Q: No more questions about chip dip or even exit plans! Does this season's early success change Penn State's ability to land better recruits? Please tell us something we can't read from other Web sites!
Have your own question?
Click here to submit your question
Tom of Cleveland
HARLAN: I learned my lesson from last year, Tom, because I swore -- around October 2004 -- that Penn State's on-field struggles doomed it for a miserable recruiting class. We know how that worked out. So now, I hesitate to draw a totally strong correlation between the on-field product and the recruiting process. However, I can certainly say that the way Penn State has started this season has become an excellent recruiting tool, something that will make is easier for the Lions to attract the top high schoolers. Several reasons: Everybody wants to play for a winner, and suddenly, it's a lot easier to portray Penn State thusly, not just for the present, but for the next few years. Second, Penn State is attracting plenty of national exposure; the school has hosted ESPN GameDay and essentially showed strong evidence for having some of the most passionate fans (especially among students) in the nation. When recruits now travel up to State College on official and unofficial visits, they can expect to see a stirring game-day atmosphere.
So yeah, in a way, the excitement Penn State has quickly generated will help recruiting. I can't say it will ensure a top-ranked recruiting class, but even after the Ohio State game, four or five high schoolers signed on to play for the Lions. Not bad anecdotal evidence to demonstrate how winning -- and winning in front of a great crowd -- can trigger the cycle of more recruits and, in turn, more winning.
But I also add my caveat, and here's the reason. So many factors go into recruiting, that winning alone doesn't always attract recruits. Some kids pick schools based on academics, some based on coaches, some based on where they can play right away. Derrick Williams, for instance, actually wanted a school where he could come in, play right away and help create a turnaround. In short, the inherent challenge Penn State presented last season influenced him to come to State College. He wanted to transform the Lions from worst (or close to it) to first. So here's a question you can have fun with: If Williams was in high school this year instead of last, would he have still come to Penn State?
Q: Where can I find a roster of the 1982 Penn State national championship football team?
Pat Barnhart of Youngstown, Ohio
HARLAN: Here's one suggestion. Go to www.nittanyanthology.com. At this Web site, you can find rosters and depth charts from every Penn State season. It's a deep and seemingly reliable resource.
Q: Chico, with all this talk of the new Penn State it seemed painfully obvious that after the score was set at 17-10, PSU reverted back to the old Penn State. Three into the line and punt. I believe this happened four times. It is a good thing the defense was up to the challenge. What happened to trying to make a first down? There was no indication throughout the game that we had a tight end. The wide receivers became invisible and short passes were nonexistent. Ohio State could stack the line and shut down the offense. You cannot always be successful without an offense in the third and fourth quarters. The plays were extremely predictable and in the finest Penn State tradition
Tony Agnone of Rome, N.Y.
HARLAN: Good point, Tony. A few players, following the game, actually told me they were less than enthused with the fourth-quarter play calling. Deon Butler, for one, swore that any of the wideouts could have broken off a big play if only a long pass had been called. (He mentioned that Ohio State was playing more and more man-to-man coverage, and its cornerbacks were creeping up to the line of scrimmage to stop the run.) Anyway, for whatever reason, Penn State opted for an ultra-conservative game plan in the fourth quarter -- this was the Pat Buchanon of play-calling. Even though it never ended up costing Penn State the win, I still didn't like the approach coaches took. Without question, they were playing not to lose. Sure, maybe they had confidence the defense could hold Ohio State, but the way I see it, the fourth-quarter strategy seemed to suggest that they didn't have confidence in the offense. Frankly, after a half-season of success, I think the offense earned the chance to win games for itself. I can't understand why it was suddenly shackled.
In the final 15 minutes of the game, the Lions didn't manage a single first down. I agree that offenses should pull back a little when playing with the lead, but there's no reason to completely go into a shell. This would have been a far greater complaint this week had Penn State blown the lead, but as it is, it still makes for an interesting note. When a game is on the line, it still seems as if PSU wants its defense -- and perhaps only its defense -- to determine the game.
