Dear friends of the Q&A and enemies of crew chief Bill LeMonnier:
Have your own question?
Click here to submit your question
OK, we're going to do things a bit differently this week. I don't believe the usual cycle of Q's and A's will work this time around. Though I received a strong blitz of questions, upon closer inspection, all those questions seemed to be, um, identical. So instead, I'll list several excerpted questions ranting about the officiating from Saturday's loss -- i.e., I'll pile "Q" atop "Q" -- and then I'll respond with one enormous "A." Thereafter, in the second half of the Q&A, I'll go back to the usual format, clearing my throat and enjoying the chance to write about something other than referees.
But first? What follows is a compilation of complaints. I chose snippets from seven of them, but I received more. Plenty more. Read them at your own peril, and I mean that not just in regard to these excerpted questions, but also in regard to my response.
(Further reading is not recommended for individuals with a history of heart problems.)
Q: It seems some "home-cooking" was in place at Ann Arbor again. Granted, Penn State had plenty of chances to put the game away. However, why was Deon Butler's "non-catch" the only play the review officials seemed to have time to catch in the critical closing minutes? Mike Hart clearly fumbled in the third quarter near midfield, and thought Chris Harrell recovered, the play was never reviewed. And, the out-of-bounds catch on Michigan's final drive was plainly obvious -- the antithesis of Tony Johnson's "good-catch" from a few years back. That was a very costly miss by the officiating crew as time was running out on Michigan. Those yards and seconds spent may have prevented Michigan from getting close enough for a decent attempt at the end zone. I'm not going to even mention the two seconds that Carr begged for and was given.
Mick of Universal City, Texas
Q: After several questionable on-field calls and the lack of any review by the replay official, can you explain the circumstances when the replay official is permitted to stop play on the field to undertake a review? As noted by the announcers and in several articles I have read since the game, it appears that a team can prevent a replay of a close call by using a no huddle offense. If the purpose of replay is to get it right, the system failed miserably on Saturday.
Jim Hickman of Palm Harbor, Fla.
Q: Could you please do your best to clarify the Big Ten Instant Replay rules and procedures for me and every other PSU fan who feels as though we got hosed multiple times this past weekend? Examples: The Mike Hart fumble; the Avant catch on the sideline; the multiple horrific spots that the refs gave to Michigan; the mysterious two seconds that Carr got put back on the clock?
Allen Dawson of New Bethlehem
Q: I am not trying to sound like this is sour grapes, and certainly it is no slight to Michigan, which played the cards it was dealt, but what is with the officiating? We get one call (the pass interference) and they get what, like, five? On the last series of the game no less! ... How many games will have to be won or lost before the NCAA does something about it? How about adding a few extra refs? Or doubling the number? Will more refs help get the calls right or just increase disagreement? I know there are many sides to this discussion, so I would appreciate your thoughts.
Bryan Salas of Albuquerque, N.M.
Q: Just out of curiosity, and not to jump back to the Penn State rallying cry of a few years ago of 'the officials are out to get us', but can anyone offer any reasonable explanation as to why there was not a review of the Michigan first-down reception in the final minute of the game? With the game hanging in the balance, it seems reasonable that every close play should be reviewed.
Chris of Belle Vernon
Q: In the loss to Michigan, Deon Butler almost made a catch on the right sideline during the fourth quarter that was overturned and ruled incomplete through instant replay. Penn State had rushed to the line to snap the ball but the replay was called for immediately from upstairs. I haven't heard anyone mention the play on Michigan's final drive where its receiver's heel clearly came down out of bounds and no replay was requested from above. I'm not sure if this would have changed what happened, but it gave them a much needed 15 yards or so and a good start to the drive.
Rob Reed of Sarasota, Fla.
Q: I realize that Penn State had many opportunities to win this game. Having said that, as I watched the game, it always seemed that Michigan got favorable spots, Penn State didn't. Plays that could have been favorable to the visitors were not reviewed while the home team seemed to get those reviews. And, of course, the two seconds that were added back to the clock. I wondered how you, an objective journalist, viewed the officiating.
Al Gmutza of Fort Vernon, Ind.
