What started as a rumor turned into a fact, then a frenzy, and finally, a supposed fallacy.

Yesterday morning, two Pittsburgh radio hosts -- former Steelers Tunch Ilkin and Craig Wolfley -- reported a rumor, citing one unnamed source, that Penn State coach Joe Paterno would soon step down and name defensive coordinator Tom Bradley as his successor.

Feeding on a Penn State football landscape scorched by back-to-back losing seasons, the rumor flamed across the state. Within hours, the Penn State athletic department, in an unprecedented move, issued a statement denying the rumor: "Statements made on a Pittsburgh radio station (Fox Sports Radio 970 AM) earlier today regarding the future of Penn State football coach Joe Paterno are unfounded and untrue."

Multiple sources reached yesterday corroborated that statement.

Advertise with us

By late afternoon, both Ilkin and his radio station backed away from the original report, saying the comments were introduced only as gossip -- never as fact.

"We said that we heard a rumor from a source," Ilkin said. "I want to make it clear, we didn't intend for this to be anything like it was."

Even so, the fast-flying rumor underscored Paterno's tenuous job status and the expectation for change at Penn State. Though Paterno signed a four-year contract before the season, the Lions' current 2-7 record has raised questions about his future. At a news conference Tuesday, Paterno affirmed his desire to remain at Penn State, adding he didn't see "any reason" to step down within the next year or two.

The Penn State release characterized all reports contradicting that as "untrue."

Fox Sports Radio 970 AM did not have a transcript of the on-air discussion, but Ilkin, Fox Sports program director Bob McLaughlin, and former Penn State lineman Leo Wisniewski -- an on-air guest yesterday with Ilkin and Wolfley -- agreed on this chain of events:

Advertise with us

At 8:30 a.m., Ilkin and Wolfley welcomed Wisniewski to the show for a biweekly segment in which the trio discusses Penn State football. Ilkin and Wolfley introduced the rumor, and Wisniewski said that he'd heard the same thing.

They talked about the scenario for several minutes, debating, in hypothetical terms, how the decision would benefit or hinder Penn State. Wisniewski, driving up to State College on business, promised to "look into" the rumor by tracking down Bradley, a friend of his. (While returning to Pittsburgh yesterday, Wisniewski said by cell phone that he was never able to catch up with Bradley.)

After a commercial break, Ilkin and Wolfley took several calls about the scenario. Representatives from unofficial Pitt and Penn State fan Web sites called the show and offered their opinions. Within minutes, the news spread to fan message boards, where it gained a sudden legitimacy.

Several Fox Sports Radio listeners wrote on message boards that Ilkin and Wolfley, when initially discussing Paterno, presented the information as more fact than rumor. Yet the station, in its release, emphasized that the Paterno rumor was never reported as news in its sportscast.

"We were not treating this as a news story," said McLaughlin, the program director. "But it became one once it left our hands and other people reported it.

Advertise with us

"Knowing what [Ilkin and Wolfley] do, they're football guys who joke around about this stuff. It's very much tongue-in-cheek."

Said Wisniewski: "It was Tunch's source. I pressed him on the air, and jokingly called him 'Deep Throat.' So it was a hypothetical discussion based on his source. I hope we didn't indicate something more substantive than what it really was."

It became very substantive. Jeff Nelson, Penn State's assistant athletic director for communications, received 15 to 20 phone calls from media outlets asking about the news. The demand for information, he said, triggered the university's press release. Nelson could think of no previous time when Penn State had responded similarly to a public rumor.

"But there were just so many people that called," Nelson said, "we decided that this would be the best way to squash it."

When Bradley walked out of a morning meeting, he saw 53 missed calls on his cell phone. Steve MacCarthy, a university spokesperson from the office of Penn State president Graham Spanier, also received several inquiries.

Advertise with us

"This is getting to the point where I'd say it's laughable," MacCarthy said.

The rumor included a suggestion that Penn State's board of trustees -- or at least several of its members -- had called a private meeting to decide Paterno's future. As the Nittany Lions attempt to attract recruits for next year, Paterno's age, 77, and uncertain job status might deter recruits from signing with PSU, a fact that Paterno's critics emphasize when stressing the need for a new head coach.

Officially, the Penn State board of trustees has not met since Sept. 17 and next meets Nov. 19.

One board member, Walter Peechatka, knew of no agenda to oust or replace Paterno.

"I had not heard anything about that at all," he said.

Advertise with us

Terry Smith -- the stepfather of highly recruited defensive back Justin King, a senior at Gateway High School where Smith is the head coach -- contacted Paterno yesterday morning. Smith said it's his understanding that Paterno will still coach the Lions in 2005.

"As far as I know," said Smith, "[the rumor] is not true."

This week, Penn State, loser of six consecutive games, travels to Bloomington, Ind., for a game against Indiana. The Lions conclude their season next week against Michigan State, and questions about Paterno's future promise to swirl.

Ilkin said that the Internet contributed to this particular firestorm. What was meant on the radio to be speculative turned into something more serious when passed along to Internet sources.

Said Ilkin: "We always joke, we never broke a story. The only thing we ever broke is bones."