Q:
When is JoePa going to put a real punt returner in there? No offense to Calvin Lowry, but he's more of a threat to fumble than anything else. And, he never looks comfortable handling the ball. Joe has Justin King and Derrick Williams returning kickoffs; how about punts too?
Have your own question?
Click here to submit your question
Mick of Universal City, Texas
HARLAN: Before I leave this world, I'd like to learn how the Egyptians built the pyramids and why Calvin Lowry returned punts for Penn State. Seriously, much respect for this astute question, Mick. I agree: using Lowry as a punt returner makes no sense whatsoever. I hate to be too tough on Lowry, because he's only doing what the coaches ask of him, but let's face it - as a returner, Lowry is unthreatening, hesitant and sometimes downright lead-footed. He fair-catches punts when the nearest defender is 15 yards away, and sometimes, he runs with punts that leave defenders on top of him like a guillotine blade. (He also has a penchant for poor decisions: note the punt he fair-caught inside the 5-yard-line in Week 1.) Then, last week, Lowry fumbled on a return, setting up Central Michigan's only score of the game. Honestly, I see no upside to leaving Lowry back there. Last year, you could maybe rationalize it, simply because nobody else on the roster stood out as somebody capable of upgrading the position. Now? Derrick Williams, Justin King and about three or four others could probably managed the punt returning duties better than Lowry does. Sure, those young guys might be prone to the occasional mistake, but let's be clear - each and every scholarship football player should be able to stand under a falling football and hang onto it. Then, it's just a matter making something happen. And that, I can assure you, is not Lowry's forte.
Q: I read your Q&A and noticed that you are checking you mailbox for the 2006 IKEA catalog. I work for IKEA and would like to send you one. Forward me the address and it will be yours. I am a Penn State alum and big fan!
Heather of Pittsburgh
HARLAN: I already get the IKEA catalogs, Heather, so don't worry, though the offer is greatly appreciated. (I pay special attention, every season, to the lighting section? I dig some of those translucent paper-wrapped fixtures.) But anyway, if you can help me get some recruiting letters from Tom Bradley, maybe I'll take you up on it.
Q: Chico, I enjoyed the JayPa article. Quick one - Was Zack Mills referring to JoePa when he said some of his coaches did not genuinely care about him? The opening phrase "unlike his father" and the closing phrase "unlike some of the coaches I've had" just seemed very confusing. What is your take?
Ron Schultz of Shaler
HARLAN: First of all, thanks for the kind words, Ron. Glad you enjoyed. The way I interpreted it, Mills was strictly comparing Jay with Joe when he said, "Unlike his father, Jay is very laid-back and easygoing." Then, I think Zack switched gears pretty quickly? he said: "He genuinely cares about you, unlike some of the coaches I've had." The last part of that quote was something of a veiled shot, but I didn't get the sense it was pointed directly (or even indirectly) at Joe. I should have stopped and asked Zack to elaborate, but by the time he was done answering, he was already off on another topic. Therefore, I guess it's up to interpretation. I wish I could answer things more definitively for you, Ron, but I guess I'll leave it at this: Some day, if and when the full Zack Mills story comes out, it will be one heck of a fascinating thing to hear.
Q: Chico, when are you going to make your first appearance on "Around the Horn" and quiet Jay Mariotti?
Greg Stein of Mt. Lebanon
HARLAN: Woooah there, Greg. One step at a time. I'm just trying to get on UPN's "Nightly Sports Call." That said, there is some hope for an ESPN appearance! Earlier in the summer, I was working on some bit-size articles about the unreality show going on at Montour High School, in which Dick Butkus engineers a guerilla-style takeover to overthrow Lou Cerro as head coach? um wait, I mean? Dick Butkus eases into the head coaching position, as Lou Cerro happily steps aside? and cameras capture what happens during the ensuing Montour season. Anyway, as I stopped by for a few preseason practices, one of the ESPN engineers asked that I sign a waiver, just in case the cameras accidentally captured me standing quietly on the sideline. So yeah, I could have my 1.5 seconds of fame. I figure "Around the Horn," after that appearance, won't be far away.
Q: Chico, give me a gut feeling. With an instant infusion of talent and speed at the wide receiver position and a still-suspect running game thus far, is it a foregone conclusion that as the passing game goes, so goes the Nittany Lions' 2005 conference record? If so, is Michael Robinson the right guy to be pulling the trigger as the season progresses?
Mark Sprague of Cumberland, R.I.
HARLAN: Yes, Robinson is the right guy, but I'll provide a little counterargument to your first assertion. I don't think that Penn State will be able to keep up its winning ways if it sticks with the pass-happy offense. Sooner than later, the passing game will be shut down, and the Lions will be forced to win with their running game. Last Saturday, Penn State passed the ball 36 times and ran the ball 31 times. Considering they were playing almost the entire game with a large lead - a situation that generally dictates a run-first, ground-it-out mentality - those numbers are almost inconceivable, given the traditional Penn State offensive mindset. And here are a few more numbers: tailback Tony Hunt had only 10 carries, and backup Austin Scott had only four. In short, the Lions offense looked like some creation of a Steve Spurrier daydream.
