Q: Chico! Great to see the man with pulse on "what's what" in Nittany Country back at it for another season! For my first query of 2005, I'll be brief. Michael Robinson looks to potentially have a nice career at the next level as a WR, but it is painfully obvious that a quarterback he is not. That said, in your estimation, how many games will it be until we see Anthony Morelli (or another quarterback) starting under center?

Have your own question?

Click here to submit your question

Mark Sprague of Cumberland, R. I.

Advertise with us

HARLAN: Thanks for the question, Mark. I should first add, I received numerous Morelli questions. Let this one stand for the masses. I received so many, in fact, that I added "M-O-R-E-L-L-I" to my Microsoft Word dictionary; I was sick and tired of seeing Red squiggly lines all over.

OK, so here's how I see the quarterback situation after Week 1: First of all, I'm not surprised -- not even a little -- that Morelli didn't appear last week. Before the game, I was speaking with another media member, who expressed his excitement to see how Morelli fared. I quickly responded that I was just interested to see IF Morelli played. We know by now that even when Paterno promises to play Morelli, it barely means anything. I trace such indecisiveness to a combination of factors. First, Paterno doesn't have full confidence in Morelli; he always favors veterans, by nature, and so long as a game is close he'd rather let Robinson decide the outcome. Second, I don't think he wants to chance to a quarterback controversy, which is exactly what would happen if Morelli came in and out-shined Robinson. Third, especially now, I think Joe is being very careful. He doesn't want to botch Morelli the way he did last season. In other words, before Joe plays Morelli whatsoever, he must make a commitment to play him frequently, and under all circumstances. If Joe can't make a commitment, Morelli would be better off redshirting.

So, you asked how many games will pass until we see Morelli starting. Well, Mark, I'd say 10 or 11, depending on whether Penn State reaches a bowl. To translate: I don't think we'll see Morelli starting this season. For that to happen, Robinson would have to flop monumentally or Penn State would have to fall into horrific injury problems at wideout. Honestly, even if Robinson plays poorly at quarterback all season, I think the job will remain his. In my mind, the interesting question isn't whether Morelli will become a starter in 2005. But I am interested in watching how the coaching staff handles him. They can't afford to botch it the way they did last season.

Q: Chico, good to hear you're still there for the Q&A. I didn't want to write last week because I wanted to see how the team responded. There was all this excitement, and then blah. My question is two-part: Is Paterno going to give in to his stubbornness and see what Morelli can actually do by actually letting him have a game? I just feel he deserves his chance. Secondly, will the O-line-ever develop these top recruits? I mean geeeezzzz. This is ridiculous, and I feel that we are being robbed because someone used to be a good and dependable coach.

John of Pittsburgh

Advertise with us

HARLAN: For Part One of your question, I'll refer you to my above answer. But I'll elaborate on Part Two, John. Nothing better than a little O-line conversation, eh? Evidently, you noticed, as I did, that the offensive line was downright abominable on Saturday -- surprising, given that at least a couple of the line's members are of high enough stock to appreciate country music. You're right, though. A lot of them arrived at Penn State as well-regarded recruits. So what on Earth happened? I do think a lot of it has to do with the coaching. We ought to reserve judgment on this year's unit, because things can change quickly in the first few weeks of a season. But this much cannot be denied: It's been too long since Penn State managed to consistently develop strong and fundamentally sound offensive linemen, particularly in the run-blocking department. Part of this has to be traced to the coaches, Bill Kenney and Dick Anderson. Media members aren't fortunate enough to watch practice, so I've never seen first-hand how they teach technique, but I do know that PSU's offensive linemen often seem unprepared for the opposing defensive lines. Even against South Florida, the Bulls' simple use of stunts caught Penn State off guard. This is inexcusable. Stunting isn't exactly a new football phenomenon. Just because the Lions hadn't seen such tendencies on film should exempt them from being able to handle it. Granted, he's a wideout, not an O-linemen, so perhaps I should go easy on him, but when Terrell Golden was asked about USF's "unexpected" stunting, he mentioned that Penn State had been unsure of how to prepare for the match-up because "[the Bulls] had a new coach or something." So I checked? the head coach has been there for nine seasons. Defensive ends coach has been there for six. The co-defensive coordinators have been there for five and eight seasons, respectively. All of which is to say, somebody at Penn State is horribly confused.

