Greetings, Q&A readers. Sorry for neglecting this fine forum last week; I, too, was enjoying the bye week, and I figured if I wrote a Q&A for last Friday, I would not have generated enough questions during the ensuing week to create a viable Q&A today. Thus, I decided to give priority to this week and create a compilation of questions I've received in the last two weeks.

Also, a note about my bye week. (Which was really one off day, Sunday.) I was fortunate enough to see Texas songwriter/deity of country music Pat Green (www.patgreen.com) in concert Sunday night at a small club in Washington D.C. I mention this for at least two reasons: First, it was perhaps the finest live performance I've ever seen, and I've seen many. Pat plays an amazing show -- endless energy, tremendously loyal crowd, music that seems to link country, folk and rock. I'd recommend it to anybody. Oh, and the second reason I mention this: For the next few years, I want to be able to "Google" my name along with Pat's and have it pick up at least one match.

Now, on with the Q&A. I received some fantastic questions this week. Competition for the Ira Rothstein award -- given to the best questioner this year -- is fierce. Currently, 34 people are on the semifinalist list -- which is to say, half as many as are on the Davey O'Brien list.

Q:

Advertise with us

Have you seen NCAA Football 2006's likeness of JoePa? It's ridiculous. He looks like a 40-year-old jackrabbit. Come on EA Sports, if you are going to represent five coaches in your game, one of them should be the legendary JoePa.

Coy Danforth of Syracuse

HARLAN: This is an Ira Rothstein contender; perhaps the frontrunner. Honestly, I have debated this question myself for many months before you put it so succinctly into words, Coy. (Disclaimer: Though I am a Syracuse man myself, I do not know Coy. I did not put him up to these shenanigans.) Anyway, let me say that Paterno's depiction in this video game -- which I have played frequently -- qualifies somewhere between careless and horrific. When I've played with friends, the post-game handshake invariably prompts some smarmy comment about how Paterno looks like some generic New York City cab driver. Or some kind of George Costanza half-brother, the one with a full head of hair. It's sad. I would pin the graphic troubles on the inability to capture Paterno's age and generally distinct hairline. If the EA game programmers had spent even a few minutes trying to add these details, they would have improved his likeness tenfold. And I agree -- because it's the college game, and plenty of lesser coaches have low profiles, there's no need to perfectly depict every head man in the WAC and the MAC and the Ivy. But EA should have picked a few. Guys like Paterno and Spurrier, for sure. I know that EA Sports has the capability to nail these depictions, because they've done it well in Madden. However, in NCAA '06, every time the cameras show a sideline image of Paterno, it just doesn't feel like the Penn State coach we all know.

Then again, considering Paterno doesn't have much use for a cell phone or a personal computer, I'll take a guess here that his exposure to NCAA '06 is fairly minimal. Probably doesn't bother him much.

Q:

Advertise with us

What are the chances of Derrick Williams returning to play in the bowl game for the Lions?

Len of Venice, Fla.

HARLAN: Not huge, Len. Williams wants to return, and it's still the goal toward which he's working, but it looks like the team isn't pushing for it. When doctors prescribed somewhere between three and four months of recovery time, it wasn't because they were rooting for a Penn State bowl loss. It was because they figured that he needed that much time, minimally, to make a complete recovery. I can understand why Williams wants to overcome this prescribed limitation, and I certainly don't fault him for trying. Chances are he'd be physically able to at least dress for a bowl game. Question is, would playing be worth the risk? If Williams isn't completely recovered, then his odds for worsening the injury (even with one hit) are great. Considering that Penn State has been just fine without Williams at wide receiver, and considering that Penn State needs Williams to be 100 percent for next season, I think the Lions would be wise to keep their star freshman out of the game. He'll be disappointed, but unless he's 100 percent, they shouldn't let him go.

Q:

Now that teams are interested in Tom Bradley, don't you think it is time for JoePa to make a statement about what he intends to do? I do not think that we can afford to lose Tom because of his coaching ability and the way he is able to recruit the talent he does.

