Jim Mone, Associated Press
Penn State coach Joe Paterno walks the sideline in the third quarter Saturday against Minnesota.
Click photo for larger image.
Whether this is something to be celebrated or bemoaned, who knows. Penn State, shaken by a few injuries and stirred with the desire to overcome them, played about as well as its talent allowed on Saturday night at the Metrodome in Minneapolis.
That fact, taken by itself, cultivated some optimism.
That fact, coupled with another Penn State loss, did just the opposite, and left the Lions wondering why their best effort wasn't quite good enough.
Sports, at times, can seem like the quintessential all-or-nothing -- win or lose; succeed or fail -- but Penn State's 16-7 loss at No. 14 Minnesota managed to defy one category or the other. It was everything. Encouraging, but discouraging. A loss, but a step forward. A game that dropped Penn State to 2-3, 0-2 in the Big Ten Conference, but an effort that left coach Joe Paterno smiling and content, with a feeling that the importance of his team's effort eclipsed the importance of the result.
As he met with the media after the loss, he spoke patiently, saying things like, "I thought we played a heck of a football game." And indeed, the platitudes about getting better every week looked true at times.
Six true freshmen have played this season for Penn State -- uncharacteristic for Paterno, who generally views first-year players as little more than props along the sideline. Several of those freshmen -- most notably receiver Mark Rubin and linebacker Dan Connor -- are turning into reliable players. They give Penn State the built-in hope for improvement.
More good signs came from the Penn State defense, which again looked like the backbone of the team, holding Minnesota to 16 points. Coming into the game, the Gophers had not scored fewer than 34.
"This was the best defense we have played against in a long time," Minnesota coach Glen Mason said.
In addition, Paterno also was encouraged by the toughness of his quarterback, Zack Mills, who threw for 250 yards (and just one interception) despite a sore right shoulder. Though sacked just twice, Mills was hit repeatedly -- and once, following a safety blitz in the fourth quarter, Mills stayed in the game though he could barely walk.
"You know, people give Zack a hard time, maybe because of his win-loss record since here's been here," center E.Z. Smith said. "But the way he leads this team ... if people knew his toughness, you'd have to rank him among the best Penn State quarterbacks of all time."
But among the players who spoke after the game, Smith's glowing words were the exception. Unlike Paterno, who measures his team against realistic expectations, most Penn State players seem to measure themselves against perfection. And the losses, no matter what encouragement they offer, leave them sickened.
As the team walked through the Metrodome tunnel Saturday, retreating to the locker room, almost 100 players walked in a single-file line. No one muttered a word.
Plenty left them discouraged. They had failed to stick with their game plan, a sure sign that the Gophers -- not the Lions -- dictated the style of play. Penn State entered the game hoping to run the ball, control the clock and keep Minnesota's potent offense on the sideline. In the end, the Lions managed just 21 yards rushing. And their time of possession? Less than 25 minutes.
Early in the game, Minnesota used one of its safeties close to the line of scrimmage, and tailback Tony Hunt never had space to run. Even his longer runs -- which is to say, anything more than 3 yards -- required several broken tackles.
"We only had, what, 50 yards rushing today?" Mills asked the media afterward.
Twenty-one yards, he was told.
Mills shook his head. "Mind-boggling," he said with dismay.
Coming off two road games against two ranked teams, Penn State returns to Beaver Stadium Saturday. But the challenge won't dwindle. The Lions face undefeated Purdue, which looks like the best team in the Big Ten this season.
A loss will give Penn State an 0-3 start in the conference. A win will provide a much-needed boost that can validate their improvement. So long as it continues.
"We just need to get over this hump," linebacker Paul Posluszny said. "All this losing, it's not Penn State football. It's our job to change that."
Said Smith: "We're definitely improving every week. Improvement is nice, but sometimes, it's not good enough."
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.