Q: Don't call me Chicken Little, but even though Saturday's game against South Florida was a win, I foresee another 4- or 5-win season at best. Except for two long runs, (one of those on a trick play), the offense did not generate any sustained drives against a mediocre to poor defense. In contrast, our Big Ten brethren breezed through opening day opponents. If South Florida had Robinson on the run, what will the likes of Ohio St and Michigan do to him?

South Florida has already exposed State's defense. Yes, they only gave up 13 points, but South Florida was its own worst enemy in dropped passes and turnovers. In the second half they ran at will up the gut of State's undersized line. What do you think the likes of Wisconsin, Minnesota, Ohio State, etc... with their mammoth offensive lines do against our thin and undersized line? Yes, our defensive backfield may rank as nearly the best in the country, but if the other team doesn't have to throw the ball it doesn't mean a hill of beans.

I don't mean to be the predictor of doom and gloom, but after the next two patsies, I see rough sledding ahead. Am I off base on this or am I not the only one that sees more problems than good times?

Mick Fulton of Universal City, Texas

Advertise with us

HARLAN: I see a few problems, Mick, and I think others do, too. But in this case, let me try to assuage your concerns about the defense. Honestly, that is the least of the Lions' concerns. Sure, the D got lucky with some dropped passes, but I was still impressed at Penn State's defensive power. Think back to the first few drives of the game: When Penn State needed to, it absolutely crushed the Bulls' offense. It was outright domination. Not even close. South Florida managed fewer than 10 yards in the first quarter. As the game wore on, the defense got a little fatigued. But that's OK. Even that can be blamed on the offense, in part, and by the time this team whips itself into midseason form, that won't happen. (Because let's be honest, fatigue should not be a factor for a defense when it spends 32 minutes on the field. Forty minutes, sure. But not 32.) Anyway, the defense has enough seniors and natural leaders to police itself. These players know how to steer themselves in the right direction.

The one concern that can be justifiably raised -- and it seems like you at least hint at it -- is depth on the defensive line. Especially after losing Ed Johnson and Lavon Chisley and (for a few games) Jim Shaw, PSU is down to its last bodies. But Saturday, I was impressed how they played, even in spite of those limitations. They faced a very respectable running back -- the kind of player who'd be able to start for many Big Ten teams -- and corralled him for the entire game. If Penn State incurs any more injuries on the defensive line, then it's time to worry. But for now, the unit is OK.

As for the four- or five-win season you fear? well, it could happen. I won't discount it. But if it does, the defense will be the last of the culprits.

Q: Hey Chico. Looking for positives on offense from Saturday, it now at least appears they finally have some play makers. It's good that they try and get the ball in Williams' and King's hands. But, what concerns me, is what appears to be a lack of an offensive system. There was no continuity in the play calls whatsoever.They didn't set up plays with other plays, there was just a mess of reverses, quarterback draws, and the occasional downfield pass. With all of their speed, I only remember two deep passes to stretch the field. One on the first play of the game and the other was to Ethan Kilmer. I understand they're trying to take advantage of Robinson's athleticism, but if he gets injured, can they really expect Morelli to run this same offense? From what you've heard, are there still three different coaches calling the plays? Until there's more of a system in place, I don't see them ever improving much on offense.

Chris of Bellevue

Advertise with us

HARLAN: I agree, Chris. The playcalling in the first game had plenty of problems. There seemed to be no direction to it. Part of this, I suspect, stems from the offensive line, which never blocked well enough to allow the team to sustain drives and sink into a rhythm. But here are a few things I noticed, in addition (or in repetition) of the points you brought up: First, this team almost never runs crossing patterns. Basically, the Lions draw an imaginary line down the middle of the field. The Y receiver stays on one side. The Z receiver stays on the other. At least for the first game, Penn State stuck primarily with fly patterns, short comeback routes and mid-range out patterns. Maybe that's because the team is depending on such young receivers, and Penn State doesn't want to overwhelm them. But there's no doubt that if PSU was to open up the playbook a bit more, it would have a more unpredictable offense. Then, moving on to the next topic, I've never seen a team run as many quarterback draws. The Lions even did it last year with Zack Mills. I understand that the Lions want to take advantage of Robinson's athleticism, but there are other ways to do it. Roll him out from time to time. I won't criticize Penn State for failing to stretch the field -- actually, I think the threat of the deep pass did just that against USF -- but the offense would help itself by adding some variety.

Q: It's abundantly clear to me that the square peg set of skills possessed by quarterback Michael Robinson cannot fit into the round hole of talent required to run the offense. I know Paterno has a history of being loyal to his seniors and that is a great quality, but not at the expense of everyone else. How can Paterno look the rest of the team in the eye, particularly the defense, and say he's got the best 22 on the field when it's clear he does not?