But I don't think that can keep up. When Penn State jumps into the Big Ten schedule, it won't be able to take advantage of blatant mismatches on the outside. The Lions' receivers won't automatically be able to out-sprint the defensive backs covering them. And thus, Penn State will be forced into more of a conventional offense. Because the group of wideouts is so young, the passing game will struggle at times - guaranteed. I don't think this team will allow itself to live and die with a group like that, a group that's still essentially unproven. Starting Saturday, the competition will toughen. The games will become closer. And running the football will become imperative.
I do think Penn State has a chance to run the ball more effectively this season, but it's too early to judge. I like Tony Hunt - he has a sturdy stride, and so long as the O-line proves half-competent, Hunt should be counted on for at least 75 yards every game. Last year, he had too many games with 20 yards or 40 yards.
The passing game, if it flourishes, will likely open up room for the running game. But I don't think you can say Penn State will live and die with the pass. After all, if the running game consistently turns into a non-factor, Penn State will struggle, too.
Q: It appears to me that not only have the young wide receivers injected much needed speed to the offense, they also appear to run more precise and disciplined pass routes. Could this be a reason that Michael Robinson seems to be getting more comfortable with each passing week? Thanks.
Jim Martin of Fairmont, W.Va.
HARLAN: There is not just one reason for Robinson's comfort after three games. I'll list them, in no particular order. Reason No. 1: As you mention, the receivers. Through three games, Penn State's key wideouts - Derrick Williams, Justin King, Deon Butler, Ethan Kilmer, Lydell Sargeant? maybe Terrell Golden - have been almost perfect. Aside from Kilmer, not one of them has dropped a pass. Not one! Last year's rotation of wideouts sometimes seemed to drop more balls than it caught. This counts as an extraordinary turnaround. And indeed, this batch of wideouts is an upgrade in almost every category. It's not just the hands. It's the downfield blocking. The route-running. The intensity. Robinson himself has mentioned that these receivers run every route with full focus. He said that last year, several of the receivers, when they figured they weren't the primary or secondary target, wouldn't run their routes full-go. Even though these guys are young, they're still leaps and bounds ahead of last year's group.
Reason No. 2: The competition. Sorry, but the triumvirate of one MAC pushover and two Big East bottom-feeders won't compare to the competition Penn State will now face in Big Ten play. And normally, when you compare teams in the upper and lower portions of Division I-A football, the biggest discrepancy in talent can been seen at the skill positions - in other words, spots like defensive back. In these last two games especially, Penn State's receivers have simply been able to sprint by the defensive backs. That's a trend that won't likely continue.
Reason No. 3: Robinson is practicing full-time at quarterback, and this makes a difference. He can devote all of his time to his mechanics and his knowledge of the quarterback position.
Reason No. 4: Robinson has not taken any bad hits, and in these last two games, the offensive line play has improved. When the quarterback is given time to throw, his comfort level will increase drastically. We noticed the inverse of this last year. I'm convinced Zack Mills could have been a more-than-capable college quarterback had he been grouped with a decent offensive line and a host of wideouts who could catch the ball better than manikins. So far this season, Robinson has had the protection. He's had the receiver productivity. And as a result, it's been easier for him to hold up his end of the bargain.
Q: I hate to be a wet blanket, Chico, but I won't believe that Penn State can beat Minnesota, Ohio State, Michigan, Wisconsin and Michigan State until the offensive line shows that it can protect the quarterbacks against a good defensive line and linebackers and give Robinson time to complete passes to the speedy receivers. Now for my question: Is there another major Division I team that uses the kooky system of one assistant coach calling the runs and another assistant coach calling the passes? And, how do they decide whether the play will be a run or a pass? Does JoePa rub his hair with his right hand for a pass and with his left hand for a run?
Chuck Leech Sr. of Huntington Beach, Calif.
HARLAN: I can't say for sure, Chuck, because you're asking me to compare Penn State against 118 other Division I-A teams. Considering that I try to eat two-and-a-half square meals every day, and considering I generally like to get 6 or more hours of sleep, and considering that I make a habit of devoting at least one of my waking hours every week to Law & Order SVU, I simply don't have the time to compile such comparative knowledge. I don't want to leave you empty-handed, though, Chuck, so hopefully I can satisfy at least some of your questioning desire by telling you that, yes, Penn State has one of the more elaborate play-calling systems in college football. But this season, to be honest, things have been going more smoothly. Used to be, players complained that they weren't receiving the play calls with enough time. Mills, for instance, would need to rush to the line of scrimmage, and his leeway for calling audibles and reading the defense would be limited. Now, Robinson seems to have plenty of time - sometimes 15 seconds or more - to walk to the line of scrimmage, set up, and look things over. Whatever is going on up there - and whatever way Joe's hair is flowing - it seems to be working well enough.
