Q:

Glad to see you are back for another year of coverage. I have written a number of mostly negative questions to both you and your predecessors over the years. Sorry, but the on-field performance warranted my queries. This year, I am currently, pleasantly confused by the Lions. I have seen many positives and negatives with the performance to date. My question this week is somewhat hypothetical in that I have heard a good deal regarding the fact that the Lions could have utilized short slants and screens against both South Florida and Cincy with success, but chose not to in order to better prepare for the rigors of a Big Ten schedule. I guess the rationale was that it would be very easy to move the ball against these defenses in this manner, but not provide much in the way of experience to the starters who would have much more challenging assignments once the Big Ten schedule begins. What are your thoughts on this? Are the Lions simply scrimmaging against these teams of lesser talent in an attempt to better prepare for the rigors of the Big Ten?

Have your own question?

Click here to submit your question

Advertise with us

Gene Ritter of Suwanee, Ga.

HARLAN: Interesting question, Gene, but I think it's way off base. If I understand what you're saying, you suggest here that Penn State might actually be eliminating certain plays from the offensive playbook because they would work too easily. No way. Penn State could have a 178-year-old coach and it wouldn't be that foolish. Let me just back up my viewpoint here with a couple thoughts. First of all, let's go back to last weekend's game. In the second half, the Lions had a pretty easy time moving the ball downfield by way of deep passes. They completed three passes longer than 40 yards in quick succession. And, in truth, they completed these passes against defensive backs who aren't of the caliber Penn State will be seeing in a matter of weeks. If the Galen Hall-JayPa juggernaut was to borrow your logic here, Penn State would have stopped throwing deep passes because it was becoming too easy. No football coach on the planet will make his job harder by scrapping plays that will work. It's simply delusional.

Second, though sideline cynics like myself can make light of Penn State's first three opponents, the Lions don't have that luxury. They can't assume a given game will yield a victory. I hate to bring up Pitt in this instance, because this forum ought to be strictly Penn State-oriented -- of course, exceptions made for Chipotle burritos and Kenny Chesney -- but what if the Panthers had scrapped certain easy plays against Ohio on Friday night? How haunted would Wanny have been after the game, knowing he could have taken easy steps to prevent the loss?

Anyway, let's not forget that Joe Paterno mentioned last week that Cincinnati was as good as Michigan or Ohio State. Oh, and then he said this week that Central Michigan was the best team his Lions have faced to date? meaning the Chippewas are better than Cincinnati? and Michigan? and Ohio State! Right. So in conclusion, Central Michigan is one of the nation's best teams, if not the best, so I don't expect JoePa to hold anything back. Kapeesh?

Q: If memory serves me correctly, was Justin King receiving 30 letters a day from Tom Bradley during the final stages of his recruiting process? If that is true, what in the world could possibly be said that would need 30 letters? I doubt if soldiers in war send home 30 letters per day. Please let me know if my memory is playing tricks on me in my advancing age. This is something that's been bugging me since what, January.

Advertise with us

Joe of Lynchburg, Va.

HARLAN: Great, great question, Joe. Honestly, to borrow from the terminology of Bednarik and Groza, you're now on the Ira Rothstein Watch List -- the annual award (OK, it's really just a sentence or two) given to the most entertaining question of the year. First of all, I am totally tickled to think that somebody like you, somebody several states away from State College, can be plagued for months -- yes, months!!! -- by the thoughts of the letters written from a Penn State assistant football coach to a recruit.

But now that I've lumbered through that long-winded intro, let me finally answer your question, albeit in a manner that will probably be of little substance. First of all, you are indeed correct that Tom Bradley, on at least one occasion, sent 30 letters to King in a given day. I agree, it's absurd. Unconscionable, really. But it also worked. I, too, would guess that our soldiers aren't writing 30 letters per day, if for no other reason that they have far more pressing matters to attend to. But what, you ask, could one say in 30 letters?

Thinking about what I receive in the mail, I'd just hope for a fall IKEA catalog.

Q: Hey Chico, great coverage of PSU football. It's obvious to me from the Week 1 game that the offensive line is in just as bad shape as it was last year, for most of the plays. However, it is clear to me that when the Lions pitch it back to Hunt, and he's got Snow in front of him or some other lead blocker, and the O-linemen make a charge up field, they have some nice success. Do you know why we don't run the ball like this more? I'm hoping we make more of a commitment to this type of running style, because it's obvious we can't pass- protect well.

