Today's referendum asks the difference between 2004 and 2005 as it pertains to Penn State, the football team that has forged one calendar year into a line now standing between an old era and a new era. Last season, the Nittany Lions finished 4-7, and fans wrote letters to the university president asking him -- no, demanding him -- to enact the directive of their newly favored Web site, www.joepamustgo.com.

Now, that hyperlink redirects Web surfers to a domain from which they can browse vacation packages, and with that, Penn State's one-year transformation seems complete. Click on www.joepamustgo.com; book your trip to a New Year's Day bowl site.

At the mid-point of the 2005 season, the Lions are 6-0, ranked eighth in the nation and first in the Big Ten. And followers, mouths agape, are searching for a way to pinpoint the turnaround. So what to make of the difference between 2004 and 2005?

One idea: Four freshmen wideouts -- Derrick Williams, Jordan Norwood, Deon Butler and Justin King -- who have combined for 55 receptions, 1,321 total yards and more highlight plays than the Lions had in the past two years combined. The difference, quarterback Michael Robinson said: "We have guys on the outside who can make plays."

Advertise with us

Another idea: The simple passage of time, and the luck that naturally rolls with it. Last year against Ohio State, for instance, two plays decided the game. Ted Ginn Jr. returned a punt for a touchdown, Robinson threw an interception that was returned for a score and Penn State lost, 21-10. This year? "One play made the difference," defensive coordinator Tom Bradley said. Lions safety Calvin Lowry returned a second-quarter interception to the Ohio State 2, and Penn State won, 17-10. The loss to the Buckeyes in 2004 officially eliminated the Lions from a bowl; the defeat of the Buckeyes Saturday officially clinched them a bowl.

One final idea: Nothing at all. There's no difference, but for the final result. "We are OK," coach Joe Paterno said. "We are not great, but we are a little better." Paterno said that Oct. 4, 2005. He said this Oct. 13, 2004: "I think we are getting a little better each week."

Now, Penn State has six games remaining -- its bowl game a definite. And the mid-year letter grades explain the difference between last year and this one.

Quarterbacks

Michael Robinson's statistics could fuel both sides of a bipartisan squabble. Don't like him? Mention his 10 turnovers, his proclivity for missing open receivers, his 46.6 completion percentage against Big Ten teams. You like him? Cite his scrambling ability, his nine touchdown passes, the vocal leadership to which teammates gravitate. Through six games, Robinson has reduced his mistakes, but he still flashes the shakiness one might expect from a first-year full-time quarterback. But to bring the political references full circle, Robinson's approval ratings, to date, are higher than expected.

Advertise with us

Grade: B

Running backs

Sometimes, Tony Hunt seems to disappear, and that's not counting the early morning conference calls in which his groggy words to the media seem indecipherable from quiet static. Without question, Hunt has improved this season, becoming Penn State's No. 1 tailback, averaging 6.3 yards per carry. But sometimes, he fades into a secondary element of Penn State's offense. Only once this year have the Lions allowed him more than 16 carries. Hunt is a strong, determined runner; thing is, sometimes he's denied the chance to show it.

Grade: C+

Wide receivers/tight ends

Advertise with us

Freshman Jordan Norwood explains all that's inexplicable about Penn State's receivers. He's 19 years old, but he has the round face of an elementary schooler and the gait of a kid hurrying after his parents in an airport concourse. When Norwood signed with Penn State, fans wondered aloud why the Lions even bothered with him. But now, Norwood's group -- which includes Derrick Williams, Deon Butler and Justin King -- has become the offense's catalyst. No group of freshmen in the nation is asked to do more or counted on so heavily. These freshmen have passed every test.

Grade: A+

Offensive line

Remove left tackle Levi Brown from the equation, and Penn State's line consists entirely of fifth-year seniors, players who have spent their careers attracting Joe Paterno's criticism for all varieties of screw-ups. Before the season, the joke went like this: The line could create holes in apartment walls (as center E.Z. Smith did, using a bow and arrow), but it couldn't create holes for its running backs. But, finally, this experienced group has found some success, and the Lions' line is playing more reliably than at any time in the previous two years. It has allowed only one sack in the past three games.

Grade: B-

Advertise with us

Defensive line

Is there such thing as a good comb-over? Certainly not when applied to follicles, but perhaps when applied to this four-man bunch. Tamba Hali, Scott Paxson, Jay Alford and Matt Rice are, metaphorically, a four-man comb-over. They spread out, stretch across every defensive down, to cover a thin position. And in this case, it works. Last year, Penn State used a defensive-line rotation dependent on six or seven players, but because of injuries and discipline problems, the line has been reduced to four. Yet, the unit surrenders just 2.3 yards per rush, and the Lions lead the conference in sacks.

Grade: A-

Linebackers

Dan Connor lost his voice following the game Saturday, which makes sense, being that the victory provided him much to yell about. The sophomore started his first game of the season, finishing with 12 tackles and providing All-American candidate Paul Posluszny with a formidable tag-team partner. With Connor back in the rotation alongside Tim Shaw and Tyrell Sales, the Lions line up one of the strongest linebacking units in the nation -- rugged enough to snuff running games, fast enough to keep up with receivers.

Advertise with us

Grade: A

Cornerbacks/safeties

Only four Division I-A teams employ secondaries that start four seniors, and, on that note, Penn State entered the season believing this unit would become the linchpin of the defense. So far, though, the secondary has fallen short of irreproachability. Cornerback Anwar Phillips shows inconsistencies, and his partner, Alan Zemaitis, hasn't grown from a very good player into a great player. Though safety Chris Harrell, absent in 2004 because of a neck injury, has returned without signs of rust, the Lions still rank fourth in the Big Ten in pass defense.

Grade: B

Special teams

Advertise with us

To be fair, Calvin Lowry's had a few punt return highlights this season. He had that 3-yard run-back against Ohio State. He broke one for 5 yards against Minnesota. Truth is, Lowry never looks comfortable when fielding punts, and the insistence to keep him there seems inexplicable. Freshman kicker Kevin Kelly, a question mark in August, has converted 9 of 11 field goals, and, considering he stands 5 feet 7 -- the shortest player on the team, he kicks with remarkable strength. The return game should be so strong.

Grade: C+

Coaching

The coaching staff stands, like a man with a marionette, atop everything happening on stage. And, when the on-field production yields a perfect record, the coaching staff must be given credit. Before the season, the offensive coaches installed a spread offense that Penn State has relied on more and more frequently. Joe Paterno realized the talent of his freshmen wideouts and immediately inserted them into the lineup, bucking his tendency to favor veterans. Even Paterno's evaluation from last season now appears correct: the Lions were only a few players away.

Grade: A

Overall grade-point average: 3.2