Penn State coach Joe Paterno has been telling anyone who would listen that he was close to getting the Nittany Lions back among the elite of college football.

He has said that he is "one or two" players away from making Penn State a contender again. He feels strongly about the potential of the younger players in the program. And he remained undeterred after the 41-10 beating at Michigan State in the season finale last week, a loss that gave Paterno a Penn State worst 3-9 record and his third losing season in four years.

"I thought we were getting closer until today," said Paterno, who has said he will return for his 39th season as head coach. "Nothing went right. ... It was just one of those years. I really don't think we're that far away, I really don't."

It's hard to imagine how Penn State could manage to turn things around and compete for a Big Ten title next season after the Lions struggled in so many facets this season. But given recent happenings in the Big Ten, it's not out of the question.

Advertise with us

It is not impossible for a team at the bottom of the Big Ten standings to rise from the ashes. Three times in the past 37 years a Big Ten team that came in last place or next-to-last in the standings has come back to win a conference championship the next season, including two teams in the past four years.

Illinois tied for last place with a 2-6 record in 2000 but bounced back with a 7-1 record to win the title in 2001.

Northwestern was 1-7 in 1999 and came in 10th in the league but stormed back in 2000, sharing the title with Michigan and Purdue at 6-2.

It happened with far less frequency before that. In 1967, Indiana shared the title with Purdue and Minnesota after going 1-5-1 and finishing next to last in '66.

So how does this happen?

Advertise with us

Well, how does Michigan lose by 55 points to Penn State one season and then come back the next and win by 31?

It's college football and the cyclical nature of the sport allows for quick turnarounds.

For Penn State to get back to the top of the conference, Paterno will have to address a litany of problems that plagued the Lions this season.

Frame of reference

Penn State doesn't have to look far for inspiration on how to make swift and effective change.

Advertise with us

The Nittany Lions were near the bottom in four important statistical categories in 2001 and managed to do a 180-degree turnaround in 2002 to re-establish themselves as contenders.

In 2001, the Lions were 100th of 117 Division I-A teams in rush defense (206.2 yards per game), 88th in rush offense (119), 84th in scoring offense (22.5 points per game) and 108th in turnover ratio (minus-1). They were 5-6 overall and 4-4 in the conference.

In 2002, when they went 9-4 and played in a New Year's Day bowl game, the Lions ranked 21st in rush defense (114.7), 10th in rush offense (228.6), 13th in scoring offense (34.3) and 14th in turnover margin (1.08).

The difference was experience and talent. Running back Larry Johnson finally got his chance to play behind four seniors on the offensive line and next to a big-play wide receiver in Bryant Johnson.

The 2003 Penn State team and the '01 team have similar statistics in the four important categories. To improve, it is up to coaches to coach better and put some of the most talented players in the league in position to achieve their potential.

Advertise with us

At times this season, it appeared the coaches were out of sync with their play calling. In a home loss to Minnesota, ESPN cameras captured offensive coordinator Fran Ganter slamming down his headphones in disgust after a Jay Paterno play call on fourth down went awry.

It was a peek into the sometimes fractured system Penn State is using, with Ganter calling the running plays and Jay Paterno calling the passing plays. And Joe Paterno takes away the play-calling duties from both of them when he sees fit.

That Minnesota sequence, in which the call came in late from the sideline and threw off the timing of the play, epitomized the problems with the system. Instead of a well-oiled machine, the Penn State offense too many times looked disorganized. Nobody knew where to go and what to do when they got there.

On defense, the coaches never did adjust to having a smaller line and opposing teams exposed the gaps in the rush defense. Without players like Jimmy Kennedy and Anthony Adams to clog up the middle, defensive coordinator Tom Bradley might need to come up with some creative ways to disguise the line's weaknesses. The Lions played straight-up defense this season and the players could not make it work.

Most of the defense returns, so some schematic and/or personnel changes could be in the offing.

Advertise with us

Evaluating personnel

The coaches must make some tough decisions in the coming months and must be prepared to live with the long-term ramifications. Zack Mills and Michael Robinson will compete for the starting quarterback position in the spring. Whoever wins the job should be the starter through the end of next season.