Advertise with us

Warren Quinn of Schuylkill Haven, Pa.

HARLAN: Sure, I guess your string of logic makes sense, Warren, but I see one major problem. How can Paterno announce his plans for the future when he himself has no friggin' clue about what will come next? Paterno has admitted, even recently, that he does not know how much longer he will coach at Penn State. Could be two more years. Could be ten more years. It's predicated, of course, on his health, his family's health and his team's success. And those are variables that defy prediction, especially when you're talking about several years down the road.

I agree, if Paterno felt that next year (or this year, obviously) would be his last, then certainly he would be wise to quickly erase the questions about his successor. (One side-note: Don't assume that Paterno, when the time comes, will be given full power to decide Penn State's next coach.) But as it is, Paterno cannot make any sort of statement. Though uncertainty about the future might frustrate fans -- especially now that Bradley is drawing some interest as a head coach elsewhere -- it would be even more irresponsible for Paterno to make promises about the future when he'd have no definitive way of holding them. So long as Paterno doesn't know his own timetable for retirement, he can't even begin to talk about who might replace him.

Q:

Looking towards next year, what kind of team do you see? With most of the team being seniors this year, does JoePa have the talent pool to put together another strong team? I do know that Morelli will be a fine QB when he gets into the game; however the offense may sputter early due to his inexperience. Also, what will the loss of the option game do to the offense?

Advertise with us

Chris of Warren

HARLAN: Interesting question, Chris, but before I answer, let me first note that this year's Penn State team has proven once and for all the crapshoot involved when predicting football seasons. I'm the windbag, after all, who thought this group of Lions would finish with a 7-5 record (counting one entirely unmemorable bowl trip). So before I tell you what I see next year, I should note that, um, I don't see very well.

Anyway, onward I go: I agree that Morelli will be OK next year. Heck, he might even be fantastic. I've been impressed with his arm strength and general functionality during his spot performances this season. Granted, he hasn't been given much action in competitive games, so it's tough to formulate a truly valid opinion. But he'll enter 2006 much as Robinson entered 2005: with little experience, but also plenty of potential. Even better, Morelli will already have a fleet of super-talented wide receivers. He'll also have a senior tailback, Tony Hunt, to relieve some of the pressure. In short, he'll begin the season with the ideal weapons around him. The only concern on offense is the line, which loses four of its starters. (And that's assuming junior tackle Levi Brown doesn't jump to the NFL.) Morelli is obviously more of a pocket passer than Robinson, so he'll rely on capable pass protection. That said, if line play approaches average, Penn State will have a prolific offense next season.

The defense concerns me, though. Penn State will have perhaps the best group of linebackers in the country (again, assuming Paul Posluszny stays in school), but with the other two units -- on the defensive line and in the secondary -- Penn State will essentially be starting over. No matter who steps in next season, the defensive backs will struggle at times. The defensive line will be solid in the middle -- with Jay Alford as a returning starter and Ed Johnson likely returning to the team -- but on the outside, the Lions will be weak. No player on next year's roster will be able to replicate the roles of Tamba Hali or Matthew Rice. As a result, the pass rush will suffer. Quarterbacks will have more time to throw. And receivers will have an easier time to get open. A dangerous combination.

In a way, Penn State, as I project it, will fit the profile assumed by several Big Ten teams this season. It's weird, because the Big Ten has a track record as a low-scoring, grind-it-out league, but this season, the conference is inhabited by teams that can score at will but cannot stop anybody. Northwestern and Wisconsin fit this mold, to name a few. And next year, I'm guessing Penn State might be similar to the '05 versions of the Badgers and Wildcats. Maybe PSU's linebackers will still help the defense remain respectable, but I'm fairly certain the D will have some rough spots, and probably cost the team a few games.

