Q: Hi Chico. Could you take a few minutes to explain how the Big Ten race could shake out? If Penn State is able to win the rest of its games, and so do Ohio State and Northwestern, there could conceivably be a tie with each team suffering only one loss. Would there be a tiebreaker in this case, since PSU has beaten OSU and NW? My primary question is: if Penn State wins the rest of their games, are they guaranteed the Big Ten title, being that Iowa now has two losses?

Brent of Escondido, Calif.

Have your own question?

Click here to submit your question

Advertise with us

HARLAN: Good question for starting things off, Brent. Let's open with the simple part: Currently, four teams in the Big Ten have only one loss. Two of them have 4-1 in-conference records -- Wisconsin and Penn State. The other two, Ohio State and Northwestern, sit at 3-1.

This has the potential to become complicated, but there's one way in which it won't. If Penn State wins its final three games, it will claim the outright Big Ten championship. Reason being, it will have defeated Wisconsin (which it plays Nov. 5) as well as Northwestern and Ohio State. In other words, Penn State owns tiebreakers against all of the one-loss teams. Provided one of the four remaining one-loss teams wins out, it is guaranteed to be pitted in the tiebreaker against, at most, one addition one-loss team. Because Wisconsin must still play Penn State and Northwestern must still play Ohio State, no more than two Big Ten teams can finish the season with one loss.

Of the four remaining one-loss teams, Wisconsin looks to have the easiest schedule. This week, the Badgers play Illinois, almost assuring the fact that they'll come to Beaver Stadium with a 5-1 conference mark. After the Penn State game, Wisconsin hosts Iowa -- hardly an easy opponent, but Hawkeyes must travel to Madison, Wisc. That gives Wisconsin two readily winnable home games, matched against an extremely tough road game against Penn State. The Lions, meanwhile, have their game against Wisconsin flanked by a relatively easy game (hosting Purdue) and a challenging game (at Michigan State). Ohio State and Northwestern, which still must square off against one another, have far more difficult schedules; the Buckeyes still must play Michigan, and Northwestern still faces Iowa and Ohio State.

So right now, to put some odds on this race, I'd give Penn State the best shot of winning the Big Ten title. Among the one-loss teams I'd say Northwestern is the decided longshot. Both Ohio State and Wisconsin are somewhere in between.

The real mess comes if all of these teams lose at least once more -- certainly a possibility. If that scenario unfolds, then the Big Ten reverts to a mess of tiebreakers involving however many two-loss teams are tied for first. The actual tiebreaker scenarios are explained at the Big Ten's web site; click on "Football," then click on "BCS Bowl Tiebreakers. But to quickly summarize: Let's say three teams are tied for the title, all with two losses. If one of those three defeated both of the other two, then that team is the conference champ. If that doesn't solve the problem, things get trickier -- far trickier. Teams can lose out on the tiebreaker for, among other reasons, for having losses to both of the other two-loss teams (in a three- or four-way tie scenario) or for having a lower overall winning percentage (counting non-conference games) than the other teams in the tiebreaker.

Advertise with us

But to summarize, Penn State remains in excellent shape. It's the only team in the Big Ten that can truly control its own fate. It wins all three, and it's guaranteed to make a BCS bowl. No other Big Ten team can say that, not even Wisconsin, which can win out and still lose on a tiebreaker to Northwestern (which beat the Badgers earlier this season). Anyway, sorry to let this regress into a convoluted explanation. This race will likely grow clearer in the next few weeks.

Q: I thought Michael Robinson did a great job of leading the team. His performance was exceptional However, I thought the coaches may have let him play a little too long, risking injury. Anthony Morelli's playing time was a complete waste. You or I could have handed the ball to the running back, then hustle back to the sidelines to watch the punt. The coaches did not give him an opportunity to develop or to become better prepared to lead this team in the event he is needed. What think you about these coaching decisions?

Bob of Ponca City, Okla.

