Q:

Chico, M-Rob looked confused a lot during the Northwestern game and did not look comfortable. He missed a lot of underneath routes, always looking for the home-run ball. Whatever happened to throwing to the tight end? I believe because of the constant shifting around the last three years at various positions, has hurt M-Rob. Morelli is clearly a more refined passer. M-Rob had countless balls tipped at the line of scrimmage against a sub-par Wildcats team. I believe the Minnesota game will be a test of what this team is truly made of. Your thoughts?

Have your own question?

Click here to submit your question

Advertise with us

Len of Venice, Fla.

HARLAN: I agree with your assessment of Robinson. Though he discovered his poise just in time for the final drive, he lacked such control for most of the game. The Northwestern game marked the first instance of the season when Robinson truly looked shaky. He committed a few bonehead plays, his hands seemed to be coated with Vaseline and -- as you note -- a few of his short- and mid-range passes missed the mark. It's impossible to condemn Robinson's performance Saturday because of the way he finished off, but he must improve to give Penn State a chance to win the next few games. A few things in particular that he must work on: too often, he looks to a primary target and nothing else; he struggles on short passes over the middle -- I've noticed he seems more comfortable throwing to the sidelines; he also fumbles way too often. Somebody later in this Q&A makes the assessment, an excellent one I feel, that Robinson plays like a sophomore. A talented one, yes. But a sophomore. Really, he's inexperienced at quarterback, and it shows. That said, he throws a fine deep ball, and that has served Penn State extremely well so far. It's almost as if the Lions have become the most unorthodox of one-dimensional offenses: they excel, above all else, at scoring by simply having their receivers sprint down the field. So far, it's working, but I think it's safe to say that the offensive must sprout some new dimensions to be effective in these next three games.

Oh, and as for Morelli, I think you're off base in saying he's clearly a more refined passer. Compared to Robinson, Morelli clearly has the stronger arm, Len, but let's see what happens when he faces first-team defenses during games that are still close. I agree that Morelli is an exciting prospect, but little about his game is refined.

Q: Chico, through the first four games, how much rotation is Penn State going through on the O-line? Are we seeing any of the younger kids getting reps? On a side note, I was at the Northwestern game and the protection looked pretty good. Northwestern's D-line looked every bit as big and quick as any faced so far this season

Ric of McKinney, Texas

Advertise with us

HARLAN: At least against Northwestern, Penn State only rotated at two O-line positions -- left guard and center. At left guard, Charles Rush (a senior) and A.Q. Shipley (a redshirt freshman) are just about splitting time equally at this point. (Though, if I may add, I think that Rush is a fairly uninspiring player, whereas Shipley shows a great amount of promise. I think PSU would be better off giving Shipley more and more playing time as things go along this season.) And at center, E.Z. Smith entered the game in the second quarter, replacing starter Lance Antolick. It would be unfair to call this situation at center a true "rotation." It's fairly clear that the rotation will end soon; perhaps it already has. As you likely know, Smith started last year, and is working himself back from a spring and summer of inactivity with the football team. He missed this time because of some mischief, having decided one late January night that it might be funny to aim Tyler Reed's bow-and-arrow at an apartment wall. After Smith damaged the property, he did some short-term damage to his standing at Penn State. However, last week, in his first game back, I was surprised at how sharp he looked. He was an immediate upgrade over Antolick, a player who worked hard to fill Smith's hole but in the end lacked the natural skills. Smith will regain his status as an every-down player, perhaps as early as this week. With Smith in there, PSU's line improves significantly. And you're right, Ric. The O-line, while hardly great, has looked competent so far this season -- a respectable improvement. That's good news for anybody who remembers watching Chris Ganter play last season.

Q: While I have always (maybe almost always) enjoyed your writing, your constant berating of State's early competition is getting a little old. With South Florida's destruction of Louisville, might this end your train of thought and rate a mea culpa?

Dave of Detroit, Mich.

HARLAN: I owe only a small one, for now. I agree that Penn State's victory against South Florida now looks a little more impressive. But only the next month or two will indicate whether that South Florida win against Louisville was a complete fluke -- a team playing the game of its season -- or a sign of a truly underrated team. If the Bulls keep it up, I'll acknowledge Penn State's first game, retrospectively, as a strong win against good competition.

Q: Do you think the Lions can win two more games this season to qualify for a bowl this year with Michael Robinson at quarterback? I'm glad to see some freshmen getting valuable experience. I feel for Michael, but I think Morelli needs to get the experience too, as a sophomore. I'm a big, big fan of Joe's, but he needs to build for the immediate future. Michael is like a sophomore quarterback now, and you might as well play a sophomore who will be back in 2006. What's your take on that?

Advertise with us

Richard of Riverside, Calif.

