Q:

Okay Chico, from a fan's perspective, I'm looking at a team with an "athlete" playing quarterback, several speedy game-breakers at wide receiver, a running back nobody knows much about because he runs behind a mediocre offensive line, an experienced and talent-laden defense with workmanlike ballers at linebacker and a conservative coach who likes to win big games close. Sound familiar? Ladies and gentlemen, I give you the Ohio State Buckeyes! My question is with two squads that mirror each other talent-wise, what role do you see any extraneous factors playing in Saturday's game? Do you prefer the "been-there-done-that" big game experience of the Buckeyes or will the home-field advantage of the Nittany Lions prove a bigger factor?

Have your own question?

Click here to submit your question

Advertise with us

Mark Sprague of Cumberland, R.I.

HARLAN: First of all, Mark, you're dead-on in suggesting that these two teams are mirror-images of one another. OK, so maybe there's a little distortion between the two mirrors -- I think the Buckeyes are a little stronger -- but overall, these teams stack up almost identically in terms of talents and weaknesses. So yes, I think there's a good chance this game will come down to the nuances. I do think the Buckeyes' big-game experience will be beneficial, for several reasons. First, Penn State's young players -- and let's face it, the Lions rely on several -- will be battling some nerves. They've admitted as much this week. Moreover, because it's a night game, they'll have all day to sit around and think about the magnitude of the game. No doubt PSU coaches will design some activities to help the team keep its mind right, but that's no easy task.

Still, I find this game fantastically intriguing. As you note, big game experience separates these two teams. So, too, do preseason expectations. The Buckeyes were pegged as a Big Ten title contender. The Lions weren't. So in truth, the Buckeyes come into this game with a taking-care-of-business mentality. The Lions, conversely, feel as if they're riding in as the unheralded team still seeking wide-scale respect.

Here's one more factor why this game is so difficult to predict. The Lions are a team with enormous potential, position-by-position. Across the board, they have the chance to really explode, as we saw against Minnesota. When all units of the offense and defense are clicking, Penn State can compete with -- and defeat -- any team in the Big Ten. You couldn't truthfully say that last season. But here's the thing. Though Penn State is a team with a very high ceiling, it's also a team that is, as I call it, very combustible. They rely on too many players who have yet to develop into sure things, players who are almost certain to turn in a dud game or two before the season is out. Mark my word, it's only a matter of time before Penn State is blown out. But? that doesn't mean it will happen this Saturday.

Q: Young Chico -- I apologize for my absence. I've been on a fact-finding mission, looking for the true Ira Rothstein, past the false sheen that Long Island casts on its inhabitants. I felt trapped, neutered even -- and I thought to myself, boy, I wish that actually happened before I had my son Michael.

Advertise with us

Anyway, Chico, my journey took me from my humblest of burgs around the country, to different dominions, places where it's all right to make no sense (1600 Pennsylvania Ave.) and others where it's everything is simply all right (State College, Pa.).

One of my stops, Chico, was enlightening, cathartic even. I forced myself to go to Columbus, Ohio, and lo and behold I saw two men with hair so ratty it looked like they were using a new shampoo called Raw Sewage. Women would walk up to them on High Street and ask them how they were doing in their AIDS Awareness and golf classes and, immediately, I knew: These were Ohio State linebackers.

Old Ira would have gone up to them and tested their intelligence with questions such as "What is Ohm's law?" and "What famous author's given last name is Korzeniowski?" and "How do you spell surname of the former Oilers receiver named Haywood?" But no. Not this new incarnation of Ira. I learned along my journey that selfish motivations beget poisoned souls.

So I simply walked up to them and, in the softest voice possible, said: "We are

... "

Advertise with us

Without missing a beat, one of them said, "Stupid ... duh," and at that point, Chico, I knew my journey was complete and that I could go home.

Who wins Saturday?

Ira Rothstein of East Meadow, N.Y.