HARLAN: I actually think coaches handled Robinson and, in the bigger picture, the entire quarterback rotation, just perfectly against Illinois. (I received numerous questions about this matter, so it seems like this is a popular complaint.) Nonetheless, I have no complaints, not one. As that rout became laughably out of hand, Penn State had a couple quick decisions to make about when to pull Robinson, when to insert Morelli and, then, how often to pass with Morelli in the game. I think Penn State did the proper thing on all accounts. This was not the game for Morelli to gain valuable experience; even if he'd been inserted half-way through the second quarter, or even at the end of the first quarter, his playing time was assured to be unimportant. That's because he was playing in a game that was already out of hand, already over. I know Penn State used Robinson in the second quarter against the Illini and still asked him to throw it a few times, but how valuable would it have been had PSU asked Morelli to do the same thing? Not much, I'd argue. First, because he was playing against a defense about as threatening as an overturned turtle. And second, because he was playing in a game that was totally over. That's not the kind of experience Morelli needs in the first place. He's already shown he can do just fine in such situations. What he needs now is to be placed into close games where he must perform under pressure, and the truth is, he probably won't get that until next season. That's just the reality of Penn State's current success -- the Lions have too much at stake in the present to try to suddenly gear their games toward preparation for the future.

Against Illinois, Penn State needed to stick with Robinson until the game was safe -- that was its duty to preserving the win. Then, it needed to insert Morelli and ask him to simply hand the ball off -- that was its duty to both Robinson's health. There's also the matter of overall sportsmanship, which is why Penn State couldn't ask Morelli to pass. Coaches with 53-point leads can't still be throwing the ball, even occasionally.

Advertise with us

I agree that Morelli's job, on this particular day, was easy. (Like you suggest: You or I could have handed off every play.) But the truth is, against Illinois, there was no other way to have it. This was not the game for Morelli to see valuable experience.

Q: It appears that Tony Hunt is the No. 1 tailback, but is there any hope for Austin Scott to get back in or is this once-touted junior now a back-up? And is his problem in his mind, with the coaches, or is he not just as good as Hunt?

Hamer Campbell of Bowie, Md.

HARLAN: Austin Scott is edging closer and closer to the dictionary definition of "bust." That's not meant as a complete indictment of his abilities, either. Since coming to Penn State, Scott has struggled for a number of reasons. Some of it has been pure bad luck: his injury in the spring set him back even farther behind Tony Hunt, and he hasn't been able to close the gap since. At this point, I'd be surprised if Scott ever develops into the tailback so many envisioned when he signed with the Lions.

The thing is, Scott had an amazing prep career. His numbers were jaw-dropping: he rushed for 3,800 yards during his senior season. One season! But for some reason, or perhaps for many reasons, he's never made the complete adjustment to the next level. Perhaps his skills just don't translate. Perhaps his work ethic is just a bit short of what's necessary. Perhaps he's lost that sliver of confidence that separates good running backs from average running backs.

Advertise with us

And indeed, right now Scott is average. If Hunt were do go down with an injury, Penn State would be lucky to have Scott as a back-up. But given the expectations Scott had entering college, that statement alone shows how he's never gotten on track with the Lions. As I see it, Scott is extremely unlikely to overtake Hunt during his career. Hunt, quite simply, is the more powerful runner. He stays lower to the ground, and he's better at muscling his way for tough yards. On plays when Scott might get three yards, Hunt will get five. That's the difference. And so long as Hunt continues to see all of the important snaps during games, I can't see how Scott will change that balance.

Most coaches this season have actually praised Scott's work. (Unlike last season, when poor work habits landed him in the doghouse.) Now, though, Scott has other things to battle. He's stuck behind a stronger player -- that simple.

Q: I know that normally redshirting a freshman has something to do with how much they've played, or haven't played. But I'm assuming the rules might be different for medical redshirts. If so, could Derrick Williams possible fall under those rules? I guess that's not going to happen, since there's been nothing mentioned about it, but I thought it was worth asking.

