Click here to submit your question

Q: Well, we are getting closer to Ray's prediction of 8-4, which was my prediction for the season. However, winning in Madison does not seem impossible anymore. I don't think it's out of reach for the Lions to win out. So, I will ask: Can the Lions win out?

David, Jamestown, Ohio

FITTIPALDO: I would be really surprised if that happened, David. Wisconsin's only loss of the season came against Michigan and that was a 27-13 game. It appears the Badgers have more than a formidable team this season. To me, the game that will determine how things play out is the game at Purdue next week. If the Lions can win in West Lafayette, they will give themselves a chance at playing in a pretty good bowl game. Because Ohio State and Michigan could play in the Bowl Championship Series, the third-place team from the Big Ten would go to the Capital One Bowl. The fourth-place team would go to the Outback and the fifth-place team to the Alamo Bowl.

Advertise with us

I am penciling in Iowa and Wisconsin ahead of Penn State, which means Penn State would still have a shot at the Alamo Bowl even if the Lions lost to the Badgers. But if they lose that Purdue game, they could be staring at a 7-5 regular season record and date in the Insight Bowl or Champs Sports Bowl on Dec. 29. That's not very attractive for a team that played in the BCS last year.

Q: First, we hear that Penn State is not recruiting well. Then they go out and have some of their best recruiting years ever. Then we hear it is inexperience. Looks to me that it is coaching. I look at what Penn State has not been able to do in the Big Ten since joining: win consistently. Why can the likes of Michigan and Ohio State reload and compete every year and we cannot?

Gary Ostrowski, Kingston, Mass.

FITTIPALDO: Well, I agree that Michigan and Ohio State have won more consistently than Penn State in recent years, but those programs have their down years, too. Look at Michigan last year. The Wolverines were 7-5 and lost to Nebraska in the Alamo Bowl. Ohio State was 4-4 in the Big Ten in 2004, 5-3 in 2000 and 2001 and 3-5 in 1999. In actuality, Penn State is third behind Ohio State and Michigan when it comes to winning consistently.

What sets Michigan and Ohio State apart? The Wolverines and Buckeyes seem to be able to blend their young talent into the fold in a better manner than Penn State, or anyone else, for that matter. They have great foundations, great recruiting bases and great tradition. I would say on the whole Penn State has done a good job of adjusting to the Big Ten, but it would be hard for any program in the country to measure up to Ohio State and Michigan on a yearly basis.

Advertise with us

Q: Why does Penn State have such a difficult time developing offensive linemen? With the exception of last year, it seems like this is a constant problem. If you look at Ohio State and Michigan, they seem to be able to reload and not rebuild with their offensive lines. Lastly, I realize Levi Brown will probably be playing on Sundays next year, but when was the last time Penn State had an offensive lineman drafted?

Ron Calloway, DuBois, Pa.

FITTIPALDO: There's a lot that goes into this, Ron. Penn State has a different method for developing size and strength for their offensive linemen. They have a different weight and conditioning program than the majority of Division I schools. With Penn State's method, it takes longer for players to develop size and strength. It is a safer but slower method of developing players. That's one aspect.

Another is recruiting and development. Penn State has not done a good job of evaluating high school linemen for the past several years. When one of these players flops, it affects your depth. Former North Hills standout Mark Farris, one of the top offensive linemen in the country when he came out of high school, is a senior and has never played a meaningful down at Penn State. Everyone from Michigan to Ohio State wanted Farris. Has Farris flopped or did Penn State do a poor job of developing him? That's up for conjecture. But the point is that there have been far too many Mark Farrises over the years.

The bottom line is that the lines have not been very good for the last several years, last season excluded. To answer your question about the draft, Tyler Reed was drafted in the sixth round by the Chicago Bears in the spring. He was cut but is on their practice squad. Before Reed, the last offensive lineman drafted was Kareem McKenzie in 2001.

Advertise with us

Q: I was at the game last Saturday but being a die-hard fan there were a few plays I wanted to see again so I taped the game. At one point the ABC sideline reporter made a big deal of talking to Chad Henne's high school coach (Jim Cantafio) who was dressed in Michigan garb. It's pretty sad when a Pennsylvania high school coach supports the competition. He was very forceful in his statement that Henne chose Michigan because they have a far superior quarterbacks coach. How do you think this type of comment from a Pennsylvania high school coach might affect future recruiting?