Q: Isn't Michael Robinson just a reincarnation of Rashard Casey? Please explain why Paterno refuses to play Anthony Morelli, who definitely has the pedigree.
Brett Simpson of Baltimore, Md.
HARLAN: First of all, Paterno doesn't refuse to play Morelli. He refuses to start Morelli. There are a bunch of reasons for this, and most of them have already been reiterated, but let me provide the one that is most often overlooked. It's an intangible one. But it might also double as the most important one. Simply said, this is Robinson's offense. Ask almost any Penn State player - Robinson is one of the most loved and respected players on the Lions' roster. He is the only offensive captain not because he plays quarterback, but because he oozes with leadership. In fact, he's one of the first true leaders Penn State has had in the last few years. He challenges players (like Austin Scott) who under-perform. He encourages and assists players who need tutelage; earlier this year, when PSU's wideout group was still greener than a Granny Smith, Robinson was so helpful to them, Deon Butler later said that Robinson had in fact become the group's leader? even though he doesn't player their position. Robinson lives with a pair of charismatic seniors, Alan Zemaitis and Matthew Rice, and both of those guys are influential defensive players from a chemistry standpoint. They've done their part in convincing players on the defensive side of the ball that Robinson is the guy to lead PSU's offense. If Morelli suddenly became this team's starting quarterback for reasons other than injury, I think the decision would cause a huge fracture in Penn State's chemistry. That's not the only reason Robinson is starting over Morelli, but I think that's a good place to start.
Q: I've heard some fans suggest that Penn State, out of the blue, now has the best 1-2 quarterback punch in the conference. Agree? I don't really think so, but I thought I'd put it out there for discussion.
Eric Gilbert of Meadville
HARLAN: Let me the end the discussion quite definitively, Eric. No no no no no no. The people who suggest this - if anybody actually does; I haven't heard this myself - are likely looking more at Morelli, whose recent performances suggest he's a more-than-acceptable backup for the season. But if you're judging 1-2 punches, the first option should be weighed far more heavily than the second. In other words, for a team to rank well at quarterback, it must have an exceptional, proven starter and a dependable backup who could come in without fans suddenly muttering a bunch of exclamation points and ampersands. (At least in cartoon-speak.) Anyway, I agree that Penn State now has a pretty decent option at No. 2. But Robinson is still far from proven. He may still grow into one of the Big Ten's best quarterbacks this season, but let's be honest - if you were picking from the lot of Big Ten quarterbacks, at least four or five of them would rank above Robinson. Easily. Drew Tate was the Big Ten's Offensive Player of the Year in 2004. Chad Henne was a stud freshman. Drew Stanton is an excellent passed in MSU's offense. Even Brett Basanez, though he plays for often-overlooked Northwestern, does a fine job running the Wildcats' spread offense. I'm sorry, but until Robinson plays himself into the upper echelon of Big Ten quarterbacks, I don't think you can argue very legitimately that Penn State has a top-flight 1-2 quarterback punch.
Q: OK, at the end of the non-conference slate, what's your revised prediction for the outcome of the season, based on what's happened so far? Any hope for a really special season? Give me some good news, Chico. Come on. I need something this season that's a lot, a lot better than what we've been getting.
Tim of Baldwin
HARLAN: I think I'll stick with the 7-4 outcome I suggested at the beginning of the season, but just for kicks, I'll break it down game-by-game. Lame as I find middle-of-road predictions, it's even worse to change your predictions as things go on.
at Northwestern - W; The Lions have looked dreadful on the road in recent years, but not as dreadful as the Wildcats' D looked last week. Finally, PSU has the offensive firepower to take advantage of this 11-man sieve.
Minnesota - L; The bubble bursts. A close, tight game, and things are about to get worse.
Ohio State - L; Much worse.
at Michigan - L; Much, much worse.
at Illinois - W; The middle-of-the-season stretch this year replicates the five-game wrecking ball that crushed this team last year. But unlike 2004, this year's Lions will have the ability to rebound. Granted, playing Illinois helps.
Purdue - W; This will be Penn State's best win in the last two-plus years. And it will be the game that cements Penn State as a legitimate bowl team.
Wisconsin - W; Yeah, the Badgers look good so far, but I'm convinced they'll fall back to earth. At this juncture of the season, they'll be a middle-of-the-pack team, and Penn State will take away the Badgers' best offensive player, Brian Calhoun.
at Michigan State - L; Everything goes out the window when that Land-Grant Trophy is up for grabs.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.