Q:

Howdy again, Chico -- I thought I'd give you a chance to step away from the usual questions and ponder what, prior to the start of this season, may have seemed in the realm of absurd ... Ethan Kilmer, NFL star.

Have your own question?

Click here to submit your question

Advertise with us

While "star" may definitely leap towards hyperbole, Kilmer seems to me to be the type of player who could have a long pro career as a special teams demon (a la Don Beebe). I can't recall a Penn State player being as dominant as has Kilmer; if he hasn't made EVERY special teams tackle the last couple of weeks, then it only seems like it. He has the speed necessary for such a position, and his playing career has been made mostly through effort, a trait also required for such future employment. While he probably won't be among the number of Nits taken in next year's NFL draft, Kilmer could be a great pick-up for some team as a free agent. Your thoughts?

Chris Santinoceto of Wheeling, W.Va.

HARLAN: Well done with the question, Chris. You know I like out-of-the-box questions -- be it regarding guacamole or Toby Keith or Ethan Kilmer -- so I'll gladly give this one a try. Had you used "Kilmer" and "NFL" in the same sentence only two months ago, I would have laughed. That's like a duet with Eminem and Sting. Even now, the notion of this senior walk-on -- mind you, somebody who didn't play football in high school after ninth grade -- making it as a pro seems far-fetched. But I admit, it's an intriguing possibility. At first blush, thinking about this scenario, I'd say it's fairly likely that Kilmer will receive an NFL tryout. He's still a long shot for a regular roster spot, but I won't count him out. Certainly, he's already overcome longer odds.

Kilmer, without question, has the physical gifts to play in the NFL. He has superb speed, and his vertical ability and strength would make the meat-market pro scouts start salivating. More importantly, Kilmer has developed some amazing instincts as a special teams player. I first noticed his knack a few games ago, when he literally flew three yards in the air to tackle a punt returner from behind. He plays like a kamikaze, running downfield and sometimes breaking through two or three blockers to make the tackle. Last Saturday, he had six of them, forcing one fumble. No doubt, Kilmer is already an NFL-caliber special teams player.

Here is why Kilmer still might struggle to make an NFL roster, though. When pro teams fill their rosters, they do indeed need players who can hold down key roles on special teams. But they don't have much room for players who can ONLY perform on special teams. Right now, Kilmer must improve drastically as a wide receiver. He is simply a raw talent as it stands. In the NFL, fifth and sixth wide receivers still must be talented pass-catchers. Only very rare players -- like the Steelers' Sean Morey -- stand out as counterexamples. You mention Don Beebe, the former (and much beloved) Buffalo Bill. One season, Beebe had 40 receptions, and during his time with Buffalo, he never finished with fewer than 11. My point is, Kilmer can get a shot at the NFL because of his special teams ability, but he might need to add slightly to his skill set before he can stick around.

Advertise with us

Q:

Historically, JoePa has been loyal to his seniors and played them ahead of possibly more talented underclassmen. I guess that helps explain leaving Calvin Lowry as punt returner. However, looking ahead to next year, who would be in the running to succeed Calvin? I think Kinlaw has taken himself out of the running with having kick-off returns of 70 and 58 yards the past two games. Having an elusive and quick returner puts the defensive coverage at too much of a disadvantage. Maybe BranDon Snow will be successor. He did well running straight ahead Saturday and not dropping the ball. What do you think?

Mick of Universal City, Texas

HARLAN: Hahaha, I'm practically rolling out of my chair right now, Mick. Gotta admit, at first I didn't pick up the sarcasm of your question. I was just about to edit it, thinking you'd misspoken. (After all, how could a 70-yard return hurt Kinlaw's cause?) Then, I realized your point -- simply tremendous.

So let me continue, channeling your sarcasm. I do think Snow would be a tremendous punt returner, provided he uses the offseason effectively. First, coaches should notify him as soon as the season ends that he will asked in 2006 to fill Lowry's shoes. And from that moment on, Snow should be prohibited from any drills that might potentially improve his speed, hands, coordination or general confidence in catching balls falling out of the sky.

Advertise with us

He should also be told explicitly that Penn State does not wish for its punt returner to break open long runs or help the offense gain field position. Snow should be informed that not catching punts and instead allowing them to roll 15 yards backwards is highly encouraged. Catching the ball and running backwards is also optional. Fair catches, though OK, are dangerously close to qualifying as a positive outcome, and should be limited. In the unfortunate event that Snow gains more than 30 yards on any particular return, he will face either deportation or an immediate forced transfer to Ohio State. Dick Anderson will be asked to recite Snow's Miranda Rights.

In the event that Snow fails to live up to these dubious requirements, he will be summarily replaced by somebody who can fulfill the task. You know, somebody like Levi Brown.

Q:

Remind me again: Why is Calvin Lowry returning punts?

Charles Boots of Connellsville

Advertise with us

HARLAN: Good question. I bet others are wondering the same thing. As in, everybody except Joe Paterno.