Jim Clark, Cortland, Ohio

FITTIPALDO: I watched the television broadcast as well and was struck by Cantafio's comments and appearance. A high school coach from any state should remain neutral and should not openly root for other teams. That's just my opinion. I feel like there should be some integrity that comes with the position. You can say nice things about schools, but you should not disrespect other schools in the process. Cantafio's comments were clearly directed as a barb toward Penn State.

Cantafio and Penn State coach Joe Paterno at one time had a good relationship, but it deteriorated after Henne chose Michigan over Penn State. Cantafio's comments echoed the comments Henne made earlier in the week about the quality of the quarterbacks coach at Penn State, who happens to be Paterno's son, Jay. Henne said he chose Michigan because he felt more comfortable with Wolverines quarterbacks coach Scot Loeffler than Jay Paterno. Loeffler very well may be a better coach than Jay Paterno, but Cantafio and Henne showed no class by singling out Jay Paterno in the manner they did.

Q: Ray, a couple of observations that I wanted your comments on:

Advertise with us

1. A.J. Wallace, the true freshman, was in on defense a lot. Was someone hurt?

2. The offensive line is not making any improvements although I thought Morelli played well when he wasn't on his back.

3. There were no shots taken down the field on Saturday. I know protection was a problem, but we needed to keep their safeties honest.

4. And lastly, I am a huge Justin King fan, but he needs to wrap people up better. There were at least two plays I remember where he could have made a big stop.

Take care and I love the column. We've got no coverage of PSU football out east.

Advertise with us

Jeff Gotaskie, Philadelphia

FITTIPALDO: Wallace is someone the Penn State coaches believe is going to be a really good cornerback down the road. I don't know if Davis has lost his starting job or not, but Paterno made it clear this week that Davis, Wallace and Lydell Sargeant would be rotating at that corner position. I think the coaches realize Wallace provides a bigger upside than Davis, who is solid but likely will not develop into a top-flight player. I think they wanted to throw Wallace into the fire against a good team like Michigan because they wanted to see how he would perform. According to Paterno, he did well. I know he got beat on the touchdown, but Wallace has speed and all the skills necessary to be a top corner in the country.

About for the offensive line, it's still a work in progress. They had done well running the ball before the Michigan game. Let's give them a pass for last week because Michigan might turn out to be the top defensive team in the country.

It's tough to judge the offense off the Michigan game because the Lions were playing with the third-string quarterback by the end of the game, but throwing deep has not be a strong suit of this team. They need to develop that as a consistent part of the offense.

As for King, I like his attitude. He's not afraid to stick his nose in there and try to make a tackle. He's just a tad too small to come up and tackle running backs who are at full speed.

Advertise with us

Q: Do you think Penn State using so many receivers is slowing Anthony Morelli's development? I think that since he is still a young quarterback practicing and playing with so many could make it harder to get timing down with all those receivers.

Todd Fleck, McKees Rocks

FITTIPALDO: Penn State's top three receivers are Deon Butler, Jordan Norwood and Derrick Williams. Each of those receivers has 25 or more receptions. No other player has more than seven. Brendan Perretta is fourth with seven catches. Chris Bell has five. I know they're playing a lot of different guys, but it seems like Morelli has developed some chemistry with his top three. I believe the passing game will get better over the final five weeks. The offensive line just needs to protect Morelli better than it did against Michigan.

Q: Is Ohio State a "protected" game for Penn State's Big Ten schedule, like Michigan State is? I know Ohio State has never rotated off the schedule, but don't recall ever having heard that it was an official rivalry game.

Jesse Weidaw of Bethel Park

Advertise with us

FITTIPALDO: Jesse, Michigan State and Ohio State are the two teams that never rotate off the Lions' Big Ten schedule. I don't think there is any official designation of it as a rivalry game, but it is a natural game to play every year because of the geographic proximity of the schools and their traditions.

Log in and chat with Ray Fittipaldo about Penn State football on Thursdays at 1 p.m.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.