PENN STATE -- On Dec. 19, 2002, Jan Murphy, a reporter for The Patriot-News in Harrisburg, e-mailed an employee of the State Employees' Retirement System (SERS), requesting salary information of four SERS members -- all of them Penn State officials, including, most notably, football coach Joe Paterno.
Joe Paterno
Yesterday, 968 days later, Murphy finally heard an official answer to her request. A Commonwealth Court panel ruled, 3-2, that the SERS is correct in releasing the requested information. The salaries, including Paterno's, are public record, and should be made available despite Penn State's current objections.
Penn State likely will appeal the decision, school spokesman Tysen Kendig said, and salary information will not be released until all appeals are exhausted. "We're obviously a little disappointed," Kendig said.
Murphy contacted the SERS in 2002 asking for the salaries of four Penn State employees: Paterno, now entering his 40 th season as the Nittany Lions' football coach; Richard Althouse, the school's budget officer; Gary Schultz, the senior vice president of finance and business; and Rodney Erickson, an executive vice president and provost.
Penn State claimed in court documents that Murphy used a "backdoor" method to request the information; the SERS is a state agency offering retirement plans for state employees. As a result, some information held by the SERS is subject to the Right to Know Act, which allows individuals access to public records.
"Access to this information allows the public to meaningfully evaluate the wisdom and appropriateness of these state appropriations," Judge Bernard L. McGinley wrote in the majority decision.
Penn State officials, before the ruling, had countered that the information should remain private. The school has long kept Paterno's salary undisclosed, though Paterno said during a visit to Pittsburgh in May that he had no problem if his salary was revealed. He joked that fans might be surprised at the modesty of the figure.
Roughly 10 percent of PSU's annual budget comes from state appropriations, Kendig said. "We're a little different in that we're a state-related institution, not a state-owned entity."
"The fact that PSU is not defined as a state agency does not change the public character of the information," McGinley wrote.
In the dissent, written by Judge Rochelle S. Friedman, Paterno was singled out from the other Penn State employees in question. Friedman noted that Paterno has been a member of SERS since 1950 -- seven years before the Right to Know Act, whereupon SERS information became subject to disclosure.
"Paterno," Friedman wrote, "was not put on notice before he became a member of SERS that his compensation information was subject to disclosure... Under such circumstance, I submit that Paterno's expectation of privacy should be recognized as reasonable."
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.