Click here to submit your question

Q: Although I heard a good deal of chatter regarding Penn State's performance to date, I am probably in the minority in that I feel the Lions are pretty much where I thought they would be at this point. I had them pegged for 8-4 this year due largely to the inexperience factor on both lines. I do have a question regarding Penn State's ability to develop/assess talent on the offensive line. It does not seem that Penn State is recruiting that poorly based on high school performance. A few examples over the past few years include Mark Farris, Dan Mazan, Joel Holler and Greg Harrison. I believe each of these players were blue-chip prospects coming out of high school. It seems that Penn State has done a better job of converting defensive linemen into offensive linemen than developing the offensive linemen they have. , e.g. Charles Rush, Levi Brown and A.Q. Shipley. What gives with developing and assessing talent on the offensive line and is this a problem for other top-flight programs?

Gene Ritter, Suwanee, Ga.

FITTIPALDO: You make some fine points, Gene. Penn State has recruited many blue-chip prospects on the offensive line in recent years who have not panned out. College coaches will tell you that evaluating offensive linemen and projecting them as college players is extremely difficult. In fact, they say offensive linemen are the most difficult players to project. Sometimes the problem is coaches fall in love with a player's athletic ability and do not take into account his football ability.

Advertise with us

There are many linemen who are recruited strictly because they are 6 feet 6, weigh 300 pounds and have quick feet. That does not mean they are good football players. Linemen must have the internal desire to be good. They must attack the weight room and have their nose in the playbook more than any other position. Other programs have had trouble evaluating talent on the offensive line, but not to the degree with which Penn State has. That's what leads me to believe that the problem is in the development of these players. After a while -- and there's been about five or six years of questionable offensive line play -- you have to consider the coaching.

Q: Ray, after watching Anthony Morelli these first eight games it seems that he has a problem going through his progressions and quickly finding his second and third receivers on passing plays. This tends to result in his throwing into tight coverage or having to toss the ball out of bounds. This was pretty evident in the Purdue game. What do you think?

Reed Kohberger, Columbia, Md.

FITTIPALDO: Sophomore receiver Jordan Norwood was asked this week how Morelli has improved this season and he responded by saying that he has done a much better job with his progressions than he did earlier in the season. So it seems like it was an issue early in the year, but maybe not so much now.

Morelli has a tendency to throw into coverage because he has so much confidence in his arm. You have to remember he is young and locking in on receivers is part of the growing process. Looking off defensive backs comes with time. As I said last week, he has played OK, not great. He was lucky on Saturday because he could have been intercepted four times. One of those could have been picked and returned for a touchdown.

Advertise with us

I actually thought Morelli was the better quarterback in the Purdue game. His passes were cutting through the wind and getting to his receivers. I think Deon Butler, Jordan Norwood and Derrick Williams each had one drop. Had they not dropped passes, Morelli would have had an even better day. If you compared Morelli's throws to those of Purdue's Curtis Painter, Morelli was much more accurate because his strong arm was able to deliver the ball through the wind.

Q: I understand the concern and discussion about the play of the offensive line and share concerns about play calling. But my question is in regard to the number of dropped passes by the receivers. It seems every game that one of the receivers invariably drop key passes, especially on third down. This was demonstrated at the beginning of the Purdue game when Deon Butler dropped a pass that would have given the Lions first-and-goal. Dropped passes have killed drives in several big games and I believe prevented Penn State from winning a couple of more games. Is this recognized as a problem by the coaching staff and is anything being done? What's your take on this? Is it my imagination?

Kevin King, Kennebunk, Maine

FITTIPALDO: Paterno was hesitant to place a lot of blame with the receivers for the drops in the Purdue game. He said the wind was so tricky that it made the ball move quite a bit. The receivers acknowledged after the first few drops that they got together and told each other to concentrate on catching the ball before trying to make something happen after the catch.

I acknowledge it was troublesome in the Purdue game, but I don't agree that they could have won more games this season had the receivers caught more passes. I just don't recall them being position to win any games when they dropped passes. The bigger issue with the receivers has been their inability to make big plays for the offense, whether it is by catching a deep ball or catching a short pass and turning it into a long run.

Advertise with us

Q: How are we ever going to find playing time for Knowledge Timmons, Lydell Sargeant and especially A.J. Wallace when Justin King and Tony Davis are sophomores? A.J. needs to be on the field and at least should get some time in the nickel, but all he does is return kicks and runs the occasional reverse. Also, what's happened with Jerome Hayes?