The same goes with the tailback position. Talented freshmen Austin Scott and Tony Hunt were benched late in the season, but they gained valuable experience and one of them must seize the opportunity to start. Perhaps more importantly, Paterno should let one player take the majority of the snaps.

All he has to do is look at the Larry Johnson tapes from 2002. It worked then. If Scott is as good as billed, he shouldn't have to wait until his senior year as Johnson did.

Paterno is convinced he has the makings of a good offensive line. Three first-year starters return next season and E.Z. Smith, who was suspended this season, should return and play center. He started six games as a freshman in 2002.

Advertise with us

The problem area remains receiver. Penn State needs someone to step up and be a big-play receiver. Maurice Humphrey looked to be that player late in the season, but his off-field legal problems have cast even more doubt over this underachieving group.

On defense, the top eight linemen return, but they need to add weight and strength and the coaches have to realize their limitations. Sophomore ends Lavon Chisley and Matt Rice have potential to be impact players, but they don't have the luxury of waiting until their senior seasons to play like veterans. They need to do it next season.

The coaches are excited about the potential of freshman linebacker Paul Posluszny, who will be an impact player in the years to come. High school seniors Dan Connor of Strath Haven and Dontey Brown of McKeesport are expected to sign in February and some expect one or both to compete for playing time right away as Posluszny did this season. If they don't show enough to warrant playing time early, the coaches will have to live with underachieving Derek Wake and perhaps LaMar Stewart for one more season. Stewart sat this season out because of personal problems. He was a part-time starter in 2002.

The secondary loses a couple of fine players in cornerback Rich Gardner and safety Yaacov Yisrael. Yisrael received second-team all-Big Ten honors and Gardner was honorable mention. Calvin Lowry should take Yisrael's place without much of a drop-off at safety, but replacing Gardner looks to be a bigger issue. Sophomore Anwar Phillips was disappointing when he had an opportunity to play.

Sophomore cornerback Alan Zemaitis, a second-team all-conference honoree, is back as are safeties Andrew Guman and Chris Harrell, who split time at the other safety position this season.

Advertise with us

There are other teams out there with bigger holes to fill, but Penn State will need some big contributions from younger players, maybe even some true freshmen, for there to be significant improvement over this season.

Attitude adjustment

Paterno has assembled an amiable cast of players. None of them speak out of turn or criticize their teammates or coaches in the media.

That might be a welcome respite from the days of Larry Johnson and Jimmy Kennedy, but these Lions have been labeled tame. Players with a nasty disposition are few and far between and no one seems to despise losing.

But maybe that's to be expected for a team that is so used to losing. Since November 1999, this team is 23-29.

Advertise with us

"We can't have this laid-back attitude," Robinson said. "We have to be all business and lay things out on the field. We get fired up for games, but sometimes there's not that sense of urgency in the locker room that needs to be there. We can't come out without intensity."

In order to contend next season, the Lions will need to make some adjustments and have some good fortune.

Maybe that's exactly what Paterno is banking on. Maybe he is waiting for some good karma to come his way. Penn State certainly hasn't had a lot of luck the past two seasons.

Paterno, who will turn 77 Dec. 21, would like to prove that those who doubt him are wrong. If he is able to get the Lions back to respectability and have a winning season next year in the final year of his contract, then he may just ride off into the sunset.

It might not be a storybook ending, but at this point, it might be the best he can hope for.

Advertise with us

BOUNCE BACK ... OR JUST BOUNCE

How Penn State has come back from the worst seasons in the Joe Paterno era:

Year

Record

The next year

Advertise with us

Comment

2003

3-9

???

Joe will be back for his 39th season

Advertise with us

2000

5-7

5-6

Win five of last seven in '01 to create air of optimism

2001

Advertise with us

5-6

9-4

Larry Johnson gets his chance and Lions play on New Year's

1988

5-6

Advertise with us

8-3-1

15th in final AP poll after wild Holiday win vs. BYU

1966

5-5

8-2-1

Advertise with us

The Paterno system kicks in in Year 2

1984

6-5

11-1

Set the table for 1986 national championship