Q: I am a die-hard Penn State fan and absolutely enjoyed the Penn State-Ohio State game this past weekend. However, like the Pittsburgh Steelers in the Kordell Stewart days, Penn State will never have a real chance at the national championship against the high-powered offenses like USC until they get a quality quarterback to take advantage of the speedy receivers. In the Northwestern game Michael Robinson overthrew so many wide open receivers that there is no way Penn State can take advantage of their speed if they have no one to throw to them. In your opinion would Anthony Morelli be a better fit? Looks like a great 2006!
Carl of St. Mary's, Pa.
HARLAN: I think that's a foolish question, Carl. No, Penn State would not be better off with Morelli. Not this year at least. You're not giving Michael Robinson enough credit. OK, so Robinson is no Matt Leinart, but nobody else in the country is. I don't know why you're picking on Robinson in this instance. You could just as easily say Penn State won't have a legitimate chance to win a national championship until a Reggie Bush-caliber player replaces Tony Hunt.
As it is, Penn State doesn't have enough talent to win a national championship -- that's right, I'm saying it! -- and it's not purely because of Robinson; it's not purely because of any one player. But c'mon, Carl. Right now, Penn State is 6-0. Its offense has gone from lethargic to legitimate in just a half-season. You mention that Robinson doesn't have the ability to take advantage of the young wideouts, but I would suggest, conversely, that the only reason you know about said young wideouts is because of the fact that Robinson is getting them the ball.
Sure, he makes more than his share of errant throws, but in all, he's played better than most would have guessed -- especially following two turnover-free games. So before you start worrying about 2006, actually enjoy this season.
Q: Chico, I love the Q&A. I've never seen Beaver Stadium so packed to the brim and fired up with such energy. I was surprised to see that Saturday's game didn't beat the PSU-Nebraska attendance record in 2002 of 110,753. If the weather was not as bad on Saturday, do you think we would've had the 900 some additional people and broken the attendance record at Beaver Stadium? But even if people didn't go because of the weather, isn't the count "paid attendance" anyways? With tickets going from $150-$250 on eBay, I find it hard to believe that any seats were left empty. The only thing I can think of is that there were more unpaid guests in attendance. Do unpaid guests such as visiting team bands, high school recruits and the media figure into that attendance number?
Dan of Monessen
HARLAN: I wasn't sure, initially, about your question, Dan, but my gut was that recruits and media members and band members weren't counted. So I asked Jeff Nelson, Penn State's head sports information director, who informed me that all of those folks are indeed counted into the official attendance totals. So when you see an attendance of 109,000-plus at the Beav, that includes everybody except those belonging to the two teams on the field. To answer the other part of your question, yes, I bet warmer or dryer weather would have boosted the attendance by the thousand or so needed for the Beaver Stadium record. Or, better yet, knowing what we now know, Penn State could have asked 1,000 high school seniors to travel up to State College for unofficial visits. That would have helped the record just the same.
Q: Are you are fan or an objective journalist? Judging by the way you gush over PSU, I would say you lean way too much towards the fan side. The season is far from over. Can we hold off pronouncing PSU is back until after the bowl games?
James Smith of Pittsburgh
HARLAN: As readers of this Q&A probably know by now, I don't turn away from profession-related questions, even when they're asked pointedly. That's fine with me. I appreciate the interest, and in your case, James, I want you to know I take your opinion seriously. I'll answer your question with as much honesty as I can muster.
First of all, I am not a fan. Let's discount that notion right away. (Though some readers may be disappointed to hear me say that.) I say I'm not fan for several reasons, and it goes beyond not cheering. I relate to Penn State differently than a fan would, because I maintain a working relationship -- one based on the sharing of information -- with PSU's players and coaches. Sometimes that relationship is frustrating, sometimes it is rewarding -- but it always remains professional. When I watch a football game, I no longer see it as good-versus-bad or black-versus-white. Now, I simply see two teams whose emotions and fortunes hang in the balance based on one outcome. My job is to provide insight and intrigue when conveying what happens.