Advertise with us

Q:

Hey, Chico! I enjoy reading your Q&A each week while I serve the Navy here in Norfolk. Thank God for GamePlan so I can watch my Nittany Lions instead of these ACC teams! Anyway, this weekend will decide the B10 champ, and for once the OSU/UM game is not the finale. I have two questions: Does the outcome of the other game in Michigan impact Joe's game plan in East Lansing? Also, do you think we should take the ball or defer if we win the toss? I guess I am asking if you think it is more important to try and get an early lead or try to shut Sparty down right away.

Joe of Norfolk, Va.

HARLAN: For once, I actually feel strongly about this. (OK, not STRONGLY. That's the wrong kind of word for any opinion about a coin flip. Maybe I should say, instead, that the logic here is obvious.) If the Lions win the toss against the Spartans, they should elect to receive. In a heartbeat. Here's why: Yeah, Michigan State can be a dangerous team, simply because of its offensive firepower, but I'd also guess that it's a team that can fold more quickly than origami. If the Spartans can't keep the game close in the first quarter, they aren't the kind of team that will persist with much energy. I feel that if Penn State grabs an early lead, Michigan State will suddenly become a very tame and feeble team. The opposite is true if the Spartans grab an early lead; though they're a team that's lost four out of five, one little spark of hope might reawaken them. So it seems obvious if you're Penn State. Take the ball, score early and basically force Michigan State into submission.

Q:

Advertise with us

Hey Chico, was it just me or did Calvin Lowry actually have a nice punt return in the game against Wisconsin? Since I am an avid reader of your column, I noticed that a lot of your questions/comments were on Lowry and how awful of a punt returner he is, so maybe we should bust on him even more in the upcoming week in hopes of him possibly breaking loose once again for a nice return.

Chris of Annville

HARLAN: Gotta admit, Chris, that Lowry has basically been a human dartboard for this Q&A this season. He's been jabbed by all of us; nothing personal, obviously, but he's simply a lousy punt returner. And, worse, somebody who keeps that role despite his painfully clear shortcomings. I'm not going to let one career-long return change my opinion of his ability. I guess I should acknowledge the accomplishment: he brought one back for 43 yards against Wisconsin. Hooray! But remember, his other three returns totaled 12 yards. I think the general rule about Lowry is as follows: He trips when other returners would not; he falls into defenders when other returners would dodge them; he finds three yards when other returners would find 10; and on the occasion that he returns a punt for 43 yards, I think it's safe to say that such success evidences that natural law that even blind squirrels sometimes find nuts.

Q:

Two questions while we wait for the Michigan State game:

Advertise with us

1. What the heck is Robbie Gould doing kicking for an NFL team?

2. How can a guy who missed damn near every important field goal in his collegiate career make a game-winner for the Chicago Bears?

I would appreciate your help in illuminating this perplexing turn of events.

John Penner of Los Angeles

HARLAN: Perplexing is the perfect word, John. Penn State is sure having a charmed year, eh? If Robbie Gould can land himself a full-time NFL job -- he's converted seven of 11 field goals this season with the Chicago Bears -- then it's only a matter of time before Maurice Humphrey wins a gold medal in the 2008 Summer Olympics and all 32 NFL teams join in a frenzied bidding war for Curtis Enis. I mean, I'm having a hard time thinking of any personnel development more improbable than Gould's emergence. I wish I could help you, John, but I'm having a hard time explaining it. I guess the thing is, confidence, especially with kickers, is so vital. And it can also be fickle. Certainly last year Gould didn't have much of it; he converted only seven of his 13 field goal attempts. Against Iowa, he missed from 51 yards and 25 yards and Penn State lost, 6-4.

Advertise with us

Gould always had a respectable leg, but only now has he put it to use. But understand one thing, John. Even now, his statistics aren't fantastic. He's made seven of 11 field goals, but that percentage is the kind of thing that places kickers on the cutting block. Most NFL teams expect their kickers to convert roughly 80 percent of their field goals. Anything less is problematic. The mini-world of NFL kicking is so cutthroat that if a placekicker doesn't immediately establish himself as reliable, he is quickly disposed of. Gould is being given a great chance here, so hopefully he takes advantage. Though he's accomplished much already -- because yeah, even getting this far was improbable -- he still faces an immense challenge.