HARLAN: It's simply glorious to see your return on the even of this monumental game, Ira, though I must say, several dear readers have ratcheted up their nonsensicality in recent weeks, perhaps to fill the void of your absence. (Note the guacamole question below.) Anyway, you seek a prediction, and at this point -- with your existence fully actualized -- I would be foolish to deny you. Sadly, however, I'll deny you the happiness of a predicted Penn State victory.

Final score: Buckeyes 17, Nits 16.

Advertise with us

Q: Hey Chico. Alan Zemaitis was quoted as saying, "This year, every team we play, we owe something to them." I'm hoping with all the hype surrounding this weekend's game, the team doesn't forget this attitude. Last week they got payback on a tired and emotionally drained Minnesota team that, in my opinion, underestimated Penn State. With a well-rested Buckeye team fully aware of our capabilities coming to town, do you think Penn State can stay focused despite the media blitz? Or is success going to their heads? I am particularly interested in your opinion as to how the freshmen are handling the national attention.

Brian of Orange, Calif.

HARLAN: I have absolute certainty, 100-percent, that the media blitz will not hinder Penn State's focus. Here's why: For one, Joe Paterno makes it his mission to keep his players at arm's length from the media. During game weeks, those players never speak with media members face-to-face. They are instead subjected to multi-person teleconferences that can be tedious for both parties involved. Trust me, there is no "blitz" or "frenzy" in these media sessions. And though Penn State is now receiving its first dose of national media attention, most of that attention generally concludes that Penn State will be back to its old beloved self if it can win Saturday. I doubt players read much of that stuff, but when they do, I would figure such talk would only enhance their focus.

As for the freshmen, fear not. Perhaps you've realized that, following the two most recent games, Paterno has allowed Derrick Williams and Justin King into the media room. In previous years, he's almost never allowed freshmen to speak. But Williams and King are different. Both have been attracting media attention for years. They were speaking to recruiting gurus and prep football writers long before they signed with Penn State. And, as a result, they're far more media savvy than the typical freshmen. They already know the rules of engagement, and this is nothing new for them.

Q: Last Saturday's game against the Minnesota showed how important the offensive line is. With all the speed and quickness that we have now, it still takes a real good performance from the offensive line to make it work. The offense really gave the defense a huge shot in the arm. This is most fun I have had watching them play in the last five years. I just hope they keep it going. The next three weeks should let us know how far they really come.

Advertise with us

Warren Quinn of Schuylkill Haven

HARLAN: That's just a comment, I guess, not a question. But yeah, you're right. The O-line is always the key. Fifty years of coachspeak doesn't lie.

Q: I wonder if JoePa will have second thoughts about not letting Derrick Williams or Justin King return punts this weekend against Ohio State when Ted Ginn kills the Lions with long returns. Your comments, please.

Chuck Leech Sr. of Huntington Beach, Calif.

HARLAN: Good point, Chuck. I think the Lions would be wise -- extremely wise -- to use Williams or King as a punt-returner this week. If indeed this contest comes down to the details, as many close games do, then why not give your team every advantage it can get? This is the flat-out truth: As long as Penn State continues to use Calvin Lowry as its punt returner, it is short-changing itself. How else to say it?? Lowry an awful punt returner; not only is he tentative, but he also has the lateral quickness of a monorail trail. I can't understand why PSU doesn't swap Lowry with a player -- like Williams or King -- who's far more likely to present a threat on special teams. Maybe, after Penn State spends the week preparing for a team with a similar return threat already in place, Paterno will realize the logic of using such a strategy himself. Though such a scenario is possible, I also think it's unlikely. Paterno sees Lowry as the safe choice as a punt returner, and I get the sense that Paterno will opt to play it safe in such a big game. Lowry, he feels, will not fumble. He won't lose the football game for you. But I argue this: Why not use somebody who can help you win instead of somebody who merely can prevent you from losing?