For instance:

Q:

I feel like I'm losing my mind when I watch Calvin Lowry run in circles, and if he's lucky, make a fair catch and hold the ball at the 4-yard line. What reasons has Joe given for keeping him back there? It's only a matter of time until it costs them a game. I understand it's a topic that's been brought up before, but I'm just wondering what possible explanation Joe can have when Calvin is easily the worst return man I've ever seen, and I'm not exaggerating.

Dave Paserba of Butler

Advertise with us

HARLAN: OK, I'll touch on Lowry once more, and then I'll put the issue to rest, so as not to jump on the poor guy too much. (Or perhaps it's already too late.) First of all, let me state that, in all seriousness, I cannot find one reason to defend Lowry as a punt returner. It is absurd, borderline insane, that he's managed to keep this job, especially on a team where dozens of players could out-perform him. At this point, I don't even blame Lowry; I blame the coaches. Calvin's been returning punts -- or at least trying to -- since his sophomore season, so that means he's worked on this particular skill for countless hours over three years. After a while, it becomes painfully obvious that he lacks whatever makes a solid punt returner. I'm not sure if Lowry needs more speed or more confidence or better coordination, but no matter. Whatever he's lacking, it won't magically appear.

That's why I blame the coaching staff. Somebody, by now, should be keen enough to encourage this change, because it will make Penn State a better team. Lowry should be removed before he costs the Lions a game. Penn State is asking Lowry to do something of which he is clearly not capable.

Following the Purdue game, one reporter asked Paterno about the punt returning situation, slyly bringing up the topic by asking if Rodney Kinlaw might have the talent to become a good punt returner. Paterno, instead, stood up for Lowry by saying, "The one thing that I have always felt that when you are going to run punts back is the first thing you have to do is get a guy who can catch the ball." This was how he defended Lowry after a game in which Lowry had DROPPED a punt! When Paterno said that, media members were literally stifling their laughter. Not that anybody disagreed with his premise -- of course you want a returner who can catch. That's obvious. But it's equally obvious that Lowry isn't that guy.

Q:

Chico, I'm a big believer that in order to have success, you need to have some guys who step up and emerge as leaders. It's clear that on this year's squad -- MRob, Poz, Zemaitis and Rice -- have all stepped up as leaders. I especially liked the clip of Rice, while walking off the field after the come-from-behind win at Northwestern saying, "This game's over. Now we focus on Minnesota." Anyway, who do you think is being talked about in terms of stepping up next season to lead a much younger team? Poz will still be there, but who else do you see emerging based on your closeness to the program? Thanks.

Advertise with us

Eric of Midlothian, Va.

HARLAN: Well, here's one way to look at it, Eric. I truly believe that Michael Robinson and Alan Zemaitis, among others, will go down as two of the most important players in the final era of Joe Paterno's coaching career. The reason is, they took on an enormous mission, the kind that might only reveal itself over the next several years: They took hold of a team with a losing attitude and used their bold personalities to change it around. Robinson and Zemaitis are great friends and roommates, but more importantly, they are both players who made sure their teammates believed in what was going on at Penn State. Both had the kind of personalities that made you want to follow them. That's not something that the average person can simply watch and copy, but I think that next year, and perhaps even in 2007, the seniors on those teams will remember the mannerisms of the key seniors from 2005 and use them to their benefit. Strong leadership is a gift that keeps giving, even when the original leaders have departed.

Paul Posluszny, provided he stays in school for his senior season, will be the natural leader of next year's team. He's already a captain this season, but he doesn't have quite the same colorful personality as Robinson and Zemaitis. He's intense, but also understated. A few of the other guys who will be key seniors next season -- Tony Hunt, Levi Brown, Jay Alford -- are not natural leaders. I honestly think that the leader of next year's team, at least offensively, will be Derrick Williams. He and Robinson share a lot of characteristics, and even before his injury this year, teammates spoke about the natural way he galvanized his fellow wideouts. I wouldn't be surprised if Williams, by the time he's a junior, is already a Penn State captain.

Q:

Do you think there's any chance that JoePa will retire after the season if everything continues smoothly and the lions win a BCS bowl? I've always thought that Joe has earned the right to leave whenever he wants to, but after reading the transcript from his most recent press conference, I want him to stick around longer to keep giving us all advice.

Advertise with us

Brian Spak of Washington, D.C.

HARLAN: At this point, I do think he'll be back for next season. On Tuesday, I asked Paterno exactly that -- if he felt there was a chance he could retire after the season. I didn't ask it because I expected him to say yes, but rather, because I was curious to listen to his reaction. Not that I wanted to provoke him; rather, I felt like his response, whatever it was, could give some clues.

Here's what he said, when asked if the Wisconsin game might become his final home game on the sideline:

"Do you know something I don't know? Have you talked to our president? I haven't even thought of that. I have no idea about that. If in pre-game warm-ups I can't get out of the way from some of those big, fat, slow linemen, maybe I might give it up. That has not come across my mind right now."

