Specify the losses however you want. Penn State lost games, seven of them total. Coaches lost sleep trying to figure it out. One quarterback, sacked by a Wisconsin defensive lineman, briefly lost consciousness. Another quarterback lost the chance at a healthy senior season.
The losses in 2004 were traceable to many factors, but, by season's end, coach Joe Paterno had a favorite culprit: his offensive line.
Usually, the offseason -- the simple passage of time -- assures a fresh start and reborn optimism. But this spring, as Penn State prepares for its Blue-White scrimmage game at 2 p.m. tomorrow at Beaver Stadium, the offensive line remains the biggest concern. The passage of time has made a suspect unit all the more uncertain.
"Our offensive line has been a concern of mine," Paterno admitted at the start of spring practice.
The five players who started most often last season -- from left to right, tackle Levi Brown, guard Charles Rush, center E.Z. Smith, guard Tyler Reed and tackle Andrew Richardson -- entered 2005 with eligibility remaining. Coaches hoped such experience would solidify the unit.
Yet currently, Penn State's first-string offensive line looks drastically different. Sixty percent different.
The left side of the line -- Brown and Rush -- remains intact. At the other positions, though, there are new players and new doubts.
In practice this week, senior Lance Antolick played center. Junior Robert Price right guard. And senior John Wilson, who started five games last season, was at right tackle.
That change happened overnight. One night -- Jan. 29. That's when a bow and arrow damaged a wall in the campus apartment shared by Reed, Richardson and defensive lineman Scott Paxson.
An investigation by the school's judicial affairs office absolved Reed, Richardson and Paxson, but resulted in the temporary expulsion of Smith, who took responsibility for the damage.
Smith, who started all 11 games last season, is no longer with the team, though his return in the fall semester has not been ruled out. Richardson and Reed are practicing. Thing is, they're practicing against the first-stringers, not with them. Paterno has placed the two linemen at the bottom of the depth chart, forcing them, at least temporarily, to spend time with the scout team.
"They messed up, so they have to take the punishment," said Brown, the left tackle. "Them coming back to having starting positions is up to Joe."
Last season, it was those playing behind the offensive line who took the punishment. The unit allowed only 19 sacks, but quarterback Zack Mills struggled to find time to throw, and he was hampered by injuries.
Against Wisconsin Sept. 25, Mills was knocked out after just two plays. Michael Robinson, who replaced him, didn't last the rest of the quarter. As Robinson dropped back to pass, looking for a receiver running deep, Wisconsin's Erasmus James knocked the quarterback to the ground, where he remained for 10 minutes.
"If they're getting hurt, it means we're not doing our jobs," Brown said earlier this week.
"At times [last year], I don't think we played up to our potential like we should have. So I think the criticism was justified. But we have to get rid of all that this year."
Brown, for one, believes the offensive line is coming together, even though several key parts have come apart.
"I think we've made a lot of progress," he said.
"The line is coming along well," running back Tony Hunt added. "They were missing a few players, but they're stepping up and looking pretty good."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.