Bill Antonelli, Jr., of Kennedy

HARLAN: Williams is not eligible for a medial redshirt. For an injured player to be eligible for a medical redshirt, the injury must take place in the first half of the season. Moreover -- and in most cases, this is an even tighter qualification -- the student-athlete may not have participated in more than 20 percent of the team's games or competitions scheduled that season. In other words, had Williams suffered his season-ending injury in Week 2, he could have taken a medical redshirt. By Week 3, that possibility was already out the window.

Advertise with us

Q: One thing I have noticed this season is how organized the offense has been. The substitution patterns, the play calling -- it all seems so streamlined as opposed to the past several seasons when players were continuously shuffling in and out (Michael Robinson lining up everywhere) and there were constant questions regarding who was calling the shots (Joe, Jay, Galen Hall, et al). Is this a product of just having a better talent pool that can function in all the different packages or did the coaches come to a consensus that they wouldn't walk all over each other in the decision-making? The return to structure has been really telling in the results this season.

Jerri Bullock of Beaver Falls

HARLAN: I will say two things: First, this is Exhibit A of how talent makes a world of difference. Yes, last year Robinson was shuffled around, but don't forget, this year, Penn State's offense still involves a lot of flip-flopping. About seven wideouts are used in formations, depending on the scenario. Sometimes the Lions use a tight end, often they don't. Sometimes they use a fullback, often they don't. In truth, there might be MORE shuffling lineup-wise than last season. Thing is, because all of the people involved are able to execute, nobody sees a problem with it.

My second point, though, directs some credit to the coaching staff. I do see one difference between '04 and '05, and this might point to the improvement you notice in organization. I think the play-callers -- Galen and Jay -- have made a concerted effort to get the plays to Robinson with more time on the play clock. That way, Robinson can quickly get to the line of scrimmage and read the defense. In the past few years, Penn State struggled with this, and often had to hurry to the line simply to get the play off. As it is, the Lions ask provide Robinson a lot of freedom to change plays and blocking schemes at the line of scrimmage, so he needs all of the time he can get. So far so good, I say. Sure, the coaches have made a few small adjustments. But mostly, I pass along credit to the players.

Q: Get out your crystal ball and imagine that State wins out, like it should, goes 10-1, winning the Big Ten and getting to a BCS bowl bid. Who do the Lions play and in which bowl?

Advertise with us

Second question. Did Anthony Scirrotto win the punt returning job from Calvin Lowry with his second-half performance against Illinois? And, if not, maybe Rodney Kinlaw would be a viable second option seeing how he broke off a nice kickoff return. But, I guess that requires a different skill; catching a kick and running with it.

Mick of Universal City, Texas

HARLAN: Mick, I'll answer Part One of your question a bit later on in the Q&A. As for the punt return job, I have to admit defeat. I've advocated for weeks that Lowry should be replaced, and little to my surprise, it seems like nobody's bothered passing that message along to Paterno. Only a 53-point lead could pluck Lowry from the lineup, and though Scirrotto looked comfortable in that role when given a chance, he's not going to take the job from Ol' Lead Foot. Coaches have stuck with Lowry through every game this season, through all of his muffed fair catches and three-yard returns. It would make no sense, then, for them to replace him after he played one of his best games. (He finished with a career-high 127 return yards against Illinois.) Anyway, that modest performance didn't convert me into a Lowry supporter, but I think it bought him another boost of job security.

Q: Dear Chico -- I want to tell you that I always enjoy reading your column on Saturday mornings. Your generally pessimistic views help me balance my natural enthusiasm and optimism for Penn State football. However, after reading your answer to the referee questions I must tell you that I think you missed the point entirely. PSU fans understand football. We understand that referees and replay officials make mistakes, and most of all we understand that all the calls are not going to go your way. But when is the last time any questionable call, just one, went in PSU's favor in a big game? Your opinion would have been much more acceptable to me if you could have cited some examples (this year or in years past) where PSU has been the beneficiary of some questionable calls in a big game. You can't do it can you? Well, not unless you go back over 20 years anyway. Combine the 2005 Michigan game with all the horrible calls in 2002, the snub from the big 10 voters in 1994 and yes, PSU nation sees a conspiracy.