Advertise with us

Q: Chico: I really enjoyed the fierce hitting in the Minnesota game, particularly the smack that Paul Posluszny put on the Gopher running back at the goal line. How do you rank that hit in terms of recent Penn State history? I thought it was a super play!

Tony Ciucci of Pittsburgh

HARLAN: I thought the hit was a fantastic play, but I'd hardly rank it that high on any list of greatest hits. In fact, I don't think it was even the best hit of the game. I'd give that one to Michael Robinson, for his hit on Brandon Owens. For one, Robinson is a quarterback -- a position rarely associated with delivering huge hits. Second, the hit crystallized a key moment in the game, and third, it helped rally the team. (In addition, the hit was serious enough that it knocked Owens from the game.) If Posluszny's tackle had taken place at a more critical juncture of the game, then perhaps I would allow it a little more importance. As it was, it will make for nice footage when Penn State releases its 2005 season DVD, but it won't live on as the hit people remember.

Q: There now appears to be too much young talent at linebacker. With the lack of depth at defensive line this year, a switch to a 3-4 defense for this season and the next several years may be the way to go. What think you?

Bob of Ponca City, Oklahoma

Advertise with us

HARLAN: I disagree. Penn State should, and will, stick with the 4-3. Thing is, you can't switch to a certain kind of defense simply because you have players stocked at a given position for one- or two-year window. That's shortsighted. If Penn State were to switch to a 3-4 base defense, its coaches would have to teach and learn new techniques; its players would have to learn an entirely new system of defense. The Lions would also need the kind of run-stuffing nose tackle that few pro teams, let alone few college teams, can find.

Even if PSU sticks with the 4-3 defense, I don't think you can say it has "too much" talent at linebacker. Having strong talented depth is never a horrible problem. The players who are simply too talented to keep off the field -- Paul Posluszny, in particular -- will play regardless of the defensive system. Using three linebackers instead of four simply means the rest will have to fight that much harder for playing time. Nothing wrong with that. And if one of those players suffers an injury, the Lions can pluck a capable back-up from the bench. If they switch for the 3-4, they'll lose that luxury.

Q: I think we should calm the excitement about the win over Minnesota. Minnesota looked listless after a tough game with Purdue; note Purdue's collapse against Notre Dame. This seems to happen frequently in the Big Ten when a team wins a tough game and has to go on the road the next week. Minnesota didn't blitz the entire game, giving Robinson all day in the pocket and yet he was still only 12 for 32, which is a bit disconcerting. Some of his passes looked like a reincarnation of Steve Blass pitches. Ohio State is going to have much more team speed on both sides of the ball and a lot more weapons to deal with. State may have the adrenaline and crowd support to sustain them early, but do you think they have enough to handle Ohio State for four quarters? The only passes Robinson seems comfortable throwing are bombs and it was obvious that Minnesota sat in deep zones to take that away. Ohio State's corners are going to show things that our freshmen receivers haven't seen yet. Will they be able to overcome this?

Mick of Universal City, Texas

HARLAN: I'm not certain that Penn State's offense will succeed on Saturday, Mick, but here's one reason I'm fairly optimistic about the Lions' offense this season. It shows an unfailing ability to adapt. Yes, you mention the fact that OSU's corners might have the ability to take some things away from PSU's young receivers, and you're probably right. But here's the thing -- in each of the last five games, Penn State has moved the ball by taking advantage of whatever the defense wasn't taking away. Remember, the Gophers, all things considered, did a pretty good job of removing the long pass plays from Penn State's playbook. And in turn, Penn State was still able to adapt: it spread out the offense and ran Mike Robinson and Tony Hunt up the middle. I see this as a reason for optimism -- the Lions can change their stripes almost on the fly, so if Ohio State makes it a point to gameplan against one particular aspect of the PSU offense, there's reason to believe Penn State can still overcome that. Such is the advantage of having a balanced offense.

