Click here to submit your question

Q: When Wisconsin purposely ran offsides twice on kickoffs at the end of the first half to run time off the clock, it raises all kinds of questions about the new clock rules and the integrity of the game. Does it surprise you that a program like Wisconsin would do something so cheap? Do you think this will initiate new tweaks to the game clock rules?

Robert York, Jefferson Hills

FITTIPALDO: I think what it did was it made people on the outside more aware of the rule. For those unaware of the new rules, the clock starts when the kicker's foot touches the ball. In years past, it started when the receiving team touched it. The coaches on both sides, obviously, knew the rule.

Advertise with us

Wisconsin coach Bret Bielema tried to exploit the rule to his team's advantage. Paterno was upset because the officiating crew did not know the rule. Penn State coaches said after the game that the referee was supposed to call an unportsmanlike conduct penalty after the second offsides penalty. Referee David Witvoet did not do that. That's why Paterno was having a fit on the sidelines.

As far as Wisconsin doing something so bush league, yes, I am a little surprised. I think you have a situation where you have a 36-year old rookie head coach who is trying to do everything in his power to help his team win. He thinks he's out-thinking the opposing coach while all he's doing he tarnishing the game. He does not know any better. I'm sure when the time is right he will be told what he did was wrong. In his quest to exploit the rules, he did a disservice to the game of football. You're supposed to play the game within the spirit of the rules. He clearly violated that credo. Here's all you need to know about the way Penn State coaches felt about Bielema's decision. When asked after the game if Penn State had that play in the playbook, defensive coordinator Tom Bradley answered with a curt 'No.' The message got across loud and clear.

Q: The entire season Penn State has lost yards on the pitch to the outside with Tony Hunt. With the exception of Kinlaw running to the outside they have been horrible. So explain to me how Penn State can pitch to Hunt on fourth and 1 in the Wisconsin game? Even more disappointing is that the unimaginative play call came after a timeout. I bet the average per play on that play for Penn State this year is minus-3 yards. Disappointing.

Gary Ostrowski, Kingston, Mass.

FITTIPALDO: I was not enamored with that call, either, Gary. Hunt's strength is running north and south, not east to west. I wanted to see a fake to Hunt up the middle and then a play-action pass with two options. One option is a short, safe route for a first down. The other is a deep pass if the receiver is wide open. That's just me being an armchair quarterback, though.

Advertise with us

I thought the play calling for the entire game left a lot to be desired. How about that reverse to Chris Bell in the red zone? Or the play call on the Morelli interception? In a game like that, where points were at a premium, you have to make sure you come away with points there. It was 3-3 at the time. If you have to pass on that possession, you had better make sure it's a safe route with minimal risks. It was not a great day for Galen Hall or Jay Paterno calling plays.

Q: Penn State has an anemic offense. People blame Morelli's inexperience. This is his third year in the program! I blame Jay Paterno. Please name a quarterback he can take credit for developing. I don't count Michael Robinson because I feel he won with athleticism and determination. He was an anomaly. Zack Mills got worse during his career. Also, why so many passes to the sidelines versus the middle of the field? Penn State receivers have very few yards after the catch. Finally, if the line can't block, why not bring in a few extra linemen like Wisconsin did a few times?

Glenn Linsky, Plano, Texas

FITTIPALDO: Glenn, I recall one play during the Wisconsin game when Penn State max protected. The coaches kept eight people in to block and sent two receivers out into the pattern. And guess what? Morelli still got sacked. That's all you need to know about this offense. The coaches have not figured out a way to protect Morelli. If he had more protection maybe Morelli would be able to throw over the middle more.

Jay Paterno has not had a great record in developing quarterbacks, but you at least have to give him credit for Robinson. No one saw Robinson coming into his own the way he did last season. Give credit where credit is due. When the offense struggles as it has this season, Jay Paterno is criticized. That's the way it should be. As coaches they hand-pick these players and are responsible for developing them. When an offense goes this bad, there is plenty of blame to go around.

Advertise with us

Q: Many Penn State fans have been disappointed in the performance of the offense. Please give us your top three reasons why the offense has been so bad.

Chuck Leech, Sr. Huntington Beach, Calif.

FITTIPALDO: 1. A porous offensive line. 2. Failure by the coaches to adapt to personnel issues with the line. 3. No big plays from the receivers, most notably Derrick Williams.

Q: We are lucky to have won six games so far. I don't see Michigan State as a gimme anymore. Good thing we have good ol' Temple to knock around to get seven wins. We don't deserve a bowl. What we do need is coaching changes, especially at the top and his son. What do we need an offensive line coach for up in the booth? He needs to be down on the field kicking tail!!!

Ron Smith, East Stroudsburg

Advertise with us

FITTIPALDO: Well, I wouldn't say lucky, Ron. Penn State maybe was fortunate to beat Minnesota, but hardly lucky. The Lions made one more play than the Gophers in overtime and they did it on the road. And if Penn State is undeserving of a bowl, you have about 25 or so other teams in the same boat. As for offensive line coach Dick Anderson being up in the booth, his assistant Bill Kenney, who coaches the tackles and tight ends, is on the field. Not that it does much good. They need some linemen kicking tail on the field. Not a coach kicking tail on the sidelines.

Q: There were frequent shots of Joe Paterno jumping all over Mike McQueary during the Wisconsin game. Was this dissatisfaction with the play-calling, execution or a little of both? Obviously, the offense has underperformed this year and I believe it starts with the line. Do you foresee any coaching changes during the offseason with either line coaches or coordinators? Something has to change!

Mick Fulton, Universal City, Texas

FITTIPALDO: Paterno screams at McQueary every game, so that's nothing new. I would love to hear what he is screaming about, though. McQueary is merely the messenger and convenient target because Jay Paterno and Galen Hall work from the press box. Wouldn't it be great if NFL Films had a microphone on Mike for a game without Joe's knowledge? That would be entertainment I would pay for. As for coaching changes, I don't see any being made with Joe's current contract situation. I'm guessing the new coach will want to bring in some new people to work with the line, but that's only if someone is brought in from the outside. I don't see many changes if someone is hired from within to take over.

Log in and chat with Ray Fittipaldo about Penn State football on Thursdays at 1 p.m. .

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.