UNIVERSITY PARK, Pa. -- Just an approximation here, but Jay Paterno is about seven letters away from the perfect life, those seven letters of course being the most complicated part of his existence, his last name. See, what if this smiling guy -- hair parted like a schoolboy of the Fifties -- was simply Jay, a Jay like any other small-town chatterbox, sitting in his living room wearing mesh shorts and cracking jokes and just about ready to go to bed?
Steve Manuel, Associated Press
Penn State quarterback coach Jay Paterno works with the Nittany Lions' quarterbacks Michael Robinson, left, and Anthony Morelli during pregame warm-ups Saturday at Beaver Stadium in University Park, Pa.
Click photo for larger image.
Jay, were he simply Jay, could waive the English teachers' prohibition of nice. No other way to say it, Jay would have it nice. A wife in the other room, an old graying beagle flopping around on the carpet, four kids upstairs -- all sleeping quietly at this hour -- and Jay would never have to worry about those kids showing up at school one day and learning how their father became State College's foremost public enemy.
Jay could grab a few friends and a few brews, which he can't do with that last name. ("It's gotten to the point," he says, "that if I even set foot in a bar, people will be saying, 'Jay was out drunk, stumbling and silly.' ") He could coach, which he loves in the same manner his father does, and not hear fans fire arrowed criticisms about his competence or his motives.
For 11 seasons now, Jay, 36, has worked as a Penn State football coach -- an assistant to his 78-year-old father, Joe Paterno -- and in more ways than Jay can count, he has learned every inescapable pressure and every added value inherent in his last name. The folks around town who dislike Jay find plenty of ammunition, which Jay's sometimes-righteous personality doesn't help to diffuse. Four of the past five seasons, the Nittany Lions have finished with a losing record. And during that half-decade, Jay has coached the quarterbacks, players whose performances have wavered between inconsistent and treacherous.
"Jay takes it worse than anybody, no question," his brother, Scott, says. "Because of the field he's in, there's always this sentiment: Is Joe grooming him to take over? Is he propping up an idiot son? There's a perception that Joe is unassailable, so maybe in order to draw blood you go after Jay."
Says Jay: "We've become, as a society, a lot less civil. Whether it's me or a politician or anybody in the public eye -- actors, actresses, what have you -- I think we forget there really is a human being inside the core of that image or persona."
Then, as Jay speaks, he offers a few important disclaimers. He acknowledges, yes, he could go elsewhere -- some faraway map dot of America where his last name doesn't double as such a burden -- or he could find another profession ... you know, any other profession. He just happened to pick the one in which his father poses overhead, the last don of immovable coaching legends. So, yeah, Jay acknowledges every criticism, to some extent, counts as a self-enforced flogging. A chosen beating on account of the family name. Because all this is Jay's choice, right?
Well, that's where this gets tricky. On this particular Friday night, as Jay entertains a visitor at his house, only three traffic lights separate him from Beaver Stadium. He will arrive there the following morning by 10 a.m., and that thought makes him glow. Jay loves many things beyond football, but other than his family, nothing more than football.
Joe Paterno fathered five children, but only Jay, the second youngest, fell hard and hopelessly for the sport that would grow into his blessing and his curse. Never, not once, did Joe encourage his kids to follow football -- if anything, he built barricades between his family and the game -- but some nights, Jay would bring his toys into the den as Joe studied film. With a set of Lincoln Logs, Jay scribbled uniform numbers on them and lined up the pieces in football formations. Saturdays, even by age 5, Jay would sit in Beaver Stadium, section SK, and sit transfixed.
He could have been sick enough for the emergency room on Thursday, but his mother, Sue, would force him to attend school Friday in order to make the game Saturday. "Miracle cure!" Jay says now, laughing. "Jesus came down, healed me; I never missed a Friday of school."
This was a lost cause, an idealist in love. Granted, Jay might still do other things some day. He dreams of writing short-form fiction and does now when he finds the time. He'd love to win a lottery, move to Colorado and ski. Maybe coach the Dallas Cowboys. "Well wait," he interrupts. "Scratch that. I couldn't work for Jerry Jones." Anyway. "No matter what I ended up doing," he says, "I'd still be trying, every Saturday, to get back into Beaver Stadium."
