Click here to submit your question

Q: It looks like Penn State is back to its natural offense: slow developing running plays, not much deception and a drop-back passer. In the past in the drop-back scheme, no one was open down field. Last year the quarterback bailed the offense out with his ability to create, which opened up the passing game. Do you think the offense is in for a drought this season?

Frank Kost, Albany, N.Y.

Fittipaldo: That's a good question, Frank. The offense is out of sync. It does not appear the coaches or players are comfortable yet. Anthony Morelli has played well at times, but he has been inconsistent. The receiver rotation, to me, is out of whack. Derrick Williams has played more at tailback than receiver the last couple of games. There are so many different combinations of receivers that it's hard to keep track of who is on the field. As to your question about the drop-back passer, talent wins. I understand that Michael Robinson was a dual threat last season, but it's silly to suggest that Morelli cannot be a success because he does not run. Does Tom Brady run? Does Peyton Manning run? Morelli has a rocket for an arm and some receivers who are regarded as the best in the country. I just don't buy that the lack of a running threat at the position is the root of their problems. I believe it lies in play-calling and finding the right roles for the receivers.

Advertise with us

Q: OK, they replaced the holder and the snapper for field goals and Kevin Kelly still goes 3 for 6, and the misses were gimmees. It appears Kelly is still suffering from a hangover from his Orange Bowl meltdown. Do we start looking for a new kicker now, too?

Mick Fulton, Universal City, Texas

Fittipaldo: Joe Paterno said Kelly had been missing to the right in practice, so he thought he was overcompensating for that in the Youngstown State game. To be fair, those were the first three misses of the season for Kelly. He had been 3 for 3 going into the game. The botched field goals against Akron and Notre Dame were due to bad snaps and bad holds. Kelly never even attempted kicks on those. I think they're going to go through the season with Kelly. If he doesn't improve, I'm sure they'll look to recruit a placekicker for next season.

Q: Has the Big Ten ever considered adding Pitt to the conference? It would seem quite beneficial. It would bring back the Pitt-Penn State game and it could be played again in November. It would also give the league an even number and add more talent in football and basketball.

Greg, Mesa, Ariz.

Advertise with us

Fittipaldo: Pitt is always one of the schools mentioned when Big Ten expansion is brought up, but from what conference executives say, expanding to 12 teams is not going to happen anytime soon. The conference has said that it is not going to add another school just to add a 12th team and balance the schedule. The Big Ten is not in favor of playing a conference championship game, so that is not a consideration for the league. Notre Dame is the school that is talked about most often. But Notre Dame makes too much money as an independent, so it will never join. Pitt, Syracuse and Missouri have been mentioned as well, but there does not seem to be a strong push to get any of those schools to join. Joe Paterno has been on record that he would favor Pitt if there is ever expansion. As someone who covers college football and college basketball, I can say without a doubt that moving to the Big Ten would be a bad move for the Pitt basketball team. It thrives in the Big East. I say keep it the way it is. We've had enough conference shuffling the past few years for my taste.

Q: Ray, on the subject of the Pitt-Penn State game, I wish Penn State would add West Virginia and Maryland back onto the schedule and quit playing the cupcakes. I realize they play a tough Big Ten schedule each year, but I miss the days when they played all of those games in their backyard.

Steve Hoover of Warriors Mark, Pa.

Fittipaldo: I grew up on all of those games, Steve. It was tremendous. Truthfully, I don't know if Penn State would want to play Maryland. The Lions dominate recruiting in that area and playing the Terrapins would only hurt them. I like the idea of playing West Virginia. If Penn State is not going to play Pitt, the Lions should schedule West Virginia like they did with Notre Dame, Syracuse and Alabama. People like you and me want to see those games. As for the cupcakes, they are here to stay. The 12th game is being used as a revenue generator and schools like Penn State will play I-AA teams or lower level I-A teams to fill the schedule. I would not expect more than one marquee non-conference game a season.

Q: You make several good points regarding renewing the great Pitt-Penn State series. I am a proponent of doing this. However, I found one of your salient points regarding renewing the series of particular interest: "The series should be played because it would be beneficial to Pennsylvania football on the whole." Can you please explain how this rationale was applied when Pitt shamefully sat on the sidelines and let Temple (a fellow commonwealth support educational institution) be shown the door by the Big East Conference? I will wait, probably in vain, for your viewpoint.

Advertise with us

Bob Malecki of Binghampton, N.Y.

Fittipaldo: If my memory serves, Temple was given plenty of opportunities to get its football program in shape on and off the field and the Owls failed to do so. Temple drew some of the smallest crowds in Division I-A football. The school was not providing the Big East with much-needed revenue streams. On the field, the Owls were and continue to be the worst Division I-A football program in the nation. Had Temple improved one of those areas, it is not likely the Big East would have shown it the door. But the Owls could not get their act together and the conference had to make a move. A program like Temple can have detrimental effects on a conference such as the Big East in these days of the Bowl Championship Series. I'm not sure how Temple factors into the Pitt-Penn State series, but there's some background for you on their removal from the Big East.

Log in and chat with Ray Fittipaldo about Penn State football on Thursdays at 1 p.m. at http://www.post-gazette.com/chat/

.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.