Advertise with us

Now I will say this. Ohio State's defense is drastically better than Minnesota's, and for that matter, drastically better than anything Penn State has seen all season. There's a chance the Buckeyes might just shut down PSU's entire offensive operation, at which point balance won't mean a thing. I can't say for sure if this is the game where Penn State's offense falls back to Earth, but even if it does, I think this is an offense that will be fairly productive most games for the remainder of the season.

Q: Chico, long-time reader, first-time writer. I have to take exception to your analysis of PSU not going for the two-point conversion on the final touchdown to go up by six instead of five. I know JoePa said he didn't even think about it, nevertheless, I believe you don't go for two here since if there is a turnover the other way for 98 some yards, Northwestern gets two points, making the lead only 3, a field goal to tie. I know you could call a safe play, but the way the ball was bouncing around, especially slipping out of Michael's hands, I think you simply kick the extra point. Keep up the good work and the good fight.

Peter Hmel of Gaithersburg, Md.

HARLAN: I appreciate the inaugural mailbag drop-in, Peter, but I'm gonna stick with my original thought here. The way you rationalize it, Penn State shouldn't have gone for two out of fear that maybe -- on some super-slim chance -- the opposition returned the ball 90-some the other way. Quite simply, that is the definition of playing scared, playing not to lose. A team shouldn't be deterred from trying for two simply because one out of 1,000 times it will result in two points going the other way. Penn State has to have confidence in its own players to get the job done. Say the Lions had gone for two in the aforementioned situation. They had a 40 percent chance to creating a six-point lead. They had a 59.9 percent chance of kicking off with a four-point lead. And they had a 0.1 percent chance of kicking off with a two-point lead. (If a fumble or interception was returned the other way.) No football team should let an extremely unlikely negative outcome prevent them from going for a very possible positive outcome.

Just my thoughts.

Advertise with us

Of course, had some 320-pound Northwestern defensive tackle lumbered 98-yards downfield for a return, I probably woulda ripped JoePa for trying the conversion.

Q: Suppose that Beaver Stadium was filled with guacamole. Theoretically speaking, how many chips would it take to dip all of the guacamole out of the Beav?

Rick of Pittsburgh

HARLAN: I am glad you felt the need to clarify that we are speaking "theoretically," Rick. Because were we to test this experimentally, I think we'd ruin the world's avocado supply before we found an answer. But anyway, to answer your question, I think we first must determine the average size dip of guacamole placed on a chip. For instance, were I the one determining the dip size, I would probably opt for a larger dollop of guacamole than the typical Beaver Stadium attendee. (I do love the green stuff!) I could probably finish of a Beaver-sized guacamole bowl with 12 or 13 chips. I think the average person might need 12 or 13 billion. But that's just a guess. What say you?

Q: Chico, I enjoy your coverage of the team, and thanks to Internet I can listen to your questions at the press conferences and of course the games on Saturdays. It helps me keep linked to my blue and white blood. Anyways, on to my question of this next stretch, do you agree that Michigan and Purdue could be our big upset victories this year? I feel that Michigan has issues that make it suspect.

Advertise with us

B.J. Biringer of Valencia, Spain

HARLAN: First of all, B.J., let me say that I'm pumped to receive a question from a reader in Spain. I dare say you're the first international mailer I've had since I started this mailbag in 2004. (That said, I have had mailers from other planets, and I suspect Rick, he of the question above, might qualify.) Anyway, it's too early to know whether the games against Michigan and Purdue will even count as "upset" opportunities for Penn State. If the Lions topple Ohio State, they'll probably jump into the top-10. And at that point, they'll be the higher-ranked team in almost every game they play thereafter.

But just one note about Michigan. Don't be fooled by the Wolverines' sluggish start. This is still an excellent football team, one of the three or four best in the Big Ten. And when Mike Hart is healthy, they can beat any team within the conference. If Penn State does indeed beat OSU on Saturday, it will have another huge test looming just days ahead.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.