Click here to submit your question
Q: The level of talent from year to year on offense and defense appears to be equal, but the development of these players is very different. If I was a high school quarterback or offensive lineman, I would not want to come to Penn State. My chances of getting into the NFL would be small. The defense has done a very good job of developing all positions and getting these players drafted, especially defensive linemen over the last several years. The offensive troubles must be attributable to coaching techniques and philosophy. Is it time for a change in these areas?
Bob Griffin, Ponca City, Okla.
FITTIPALDO: You make some excellent points, Bob. Here is some evidence to further illustrate your point. Since 2000, Penn State has had 26 players drafted. Fourteen have played defense, 11 played offense and one was a kicker. But of the 11 offensive players drafted only two were drafted in the first round, Bryant Johnson and Larry Johnson in 2002. No quarterbacks (Michael Robinson was drafted as a running back) and only two offensive linemen were taken. No other offensive player was drafted before the third round.
Of the 14 defensive players drafted, five were taken in the first round and two more were taken in the second round. Tom Bradley and his staff do a great job of developing players and getting them ready for the NFL. The same cannot be said for the offense. Two of those 11 offensive players were drafted despite playing sparingly for Penn State. Matt Kranchick and Ethan Kilmer played minor roles with Penn State, but wound up getting drafted. Did the offensive coaches get enough out of their talent when they were at Penn State? That is certainly up for debate.
Joe Paterno thought the offense was getting a little stale a few years ago and brought in Galen Hall to replace Fran Ganter, but not much else changed. Dick Anderson and Bill Kenney still coach the offensive line and Jay Paterno still coaches the quarterbacks. I would say it's time for more changes, but Paterno is not one to shake up his staff all that much, especially when he is heading into the final year of his contract next year.
Q: After Saturday's game most of us Penn Staters will pick up the rake and start our fall chores. That was pathetic! For a team that has not one, but two, offensive line coaches, what is the problem? Why is the play calling so conservative? Morelli only threw two deep balls. Morelli missed on the one and the receiver did not make the catch on the other. And what really drives me crazy are the stupendous third-down calls where they don't even try to get a first down. Why even try if that's what they're going to do?
Gary Ostrowski, Kingston, Mass.
FITTIPALDO: You're not the only one frustrated with the play of the offensive line, Gary. Paterno was furious at his line after the game and the linemen admitted that they were dominated by the Illinois defensive line. It's not something new. The offensive line has been a problem area for three out of the last four seasons. They have not recruited extremely well and those guys, for whatever reason, are not being developed into players who can compete at the Big Ten level.
The play-calling was a popular topic after the game among the players. Deon Butler, a well-spoken and thoughtful player who is far from a malcontent, said the play-calling did not take advantage of the aggressive Illinois defense. Levi Brown, the left tackle and a team captain, mentioned how there were too many defenders to block. Reading between the lines, the players believe there are opportunities for the offense to be better, but they're just not getting into the right plays. Penn State will be hard-pressed to finish with a .500 record if the coaches don't figure out solutions for the struggling offensive line and do not put the players in better position to succeed.
Q: I read your response last week concerning the development of the offensive line and you say that Penn State has a different program and it takes longer but is safer. Would you like to expand on that answer?
Bob Monroe, Lexington, Ohio
FITTIPALDO: I would say the majority of college teams use Olympic style weight lifting in the strength and conditioning regimen. I don't know a percentage, but it would be upwards of 80 or 85 percent. Olympic style lifting involves power lifting. Players do multiple sets of exercises. For instance, three sets of bench press, three sets of clean and jerks, three sets of squat, etc. At Penn State, players work out for about 30 minutes and do one set of one exercise to exhaustion before moving on to the next exercise. It's something Paterno believes in. Michigan employs a similar training regimen and the Wolverines are never talked about as team with a weak offensive line. Some NFL teams use it, including, I believe, the Steelers.
There are some who believe that the strength program holds players back and does not allow them to develop quickly enough. Others, like Paterno, swear by the regimen because they believe it is the proper way, a gradual way, of developing players physically. When Penn State struggles as it has on the offensive line this season you will hear people say the reason is the strength program. It's going to be a topical subject when the team loses because they are in the minority.
Q: The Illinois game was hard to watch. One observation of mine is that the defensive backfield does not tackle as well as it has in years past. Also, the safeties seem a bit shaky defending the pass. My first question is: are the Lions thin at safety? Next, the offense is offensive. The excuse of inexperience is well-worn. Are the players that comprise the offensive line so much less talented than every opponent or is this a result of poor coaching? Finally, what is Jay Paterno's role as quarterbacks coach and why does he sit in the press box during games?
Chris, DuBois
FITTIPALDO: You saw the good and the bad of the Penn State secondary on one play Saturday. Sophomore safety Anthony Scirrotto missed the tackle that led to Mendenhall's 79-yard run, but sophomore cornerback Justin King ran him down and prevented a touchdown. The defense held Illinois to a field goal. It was a huge play in the game. I would agree that the tackling has not been up to par, but you have to remember that it is a young group. The common denominator among all four of the first-year starters is that they're all tremendous athletes. Once they learn the game, they will put themselves in better position to make plays.