Louie Burton, State College

FITTIPALDO: I think you have a three-year starter and a potential shutdown corner in King, so the Lions are set at one corner position. I think the long-term plan is to have Wallace opposite King. That should happen by the beginning of next season.

Defensive coordinator Tom Bradley played Wallace, Davis and Sargeant three weeks ago against Michigan. It wasn't because Davis was playing horribly, the coaches just wanted to work in Wallace and Sargeant because they have great potential. Wallace got beat for a touchdown in the Michigan game. I don't know if that is why he hasn't played as much in the last weeks or not. Obviously, the defense performed well against Purdue, so I would not expect many changes for this week's game against Wisconsin. As far as Hayes goes, he is playing behind three very talented linebackers in Paul Posluszny, Sean Lee and Dan Connor. Hayes has a lot of potential, but he's going to have to wait his turn.

Q: I don't really know a lot about backup quarterback Daryll Clark. What are his strengths and weaknesses?

Advertise with us

Peng Xu, East Lansing, Mich.

FITTIPALDO: Clark is a redshirt freshman from Youngstown, Ohio. He is a lot like Michael Robinson. He has a lot of natural athletic ability and is very good at moving around the pocket and scrambling. We don't know much about his passing ability because he has not had much of an opportunity to demonstrate it during games. Morelli will be the starter next season, but Clark will have an opportunity to start as a junior. He likely will battle it out with true freshman Patrick Devlin, a highly touted player out of eastern Pennsylvania.

Q: Do you think Tom Bradley will hang around long enough to take over the program or if another job is offered this year will he finally take it? I worry because Bradley is way too good of a coach to be strung alone by Joe's unwillingness to address his retirement. Joe thinks it is funny to make comments like he may be able to coach 10 more years, but I think for a man who has done so much for the university it is wrong and selfish to leave the future of the program in such flux.

Dan VanDyke, Chicago

FITTIPALDO: Bradley's name has been out there for a few jobs over the years, but he has not ever been close to accepting another job to my knowledge. I don't know if that's because he does not pursue many jobs or if it's because there is a perception that he is a Penn State lifer. I think it would be a shame if Bradley never had the opportunity to be a head coach. He has been too successful as a defensive coordinator not to get that opportunity.

Advertise with us

He is a tremendous recruiter and is able to relate to young players today. Many programs have exit strategies in place for when a long-time coach steps aside. Wisconsin, Penn State's opponent this week, had one. Barry Alvarez tabbed Bret Bielema as his successor, and you can see that it has been a smooth transition. The Badgers have not missed a beat. Joe has refused to have one.

It has been rumored that Bradley is the man to take over, but it's far from a done deal. We've heard the theories that Joe is waiting until Jay Paterno, his son, is ready to take over. There are some people who believe an outsider needs to come in and take the reigns, someone like Iowa's Kirk Ferentz, for instance. Paterno's contract runs out at the end of next season, so we'll find out then. I've heard that the board of trustees will not allow him to coach after 2007, but we'll see. Paterno is the one who has traditionally called the shots up there.

Q: Does Penn State have any offensive packages with Derrick Williams at quarterback? It seemed that last year they used his versatility more. I think he could create matchup problems for defenses having to account for his speed.

Michael Graham, Spring City, Pa.

FITTIPALDO: They do have a package where Williams comes in at quarterback, but the coaches have not utilized it the past few weeks. Even when they did run it early in the season, it was not in the red zone, it was in the middle of the field. In case you have not noticed, Williams is not having a great year. He cannot make defenders miss in the open field as a receiver or punt returner, so I'm not sure why you think he would be effective as a quarterback in those situations. Also, Robinson was a quarterback in training as a young player, so he was effective in those goal line situations because he was a run-pass threat. I know Williams was a quarterback in high school, but I don't think he is the passer Robinson was.

Advertise with us

Q: When Penn State punted against Purdue and the Penn State player caught the ball, isn't that the same as downing the ball?

James Haley, Underill, Vermont

FITTIPALDO: No, it is not. My understanding is that the punting team must give the receiving team an opportunity to field the punt and make a play. That opportunity was not given to Purdue. Thus, the penalty was called.

Log in and chat with Ray Fittipaldo about Penn State football on Thursdays at 1 p.m.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.