HARLAN: Good point, first of all, on saying that Robinson plays like a sophomore. That's a concise way to encapsulate his abilities: he plays like a talented prospect without much quarterbacking experience. (Problem is? By the time he gets the right experience to develop into a first-rate reliable quarterback, he'll be property of some NFL team? or some NFL Europe team? or some workers union? or something.) Anyway, based on cold logic, you make a salient point. Essentially, you suggest playing Morelli over Robinson because -- at least entering the 2006 season -- both shared roughly the same level of polish and experience at the quarterback position. Here's why I think Penn State has no choice, though, but to play Robinson this season. As I've mentioned before, his teammates respond to his leadership -- more so than they respond right now to Morelli's. Moreover, Robinson, after waiting so many seasons without complaining, deserves an opportunity to play quarterback for this team. So far, he's been shaky at times, but if you let your eyes blur a bit, you can picture a quarterback who, by season's end, will work almost perfectly for this offense. Of course, a lot can happen between now and the end of the season. Robinson might regress or continue his turnover habits. He might continue his current level of play, which will be good enough to beat the weak teams but too inconsistent to topple the better teams. He might also improve, and leave fans wondering what might have been had Robinson given years, not months, to play his position.

Anyway, to the point. You say that Paterno's responsibility is to the future. I say that he holds responsibility to the immediate future -- as in, the next seven or eight games of 2005. And in those games, Robinson, in part for intangible reasons, gives this team a better chance to win. He'll get the Lions to a bowl game, I think. Might not be a great one, but it will be an improvement over what they've had in the previous two seasons.

Q: Chico, Let me start by saying that I love your PSU insight. I read just about everything that I can get my eyes on with regards to PSU football and I can always tell that you truly know what is going on with the team, on and off the field. Which brings me to my question. I read recently that you said that there is not P-G bias against PSU and that both PSU and Pitt have their separate coverage teams. [Sunday's] articles, however, by Ron Cook and Bob Smizik, prove that there clearly is a bias. Penn State beats a Big Ten opponent in Northwestern and Ron Cook writes that they were lucky that they played

Northwestern and that they would have been beaten by any good team. Pitt on the other hand beats I-AA Youngstown St. and Bob Smizik writes how this is just what they needed to stop their skid. How is it unbiased to bash a win against a Big Ten opponent for PSU, only to praise a clearly weaker Pitt team for their win against Youngstown State? Are you sure that the P-G writers still have no bias against PSU?

Advertise with us

Pat Bernot of Butler

HARLAN: I really don't want to be put in the somewhat uncomfortable position of defending those who can speak for themselves, Pat, but let me say this: Both Cook and Smizik are columnists. They are entitled to write what they want, so long as their opinions are honest and backed with solid reporting. In the instance of their columns last Sunday, one can easily make arguments that both were spot-on with their opinions. If I could caution one thing? remember, don't look at one example -- two columns, juxtaposed against one another -- and try to paint some big-picture theory. Over the course of many weeks and many columns, the coverage is equal and fair -- guarantee it. Cook and Smizik have too much respect for their jobs and their professor to harbor any biases toward Pitt or Penn State, and I'm sure they'd tell you the same thing.

Q: OK, Chico, I admit it, I was wrong. Our best player isn't a punter -- though our punter is pretty good! Our best "player" is actually a group of freshmen wideouts -- the kids are good! But, sadly, the team isn't! Had we been anywhere in the Big Ten [Saturday] but Evanston, we would have lost by 21 or more. Don't let the folks up there drink the Kool-Aid! Why is Joe so stubborn?! He is going to sit Morelli and stick with Robinson no matter what he does or does not do. How do you explain the fact that in three-plus years the crack coaching staff hasn't found a position for Robinson -- unquestionably a gifted athlete, but not a quarterback. We continue to let talent waste away on the bench -- Morelli, in this case, a kid with a gun for an arm! At least Joe is playing the young wideouts and not sitting them. Ready to revise your season picks? No Kool-Aid for me just yet -- that was Northwestern!

Jack of Dallas, Texas

HARLAN: The quarterback situation is complicated -- as illustrated by the number of questions that continually draw up new opinions and ideas -- but when you boil it all down, I think Penn State is handling things mostly the proper way. Robinson should be this team's starter. I've provided multiple reasons for this in recent weeks, and none of those reasons have to do with Paterno being "stubborn," as you say. Would Robinson be a more polished quarterback if he'd been handled properly during his first three years? Yes, obviously. But Robinson, though flawed, still deserves this chance. And through four games, I'd say he's earned the opportunity to continue as the starter. Granted, he's made numerous mistakes, but the season is one-third over, and he's already thrown nine touchdown passes -- more than Zack Mills threw all of last season!

Advertise with us

Another way to look at it: Before the season, one strong reason for playing Morelli at quarterback was because that would allow Robinson to return to wideout, where he could help allay PSU's weakness at that position. Well, now I would contend that wide receiver no longer counts as a weakness. In fact, if Robinson was switched back to receiver, he wouldn't even be on the field all that often. You say, Jack, that it's a shame that somebody of Morelli's talent can waste away on the bench. Well, I counter that if Robinson was pulled in favor of Morelli, an even greater talent would be relegated to the bench.