Jim of Newtown, Pa.

HARLAN: Robinson needs to be the on the field, in at least some capacity, Jim. I'm assuming you're in agreement with this. Next to Derrick Williams, he remains the offense's most explosive player. Next to anybody, he is the most experienced player. He can't leave the field, simple as that. Truth be told, I think Paterno does have the 22 best players on the field, or at least he's close. A few of the younger receivers might be better or more talented than Ethan Kilmer, but even the top wideouts, after Williams, are practically used interchangeably. I think Tyler Reed is far better than Robert Price at right guard, but I predict that Reed will be starting by Week 4, if not sooner. After that, I think Paterno basically has his strongest lineup on the field.

Q: As much as the Penn State football program is in flux nowadays, at least one thing seems to remain the same -- the uniform. However, wasn't there a time in the late 1960s or early 1970s when PSU had the uniform number on the helmets, too, similar to how Alabama does. Do you know the background of that uniform and does PSU ever plan to go back to such a thing? That's a decision I hope never happens. Keep up the good work.

Advertise with us

Nick Zulovich of Greenville, N.C.

HARLAN: Penn State is unlikely to make any drastic changes to its uniforms any time soon. Heck, from the stories I hear, it sounds like all the traditionalists in State College started steaming when the team added a Nike swoosh to the get-up. One can only imagine, then, what would happen if some decals were added to the helmets. But I'm with you, Nick: I hope the Lions stick with the uniforms they have. I like 'em a lot. Very classy. Extremely unique. There is a certain appeal in simplicity, I'd say. As for the history of the numbered helmets, PSU used them up through the mid-70s. Some of Paterno's best teams wore numbers on the helmets. Maybe you've noticed that a lot of schools are now reverting to that retro look; even my sorrowful alma mater, Syracuse, recently added numbers to the helmets. And that's not the only school to recently make the change. But no, I don't think Penn State will do it, nor do I think they should.

Q: Can you help me to understand how it is that (as of 9/3/05) the PG has dedicated two articles (with headlines referring to the incident) and one complete opinion column to Dan Connor making prank phone calls while there is no mention of a DUI arrest of a Pitt tight end in the paper? Is it any wonder why PSU fans think that there is a bias in the coverage of the two teams?

Ron Schultz of Shaler

HARLAN: Valid question, Rob. I will answer this question because I feel a little insight and explanation can help, in this instance, to provide some understanding. First, the Post-Gazette has no bias toward either team. None whatsoever. Coverage of Pitt and Penn State are essentially independent of one another, and contrary to popular belief, there is no "Big Brother" force that directs the reporters who deal with either program. Essentially, when you see differences in coverage, it stems from with individual differences in the reporters on the beat and, perhaps more important, the amount of access coming from the program. A few administrators from Penn State mentioned the same concern, Rob, that you wrote above, and this is what I told them: When the Connor news broke, for instance, it came during a dead period between PSU's Media Day (on Aug. 13) and JoePa's first press conference of the season (Aug 30). During these weeks of summer practice, many programs, Pitt included, have players and coaches available to speak to the media almost every day. Penn State is the exact opposite -- during the weeks leading up to the season, its players are secluded, leaving the media to deal with a dead period of unavailability. I am not casting judgment on this policy, because every program is free to operate as it chooses. But I can tell you exactly how it affects the media coverage. When some news -- any news -- breaks at Penn State during this dead period, it immediately consumes an enormous fraction of the overall coverage because it is, quite literally, the only thing media members have access to. In terms of my own coverage, happenings at Pitt never factor into the equation. Yes, I work for a newspaper in Pittsburgh, but I don't follow the Panthers, I don't root for the Panthers, and because I'm traveling with Penn State every weekend, I don't even watch the Panthers.

Advertise with us

Q: How long will Joe stay with Robinson at quarterback? If they win their first three games, which shouldn't be too difficult, but Robinson does not play very well, will he remain the starter? Loyalty at quarterback over the last several years has really hurt the team. If Robinson were to be the quarterback this year, then he should have been the quarterback last year as well.

Bob of Ponca City, Okla.

HARLAN: As I stated earlier, I think we'll see Robinson for the long haul. If indeed he struggles, the one change I could envision is an increase in Morelli's playing time. He might start appearing more and more, spelling Robinson at increasingly critical parts of the game. But I doubt that scenario will unfold. This is Robinson's offense, for better or worse.