After playing as a career scout-team quarterback at Penn State, Jay worked at Virginia and Connecticut and James Madison, serving in order as a grad assistant, a receivers and tight ends coach and a quarterbacks coach. It was the first period of his life when Saturdays didn't mean dressing in blue and white. Even so, the Penn State teams during that span, the Lions teams that Jay never watched or coached, he still referred to them as "We." After the 1994 season, Jay received at least three coaching offers, but when a job opened at Penn State, the others could have offered a castle and a country club membership. Didn't matter.
Jay was back at Penn State, still looking younger than some of the players. He adjusted quickly to calling his father "Joe" in professional settings, and he braced for some of the good-natured abuse that follows the coach's son. Sure, he sacrificed some of his identity, but he was ready. "He could have gone somewhere else," says former assistant Kenny Jackson, who coached at Penn State from 1993-2000. "But he knows no other place. He could go elsewhere, but his mind would still be here. ... He's fighting for his family identity."
Jay doesn't want to talk about the abuse because if he talks about it too much, he'll sound like a whiner, and then -- hey! -- more stones for everybody else. He allows room for the traditional keep-it-in-perspective byword, but this sounds more genuine: he starts rattling off flashpoints of the world's grief ... Katrina, Iraq, only he doesn't stop there. Another example, a second, a third. Like he's reading The New York Times. By the time he mentions the tensions in Northern Ireland, he is nodding his head vigorously, saying, "Listen, I just want my kids to understand that the world is so much bigger than football."
Only in the past two or three seasons, in step with the losing and quarterback struggles, has Jay become a favorite target of the anonymous message-board blitzkrieg. Is he angling to become his father's successor? Does he know enough to coach the quarterbacks?
Jay's problems extend beyond the roots of nepotism. He spent his first five seasons with the Lions coaching the tight ends, but since then he has guided the quarterbacks. Zack Mills, in four years under Jay, struggled as a junior and senior more than he did as a freshman and sophomore. Some chalked it up to inept wide receivers or poor play-calling. (Jay calls the team's passing plays.) Others trace it directly to Jay's guidance, though Mills, who graduated last season, defends his coach.
"Unlike his father," Mills says, offering a sad chuckle, "Jay is very laid-back and easygoing. He is a great guy. And he genuinely cares about you, unlike some of the coaches I've had."
Jay's current situation, fighting the baggage of his own last name, might overwhelm a realist, but Jay is a dreamer. When he sends e-mails, the signature at the bottom of his name lists, chronologically, Penn State's undefeated seasons, and the ellipses after "1994" tells much of Jay's expectations. When coaching Brad Scioli in 1997, Jay challenged Scioli to swear off drinking for the season. They did it together, really, and Jay hasn't had a drop of beer or wine since. Even at Scott's wedding, he wouldn't touch the stuff. Not until Penn State wins the Rose Bowl.
"Even now, I don't touch it," he says. "I don't need it to be social. I don't even need it to be a jackass. I can be a jackass without alcohol."
He has dedicated himself, instead, to working 80 or 90 hours a week and developing a tight relationship with his players, a mix of love and soft criticism. From time to time, only rarely, he allows himself to think about his next job, and if it could even come at Penn State, whenever his father retires. He's argued with his brother, Scott, about what might come next.
Jay, the idealist, thinks he could do it. He could be the head coach, if the opportunity somehow arose. With enough exposure, with enough success, his last name could help embolden a family tradition, not ruin it. Says Scott: "But I've told him it would be in his best interests to have another stop on his resume. That might be the only way to get rid of all the baggage that, unfortunately, would be in place. He's got to go someplace else and be so successful that people are begging him to come back."
Maybe this is routine for sons of famous men. They strive and face backlash, in cycle.
"People always wonder about Jay's agenda," Scott says. "Well, Jay supports Joe, unequivocally."
Now, he's just wishing for others to do the same for him.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.