Q:

How ironic it would be if some way, some how, Penn State ends up facing the team that it spent the summer learning the spread offense from, Texas, for the BCS Championship. I know Mack Brown and JoePa are great friends but is it common practice that coaches help each other to this extent?

Mike Davic of Pittsburgh

HARLAN: First of all, it's very unlikely that Penn State and Texas play in a bowl. That's simply because Texas must first lose (thereby giving hope to the chances of a PSU-'Horns Fiesta Bowl match-up) or USC must lose (thereby allowing a slight chance for a PSU-Texas Rose Bowl). Either way, I think it's improbable. But as for the second part of your question, it's actually quite common for coaches to take annual "field trips" to other schools to exchange ideas and strategies. Penn State does it almost every year, actually; only this year, for some reason, did the trip attract any attention. Generally, a school will pick a program to visit that shares some similarities (talent, size, etc.) but plays in a different conference. Texas worked well this year because the Lions wanted to leave Austin with some ideas about employing an athletic quarterback in the offense. Not only do Brown and Paterno know one another well from Nike trips, but moreover, both teams' offensive coordinators share deep roots. This year, the trip worked well, but I'll say it's highly unlikely that there's any sort of holiday reunion.

Advertise with us

Q:

Is Poz really the best linebacker ever at Penn State, as Jack Ham has stated? Remember that guy -- Lavar Arrington? Not taking away anything from Poz.

David of Jamestown, Ohio

HARLAN: Tough for me to say, David. I never saw Ham play, so I don't feel safe making a comparison. Posluszny, who's watched film of Ham from his Steelers days, doesn't think there's much of a contest. He says Ham is the better player -- by a landslide. That sounds, to me, like undo modesty, which is exactly Posluszny's style. At least comparing him to other linebackers in the Big Ten, I don't think there's any question his only peer is Ohio State's A.J. Hawk. I bet Hawk receives the Butkus award this season, mostly by virtue of his seniority, but I'd still be willing to make a case that Posluszny is the more complete player.

Q:

Advertise with us

Chico, last Tuesday you mentioned that Penn State is looking for a new opponent to replace Louisiana Tech next year. The same day, your fellow writer on the Pitt side reported that Pitt is looking for another D-I opponent next year. I see a common solution here. Do you? What type of forces would be required to make that happen?

Dan of Devon

HARLAN: Won't happen, Dan. Wish I could provide you with even a kernel of hope, but I can't. When I floated the possibility by athletic director Tim Curley last week, he basically dismissed the idea, and it seemed to me like if we'd been sharing a few beers instead of a formal conversation, he would have just laughed in my face. It's too illogical. In this case, the Pitt-Penn State arrangement (or lack thereof) won't happen for one main reason. The two teams have their open weeks on different weekends, so even if one school agrees to change its schedule to create the dream match-up, said program will not have solved its problem -- it will still have a hole in its schedule, just on a different weekend.

As it is, Pitt is slated to play Michigan State on Sept. 16. That was the date on which Penn State was supposed to play Louisiana Tech -- that is, before Tech backed out one and a half weeks ago. This curveball was thrown at Penn State so late, it will struggle to find a Division I-A opponent that doesn't already have a game scheduled that week. (Or, if a team has an open spot that week, it probably wants to save it as a bye week.) That's why Penn State will probably have to settle for a Division I-AA opponent. Then again, that's not the worst thing. Because look at the Lions' opponents before at after that weekend. On Sept 9: at Notre Dame. On Sept. 23: at Ohio State.

Looks like they could use a serious breather in between.

Advertise with us

Q:

Chico, great work on keeping us Lions fans informed every week. For argument's sake, let's say that Pen State had won the Michigan game and ran the table to an undefeated 11-0 season. With the current BCS mess, I believe Penn State would have been served another injustice going undefeated and no title game to go to because USC and Texas are ranked one-two. Your thoughts?