(Exhale)
HARLAN: Hey, thanks for asking, Al. OK, there is a lot to cover here, and I'm a bit apprehensive about treading through all of the details, because I've quickly learned that Penn State fans interact with the refs like swatters interact with flies. But, here goes nothing:
First of all, I can summarize the anti-officiating uproar in one word: unreasonable. For some reason, it genuinely bothers me that folks could spend almost four hours watching one of the most beautiful college football games of the season and then rail so nastily against seven guys -- one ref, one umpire, one linesman, one line judge, one back judge, one field judge, and one side judge -- who are essentially trying their best to do a good job. I'll be blunt. These officials did not cost Penn State the game. Sure, there were some questionable calls -- and I'll get into them in a moment -- but I would argue that this game had at least a dozen turning points of far greater significance than any decision made by a referee.
I would bet that any Penn State player would agree with me, and not just because he feels it's the sportsmanlike thing to say. Think about the litany of plays and decisions that determined this game -- the missed field goals, the conservative first-half play calling, the defense on the game's final play, Calvin Lowry's misplayed punt (more on that later), the picturesque deep ball completed past Justin King. I could go on and on. Each of those plays, stacked atop one another, directed this game toward its conclusion. I refuse to admit that seven fair and principled referees did more to affect the outcome of the game than the near-100 players who competed on the field.
Mostly, I think that the anti-officiating sentiment is baloney. It comes as no surprise that close games will invariable deliver scrutiny on the officiating crew, so the significance of every call is magnified. But c'mon. Ruling on the plays of a game is something that is, by nature, somewhat subjective. This is a constant of football. People from Penn State will always believe that refs make an inordinate number of calls against them, but the truth is, people from every school believe an inordinate number of calls go against them. Refs operate in the precarious middle ground where everything they do has the potential to anger fans from one side. Thus, fans from Team A remember every call that went against them; fans from Team B remember every call that went against them. In the end, nobody is happy. All of which is to say? I don't fault the refs. Penn State still would have lost to Michigan even if every call I'm about to describe would have gone in the Lions' favor.
Now, let me proceed...
A little about Big Ten replay: During a game, only one individual -- a technical advisor in the press box -- has the ability to stop the game and call for a replay. This advisor should theoretically have access to television feeds, thereby allowing him the chance to see immediately replays of every close call. There is no limit to the number of plays that can be reviewed in a game. The other important question is, What is reviewable? Question-writers have already mentioned a few bothersome plays from the Michigan game -- the Avant catch and the Hart fumble, most notably. Both of those plays are indeed reviewable, because the Big Ten allows for replay of situations "governed by the sideline" or for situations regarding "recovery of a loose ball." Even when an offense is in hurry-up mode, the press box replay official should theoretically be able to quickly watch the play and, if necessary, call for a review.
So let's go through some of the specific plays, shall we? I believe that two plays during the Michigan game would have been overturned in Penn State's favor had they been reviewed. The first one -- Hart's fumble, which seemed to pop out just before he hit the ground. The second one -- Avant's catch on the last drive, which probably been overturned had replay officials taken a second look. Though I have basically defended the officiating to this point, I can see -- at least somewhat -- why these two plays stirred fans' anger. After all, the Big Ten instituted a replay system essentially to ensure that plays were ruled properly, even if the initial ruling was incorrect. But here's the reason even this instant replay system isn't foolproof: Used to be, people complained about the refs' calls. Now, they just complain about the decision to review the plays' calls. Truth is, when you boil it down, it's still a judgment call somewhere along the line. Always will be. There will always be human judgment involved somewhere in the process. This will never be eliminated, and that's why controversy about officiating will never be put to rest.
Now, one final comment, if you'll allow me. Many observers, in the wake of Saturday's game, have focused on the two seconds placed back on the clock following a Michigan play with a half-minute to go. We could argue for hours about when, exactly, Michigan signaled for a timeout, but I think it's bunk that everybody is up in arms about that determination. You cannot draw a straight line from that decision to the final play of the game -- which occurred with one second remaining -- and state that the final play never would have happened were Michigan's two seconds never returned. Sorry, doesn't work like that. If Michigan's timeout comes with :28 left instead of :30 left, everything thereafter unfolds differently. Quite possibly, to bypass a few what-ifs, the play the Wolverines run with six seconds left could very well start instead with four seconds left -- and if that were so, Michigan surely would have thrown to the end zone instead of waiting for one more play to try.
Sure, people can complain all they want about having a game that lasted 60 minutes and, ahem, two seconds, but I believe it's irrelevant. Take any close game and you'll find something about which to complain. That's the great thing about football. And, on the flip side, that's the reason to tell your children not to grow up to be referees.
