Click here to submit your question

Q: We got a kick in the face this past weekend, but I'm still of the opinion that this is a highly competitive team that could possibly pull off an upset of Ohio State and can definitely beat Michigan. Besides the obvious -- cutting down on downright fatal errors like turnovers, bad option calls, etc. -- what does this team have to do to make itself a top 15 team?

Alyssa Fussman, New York, N.Y.

Fittipaldo: I am still of the opinion that Penn State will be a good team (8-4 is still my prediction), but I would hold off on the talk of beating Ohio State and Michigan. The Lions are talented, but they remain inexperienced. I believe you will see this team make some big strides later in the season once the younger players are more comfortable. I just don't think they'll be that much better next week. It's asking an awful lot of a team this young to go on the road and beat the No. 1 team. What do they need to do to get back in the top 15? The defense has to get back to where it was last season and the season before. The offense is going to be a work in progress, so the defense must be able to hold teams down. The special teams must pick it up as well. The play of the special teams has been awful through two games. They need the kicking game to help the offense and defense and right now the special teams are doing more harm than good.

Advertise with us

Q: I really feel that our offense will come around to be very good. The defense struggled against Notre Dame. How much blame goes on the coaching? I think it was a bad job on their part.

Donnie Jenkins, Ellwood City

Fittipaldo: When you lose 41-17 I think there's enough blame to go around for everyone. There were physical mistakes and mental mistakes by the players and the coaches. In my estimation, the coaches didn't put some of the players, most notably Anthony Morelli, in the right situations to have success. I'm not a coach, but I liken having Morelli run the option to having Barry Bonds bunt. Or having Michael Jordan set picks. Or having Mario Lemieux play defense. You should play to your strengths and Penn State didn't do that against the Irish.

Q: The fake punt call by Charlie Weis was a little bit of rubbing it in your face and something the Penn State coaching staff will remember. At that point of the game Penn State was getting whipped 27-3. It's OK for Notre Dame to score more points, but why surprise? I thought it was a cheap call by Weis. What are your thoughts?

Gary Ostrowski, Kingston, Mass.

Advertise with us

Fittipaldo: At the time it seemed a little odd, but the explanation afterward was that it was an automatic call by the personal protector, Travis Thomas. All week long in practice, the coaches instructed Thomas to run a fake against a certain Penn State alignment. When the alignment presented itself, Thomas did his job and made the call. I have no problem with it. It was the third quarter, and Penn State had proven that it was capable of moving the ball.

Q: At what point will Penn State pick a few receivers and let them play the game rather than shuffling in a crop of players. Fresh legs only applies to boxers. Your thoughts?

Bill Earley, Philadelphia.

Fittipaldo: By my count, Penn State is using six receivers on a regular basis: Deon Butler, Derrick Williams, Jordan Norwood, Brendan Perretta, Chris Bell and Terrell Golden, who didn't play against Notre Dame. I'd like to see Butler, Williams and Norwood on a regular basis. I feel like they should be on the field when Penn State decides to pass. If they go to four wides, I'd like to see Bell get the majority of the snaps. It's a Catch 22 situation -- Penn State is blessed with great talent and depth at receiver. I'm sure the coaches are going through the process of figuring out how to deploy each of them. Hopefully, they'll have it worked out for the Ohio State game. I agree with you, Bill, I don't like the mixing and matching. They need some continuity in the passing game.

Q: I was thrilled that a talented young man like Justin King, from my Gateway alma mater, chose Penn State, but he is too light to play cornerback in the Big Ten. Can he tackle someone without getting run over?

Advertise with us

Mark Miller, Murrysville

Fittipaldo: King is not afraid to come up in run support, but he has been nothing more than a speed bump in the first two games. He is a little light, but that's no reason for him not play corner. How often did Deion Sanders make hard tackles? If King can be a shutdown corner then he will be doing a great service to his team. Maybe all he really needs to do is tackle lower rather than trying to take on bigger players with textbook chest-on-chest tackles.

Q: Does Jason Ganter get replaced as the holder on field goals? He has botched three attempts in two games. The first two in the Akron game can be attributed to the weather. But the one against Notre Dame was an omen of things to come. He is listed as a safety on the roster, correct? Well, with the other safeties also dropping interceptions, it's obvious why they aren't receivers. Why not put the backup quarterback as the holder?

Mick Fulton, Universal City, Texas

Fittipaldo: Ganter is still listed as the holder on the depth chart, but I have to believe the coaches are considering their options there. Ganter did a good job as the holder last season, but it's beginning to look like there's a mental block there. If they can get a couple of field goals off without a hitch, he might be able to save his job, but one more mistake and he's likely headed to the bench.

Advertise with us

Q: Your answer to the person last week who asked about Pitt fans getting over the loss of the Pitt-Penn State game got me to thinking about the game. Playing the game on a warm September day when the season is just getting started isn't the same as the way it used to be when it was played post-Thanksgiving in the cold. I'm not sure if it would be better to let the series die as a great memory than live on as a poor imitation of itself. This was a prelude to my questions: Could it ever be as great as it once was? If Pitt really needs this game, why not play two years out of three at Penn State? Historically, the game was played almost exclusively in Pittsburgh until about 1970. The reason for that, as I've always heard, is that Penn State, as the lesser of the two programs back then, needed the game to give the program credibility. If the shoe is on the other foot now, why shouldn't Pitt do the same? And all of the reasons I've seen for resurrecting the series seem to involve benefiting Pitt football or Western Pennsylvania football. I've never seen any clear description of why resurrecting the series would be of tangible benefit to Penn State specifically. Do you know of any?

Harry Engleheart, Newburyport, Mass.

Fittipaldo: Allow me to answer your first question and then I'll move on to the others. I agree that it will never be the same as it was in the 1970s and 1980s. Those were different times. Both programs were thriving as independents and the games helped the national championship picture develop on several occasions. Now the schools are in different conferences, and yes, early-season matchups are not as attractive for me either.

As for your second question about a two-for-one series, you'll never see Pitt go for that. The Pitt athletic administration told Penn State to forget about any such arrangement and it was the right call by the Panthers. I find it funny how Penn State fans view the state of their program. Before the first-ever Bowl Championship Series bowl game last season, Penn State had four losing seasons in five years. What makes any Penn State fans think that the Lions are on better footing than Pitt? Pitt is the perfect example that making a BCS bowl game guarantees nothing. After playing in the Fiesta Bowl in 2004, Pitt fell back to reality last season with an average season. Let's view the Pitt-Penn State discussion as something that would be beneficial for both programs. The series should be played because it would be beneficial to Pennsylvania football on the whole. It's silly to suggest that Mississippi should not play Mississippi State. Or USC should not play UCLA. Or Oregon should not play Oregon State. That's what Pitt-Penn State was, a great in-state rivalry. You play the game, regardless of conference affiliation, because it's the right thing to do. Plain and simple. Don't make it anything more than that.

There were a few other questions about the Pitt-Penn State series in my email this week and I just wanted to address one common subject. Some suggested that no one outside of Western Pennsylvania care about the series. All I can say to that is when the series is brought up to former Penn State players, every single one of them says they want the series to be renewed. The players who took part in the games understand the magnitude of the series, regardless of where they grew up. Many of them are not even native Pennsylvanians.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.