You ask, secondly, if I consider myself objective. Anybody who uses the term "objective journalist" is either kidding you or kidding himself. Totally objective journalism doesn't exist. We all enter every story, every article with biases, and though a professional journalist tries to reduce those biases, they can never be totally eliminated. Objective journalism is like absolute zero: you can never quite get there. That said, I've never been inclined to lavish Penn State with excessive praise. If you think I have a tendency to "gush" about the Lions, you must not have read a single word I wrote last season. You're right -- I have essentially said that "Penn State is back" this season, but I don't say that from a fan's perspective. When I say Penn State is back, I simply want to convey that the Lions have regained the swagger -- and the national spotlight -- that once was lost. If I waited until the end of the season to reserve judgment, I'd come off as being pretty darn slow and indecisive. When writing daily articles, I don't have he luxury to keep everything vanilla until the conclusion of the season. That would short-change the emotion I hope to inject into every article.
Q: There is one of PSU's heralded freshmen wideouts we haven't seen much of lately. I don't recall seeing Lydell Sargeant on the field since Week 1. Is he hurt, or just unseen because of the other four freshmen at wideout? If he isn't hurt, given he has played a few plays in week one, it would seem that his redshirt year is being wasted, as we saw last year with Anthony Morelli. Any idea what is up with Sargeant?
John Penner of Los Angeles, Calif.
HARLAN: Sargeant is not hurt, John, but you are correct in your observation about his playing time at wideout. In the season opener, he saw multiple snaps in Penn State's three- and four-receiver sets, and at the time, it looked like he'd grow into one of the go-to freshmen. Well, the season is half over, and Sargeant still only has one catch -- a four-yarder in the season opener. His offensive playing time is way down. (Against OSU, I don't think he saw a single snap at receiver.) He's still appearing on special teams, though. I wouldn't necessarily say he's wasting his freshman year. Think about it. Very few freshmen, especially in typical seasons, come in and immediately make a tremendous impact. Maybe Williams and King et al are skewing our expectations. Most players, though, make pretty quiet contributions in their first season or two -- like Sargeant, by playing on special teams. That doesn't mean he's being wasted.
Q: Hey, Chico, I've seen a lot being made about Penn State canceling the official visits that had been scheduled for recruits for this past weekend, but I'm wondering if everyone truly understands what goes into an official visit. The fact that the game was moved to a 7:45 p.m. starting time eliminated a lot of the time (pretty much a whole day) that the coaching staff would have been able to devote to these recruits, and really would have short-changed their visits. From people I know that were at the game, there were many of the players that are being recruited on the sidelines attending the game on unofficial visits, so that, along with all the media coverage surrounding the game should minimize any potential negative fall-out in terms of recruiting, from having to reschedule those official visits. Your thoughts?
Chris Santinoceto of Wheeling, W.Va.
HARLAN: For the benefit of everybody reading this, Chris? well, actually, it might be for the detriment of everybody reading this? I am going to recount the NCAA-defined differences between official and unofficial visits. Division I-A football programs, per NCAA bylaws, can allow a given prospect only one official visit during said player's high school career. With few exceptions, a program is limited to hosting 56 official visits per year. Those visits may not exceed 48 hours in length. The school is allowed to pay for transportation costs to and from the prospect's home.
For unofficial visits, the rules are a bit different. High schoolers can take an unlimited number of unofficial visits, provided they do so on their own dime. The school, however, may provide complimentary admission to home athletic events.