Now, moving on.
Q: Chico -- Two different topics. Now that D-Will is out for the year, do you have a sense for who will take over as the big-play threat? I think Kinlaw has looked very good and fast when he's been in there, so I'm thinking he could fill that role fairly well. Any insight regarding whether or not that's the direction they're going to go in, and if not, any ideas why not?
Eric of Midlothian
HARLAN: Kinlaw is not the guy, Eric, mainly because his playing time won't increase as a result of Williams' injury. As I see it, Williams' injury will have these after-effects: First, Tony Hunt will see about three or four more carries per game. Second, Justin King might have a few more plays designed to get him the ball, especially early in games. Third, Deon Butler, Jordan Norwood, Terrell Golden and Lydell Sargeant will each be on the field for a few more snaps. (And Butler and Norwood were playing a lot beforehand.) The fourth and final side effect? Well, the way I see it, each of the aforementioned receivers will suddenly find it a little harder to get open. That's because when Williams was on the field, defenses always had to devote an inordinate portion of attention to him. That's not to say he was always double-covered; he wasn't. But no matter where Williams lined up -- at wideout, at running back, even in shotgun as a quarterback -- he always had several pairs of eyes watching him. I don't think any other wideout on Penn State's roster will force defenses to devote similar focus. And by extension, the attention that Williams' once drew to himself will now be divided among the other wideouts on the field. I'm not sure that will noticeably impede Butler and Norwood et al, but it's something to keep an eye on.
One more comment, if I may. You ask who will take over as Penn State's big-play threat, as if it's a given that somebody will. That's a fallacious assumption. Nobody will "take over." Several players will see more playing time, perhaps even see their stats increase, but that doesn't mean anybody will be able to replace Williams. Justin King is the only Lion who can match Williams' explosiveness, and Penn State needs him too badly on defense to turn him into a focal point on offense. So my guess? Penn State will miss Williams. Maybe not badly, but noticeably. The Lions' offense will still be OK, but this much can't be contested -- it's not as good as it was one week ago.
Q: Chico, only now am I calm enough after the Michigan loss to address a concern I have with the Lions. More to the point, why is Calvin Lowry still returning punts? I am certain if asked that question Paterno will claim his seniority status gives him the nod over the underclassman but at best all he can do is make a fair catch. He brings nothing to the table. Why not put someone back there that can actually do something? What do the coaches see in him that no one else with a football IQ over 50 does?
Jim of Philadelphia
HARLAN: As perhaps you know, Jim, I don't think much of Calvin Lowry's return abilities. He's a respectable safety, but something happens to him when he stands alone at the far end of the field and waits for a football to tumble out of the sky. In this simple moment, trying to return a punt -- and mind you, this is something Lowry has practiced thousands of times -- he looks, at best, bewildered and, at worst, apoplectic. Personally, I have an IQ of 51, and I know for a fact that at least a half-dozen players on Penn State's roster could qualify, right now, as an upgrade over Lowry. So long as the Lions keep ol' Cal back there on punts, they're not fulfilling their entire potential as a team. The punt he failed to catch against Michigan in the first half (it bounced 15 yards backwards, costing the Lions key field position) was truly unacceptable. But I can't say it was surprising. That said, here's a list of folks who could probably turn into better punt returners than Calvin Lowry.
Lydell Sargeant -- I like his set of skills; he's a poor man's Derrick Williams.
Justin King -- I like his skills even more; he's an upper-middle class man's Derrick Williams.
Kevin Kelly -- Sure, he's 5-foot-7, but that just means his eyes and arms are lower to the ground, thereby allowing him a few more milliseconds to decide whether or not to signal for a fair catch.
George Costanza -- Good hands, the scouting report says. (At least that's what I gathered after learning he worked briefly as a hands model.)
Anybody who's ever tossed an M&M into the air and caught it with his mouth -- Lowry would fair-catch the M&M, then accidentally let it roll into a dusty corner of the floor
Any human being with the hand-eye coordination to either catch a fly ball, pull a box of cereal from the top grocery store shelf or properly stow luggage in an airplane.
Nobody. That's right. Don't even use a punt returner. At least one time out of 100, the ball might land at the right angle and bounce forward 15-odd yards. And that's more than we're used to seeing from Lowry.
