Q:
I think Penn State could have legitimately won (the Northwestern) game, 70-0. It was their first complete effort of the season and though the red zone faltering is a concern, I think that will come along. Would you agree or disagree? Also, what is the word on Levi Brown?
D.J. Powell of Beltzhoover
FITTIPALDO: It was Penn State's best effort of the season, but as Joe Paterno pointed out after the game, there is reason for concern. If the Lions squander scoring opportunities in games against top 25 teams it will be harder for them to recover. Anthony Morelli and the rest of the offense have to find a way to score touchdowns and not settle for field goals.
But there were several positives to come out of that game, including the strong play of the defense. The defense was excellent again and has now played three very good games after that embarrassing loss at Notre Dame. It's looking more and more as if Tom Bradley is going to have one of the better defenses in the conference and the country before the season is over. As for Levi Brown, Paterno said he is hopeful that he can return for this week's game against Minnesota. He dressed for the Northwestern game but was held out as a precaution.
Q: Morelli looked much better. However, he did throw some ill-advised passes. The score should have been 35-7 art halftime instead of 16-7. What does the offense need to do to be more efficient in the red zone? I don't think it is solely Morelli's fault as they cannot run the ball effectively inside the 20 either.
Mick Fulton of Universal City, Texas
FITTIPALDO: Maybe all they needed was some confidence. After kicking those field goals early in the game against Northwestern, the Lions punched in a touchdown at the end of the second quarter. They went on to score two more in the second half. We'll see if there is a carryover. I just think they need to cut out the mistakes and have someone step up and make some plays. Tony Hunt could be the guy, despite his fumble that ended the first drive.
Q: Anthony Morelli had a terrific game Saturday - the first of many I hope. But in many respects it seemed the Penn State receiving corps just flat outgunned the Northwestern secondary. I wonder do you see Morelli making the proper reads, going through his progressions and adjusting when necessary? Even the pick seemed like a great defensive play more so than a poor decision
Dan Schleichter of Philadelphia
FITTIPALDO: Deon Butler said after the game that Morelli was reading that Butler had man-to-man coverage on the backside, which is where many of those big plays came from. You have to give Morelli credit for recognizing one-on-one coverage and giving his receiver a chance to make a play. I noticed a few occasions where Morelli missed an open receiver, but that's going to happen. No one is going to be perfect.
I think the most important thing to come out of that game was Morelli and the way he responded after that early interception. In my estimation it was a poor throw and a poor decision, but he came right back and had a great day throwing. That showed me something. He proved that he has a strong mental frame of mind and confidence in himself, especially when you consider how the Ohio State game ended.
Q: Given the lack of production from Derrick Williams and the record-setting day from Deon Butler, is Williams -- because of his talent and pedigree -- drawing excess coverage that is allowing Butler to get open more often? Or have Morelli and Butler just developed a natural connection where Deon is Anthony's go-to guy. Or was it just a matchup thing? This isn't meant as a slight to Butler because the guy plays his rear end off. Just wondered.
Jen Kasek of Shadyside
FITTIPALDO: Teams are paying more attention to Williams this season, but he does not seem to have that extra gear that he had last season. The coaches have tried to get him the ball in the open field and he has not been able to make anyone miss and make any yards after the catch. It just does not appear that he has that same burst and open-field ability that he possessed last year.
Butler had one-on-one coverage and exploited it to the tune of 216 receiving yards. He did something Williams has been unable to do all season -- run by his defender. I don't know if Morelli has a go-to guy yet, but Butler certainly has made more big plays this season than Williams. The beauty of having a deep and talent receiving corps is that the opponent cannot double-team everyone. Someone is going to be open. Pretty soon, Butler is going to be the guy drawing the double teams and Williams will be left one-on-one. It will be up to him to make a play.
Q: How would you evaluate Paul Posluszny's play this year?
Michael J. Keller of Aliquippa
FITTIPALDO: I would say, without a doubt, that Posluszny played his best game of the season last week against Northwestern. Posluszny said as much after the game. He said it was the most comfortable that he has felt since last season. Paul admitted that it has taken him some time to adjust to playing middle linebacker. Even this week he said it is a work in progress. But I think Paul and the coaches have to be happy that he is getting close to being his old self. It certainly looked that way against Northwestern.
Q: Loathe as I am to admit that Ron Cook ever has made a point about anything, he did make the rare salient one the other day regarding the wasting of Anthony Morelli's redshirt. So that said, they aren't going to make the same mistake with Pat Devlin, right? Will he, or has he already been declared a redshirt? And while on that topic, same question about Austin Scott? Or is that kid just lost?
Brian Miles of Beechview
FITTIPALDO: Devlin had mononucleosis during preseason camp and did not get much work, so it was pretty much a foregone conclusion that he was going to redshirt after that. I think the coaches have learned a lesson well. When it was time to play some backups late in the game against Northwestern, Paul Cianciolo went in as the third quarterback. Devlin will not play unless there are injuries to players in front of him. As for Scott, the coaches said he had a terrific summer and is ready to play. They are actually doing him a favor by redshirting him. They want to give him the chance to be the No. 1 tailback next season.
Q: Ray, call me crazy but I am making bets with friends that Penn State will be a top five team next year and have a shot at the title game. I know we have a ways to go this year before we can look ahead, but with the line maturing, Morelli taking his lumps this year, a viable back in Scott returning, all those young receivers, not to mention a favorable schedule. You would have to think next year is Joe's best shot at competing for a third national title, right? And if I am not crazy, what type of record do you think they'd need to finish with this year in order to get a top 10 preseason ranking next year?
Dan Vandyke of Chicago
FITTIPALDO: It's so hard to say with seven games remaining this season, but I'll humor you, Dan. The offense will be much better, if only for the reason that Morelli will have one full season under his belt. Having a veteran quarterback is so important in college football. Look around the country. You're hard-pressed to find an upper echelon team with a first-year starter. USC is an exception this season. The line will be good. The receivers should be better than good. The only question mark will be Scott. The only concern on defense would be a replacement for Paul Posluszny, but Jerome Hayes should be able to step in and play well. Perhaps the most important element is the schedule and it is very favorable. Penn State plays Florida International, Notre Dame and Buffalo at home and Temple away in the non-conference. The Lions get Ohio State and Iowa at home. The only tough road game is at Michigan. About next year's preseason rankings, I'm guessing Penn State would have to finish 9-3 to get a top 10 ranking. Of course, a lot of that would depend upon what other teams have coming back, but Penn State certainly will have the talent and the schedule in place for a run at a Bowl Championship Series berth next year.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.