As for the offensive line, as I stated above, I think the poor play is a result of poor recruiting and a poor job by the coaching staff developing these players. I should mention that all college coaches agree that offensive linemen are the most difficult players to evaluate in high school. The tricky part about recruiting tackles, for instance, is that you need to recruit good athletes. But on many occasions the big kids who are athletic don't have tenacity or football instinct. When you have to play unathletic people at tackle, you get exposed by speedy and athletic defensive ends. It's a Catch 22. You really have to have people on your staff who understand what it takes to be a good offensive lineman. I would say Penn State has done less with more at offensive line and at some point, you have to say it's the coaching because it has been a persistent problem. As for Jay Paterno, he shares the play-calling duties with offensive coordinator Galen Hall, so that's why he's in the press box and not on the sidelines.
Q: An observation: When the TV cameras turn on Joe Paterno I have never seen him with a clipboard or earphones or for that matter involved much with any discussion on the sidelines with other coaches or even the players. It makes it look like he's not really running the team, especially when you compare those moments with the activity typically swirling around every other coach.
Chuck Margiotti, Plainsboro, N.J.
FITTIPALDO: To my recollection, that's the way it's always been, Chuck. I don't ever remember seeing Paterno with headsets going back to the 1970s. I could be wrong, but I don't think so. That's the way he likes to coach. He delegates to his assistants and puts his two cents worth in when he feels it is necessary. But I do see your point. The game has changed and head coaches are in constant communication with assistants for most every other team. If you notice, Joe doesn't even accept or decline penalties anymore. You'll see Tom Bradley doing that for the defense. Joe's role is more overseeing and motivating. Take the Illinois game for instance, he watched the first half and then challenged the defense to turn the ball over in the second half. The Lions got four turnovers and won the game. Joe still carries some weight even though the assistants run the team for the most part.
Q: Ray, did the Big Ten ever review the hit on Morelli? It seemed pretty clear that it was a helmet to helmet hit and was definitely after the ball was thrown. The defender could/should have slowed up some. It seemed like the same thing happened when Erasmus James decked Mills and Robinson a couple of years ago and was never penalized during or after the game. If the hit on Morelli took place in the NFL wouldn't there be at least a fine since they try to protect players from helmet to helmet hits?
Bill, Pittston, Pa.
FITTIPALDO: The Big Ten never had anything to say about the hit to my knowledge, Bill. It appeared the Michigan defender caught Morelli under the chin, which technically would be helmet to head. It was a questionable hit, but Paterno didn't seem to have much of a problem with it. He pretty much said 'that's football.' If that hit happened in the NFL, there would have been a penalty and a fine. But in the NFL, they fine you if breathe on the quarterback.
Q: I don't like Posluszny at inside linebacker. Posluszny is a natural outside linebacker where he can better incorporate his speed. Tim Shaw is overmatched at defensive end. I believe the defense is better with Posluszny, Shaw and Connor at linebacker and Josh Gaines and Jim Shaw at the ends. Do you think Sean Lee is that good to warrant moving two of your better players out of their natural positions?
Bob, Cranberry
FITTIPALDO: There is no question the coaches asked Posluszny and Shaw to make some sacrifices this season. It appears that Shaw is really making a sacrifice. I rarely hear his name called and he doesn't seem to have much of an impact on the game from defensive end. Posluszny, after a slow start, is playing really well at inside backer. He made 13 tackles, had a sack and forced a fumble that led to a touchdown against Illinois. He's not having the type of year he did last year, but he has picked up his play in the last few weeks. To answer your question, it was a matter of getting your 11 best football players onto the field. I think the bottom line in all of this is the coaches believe Lee is better than Tim Shaw at linebacker, but they believe Shaw is one of their best 11 players. Lee gets praised by the coaches and his teammates on an almost weekly basis.
Q: Two years ago Penn State landed what many said was the No. 1 recruit in the nation in Derrick Williams. Why has he not developed into a bona fide No. 1 receiver? Is it that he is not as good as advertised or do we not have the right scheme for him?
George Marzano, Philadelphia
FITTIPALDO: Williams is a big mystery to me, George. He seemed like he was a more elusive player in the open field last year. He just does not seem to be able to make anyone miss this year. The coaches say he is getting double-teamed, that he is getting paid more attention. If that's the case, the passing game should be flourishing because Deon Butler and Jordan Norwood would have single coverage. I think the problem has more to do with the offense as a whole than Williams, although I have heard from some Penn State watchers that Williams was a tad overrated as the No. 1 recruit.
Q: An Ohio State fan recently suggested to me that Penn State cut its losses and leave the Big Ten. He observed that Paterno didn't realize how tough the Big Ten would be, citing only two Big Ten titles. He stated Penn State only makes a national title run or conference title every few years, noting that Michigan or Ohio State always dash their hopes. Should Penn State look at the ACC or the Big East? Or be an independent? Or is this guy just trying to get into my head?
David Gallagher, Jamestown, Ohio
FITTIPALDO: Penn State has 14 years invested in the Big Ten. The Lions are not going anywhere anytime soon. The only two teams that have had more success in the Big Ten since 1993 are Michigan and Ohio State. Those two teams have ruled the Big Ten for years. Penn State had the talent to win a conference championship in 1999 and 2002, but got beat in big games. Sure, it's harder week in and week out in the Big Ten, but I think the people at Penn State realized that going in.
Log in and chat with Ray Fittipaldo about Penn State football on Thursdays at 1 p.m.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.