First there were 29 names, and hope overflowed. No, it wasn't even hope -- it was something more certain, it was conviction. Penn State's recruiting class from five years ago created belief, because these were talented football players, and talented football players are taught to believe in themselves.

Peter Diana, Post-Gazette

Joe Paterno and Zack Mills -- a quarterback in the Class of 2000 -- along the sideline Saturday at Ohio State. "There were a lot of expectations," Mills said.

Click photo for larger image.

Advertise with us

The Class of 2000: A look at Penn State's much-heralded recruiting class of 2000

In February 2000, when the 29 names were announced, experts believed, too. They called it Penn State's best class in years. One of the top five in Division I-A. Of the 29 players, most picked Penn State over schools such as Notre Dame or Florida State or Michigan.

When a reporter called quarterback Zack Mills, then a high school senior from Ijamsville, Md., and asked him about the decision to attend Penn State, Mills said, without flinching, "I want to win a national championship."

On behalf of mercy -- and because surely, for the sake of 29 men, we can forgo a list of how the belief so painfully eroded -- let's just fast-forward through time, skip all the seasons of redshirting and waiting and losing and waiting some more; let's just find Mills again -- yesterday, in fact -- talking about his same recruiting class of 29, linking past to present.

Here, as he wonders aloud, he asks just one simple question. "What happened?"

Advertise with us

"I can't put my finger on exactly what has gone wrong," another senior, linebacker Derek Wake, said. "But it's definitely been a hard road."

"There were a lot of expectations," Mills continued, "and obviously it didn't work out that way at all."

Of the 29 football players to enroll in Penn State for the 2000 season, just eight remain with the team. Only four -- Mills, Wake, fullback Paul Jefferson and guard Scott Davis -- likely will start Saturday when the Lions play host to Northwestern. Over the past five seasons, the Lions have compiled a 24-32 record. They have one bowl appearance. No bowl wins.

The class of remaining fifth-year seniors has endured, and likely contributed to, the worst statistical half-decade span in Joe Paterno's coaching career.

"I definitely remember all of them that came in with my class," Davis said.

Advertise with us

He remembers the hype, and how true it felt. He remembers his goal: Like Mills, he wanted a national championship. He remembers the 29, and he remembers how such promise chipped away.

Four players transferred. (They picked schools such as Hofstra and Millersville.) At least two left because of academic trouble. Four left after four years without redshirting. (Only one, Sean McHugh, plays in the NFL.) Five had their careers short-circuited by injuries. Six left the team with eligibility still remaining.

More careers were marked by pain than success. After one season, quarterback Zac Wasserman left school to be with his mother, dying of cancer in California. Just weeks into the 2000 season, Adam Taliaferro -- who coaches later said could have been a surefire NFL first-round pick -- was temporarily paralyzed after he tried to make a tackle against Ohio State. He never played again.

Those who remain with the football team are pricked by reminders of the on-field failure. Mills especially. He has received e-mails and nasty phone messages this season telling him to "hang it up." Two weeks ago against Iowa, fans routinely booed Mills. Except when he left the field with an injury. Then they cheered.

"That hurt," Mills said.

Advertise with us

For the longest time, Mills -- a four-year starter -- and his fellow seniors clung to hope. Coming off a 3-9 season in 2003, they swore 2004, their senior year, would improve. They prayed for an ending they could cherish.

They didn't get it. Penn State is 2-6 and hasn't won since Sept. 18. Even one week ago, Lions players hoped for an unlikely turnaround and a bowl bid, but a loss Saturday to Ohio State erased such a possibility.

The seniors, finally, turned to the truth: They have three games to go, and not much to play for.

"It's kind of scary in a way," Wake said, "because I only have a few weeks left. I think about it ... all the practices, all the work. I'll only be running out of that tunnel a few more times. And the rest of my life, no matter what I do, I'll never run out of that tunnel again. It's hard to think about that."

Wake recalls, with a smile, his visit to Penn State in fall 1999. The Lions were undefeated at the time, and contending for a national championship. Bhawoh Jue, now in the NFL, showed Wake around campus. Wake toured the weight room, the stadium. His feeling? "Awe."

Advertise with us

His decision to come to Penn State really wasn't a decision at all. No other school compared.

On Jan. 30, 2000, Wake offered a verbal commitment to Penn State. He became one of 29.

Now, Wake's getting ready to graduate. He'll gain enough credits to do so by the end of the semester. He'll leave with more disappointment than he ever expected and fewer victories than he ever imagined, but he also said that, given the chance, he would do it again.

That's because he'll leave Penn State with another belief -- much different than the one he had five years ago.

"Whatever happens next in life," he said, "I'll be prepared for it."

Advertise with us

NOTE -- Two former Penn State standouts -- Charles Sieminski and Jerry Sandusky, also a former Lions' coach -- will be inducted into the Pennsylvania Sports Hall of Fame. This banquet will be Saturday at the Four Points by Sheraton Pittsburgh North, Marshall.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.