Jim Sassak of Beckley, W.Va.

HARLAN: I was talking about this with a co-worker a few days ago, a dude who's an ardent Penn State fan. "You know," he said, "losing to Michigan was really a blessing in disguise. Because if we were 10-0 right now, I'd just be so frustrated with [being behind Texas and USC] that I wouldn't even be able to enjoy the season." Interesting idea. I'm not sure if that sentiment speaks for all Penn State fans, but I do think he has a point. Had Penn State deflected that final pass in Ann Arbor in mid-October, the Lions would still be undefeated -- but they would also likely be on the wrong side of the national championship picture. The Lions' situation, most likely, would mirror Auburn's one year ago.

So was Penn State's loss a blessing in disguise? Well, that's tough to truly rationalize. But I agree that it's prevented LOTS of complaining. (Not that it would be unreasonable complaining; the BCS system is absurd, illogical and possibly neurotic, considering the bonanza college football lovefest that a playoff would generate.) Anyway, that's a footnote to the more relevant point. The difference between a 10-0 Penn State team and a 9-1 team is fairly clear: If the Lions had defeated Michigan, they would be ranked third in the BCS instead of fourth. So yeah, you make a good point, Jim. Third would feel like an injustice. Fourth, at least for now, certainly doesn't.

Advertise with us

Q:

(Editor's note: This is not really a "Q." It's better described as an "O" -- as in, observation. Or, a "TO," as in, timely observation. Well, TO is already taken, and we're sick of him. Perhaps an "AO," as in, an astute observation. Yeah, that works. Anyway, Nate from State College wrote this for submission, and I figured I'd publish it and spread the knowledge. Props to Nate for the research. I'd give him a cash reward or something, but the Q&A runs on a strict and fixed budget of zero dollars.)

Sorry to send you such a lengthy letter, but there's a strange quirk in the wording of the BCS selection process that could effect PSU in a potential BCS bowl if they take care of business this weekend.

According to the BCS Web site:

"Any BCS bowl game(s) still remaining unfilled will submit a listing of its top three team selections to fill its at-large slot. Any team that is guaranteed a berth in a BCS bowl game and that has not already placed in such a game must be listed among such bowl game's first two selections. Each BCS bowl will then be given its highest preference of teams."

Advertise with us

So, let's say everything stays the same. USC, Texas, Miami, and LSU are locked into their games. (USC and UT in the Rose Bowl, Miami in the Orange Bowl, and LSU in the Sugar Bowl.) It seems to be a foregone conclusion that an eligible Notre Dame team would be the first pick of the Fiesta Bowl, who gets first pick of any eligible team to fill the void left by Texas.

Two teams would remain with automatic berths, Penn State and West Virginia. According to the above rule, both of these teams would need to be among the top two choices in their pecking order. Assuredly, every bowls request would look like this: 1. Penn State 2. West Virginia 3. Ohio State/Virginia Tech/Alabama

If it that went that way, the BCS match-ups would be: Rose: USC-Texas Fiesta: ND-WVU Orange: Miami-PSU Sugar: LSU-other at-large team

The only way the Fiesta Bowl could avoid getting West Virginia is by picking PSU with its first pick. Then it could assume the Orange Bowl would pick Notre Dame, and list a different team as its No. 1 with West Virginia as No. 2. The ballots might look something like this... Orange: 1. Notre Dame; 2. West Virginia; 3. Ohio State Fiesta: 1. Alabama; 2. West Virginia; 3. Notre Dame Sugar: Doesn't really matter, they get stuck with WVU.

That would give us bowl match ups of: Rose: USC-Texas Fiesta: PSU-Alabama Orange: Miami-Notre Dame Sugar: LSU-WVU

Advertise with us

Of course the BCS reserves the right to reshape the bowls if they feel a more compelling match up can be achieved. But if it adheres to its own rules, the Fiesta Bowl would have to choose between getting Notre Dame or not getting the black sheep of the BCS [the Big East representative].

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.