MINNEAPOLIS -- They kept the game close. And that alone spotlighted their deficiencies.

More on
Penn State:
Penn State Notebook: Paterno turns to freshman WR to jolt offense

Late yesterday in their game against Minnesota, the Penn State Nittany Lions needed to make a comeback. But leaning on starting quarterback Zack Mills, who played despite an injured right shoulder, and a running game that could never establish itself, the Lions' offense sputtered when it needed to flourish, leading to a 16-7 defeat against the Golden Gophers last night at the Metrodome before 50,346.

Though Penn State (2-3, 0-2 Big Ten) dropped its second consecutive game, it did many things well. It held one of the NCAA's most potent offenses to just 16 points. It blocked three kicks -- two field goals and one extra point. Even so, the offense struggled, and the combination of Penn State's running and passing game looked, at times, about as unsightly as the Metrodome stands -- a mix of maroon and gold T-shirts and empty purple seats.

Advertise with us

For the game, Penn State rushed for just 21 yards on 22 carries. Mills threw for 250 yards, but much of that was amassed with short dump passes. Most important, the team scored only one touchdown.

"We need to make plays," said Mills, who completed 24 of his 46 passes. "We've scored 10 points in our last two games. That's not very good at all."

At times, Penn State's offense had all the movement of roadkill. Never, before halftime, did the Lions get within 34 yards of the Minnesota end zone. Without injured Michael Robinson, the team's do-everything (or at least try-everything) talent, offensive coordinator Galen Hall searched deep for offensive solutions.

He tweaked his lineup. (Freshman wideout Mark Rubin started ahead of veteran Terrance Phillips.) He used an array of screen passes. (That, at times, served as Penn State's best offensive play.) He tried to establish a running game. ("Tried" being the operative word; in the first half, starting tailback Tony Hunt finished with 38 yards on 15 carries.)

Driving with less than four minutes remaining in the game, Penn State, following a blocked field goal, had a final chance to make it close. But Mills lofted a ball into the corner of the end zone that was picked off by Minnesota safety John Pawielski. The play all but ensured Penn State's eighth consecutive road loss.

Advertise with us

"I told the guys," head coach Joe Paterno said after emerging from the loser's locker room, "I don't have to teach you how to fight. I have to teach you how to win the game."

Much of the fight came from Penn State's defense, which kept the game close. The Golden Gophers entered the game ranked third in the NCAA in total offense, yet Lions made that statistic look misleading at times.

Two big plays, in essence, led to Minnesota's first 10 points. The first play of the game -- a surprise Minnesota onside kick, chopped into the air by kicker Rhys Lloyd and recovered by wideout Jared Ellerson -- gave the Gophers excellent field position. And, it gave the Lions a queasy sense of familiarity.

Minnesota coach Glen Mason had attempted a similar surprise onside kick last year, in a Gophers' 20-14 win. This time around, Minnesota took over at the Penn State 45. Ten plays later, after a 21-yard Lloyd field goal, the Gophers owned a 3-0 lead.

"Disappointing," senior linebacker Derek Wake said. "For them to start the game like that, it was a blow to our optimism."

Advertise with us

That lead would swell on the second big play of the first half. Though both offenses stagnated at times, Minnesota's busted out late in the first quarter, when the team faced a third-and-11 at its own 13. Mason sent three wideouts to the right. Then, quarterback Bryan Cupito handed off to Laurence Maroney, who cut to the right, where he blazed through the Penn State line and suddenly saw nothing but a pasture of green turf. Safety Calvin Lowry dragged down Maroney after a 64-yard gain -- the first time all season Penn State allowed a rush longer than 20 yards.

From there, Minnesota used a conservative stable of running plays to grind the ball toward the Penn State end zone. When the Gophers faced a fourth-and-1 on the goal line, they didn't hesitate. Maroney took the handoff, squeaked behind the left guard and scooted into the end zone to give Minnesota a 10-0 lead. Maroney finished with 146 yards on 25 carries.

Penn State's unsavory tendency to allow long scoring drives immediately after halftime continued last night. This time, an 11-play, 78-yard Minnesota drive to start the third quarter expanded the lead to 16-0. And though the drive itself seemed typical of Penn State this season, the final play of the procession -- a 19-yard run by Marion Barber III -- demonstrated many of the defensive mistakes Penn State had heretofore avoided.

On the run, Barber, jutting to the left, broke three tackles. First from linebacker Paul Posluszny. Then from Lowry. Then from linebacker J.R. Zwierzynski. Finally, Barber was dragged down by Dan Connor. By then, however, he was already in the end zone.

"Guys are real close to making plays," safety Andrew Guman said. "We're trying, and we'll find a way sooner or later to turn this thing around."

Advertise with us

Penn State finally scored in the third quarter, marking the first time in two weeks the team had found the end zone. A plodding drive, keyed by seven consecutive Mills pass attempts, ended when Mills completed a 6-yard pass to tight end Isaac Smolko in the right corner of the end zone.

"I think we have to definitely get things going," Hunt said. "We had lots of opportunities, but you've gotta capitalize. We didn't, and we paid for it."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.