Q: Thanks for all the great Penn State coverage. Do you have an opinion on why we are seeing more discipline problems with the team the last few years? It seems in the past we never heard of any problems. Either they didn't happen or they were covered up well. What do you think?

Mike of Lincoln, Calif.

Advertise with us

HARLAN: I trace it to a mix of reasons, Mike. All of the factors you mention carry some truth. In many ways, the media's willingness to report such transgressions has changed in the last generation. No longer can schools simply police themselves by privately handling all matters. Used to be, Paterno would practically terrorize players who screwed up, but the public never learned of the particular transgression. Now, many things are still kept under wraps, but some things do get out. The media searches for these things more vigilantly. And sometimes, Penn State self-reports its problems. (For instance, when official news regarding Dan Connor and, earlier, E.Z. Smith were handed down, the athletic department released short press releases providing some of the basic information.) This stems from another factor in the increase of knowledge about transgressions -- the Internet. Almost all news about almost every Division I-A football team makes its way onto message boards. So by extension, nothing stays secretive. When Penn State releases information about its troubled players, it often stems from a desire to get the truth out there, which in turn prevents the proliferation of message board rumors.

So do I think that players are acting out or getting in trouble more than they once did? No, not really. I think it's been going on for years. These players weren't saints 30 years ago or even 60 years ago. We just know more about it now.

Q: Good to see that you're back for another year of Penn State football, lending beautiful description to the Nittany Lions' games. See, out here in the middle of Idaho, I live in a tiny, two-room wood cabin with no cable television. I can only track my favorite college football team by using this here personal computer that I bought for $63 at a flea market in Nampa and a dial-up Internet connection that's slower than my brother-in-law in a barrel-racing competition. (But don't tell him I said that. Ol' Jed's very sensitive about his barrel racing.)

Anyway, having played defensive end at Nampa High back in the '70s, I especially enjoy reading about Penn State's defensive players. Heck, for the first quarter on Saturday, they seemed stingier than daddy's llama on shearin' day. (And that's after we zap the little bugger with a rusty cattle prod a couple dozen times.)

So which of Penn State's defenders would you say is the stingiest? The best at penetrating an opponent, if you will.

Advertise with us

Would it be Tim Shaw or Paul Posluszny, they of 10 tackles on Saturday? Or perhaps Scott Paxson, the fearsome tackle?

Thanks for the insight, Chico. You should try to make it out here to the Gem State some time. We make a mean red beer; there's no finer breakfast than some icy Miller Lite and tomato juice. Except for the $2.99 Grand Slam at the Denny's in Preston.

Richard Gosinya of Macks Inn, Idaho

HARLAN: Thanks for the, um, question, Richard -- or have you stolen Ira Rothstein's identity, ala the Monstars unto Larry Johnson in Space Jam? First, to preface, I've actually been to the Gem State before, and I have indeed sampled red beer. I could never quite develop a taste for it, because I swear that tomato juice and beer makes for an odd combination, but hey -- Jay Paterno and Galen Hall make for an odd combo, too, and that doesn't seem to stop Penn State.

Anyway, you ask about the D's stingiest player. It's not Shaw, nor is it Paxson, though both are strong players. Posluszny will probably take the title next year, but for now, I still have to give respect to Alan Zemaitis, the senior cornerback, who generally manages to shut down half of the field every game. He's also the defense's emotional leader, because he plays with and speaks with the kind of energy that is contagious. Sometimes, even when holding court with a bunch of jaded and tired media members, Zemaitis' passion can even get the media fired up. I don't advocate the football-is-war analogy, but Zemaitis truly believes it. This week, he talked for a few minutes about the similarities, and though he went overboard with the comparison, it underscores the way he feels about Penn State football. Once upon a time, Zemaitis told me he'd be happy to suffer a career-ending injury, so long as it happened on the last play of a bowl game. In other words, he loves college football so much, he sometimes doesn't even know how he'd feel about taking his passion to the pro level. That's unconventional, but with Zemaitis, it's also genuine.

Advertise with us

Q: If Pitt and Penn State were to square off this weekend at a neutral site, who do you think would be victorious? Why?

Robert York of Jefferson Hills

HARLAN: Too early to tell. I didn't get to watch Pitt's first game, so I can barely judge. Ask me at the end of October and I'll come up with something that's equal parts witty, insightful and guaranteed to anger the good folks from either BlueWhite Illustrated or Pantherlair.