Don't worry, Morelli will have his time at Penn State. This year, though, belongs to Robinson -- at least until he seriously proves otherwise. But for now, Paterno is playing Robinson at quarterback because he feels that gives Penn State the best chance to thrive this season. Things will surely get tougher, schedule-wise, starting this Saturday, and I agree that Robinson must reduce his mistakes. If he struggles during the upcoming month -- and Penn State is, say, 4-3 or 4-4 -- then the Morelli conversation is warranted.

Q: Chico, it was a painful game to watch, but in previous years we lose that game. Maybe Penn State is finally turning the corner. At any rate, I thought there were two coaching mistakes. First, on one of Northwestern's last drives they were called with a holding penalty on second down. Penn State declined the penalty, which would have made it second-and-25. Instead, it was third-and-15. The Wildcats converted on third down for 14-plus yards. They converted fourth-and-inches for a first down. Wouldn't the odds have been more favorable for accepting the penalty? The second question I have is why didn't they attempt a two-point conversion after the last touchdown? A six-point lead is much more significant than five. If Northwestern did score, they would have to convert the extra point. There was nothing to lose. A five-point lead is no better than four at that stage of the game. Just curious for your thoughts on these two decisions?

Brad Williamson of Bridgeville

HARLAN: Thanks for the question, Brad. OK, so let's go decision-by-decision here.

Advertise with us

First scenario: Penn State declines a holding penalty to set up a third-and-15 situation for Northwestern's offense. I agree with this strategy 100 percent, and from watching football for many years and at many levels, I would suggest that almost every head coach would do similarly. Odds dictate that it's harder to pick up 15 yards in one play than it is 25 yards in two plays. Simply said, in the first situation, the offense MUST gain 15 yards. Second situation, the offense needs to average only 12.5 yards per play, and though this is hardly a light task, you're essentially allowing the offense several ways to pick up the first down: It can use one long play, or it can string together two decent plays. By staying on the field longer, you're also increasing the odds for a defensive holding penalty or facemask -- that kind of thing that would lead to an automatic first down. Just because Penn State allowed the first down in said situation doesn't mean it made the wrong decision.

Second scenario: With less than a minute left, Penn State scores a touchdown to go up four points. They kick the extra point for a five-point lead. Why not go for two?

During his weekly press conference, somebody actually asked Paterno why he chose to kick the PAT. And Paterno said he had no clue why on Earth the reporter would even suggest the two-point conversion. Well, to be blunt, I was totally surprised by Paterno's answer. Truth is, he should have gone for two there, as you seem to sense. You're exactly right: with only a few seconds left in the game, a four-point lead and a five-point lead are essentially the same. Either way, Northwestern still needs to score a touchdown. So why not try for a six-point lead, thereby making it essential for the Wildcats to convert the extra point if they score a touchdown? I think it's almost frightening that Paterno never thought about this. Granted, in college football, a kicker can be counted on to make between 95- and 98-percent of his PATs, but those percentages should not be discounted. Say Northwestern scored the presumed go-ahead touchdown: Penn State would still have a small chance of forcing overtime. Obviously this never came into play, but I think the Lions could have handled this better.

Q: What is the real reason that Joe has recently decided to play solid freshman? For so many years the freshman and sophomores waited patiently behind qualified upperclassmen. Does this change speak more to his "exit plan" or to a lack of depth from the previous recruiting classes?

Tom of Cleveland, Ohio

Advertise with us

HARLAN: The real reason is that he needs to. Justin King and Derrick Williams and Deon Butler are all exceptional players. Yes, it's true that Penn State typically operates with the wait-your-turn philosophy when it comes to younger players, but in this instance, there is no reason to wait. In older times, Penn State was stocked with juniors and seniors at most positions. At wideout, though, the Lions entered the year without a single experienced player. Paterno had no choice but to let these young players sink or swim. It's simple as that. This has nothing to do with his "exit plan." I don't know how one can extrapolate an exit plan from watching, say, Jordan Norwood catch five passes.

Q: Hey Chico! Yet another offensive query for you to ponder, this time concerning the passing game. I'm wondering, can you tell us if the multitude of batted balls by the opposing defensive line is a product of Michael Robinson not choosing appropriate throwing lanes, or is the O-line just giving that much ground?

Mark Sprague of Cumberland, R.I.

HARLAN: This week, Robinson offered an explanation for it, Mark, and I'll relay it here. Robinson mentioned that Northwestern's defensive linemen weren't making it a priority to rush after him; instead, on many plays, they were waiting at the line of scrimmage, taking up space in the passing lanes and jumping at the proper time. You hear this explanation quite often after games in which a quarterback has some balls batted down by linemen. I tend to think scrambling quarterbacks are more often presented with opposing linemen who strategize not to go all-out with the pass rush; in other words, the D-line shifts more into a "spy" mode. So perhaps this is something to which Robinson must adjust.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.