Both are vital to recruiting, and both can lead directly to recruits signing on at a given school. You are indeed correct, Chris, in saying that Penn State had a handful of players in State College on unofficial visits. The Lions have that almost every game. They also pick a few weekends every year to host a handful of official visits. In this case, I do believe that canceling those visits was a bad idea. Even if the coaches couldn't have spent much time with the recruits, I think that seeing such an atmosphere -- and, in hindsight, such an important PSU victory -- could have been used as an invaluable recruiting tool. As it turned out, though, Penn State botched the situation -- mostly, because it waited so long to cancel the trips. How would you feel, after all, if you'd arranged your schedule to travel out of state for the weekend and then, suddenly, a travel agency told you the trip wouldn't happen? Those high schoolers have a right to be upset. If in fact those trips were canceled because coaches were concerned about not being able to spend enough time with the recruits, I must simply wonder why Penn State waited so long to notify them. The start time for the Ohio State game was announced before the season began.
Q: Yes, it was a huge win over Ohio State, but don't you think the offense played more "not to lose" versus to put the game out of reach? I counted at least three straight series where we ran a dive with Hunt on first-and-10. I thought Galen Hall was brought in to innovate the offense; not to reincarnate the '86 offense that beat UM in the Fiesta Bowl. Yes, a win over Ohio State at this stage is huge. But, a play action pass to Smolko over the middle would've been nice to see, especially since Ohio State was run blitzing nearly every play. It looked like the game was turned over to the defense to win after our field goal to start the second half. I know you picked Ohio State to win, but your latest column appears to have made you a believer now. What do you think about the offensive strategy in the second half?
Mick of Universal City, Texas
HARLAN: As I stated earlier, I wasn't enthused by the offensive strategy late in the game. I've never been a fan of teams altering their game plans simply because they own the lead. That's why I don't like the prevent defense. And I would go so far as to call this the offensive equivalent: This was the prevent offense, if you will. It was designed, essentially, to minimize the chance of costly mistakes. But by extension, it drastically reduced the chance to Penn State scoring. That wasn't fair to the PSU defense, which could have benefited from a little security.
Q: I saw that you were pumped up by the question from the PSU fan from Spain so I decided to write you a question from China. I love reading your coverage of the Lions. I am probably one of the few people on this continent who is up, listening to Penn State live on the Internet. Most games start in the middle of the night here. Unfortunately, I do not get to see them play. Therefore, I need you to help me understand where these players rank compared to some of Penn State's all-time best at their respective positions. Example: where does Posluszny rank in the linebacker category, etc. From the amount of times his name is mentioned on the play-by-play, he must be up there with some of the best.
D. Kirtz of Shangha, China
HARLAN: OK, I'll pick out three players and try to describe them to you, giving you the kind of detail you might not be able to pick up on the Internet broadcasts?
Paul Posluszny: He's Penn State's best player, no question about it. Even on plays when the announcers don't mention his name, he's probably doing something right -- be it dropping back in a passing zone and taking away a throwing lane, or simply pursuing a quarterback and forcing him to hurry a throw. He's a throwback player, the kind that Penn State should be proud to have. Coaches call him Shane Conlan reincarnate. Picture Conlan, and you have a good idea.
Michael Robinson: His throwing motion isn't pretty -- it's almost like he's loading a slingshot, as he slowly pulls his arm back -- but he throws a high, arching deep ball that ranks among the best in the Big Ten. He runs hard, and outside of the pocket, he seems to find another gear. Still, I get the sense that every time he runs, fans in Beaver Stadium hold their collective breath; we've seen too many fumbles to forget Robinson's downside just yet.
Tony Hunt: He runs with a powerful gallop, and he's done a fine job this season of churning out tough yards by keeping his legs moving and hauling defenders. The one thing that prevents him from becoming a top-tier back? He's had several runs this season -- probably between three and five -- where's he's been one missed tackle away from breaking off an enormous touchdown run. He still lacks that breakaway potential. A lot of his 10- and 12-yard gains are oh-so-close to being 50-yard touchdown runs.