Advertise with us

Eric of Midlothian, Texas

HARLAN: It's a byproduct of using more wide receivers and spreading out the offense. I feel it will be interesting to watch how this develops during the season, Eric. You make a good point. Before the previous game, actually, Tony Hunt was asked for his thoughts about the running game, and he specifically mentioned that he hoped for a few more runs behind the fullback. The thing is, I think PSU will gradually de-emphasize the fullback position this season, if it hasn't already, in favor of more three wideout sets. Once King, Williams, Butler, Sargeant et al progress, it will be harder and harder to keep them off the field. So Penn State will have to find a happy medium. But one other thing to consider: If indeed Penn State can truly stretch the field with the vertical passing game, as it did last Saturday, that will help the running game infinitely, purely by stretching the opposing defense and keeping it off guard. In that way, the wide-open attack might help Hunt more than he ever dreamed. We'll see. It's certainly something to watch.

Q: Hey Chico! Are most of the loyal PSU fans in that infamous river, Da Nile?! I love the Lions -- have lived and died with them for over thirty years. BUT, the offense is maybe the worst ever -- and that's saying something considering what we've seen the past few years. Our best player is a punter and the defense can't pitch shutouts in the Big Ten. We're toast!

Jack of Dallas, Texas

HARLAN: I love it: Da Nile. But c'mon, Jack. For all your clever wordplay, I think you're in another river -- maybe the WaBASH or something. There's no reason to bash Penn State just yet. Between Week 1 and Week 2, the offensive line improved; Michael Robinson improved; even the play-calling seemed more consistent. Penn State's offense might again prove to be sub-par, but let's not cast complete doom over the unit just yet. That said, I do like Jeremy Kapinos.

Advertise with us

Q: I have so many questions and comments about PSU football, but I'll just ask/make a few. Do you think that the inability of the offensive line to perform satisfactorily for a few years is due to poor selection of recruits or poor position coaching? Do you see any improvement on the horizon? How could JoePa ever consider redshirting Morelli when he is the only QB, other than Robinson, who has taken a snap during a game? Which players do you expect to transfer after this season because of lack of playing time (Scott, King, Williams etc.)? I'm exhausted already and haven't even scratched the surface of my questions/comments.

Chuck Leech Sr. of Huntington Beach, Calif.

HARLAN: Wow there, Chuck. Let's slow down. I'll start with your last question first, purely because it's the easiest to cast aside. There's no way I can foresee who might entertain transferring after the season. Not with nine or ten games still remaining. Even the average 1-800 tarot card reader couldn't tell you what's going to happen between now and Jan. 1. Maybe Austin Scott will turn into a 1,200-yard rusher. Then again, maybe he'll decide to leave school and pursue a carpentry career. (Hey, give him some two-by-fours, and he can make you a doghouse.) Who knows. Anyway, I won't speculate on transfers for quite a while.

Next, Morelli. I doubt JoePa ever seriously considered redshirting Morelli. If he had, that would have meant basically resigning yourself to the fact that Paul Cianciolo would serve for the year as the back-up. And let's face it, the back-up almost always goes through the season with some playing time. Especially with the way Michael Robinson scrambles, he's bound to be injured, even if only for a short period, before the season concludes. Of course, after Saturday, all Morelli redshirt talk is over. He played. He played well. And best as I know, he has yet to transfer.

Finally, the O-line. I feel like I've answered this question, or some derivative thereof, countless times. I've always spread the blame a bit more to coaching, because in truth, Penn State has landed some quality recruits. The Lions have never developed them. During that span, a lot of players have struggled on that O-line, and the coaching has been the one constant. Recruiting is an inexact science, yes, but when you take dozens of players over a matter of years, that's a pretty telling sample.

Advertise with us

Q: If Michael Robinson continues to struggle in this offense, how long will Joe Paterno wait to give Morelli the game experience he needs for next year?

Tom of Cleveland, Ohio

HARLAN: I think Morelli will play whether Robinson struggles or not. His performance on Saturday was encouraging, without question. Granted, Morelli was playing when the game was already decided, but he looked sharp. This much is certain: When Morelli lets go of the football, it has a lot more zip than Robinson's passes. You can tell with the naked eye that Morelli is an extremely skilled passer. Question is, does he have the other variables -- knowledge of the offense, leadership abilities, the instincts to improvise but avoid mistakes? Only time will tell, but I think that we'll gradually learn more and more about Morelli. He'll start appearing now in some tighter, more important situations. And hopefully, by season's end, Penn State has some answers about the man who will almost certainly start at quarterback next season. (Unless he transfers, that is.)