Marcus Zone of Erie

Advertise with us

HARLAN: Marcus, as I read your question, I nodded my head for the first few sentences. You made a few good points. (Perhaps I wasn't condemning enough of the officiating against Michigan; who knows. When somebody has a bad day's work, maybe they deserve criticism. And maybe I should have come down a bit harder on the refs.) But then I got to the second half of your question, and that's where you lost me. Please, I don't even want to hear about the promotion of some ridiculous conspiracy theory. If you don't think Penn State hasn't gotten a close call go its way in the last 20 years, you either haven't been watching very closely or you have an exceptionally selective memory.

Q: Howdy, Chico -- the progression of the offensive line's successful play this season is now really starting to attract some attention. Prior to this season, a lot was made, and maybe rightly so, about the lack of success seen by Penn State's offensive line prospects, even those rated very high coming out of high school. Prior to last season, Penn State made a radical change to its traditional blocking schemes by going to a new zone-blocking scheme. Could that transition (as well as the fact that without any sort of threat at wide receiver last year, the line had to contend with 8- and 9-man defensive fronts) help better explain the offensive line's lack of success last year, more so than poor coaching?

Chris Santinoceto of Wheeling, W.V.

HARLAN: I'll go with the lame "combination of factors" on this one, Chris. But wait! -- stick with me. I'll try to spice this up.

Factor No. 1 (and I think this one is most important): experience, pure and simple. Four of the five starting O-linemen are seniors. By now, they have roughly 100 starts among them. Sometimes it just takes longer for college players to "get it." I'll admit it -- at the start of the year, I had essentially given up on the prospects of this particular unit ever approaching decency. After all, I figured, if a player doesn't learn what it takes in two years as a starter, how much can he possible improve in the third? I think I overlooked one factor, though. These linemen all have a strong sense of pride, and, in a way, sentiment for their legacies. E. Z. Smith said this week that the linemen talk "almost every day" about how their careers are winding down and how they must take advantage of it. Even when the season started, these linemen grouped together and promised to improve their work ethic and communication. It's shown. Now, with four seniors on the line, this group finally "gets it." It's a surprise, but for Penn State, it's a welcome one.

Advertise with us

Factor No. 2: the zone blocking. I don't really think the line struggled last year because of the zone blocking, mainly because the scheme isn't that complicated. Penn State knew even the intricacies of it by the time it opened in 2004. So my point is, I think the improved comfort with the zone blocking, if there is any, remains only a secondary factor in the O-line's improved play this season. Granted, a second year of practice with a particular scheme cannot hurt, but I think the line's improvement has been more mental than physical.

Factor No. 3: the coaching. In the past, I've blamed O-line coaches Dick Anderson and Bill Kenney quite frequently for their failure to build up many top-flight linemen at Penn State. If I stick them with the blame, I must also give them a portion of the credit. Again, this is a secondary factor in the line's improvement. But more to the point, perhaps it demonstrates that both of these guys, though often criticized, can indeed be capable coaches.

Q: Ah, my dear friend Chico. How are you? I monitor your writings closely since moving to America from my native Russia. Sadly, I fear I chose wrong American city to live in. The Gary Chamber of Commerce made this place sound so very good; they say something about milk and honey and fair-skinned maidens. Alas, I take comfort in your stories about this wonderful football team. I see the Lions are playing the Boilermakers this weekend. Because my English is not so good, I'm curious about where this word Boilermaker comes from. I asked my friend Richie at neighborhood pub about it, and he said something about a Boilermaker being a drink: a shot of whiskey dropped into a beer.

We know nothing about whiskey in Russia. All we have is vodka. I tell you, my friend, kids practically pour that stuff on their cereal over there. So I do not know what Boilermaker tastes like. I imagine it something like gasoline and maple syrup -- if that make sense.