Q: Hey Chico, I am a fifth-year senior at Indiana, and I just got back from the Indiana vs. Illinois tailgate. The word around Bloomington, Ind., is that Indiana has a good chance to win the Big Ten and make a BCS bowl. I know that Penn State is looking good right now and they seem to have a good chance at winning the conference title, but I am all for Indiana. Who do you think has a better chance, IU or Penn State?
Mike Semaan of Bloomington, Ind.
HARLAN: For the sake of full disclosure, I should acknowledge that I know this individual -- despite what his smart-aleck introduction might suggest. Mike and I actually grew up together, neighbors on the same baseball teams and such. We were also both very talented at wasting our time playing Madden video games together. (Though I must say, Mike was the better sport when it came to losing; he did have more practice at it.) Anyway, if your question does somehow carry a thrust of seriousness -- and I am not convinced that it does -- then let me tell you definitively that Indiana's chances of winning the Big Ten are about as high as me eating a stadium-sized bowl of guacamole. That said, the Hoosiers are moving in the right direction. They're 4-1 overall, 1-1 in the conference. Not bad for first-year coach Terry Hoeppner. I still remember back in August at Big Ten media day, Hoeppner took the podium in front of several hundred hungry and bored media members and talked -- as if he'd just consumed 13 double-shot espressos -- about how Indiana football was back! "Yes baby, back!"
Mostly, the hungry and bored media members just rolled their eyes. But now, it actually does look like Indiana is moving in the right direction. Still, based on where Hoeppner started, he'll need a few years before he can hope to contend for any kind of Big Ten title.
Q: I know it's probably a mistake to look at next year, but I can't help myself. On offense, I'm excited about Morelli and the skill positions, but who's there to fill the void on the 0-line? Same question for the D-Line. If we could get these positions filled for next year, then I see no reason why we couldn't be right back on top. So my question: Is there depth at the line positions to fill the voids next year?
Gene of Chicago, Ill.
HARLAN: You're right, Gene. It's a little too early to look ahead, but for the sake of passing the time, I'll pontificate. At first blush, the D-line will be in better shape come 2006 than the O-line. Though Scott Paxson, Tamba Hali and Matthew Rice will all depart, Jay Alford will be back for his senior season. He'll be joined inside, most likely, by Ed Johnson, who's missing this current year for disciplinary reasons. Still, Johnson is an excellent player -- a defensive tackle with NFL potential. The end positions will be a bit trickier, but expect Mike Lucian and Josh Gaines -- both of whom have seen playing time this season -- to be the front-runners.
On the offensive line, only Levi Brown will be back, leaving four openings. A.Q. Shipley will almost certainly start at one of the guard spots, considering that he's played on-and-off with Charles Rush thus far in 2005. But after that, there are a lot of question marks. Some of the players to look at: guard Greg Harrison, currently a redshirt freshman, center Patrick Weber, now a sophomore, and tackle Gerald Cadogan, currently a redshirt freshman.
Q: Hey Chico! I can't help but wonder how many more questions you're getting these days now that the Nits are playing meaningful games. That said, I'll keep my weekly query brief -- in last week's Q&A, you opined that due to it's reliance on unproven talent over the long haul of a season, Penn State is due to "turn in a dud game or two" by season's end. Not to put you on the spot here, but do you feel that going into Ann Arbor as a (as of Wednesday) 3-point dog, this is finally the week for a letdown? Why or why not?
Mark Sprague of Cumberland, R. I.
HARLAN: No, this won't be the week Penn State will get blown out, but I foresee a tough game. I'd put the odds of a PSU loss at 65 percent: the Lions are playing against a 3-3 Michigan team, but don't let the record fool you. This team is loaded with talent, and given that the Wolverines are playing at home, Penn State might just be walking into its toughest game of the season. Remember, Penn State has only played one road game this season, and certainly Ryan Field can't compare with Michigan Stadium. If I'm forced to make a prediction? 24-16, Michigan.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.