It's tough to read too much into an answer like that, but Paterno has said in the past that so long as he still enjoys it and still maintains his health, he will keep going. Granted, many coaches would feel the urge to eye that poetic ending -- imagine, for instance, Paterno leaving with an 11-1 team and a BCS bowl victory -- but Paterno seems unconcerned with that. For now, Brian, I think you'll get your wish. I'd guess that Joe will stick around, no matter how this season ends.

Advertise with us

Q:

Michael Robinson deserves credit for elevating his play. What have he and/or the coaches done to where he is playing very well? If he continues to play the rest of the season (and postseason) this way, where do you see him drafted in April? My guess is any where from the third through the sixth round.

Joe of Forest, Va.

HARLAN: I think your guess is a good one, Joe. A few things I can say about Robinson's pro chances: First, he will play somewhere; he has too much athletic ability to fail in the NFL. Second, he's smart enough to put his love for quarterback aside if that's the way he must earn an NFL paycheck. In other words, he won't let his stubbornness get in the way. Yes, he prefers quarterback -- he always has -- and he said this week that he still holds a belief that he can continue to play the position in the pros. But, when Robinson faced a few follow-up questions on the matter, he seemed relatively open to playing wide receiver, running back, etc. The only notion that caused him to recoil? Playing safety. He joked that he hadn't tackled anybody in five years, so he couldn't understand why an NFL team would want him to start doing it all over again. And hey, it made sense to me.

Personally, I think Robinson will make for a valuable, versatile player in the NFL. His hit on Brandon Owens in the Minnesota game was the type of thing most running backs would be lucky to get. He's physical and mobile, all at once. I think he'd make a solid slot receiver, the kind who sees a lot of short passes and the occasional snap in the backfield. Of course, much of Robinson's future will be determined by the needs of the team that drafts him, but Robinson will be OK so long as he maintains his current attitude -- which is to say, his willingness to adjust and adapt.

Advertise with us

Q:

Oh, dearest Chico. Upon inspecting the yellowed dispatches in my morning newspaper --- and oh, how I yearned, in that moment, for the sagely blocks of information once dispensed by that fellow Albert Merriman Smith, doing a man's honest work on that fateful day when the president went down in Dallas -- I encountered a line of verbal interlocution telling me that Ye Olde Joe Paterno was in the running for the George Munger Award. Now that ain't half bad, I tell you, because Munger was pacing gridirons up and down the East Coast during a time when the ol' troops ran the single wing and that group of Quaker boys from Franklin Field stormed through the Ivy League. So I pose to you a question, Chico: Does our very own Brown-educated bastion of gridiron traditionalism deserve an award recalling Munger himself, or might this esteemed token of accomplishment be better earned by an individual such as Charlie Weis or the junior Shula character down in the fair state where they stick numbers on the crimson helmets. Of course, if Alabama had real players, they'd be wearing leather helmets, but that's just me.

W.F. Whence of Quillsville, Mass.

HARLAN: Whew, W.F. Let me gather my thoughts here. If I correctly interpreted that messy, multi-syllabic jumble, you are simply asking me whether I think Paterno deserves to be named coach of the year. It's an intriguing possibility, I must admit. Just to bring folks up to date, here's the latest: This week, the Maxwell Football Club announced its 12 finalists for the Munger Award, given to the coach of the year. When I take a quick look at the list, I see a few favorites. Paterno is one of them, certainly. Charlie Weis, too, will receive a yard look. Same with Mack Brown (Texas), Mark Richt (Georgia), Mike Shula (Alabama), and perhaps even Les Miles, who had to keep his LSU team together in the trying months following Katrina.

That said, I do believe Paterno is deserving of the award. I'm not yet ready to say he SHOULD get it; a lot of that depends on how the final games play out, not just for Penn State, but for several other teams. Fact is, though, Paterno's taken a team that most expected to generate six or seven wins and lifted it back to the elite level. One can argue about how much credit he deserves for this -- there's reason to believe his involvement in the minute-to-minute management isn't at the level of, say, a decade ago -- but without question, he's put together a memorable season. He certainly has sentiment on his side. Even a year ago, most Penn State fans seemed willing to push Paterno from his head coaching position. But now, in his 40th season, he's held the reins of a team that's developed a new foundation of talent, utilized a fresh offensive style and risen back to the top of the Big Ten. That's pretty remarkable. If Paterno can help Penn State win its final two games, I'd give him at least a 50-50 shot of winning the award.

Advertise with us

I think Weis also has a good chance, though it sometimes seems to me like his hype is more substantial than his actual performance. Yes, he's done a fantastic job rebuilding the Irish in a short period, but in reality, his team is 5-2 right now. That's good, but hardly great. And he's doing this with players who he didn't recruit, players who were brought in by his successor -- a man, mind you, who actually started HIS tenure at Notre Dame more impressively than Weis is doing now. Shula might be the other top contender, if Alabama can win out. Few expected the Tide to be so mighty this season, and since 'Bama lost Tyhrone Prothro earlier season, Shula has done a good job keeping the offense together. It still might be a bit early to figure out this coach of the year race, but for now, I'll say this: Paterno should keep some open space on his mantel.

Q:

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.