Any project that resolves to pull back the crusted, often-contradictory layers that make up the iconic legend that is Joe Paterno, let alone a book-length examination, faces more obstacles than would generally be worth surmounting.
"THE LION IN AUTUMN: A SEASON WITH JOE PATERNO AND PENN STATE FOOTBALL"
By Frank Fitzpatrick
Gotham Books ($26)
As a former Penn State sports beat writer for papers in the state's two biggest cities long ago, I can tell you that covering athletics there on a daily basis was essentially a matter of getting comfortable with the constant realization that the Western journalists who were covering the Kremlin during the Cold War were having a harder time, but not by much.
But even today's best possible result would still amount to a sports book, always a dubious genre, and on top of that, a sports book of finite audience, i.e., fans of the Nittany Lions, far-flung and numerous as they may be.
Frank Fitzpatrick's new book, however, has to be judged a rather startling success, even if it didn't turn out the way it might have been intended. There are significant journalistic and even literary elements that have saved this project in the face of the typically difficult access issues Paterno and Penn State can always erect with practiced efficiency.
Fitzpatrick, a Pulitzer nominee with the Philadelphia Inquirer, relies on his own tenacity and attention to detail with just the right amount of historical perspective and writing ability to scrape together 320 pages he can surely be proud of, even if not a lot of what appears here is new.
The success comes more in the care and consideration he takes explaining every plausibility behind the decline of a football program once considered the nation's gold standard, even if Penn State often had to say so itself.
Consider just this metaphor Fitzpatrick puts together on the perspective of university President Graham Spanier, the man who might have to take Paterno's craggy hands away from the monument he's been sculpting for more than half a century:
"At that moment, on his rapid sideline walk, Spanier found himself flanked, both figuratively and literally, by two Joe Paternos.
"To the president's left was the 77-year-old coach, his body tilted sharply forward in a posture of surrender as Penn State neared its 16th defeat in 21 games. This Paterno appeared tired, confused, vulnerable. ... Not far off to Spanier's right, however, in a stone grotto just outside the stadium's student section, stood a much sturdier version. Smiling, upbeat, vigorous, this bronzed Paterno was vibrantly middle-aged, his index finger thrust skyward in a permanent reminder that he had made Penn State No. 1.
"This was the uncomfortable geography Spanier occupied. Marooned between the puzzled old man and the bronze legend. ... Attempting to push the coach aside after 54 years and 341 wins would be no less difficult for him than lifting the seven-foot-tall, 900-pound statue."
As calls for the old coach's head intensified during last season's 4-7 autumn (which followed a 3-9 autumn), Spanier apparently took to noting that age was not necessarily an obstacle to achievement. Michelangelo, he noted, painted the Sistine Chapel at 71.
I don't imagine he ever pointed out that at 77, however, Michelangelo lost six of his eight Big 10 games and was nearly tripped up by Temple at home.
Readers locally will find in these pages both the real story of Paterno's "plan" to make Hall of Fame-destined quarterback Jim Kelly a linebacker, and the re-emergence of former Pitt coach Jackie Sherrill, once considered by Paterno the embodiment of everything that was wrong with the college game, now counseling old Joe in his hour of need.
What Fitzpatrick can't conclude or sufficiently explain while he watches Paterno's 2004 team weather the school's fourth losing season in five years, he casts against an elegant backdrop of college football history and Penn State's place in it.
A lot of these historical chapters wouldn't be here if the author's access to Paterno, his players, his coaches, and every other aspect of Penn State somehow were limitless.
Still, the whole thing works as a sober, informative text, and Paterno emerges as a complex and ultimately sympathetic figure without an ounce of pity from the author, which is, of course, as it should be.
Fitzpatrick may ultimately have settled for a field goal here, but he directed one beautiful, sustained drive.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.