As of Friday, 114 football players crowded the Penn State roster, and that number has yet to change, presuming nobody's since forgotten to shave in the morning. Then again, the last 10 days have turned the Nittany Lions belly-up -- a collective green light to all oncoming mayhem -- thereby delivering the team to a position where, now, players can somehow find trouble for themselves given only the resources of a telephone and a little free time. (See: Connor, Dan; suspended infinitely, prank calls.)

As the Lions approach their first game -- Saturday against South Florida at Beaver Stadium -- the team has lost players this offseason on account of academics, injuries, transfers, a bow-and-arrow-shooting incident, a sexual misconduct violation and then, as icing smothered the cake, a prank-calling episode.

So who's to say which player might somehow disregard the 8 1/2-by-11-inch sign posted in a meeting room in the Penn State football complex, a message that notes, ominously: "Unkempt facial hair -- SEE JVP."

At this juncture, though, Joseph Vincent Paterno has a right to be fastidious, even when it seems overdone. That's because the Lions now hang perilously in balance, leaning halfway toward a turnaround season, halfway toward another year of woeful losing. They have the talent to contend for a Big Ten championship; they have the shortcomings to plummet into the Big Ten cellar. Their season could swing wildly in either direction -- aiming, if you will, for champagne or Champaign.

Advertise with us

So, with the season soon under way, Penn State remains a collection of uncertainties, and the prognosticators can logically envision the Lions turning, piece by piece, into the team fans dream of or the team fans dread. Here, we detail the best- and worst-case scenarios, position-by-position. If it even bears mentioning, the difference between these scenarios, true to Penn State's essence in 2005, is just about as thin as a strand of chin stubble.

Quarterbacks

The best case: A trimmed-down Michael Robinson improves his accuracy, lowers his interception ratio and leaves PSU fans wondering why he's been playing wide receiver all these years.

The worst case: Robinson never looks comfortable leading an inexperienced offense and still can't complete more than 50 percent of his passes. By season's end, Anthony Morelli swears he could win a mayoral race.

Likelihood of best case: 45 percent

Advertise with us

Running backs

The best case: Tony Hunt develops into a 1,000-yard rusher -- even finding space when the blocking struggles -- and Austin Scott finally provides evidence of why the Lions once recruited him so ardently.

The worst case: Hunt and Scott never appear to be the offense's true weakness, but the running game fails to generate any kind of threat against better defenses. After two years in Paterno's doghouse, a snout grows from Scott's facemask.

Likelihood of best case: 70 percent

Wide receivers/ Tight ends

Advertise with us

The best case: By the end of the season, nobody bothers with this caveat: "...But they're young." No, just talented. Derrick Williams performs as advertised, scoring a half-dozen touchdowns, and either Justin King, Deon Butler or Terrell Golden emerges as a No. 2 threat.

The worst case: The unit never recovers from the loss of Mark Rubin, the freshmen look like freshmen and Joe Paterno spends his weekly press conferences lamenting that a few more plays from the wideouts could have made the difference.

Likelihood of best case: 35 percent

Offensive line

The best case: E.Z. Smith returns as a starter by midseason and looks like PSU's best center. Tackles Levi Brown and Charles Rush anchor the left side, while two bodies on the right -- anybody over 6-foot-2 and 290 pounds will do -- manage to adequately protect Robinson's front side.

Advertise with us

The worst case: The group repeats its 2004 performance. As a result, the running game struggles. As a result, defenses key in on the passing game. And as a result, when the PSU offense takes the field, punter Jeremy Kapinos knows he has 120 seconds to warm up.

Likelihood of best case: 40 percent

Defensive line

The best case: Tamba Hali turns into the team's best lineman since Courtney Brown, and the interior grunt-workers, despite playing without the talented Ed Johnson, replicate the run defense from 2004, when PSU allowed only 3.2 yards per carry.

The worst case: The lack of depth hurts. A team that, in 2004, relied on rotations among its ends and tackles loses that luxury. A slew of opposing Big Ten running backs top 100 yards. Lavon Chisley and Johnson, both of whom looked like role players last season, seem far more important now that they're gone.

Advertise with us

Likelihood of best case: 60 percent

Linebackers

The best case: Dan Connor returns to the starting lineup before the Big Ten schedule and plays like Paul Posluszny did last season. Posluszny, meanwhile, plays like Shane Conlan did in 1986. Though only a reserve, Tyrell Sales looks like the next Linebacker U. torchbearer.

The worst case: Posluszny continues his growth as one of the Big Ten's best linebackers, but nobody else comes close to matching him. Connor, following his prank-calling brain cramp, slumps mightily -- hey, he's a sophomore -- and Tim Shaw proves himself to be all-speed, no-instincts.

Likelihood of best case: 75 percent

Advertise with us

Secondary

The best case: The quartet of seniors leads the defense and becomes one of the top five secondaries in the nation. Alan Zemaitis shuts down half of the field, and after a few weeks, opponents learn that the underrated Anwar Phillips can do the same.

The worst case: Injuries or previously unnoticed flaws render this group average. Some of the more experienced quarterbacks keep the secondary off-balance, and Chris Harrell plays with the rust of somebody who missed the 2004 season.

Likelihood of best case: 85 percent

Special teams

Advertise with us

The best case: Penn State suddenly discovers a kicker who can make 75 percent of his field goals -- or at least most of his PATs -- and either Williams or King breathes some firepower into a return group that in 2004 generally found its best play to be the fair catch.

The worst case: Both of PSUs freshmen kickers struggle, looking like... well, Robbie Gould. Though Kapinos develops into one of the Big Ten's best punters, he is the lone bright spot.

Likelihood of best case: 25 percent

Coaching

The best case: Paterno gets the season he's long been waiting for, and by season's end, the "Joe-must-go calls" have all but died. Even so, the timing for Paterno's departure suddenly feels perfect.

Advertise with us

The worst case: The drama thickens. For the third consecutive year, Penn State refuses to designate one offensive coach as the play-caller. The offense looks discombobulated, and by season's end, so does Paterno. The legend's old success sinks deeper into history.

Likelihood of best case: 40 percent

Carolyn Kaster, Associated Press

Still the man in the middle of it all after 40 years.

Click photo for larger image.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.