Michael Robinson never expected, in his first 60 minutes of football this season, to run 18 times. He never imagined absorbing a battery of hits vicious enough to leave him aching through yesterday morning.

When he allowed himself to look forward to his 2005 debut, he never envisioned a stat line that would double as an eyesore: 90 yards passing, one interception.

But Robinson, Penn State's quarterback, always braced himself for one thing. The criticism that would follow his first struggles.

"I knew it was going to be like that," Robinson said. "What can I say?"

Advertise with us

Criticism is fickle, by nature, and Robinson learned this much in his first three seasons at Penn State. When now-departed first-stringer Zack Mills bounced through a turbulent career, Robinson grew, at times, into the fan-favorite. Now, the starting job belongs to Robinson, but his ascension into such a role invites several questions, concerns that gain volume after performances such as his 2005 debut.

Can Robinson -- a wideout for much of last season -- transition smoothly into somebody throwing passes instead of catching them? Or does Penn State's backup quarterback, talented but untested sophomore Anthony Morelli, deserve playing time?

Already, Robinson knows his Week 1 performance awakened such questions.

"They have their opinion," he said. "I'm just glad they're not the coach."

In a way, Robinson's final season at Penn State feels like a mission of persuasion. In prior seasons, even as he practiced with Penn State's receivers, he never let coaches forget his true goal: to play quarterback. When thrown into games, usually as a result of Mills' injuries or ineffectiveness, Robinson looked raw -- he flashed potential, but he lacked accuracy. (His career statistics entering this season: 44.3 percent completion rate, 6 touchdowns and 11 interceptions.)

Advertise with us

During the summer, quarterbacks coach Jay Paterno promised that Robinson would benefit from his current security. He was practicing full time at quarterback, without the threat of moving to another position.

So finally, Robinson has part of his wish. He's the quarterback. The next step: Becoming the quarterback, no questions asked.

Against South Florida, Robinson threw only 15 passes, completing nine. Playing in tandem with a fleet of novice receivers -- the six who saw playing time Saturday had combined for three career catches -- Robinson never discovered a rhythm. A porous offensive line allowed three sacks and ensured Robinson spent most plays still feeling more like a runner than a passer. In total, his 18 carries produced 36 yards. "And I know six or seven of those [carries] were scrambles or broken plays," he said.

"Michael had a pretty good game," head coach Joe Paterno said. "There are a couple things he can do better. ... He went into the game thinking he had to win the game by himself."

During the same news conference in which he assessed Robinson's performance, Paterno drew a line to a corollary issue. Morelli currently waits as the second-stringer, a veteran of only 13 passes. Against South Florida, Morelli expected playing time, and in the game's waning minutes, still without a snap, Morelli sat by himself on the bench.

Advertise with us

"I think we have to make up our mind to get him in the game," Paterno said. "Where, when and how you do it is always tricky."

Paterno then went on to mention that the decision would require caution. Because Morelli's first step on the field will effectively squash the chances of a redshirt, Paterno must commit to playing Morelli regularly before he decides to play him at all. And of course, playing Morelli regularly brings up its own concern:

Said Paterno, "I don't want Michael Robinson ever to think that we don't feel he is the guy that can get the job done."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.