Q: There have been a lot of questions/concerns about the performance of Penn State's offensive line, not only this year but also in the past several years. What is the status of Mark Farris? He is listed as a back-up tackle and has yet to come close to reaching the potential he had coming out of high school as a top recruit. Look at the career of Mike Jones at Iowa, a player who ranked similarly to Farris coming out of high school. Is Farris the exception in his slow development or should we expect similar progress from guys like Greg Harrison, Gerald Cadogan, etc.?

Brian of Greenville, Pa.

Advertise with us

HARLAN: Yeah, Farris is going nowhere at Penn State. Frankly, I haven't seen him on the field enough to assess his play -- he didn't even appear in the game last week -- but he isn't showing enough in practice to crack what is a fairly weak offensive line. He has been a disappointment, like several other PSU linemen who came to college as well-regarded recruits. Just because of Farris' struggles, don't expect other youngsters to follow suit. After all, recruiting is inexact, and every team -- every team -- has players who never pan out. The thing that concerns me, though, is the bigger picture. Penn State hasn't developed a top-flight lineman in years. The Lions have developed average linemen, and even a few above-average linemen, but it's been years since they've had a mauler. And the longer that goes on, the tougher and tougher it will become for PSU to attract O-line recruits with that kind of potential.

Q: I have to take issue with a response you gave in last week's Q&A where you called Penn State's out of conference schedule "shamefully easy." I agree that this year's schedule does not live up to past year's OOC (out of conference) schedule nor does it live up to the OOC schedules of programs of national prominence.

However, consider first that Penn St. was scheduled to play Alabama this year before the Tide backed out, leaving Penn St to scramble late to find a fill in (which became Cincinnati). Second, as you know, schedules are put together years in advance, and when this year's schedule was created (I believe) South Florida had come off of an 8-3 season which included a win at Pitt. Third, these two OOC games are against teams that are now in the Big East and teams that Pitt will get to play every year. Does this mean that Pitt's in conference games are now considered "shamefully easy," and if so, how is a BCS bid justified for the Big East and what defines a "successful" season at Pitt now? 8-3, 9-2, 10-1 if your victories are against South Florida, Cincinnati, UCONN, Rutgers every year? Finally, Penn State, like Pitt I believe, does a fair job on most years to schedule at least one respectable non-conference opponent (Miami, Notre Dame, Nebraska, B.C., Alabama to name a few). Because of one year with unusual circumstance, Penn State's scheduling should not be considered "shamefully easy."

Mike of Lexington Park, Md.

HARLAN: OK, Mike, maybe "shamefully" was the wrong word. I still stand by the fact that Penn State's out-of-conference schedule is pathetic. One of the weakest among all Division I-A programs. But "shamefully" neglects the fact that Penn State at least tried for something better.

Advertise with us

But please, it's best not to bring Pitt into the discussion. A different standard should apply when assessing in-conference schedules. Here's why: because the goal of in-conference play is to win the conference title. And in trying to do that, every team in the conference plays an equal slate of teams. So relatively, no in-conference schedule is easier than the other. If Pitt is trying to beat out Louisville for the Big East title, both teams essentially have the same path to that mission. Pitt has no choice but to play the teams in its conference. With out-of-conference schedules, there is an element of choice. Therefore, it should be scrutinized differently.

Q: Recently, I was taken on a wild ride through the State College Wal-Mart via a story on a tough-looking, soft-hearted football player named Alan Zemaitis. This is a tour de force article on par with the latest flick starring Keanu Reeves. It was also a nice change of pace from all the other newspaper articles I've been reading lately, regarding how the recent natural disaster will affect wheat and barley sales in my beloved home state. And as I looked over the pictures of the cornerback looking intimidating -- on a shopping trip -- I found myself wondering aloud, "Will the Penn State secondary bring the same fire to the field that Zemaitis does to Wal-Mart?"

Mitch J. Leier of Minneapolis, Minn.

HARLAN: The article you mention, Mitch, is worth linking, provided we are not breaking any copyright laws in the process. Frank Bodani, who wrote this piece for the York Daily Record, should be applauded for taking a story that's been told many times and re-energizing it with a new depth. Through Bodani's writing, readers gain a real sense of Zemaitis' relationship with his parents and many siblings. Not enough stories like this come out of Penn State, It came out to about 2,300 words -- or, better phrased, about half as long as this Q&A. Now, before I tack on another 1,000 words about barley sales, I should probably sign off for this week.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.