So two questions, my dear comrade: Why would a school name its football team after alcohol? Also, since I've heard Joe Paterno has ice cream flavor named after him, what would a drink in his honor be named? And what would drink consist of?

Advertise with us

OK, so that's three questions. Guess English AND math not so good.

Boris Hachyakocov of Gary, Ind.

HARLAN: Mmmm? well, I like your thinking, Boris. (And I'll take on at least the final two of your questions.) If coffee doubles as a Cup 'O Joe, I don't think there's any doubt that any Paterno-related drink should most certainly be called a Cup 'O JoePa. Naturally, this would taste nothing like coffee, because as any graduate of Syracuse knows, a good drink contains alcohol, often in unholy combinations. But now you have me thinking, Boris. If Paterno were to have his own drink, I think it should be relatively simple -- straight-forward and time-honored, but bold enough to keep its mark on you by sunrise.

No matter what, this drink must start with Jack Daniel's. How 'bout this: You add a couple drops of lime juice (because Paterno can be acerbic at times), plenty of ice and a few ounces of Coca-Cola, a drink that was created in 1886, making it at least a few years older than Joe himself.

So, there you have it -- the Cup 'O JoePa.

Advertise with us

Now go ahead and try it, Boris.

Q: Chico, you've had questions submitted from Spain and China this year. How about one from a computer run by generator in Hurricane Wilma-ravaged South Florida? Is Illinois really that bad, or is Penn State getting that much better as the season goes along? Can you talk about the bowl prospects? If Penn State should win out, where do you see them playing in a bowl game and can you speculate on an opponent?

Tom Peeling of West Palm Beach, Fla.

HARLAN: First, yes, Illinois is really that bad. Granted, this is only my second year covering Penn State and the Big Ten, but I have never seen another conference team so poor. And it's not even close. That was downright Temple-esque.

But, that statement isn't designed to steal too much credit from Penn State. Beating a team so thoroughly, no matter the caliber of the opponent, is still impressive. Especially with Penn State still staggering after a heartbreaking loss to Michigan, the manner in which Penn State rebounded counts as perhaps the best testament yet to this team's mental strength. So, to answer part two of your question, yes, the Lions are still improving -- and they are a team with a high ceiling to do so.

Advertise with us

So, if Penn State wins out -- no guarantee, certainly -- it will be 10-1, outright Big Ten champions. For now, I'll dismiss their chances of a Rose Bowl appearance. But should the Lions finish 10-1, they will be a highly desirable team to any bowl -- the team has the backing of an enthusiastic, and bowl-hungry, fan base. The Lions will end up in either the Sugar Bowl, Fiesta Bowl or Orange Bowl, obviously, but it might be a bit too early to speculate on which location it will be. That's because much of it depends on the other teams ahead of Penn State: Who makes the Rose Bowl? Does Notre Dame win out and earn a BCS berth? And (egads!) what on earth happens to the poor Big East team that somehow forces itself, wrongfully, into this mix of otherwise elite teams?

But I'll give you one scenario just for the heck of it. Let's say Notre Dame wins out and Texas meets USC in the Rose Bowl. Under normal circumstances, the Fiesta Bowl has a tie-in with the Big 12 champion (Texas, in this instance), and because the Fiesta would lose Texas to the Rose Bowl, it would have the first pick to select a replacement from the pool of remaining teams. It would face an enticing lot of teams, too -- Penn State, Notre Dame, etc. But here's the thing: the ACC has a tie-in with the Orange Bowl, and the SEC has a tie-in with the Sugar Bowl. So the Fiesta Bowl, picking in such a circumstance, would not be able to pick the ACC champ (perhaps Virginia Tech) or the SEC champ (perhaps Georgia or Alabama). That's why Penn State could very likely end up in the Fiesta Bowl.

But that said, we are getting far ahead of ourselves. Speculating, at this point, is simply an exercise in hypotheticals. Give it a few more weeks and we'll have a stronger idea.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.