Q: I'm still concerned about Penn State's inability to line up and run the ball down an opponent's throat? to out-muscle its way to a first down on third-and-two. The offensive line woes of recent years don't appear to have gone away in '05, as evidenced by a less-than-consistent running attack, let alone the fact that heading into the third game, there still appears to be no cohesive starting rotation. This from a staff that used to turn walk-on farm boys into All-Americans. My question is this -- do you feel the coaching staff will have decided on a full-time starting OL unit prior to Big Ten play, or are we in for another season of the musical chair system being employed?

Mark Sprague of Cumberland, R.I.

Advertise with us

HARLAN: I feel that by the time Big Ten season rolls around -- and it's not too far away now -- the coaches will have a good idea of their full-time starters. At least when it comes to football lineups, musical chairs is a bad thing. I'll go position-by-position across the line and give a little prediction about how I think things will shake out. If it happens, you read it here first. If it doesn't happen? well, then I will probably transfer to another newspaper and let somebody else take the heat.

Left tackle -- This job belongs to Levi Brown, no matter how hard he tries to convince the coaches otherwise. He's been a disappointment here for the first two games, but nobody is there to push him. He'll have to be an outright disaster to get yanked.

Left guard -- Last game, A.Q. Shipley came in briefly to spell Charles Rush, who was pulled after a few blown plays. Shipley actually played like an upgrade, and I wouldn't be surprised if he earns the starting job within a few games.

Center -- This is the toughest one to predict. So far, Lance Antolick has been OK. Probably a little suspect at times, but he's basically performed as one might expect of a first-time starter who walked on at Penn State. The X-factor here is E.Z. Smith, the starter last season who is now working his way back from disciplinary problems. If Smith can work himself into shape, it's only a matter of time before he regains this spot.

Right guard -- Tyler Reed is back. Robert Price started the season-opener but he was quickly and rightfully sent to the bench. Reed is the better player here -- by a wide margin. The line is better with Reed in there, and I predict that Reed will have this job for the remainder of the season.

Advertise with us

Right tackle -- Big weakness. JoePa has a tendency to overrate many of his players -- every redshirt freshman safety from New Jersey is "gonna be a heckuva player" -- so you know something is wrong when Paterno admits that John Wilson isn't much of an athlete. In fact, Wilson was removed from the lineup on Saturday because he became too fatigued. During that span, he was replaced by Andrew Richardson. Let's just say Penn State's sports information department hasn't begun publicizing either player's pancake block totals.

Q: Hi Chico, regarding Michael Robinson, let's speed up the clock a few months, forget about his remaining games at good ol' State, and speculate on his possible pro career. Do you think he'd make it, say with the Steelers, as long as we're speculating, as a Hines Ward-type receiver/former quarterback? Cheers and keep up the good work. I enjoy your coverage.

Dick Davis of Sharpsville

HARLAN: Tough to say if MikeRob would be able to convert into a wideout at the pro level. Don't forget: Just because Ward pulled off the transition almost perfectly, let's not forget that most athletic college players who change positions for the NFL never pan out. Unlike Ward, who was drafted in the third round, Robinson probably doesn't have the ability to command such attention. I foresee him as a second-day selection. Teams will probably project him at various positions -- some might envision him as a safety, some might envision him as a receiver. Wideout is probably Robinson's best chance for an NFL career, but it won't be easy. The NFL isn't a place for projects or players who need to develop their skills. To make an NFL roster, one must be polished, with very few exceptions. And any No. 4 of No. 5 receiver will have to be competent on special teams. Clearly, Ward pulled it off perfectly. But that's the exception, not the rule.

Q: As I sat down to begin to ponder the Penn State offense, I switched the Texas-Ohio State game on and, lo and behold, was perplexed as to how the Nits had made it to Columbus in such a short amount of time (and what was that strange burnt orange color on the uniforms??) It's amazing how a confidant, decisive quarterback, along with a strong offensive line, make all those quarterback draws and sweeps look genius.

Advertise with us

Chris Santinoceto of Wheeling. W.Va.

HARLAN: Very observant, Chris. But you're 100-percent correct. The latest incarnation of Penn State's offense borrows much from Texas' style. During the offseason, a few offensive coaches traveled down to Austin, Texas, essentially to study the Longhorns' offense. Clearly, it made quite an impact, because similarities between PSU's offensive philosophy and Texas' are visible to the naked eye. Both teams employ an athletic quarterback and some elements of the spread. For now, as you mention (if it even needs to be mentioned), Texas pulls this off with far more polish and consistency. But hey, at least for all of those who make a profession of bashing Penn State's offensive philosophy -- at least now we know it can work.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.