a retired Penn State assistant coach. By the time the story made news across the state, Connor already had paid a fine to the State College Police Department. Then, he paid much more. The university decided on an expulsion punishment that prohibited him from playing in the Lions' first three games. Paterno showed only agitation when asked what might happen come game No. 4.

Then against Northwestern, both players returned. Neither started, and Paterno warned that both needed to earn their old starting positions. Time -- and victories -- healed, though. This week, Penn State allowed Connor to speak to reporters during the weekly media teleconferences -- an informal confirmation that he'd regained Paterno's approval. Smith had been given the same chance a week earlier -- an opportunity to speak publicly about the mistake he'd committed and the chance to overwrite it.

"As long as coach Paterno was going to give me another shot to be back on this team, that's all I needed," Smith said. "What I tried to portray to [Paterno], I've never tried to hurt anybody in any decision I've made. I've never maliciously tried to harm anyone. I've done some stupid things, but I think he understands where I'm coming from."

"Coach Paterno has helped me out a lot," Connor said. "When this happened, he was hard on me, he was angry, but that's what I expected. It's one of those things, he doesn't take much. One more [mistake], and I think I'll be gone."

Advertise with us

Cronin knows. On Oct. 1, at 7 p.m., Cronin walked off of the Beaver Stadium field wearing his helmet for the final time. He was the Lions' nickel back, a fifth-year senior who'd turned down scholarships from smaller schools to walk on with Penn State. Then, in the early morning hours of Oct. 2, university police found Cronin slumped over on a sidewalk. He was cited for public drunkenness, and days after the charges surfaced publicly, a reporter asked Paterno about his reserve defensive back.

That's how Cronin's Penn State career reached an endpoint in three words.

"He's gone," Paterno said. "Period."

Cronin decided to leave Paterno with the final word. When reached yesterday on his cell phone, he quickly ended the conversation. Meanwhile, Smith and Connor, shown the mercy of Paterno's understanding, feel indebted to the coach who has allowed them to return. They cherish their second chances a bit more, knowing that Cronin no longer counts as their teammate.

"It's kind of a wake-up call," Connor said. "But that's how coach Paterno does business."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.