Q: How come Paterno continues to use Calvin Lowry to return punts, when he has a bunch of gamebreakers that could get him better yardage? Derrick Williams is now out, but still have Justin King, Deon Butler, Austin Scott, Rodney Kinlaw and Lydell Sargeant. Lowry will fair catch a lot or let the ball bounce in front of him and watch it role 20 yards.
Frank of Ross
HARLAN: Did I mention that I don't think much of Lowry's punt returning ability?
Q: Don't you think that people (yourself included!) are too quickly dismissing the possibility of Penn State going to the Rose Bowl? They come out this week No. 10 in the BCS rankings. The teams ahead of them have games remaining that include match-ups against other unbeatens, thorny late-season tussles against arch rivals, and conference championships. A one-loss team could end up in the Rose Bowl. It's long odds, to be sure, but remember that JoePa's 1982 champions had one regular season loss.
Joe Kaldon Jr. of Hopewell
HARLAN: I don't think Penn State has a shot, even a long one, of advancing to the Rose Bowl, Joe. OK, I admit that it's mathematically possible -- you've got me on that one -- but by analyzing the teams ahead of the Lions right now, I think it's safe to say that PSU should find some other goals to carry it through the rest of the season. Right now, we basically have four (or five, depending on the team) weeks of college football remaining, and we have seven undefeated teams. I think that by season's end, three teams will probably still be undefeated. I think there's a 90-95 percent chance that USC wins out. Probably a 75 percent chance that Texas wins out. And I'll say there's a 55 percent chance that Virginia Tech wins out. Even if two of those teams lose, several other schools -- Georgia and Alabama, especially -- will be in a better position to slide up. Penn State is currently ranked 10th in the BCS standings, as you mention, but it would need to leap-frog eight other teams (and hold off countless others just beneath it!) to jump into the BCS's No. 2 slot. That's simply too improbable, given the short time left in the season.
Q: Chico, like most Penn State fans I'm happy about the program's return to respectability again this after several horrendous years. However, I'm very disappointed that the team didn't take advantage of playing a mediocre Michigan team on Saturday to come away with a win. If they couldn't beat this very average Michigan team, I have to wonder if Penn State will ever beat Michigan. And I'm very disappointed in the play of the defense. I expected much more out of them this year. They seemed to lack fire during much of the game Saturday and the secondary's coverage was terrible. I'm particularly disappointed in the secondary's play. With all of the experience returning in the secondary, it seemed to me it would be a real strength this year. That hasn't been the case. Why have they come up so short this year?
Jerry Moore of North Potomac, Md.
HARLAN: First of all, Jerry, I wouldn't call Michigan mediocre. Maybe this year's Wolverines have more weaknesses than experts originally detected back in the preseason, but that team has still has a super-talented nucleus of players. I had one thought after watching Mike Hart: That is, Laurence Maroney is not the best running back in the Big Ten. And Henne, thought he struggled during the first three quarters, still turned out a dynamite final few drives. So long as Michigan couples those players with Breaston and Avant and Gabe Watson on defense, that team will remain a squad that can, on a good day, beat anybody in the Big Ten.
Now, onto the secondary. Yeah, I agree with you. I've been a bit disappointed in the secondary this year, because that unit's credentials entering the season were spotless. I think the play of the cornerbacks has actually been a bit more disappointing than the play of safeties Chris Harrell and Calvin Lowry. (Plus, we've picked on Lowry enough for one day.) Anwar Phillips, on one side, has been too inconsistent. Alan Zemaitis, at the other corner position, hasn't picked his game up much since last year; he's still a top-notch corner, but not the shut-down corner some might have been hoping for. (But his play stealing the ball from Henne, to give him credit, was spectacular.)
One observation I have about the cornerbacks: They seem to play better when they're given the freedom to play aggressively. Especially Zemaitis seems to relish the chance to play up against wide receivers and challenge them. He struggles a bit when asked to play back or commit to a soft zone. Though Zemaitis has learned to not speak as bluntly as he did last year, I still remember some of his comments from 2004 about his preference for aggressive defense. When Penn State spent much of the Boston College game last year stuck in passive zone defenses, Zemaitis was frustrated. I believe that, even to this day, he plays better in man-to-man defenses. That said, if PSU's secondary is going to rise to the next level, it must master every kind of defense in its playbook.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.