Before the football season started, somebody asked Penn State quarterback Michael Robinson to compare himself with Texas' Heisman Trophy candidate Vince Young, a turbo-fast quarterback and this year's coverboy for college football in the Midwest. Robinson curled his face into a sly smile. This was not the time, he decided, to coat a fellow quarterback with sugary compliments. Robinson simply said, "He's younger than me."

Related coverage

PSU Notebook: Minnesota's goal is to run, run, run

On the subject of droll comparisons, Robinson is three months older than another decorated quarterback, Southern California Matt Leinart, a prolific passer who throws interceptions about as often as he attends class. (He's enrolled in only one course this semester.) Robinson, for his part, is enrolled in only two this semester, but so long as he continues to turn the ball over at his current rate, that's where the serious comparisons to college football's best quarterbacks promptly end.

Advertise with us

"I've been putting our team in bad situations," Robinson said yesterday. "As a quarterback, I can't have those mistakes."

Because Penn State has yet to lose this season, those turnovers have faded into a secondary story line. But now, as the Nittany Lions await a game Saturday against Minnesota (4-0), they also await a soon-to-toughen schedule that will summarily prevent such turnovers from coexisting with the victories. Robinson, therefore, faces a crossroads: Cut the fumbles and the interceptions or risk cutting away at Penn State's early season success.

Through four games, Robinson takes fault -- at least statistically -- for 10 of Penn State's 13 turnovers. He has fumbled four times and thrown six interceptions, including three Saturday against Northwestern. Though his ability to connect on highlight-reel deep passes has lifted his quarterback efficiency rating to 154.4 -- 19th in Division I-A -- Penn State would prefer less bust to go with that boom.

"I'm a guy who strives to be perfect and I hate to put our team in a disadvantage," Robinson said. "And with the turnovers, that's what I've been doing -- it's a disadvantage."

Only 3 yards from the goal line last week against the Wildcats, Robinson fumbled after bursting through the line of scrimmage. Earlier in the game, he already had tossed three interceptions -- plays that led to 13 Northwestern points. After that second-quarter fumble, though, Robinson lasted the remainder of the game without a turnover.

Advertise with us

And not by coincidence. On a play late in the third quarter, Robinson, starting from shotgun formation, sprinted forward for a 34-yard gain. The end of the play was almost as notable as its distance. When he was dragged down by two Northwestern players, Robinson held the football with a death grip, using both arms and all of his focus.

Robinson, at times, can be "reckless," coach Joe Paterno allowed. "He wants to get every inch and he gets a little careless with the ball. He will get better at that."

In practice this week, the Lions called on Robinson to push through drills in which he's confronted with one defender, who's asked to strip the ball. Still, Paterno said that it's often difficult to simulate the every-inch-counts mentality that only surfaces in games.

"It is a little different when you are in a ballgame and you want to make an extra yard and you get a little bit careless with the football," he said.

"They say there are two things that create fumbles. One is lack of courage and the other is lack of concentration. I think in our case it is just a lack of concentration."

Advertise with us

Among Division I-A's 119 football teams, Penn State ranks 104th in turnover margin. No other team ranked 100th or lower in that category owns a winning record, but one way or another, the next month of football figures to fix that incongruity.

"I got those [turnovers] out of my system, hopefully," Robinson said. "But you never can know."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.