Greetings, readers and questioners and general lurkers. It's a pleasure to be back. As a few of you might know, this is my second year operating the Penn State Q&A, though for the moment I will decline all questions about the ominous and very probable sophomore slump. All questions about Penn State football are welcome, of course, and just to state the ground rules, priority is given to questions referencing country music, Chipotle burritos and Alan Zemaitis.
Have your own question?
Click here to submit your question
Q: Glad you're back for another year, Chico. As an avid Penn State fan, I'm very excited for the season to start. It seems like there's an energy around the team that hasn't been there for the last two years. But my concern is about the offensive line. It doesn't matter how great the new receivers, experienced running backs, or a new "slimmed-down" quarterback are if there's no one up front to block for them. Who do you think will be the starting five against South Florida? And do you see this as a major area of concern?
Bob of Columbia, S.C.
HARLAN: Yes, it's a concern. As last year exemplified, the offensive line, with its performance, can trigger everything else that happens on offense - for better or worse. Poor run blocking, for instance, can suffocate a running game, thereby allowing the opposition to focus on defending the pass, thereby making it far more difficult to throw downfield. When an offensive line fails to pass protect, the receivers can never make plays downfield, thereby failing to spread the defense, thereby limiting space for the running game. And come to think of it, that's pretty much what happened with Penn State last season. Because the offensive line struggled all year, nothing behind the linemen - or next to the linemen, counting wideouts and tight ends - could find a rhythm. If Penn State's O-line doesn't improve, the offense will be stuck in the same pattern. To the point of your question, I think one would be foolish to automatically assume the line will be improved. Think about it - Penn State, as of this moment, has uncertainty at three of its five line positions. The left side is solid, though unspectacular, with Levi Brown and Charles Rush. Everything else is mayhem. Because E.Z. Smith has missed so much time, the center spot is a battle between inexperienced back-ups - at least until Smith can work himself back into the starting lineup. And who knows about right guard and right tackle. If I had to guess the Week 1 starting lineup, I'd go with this: LT - Brown; LG - Rush; C - Lance Antolick; RG - Robert Price; RT - John Wilson. Players on the right side will be on a short leash, but that can almost be interpreted as the best news here. Though the Lions have no clear-cut No. 1 option at three of the O-line positions, they do have plenty of players competing for the spots. If one fails, a replacement won't be hard to find. Hopefully, by the time PSU reaches its Big Ten schedule, the team has found some fivesome capable of a decent job. Michael Robinson and the rest of the offense deserve at least that much.
Q: Why does the Post-Gazette jump on every chance they get to put Joe Paterno and Penn State football down? When something wrong happens at Penn State it makes the front page of the sports in big bold print with a cynical headline, but when Pitt does something wrong like having a player (Tyler Palko) drop the F-bomb on national TV it's like nothing happened. Yes, Penn State has had some recent off the field problems, but so have other colleges. It just seems when PSU has off the field problems the Post-Gazette really plays them up more so than if Pitt had these same problems. As much the Post-Gazette will try to degrade Penn State's football tradition with biased writing, Penn State will clean up its act and return to national prominence. In conclusion, I just would like the P-G to remain more unbiased when covering Penn State football.
Mark Haracznak of Lower Burrell
HARLAN: The Post-Gazette has no intention of denigrating Joe Paterno or his football program, and because I am the lone reporter here charged with covering ol' Joe and his football team, perhaps I should add that I, too, never aim for biased coverage. We cover all football programs the same way: we write about both the good and bad. After that, it's up to the football program to determine the balance of good and bad. But I think it does bear mentioning that Tyler Palko, the day he dropped his famous F-bomb, was actually just commenting on a Penn State headline in our paper that morning.
Q: I feel PSU will go 8-4 this year, what is your prediction?
Eddie of Stafford, Va.
HARLAN: Ah, such a simple question, but filled with so many landmines. You do realize, Eddie, that you are setting me up for disaster. Allow me to cite some reasons for why I feel this way. No. 1: If I pick Penn State to perform exceedingly well, I expose myself as a na?ve optimist, somebody prone and susceptible to the empty preseason boasting, and frankly I'd find such a reputation downright unbearable, being that I wear my cynicism as some folks wear their Livestrong bracelets. No. 2: In a similar vein, if I pick Penn State to do well, I simply cast myself into the lot of PSU followers who, as a rite of the season, overestimate their team's talent and potential. After all, familiarity and passion always skew your perspective. No. 3: If I predict Penn State to do poorly, I am immediately perceived as a geyser of negativity, one of those hardboiled media members who coulda frowned all the way through "Rudy." And I don't like, or want, this reputation. No. 4: Likewise, if I cast doom and gloom for the upcoming season, I immediately place some kind of shadowy expectation on everything to come, and because these are players and coaches I'll be learning about and dealing with all season, I'd rather not have every interaction predicated on the knowledge that I once predicted said players and coaches to fail miserably. No. 5: Nobody likes a middle-of-the-road prediction, because it's boring.
That said, I'll be boring, but mostly because this is what I truly believe. I foresee a 7-5 season. A 7-4 regular season (helped by a shamefully easy non-conference schedule) and an entirely unmemorable bowl loss. At this juncture, most Penn State fans would probably identify such a result as a disappointment, but in the wake of the last two seasons, I wouldn't be so sure.
Q: With true sophomore Mark Rubin out, will there be a receiver with game-experience ready to catch the ball from Michael Robinson and teach the young guys?
Bryan Huber of Pittsburgh
HARLAN: Tough to say. I think that the wideout spot is Penn State's greatest uncertainty heading into the season. It has the potential to dazzle. It also has the potential to disappoint. As of now, nobody - truly nobody - has experience at the position. The team's most talented wideout, Derrick Williams, played in high school last season. Deon Butler is a redshirt freshmen. Terrell Golden might qualify as the grizzled vet in the group, being that he caught three passes last year. Oh, and perhaps you noticed the senior Paterno inserted into the starting lineup. That would be Ethan Kilmer. You think he has experience? Try again. He hasn't played a game at wide receiver in his lifetime - even going back to high school.
That said, Penn State's wideout position is better than last season. I say that for several reasons. First, Williams provides a game-breaking element lacking in 2004. Second, the supporting cast is inexperienced, but also vast. At least one or two players during the season should grow into capable players. Last season, with Gerald Smith and Terrance Phillips, Penn State knew what it had; no receiver on the roster could worry a defense. Now, the PSU wideouts will likely mix some big mistakes with some big plays. But hey, I'd rather have a group that's unreliable but exciting than reliably unexciting.
This is Penn State's baby year at the position. Whoever is playing quarterback for the team in 2007 will have some of the best receivers in school history.
Q: There is still much animosity toward Paterno. I have not contributed for the past four years and hope many other alums will do the same. We just might blow "P" out of the water! Do you ever hear of any other such claims? Any other ideas how we might drag him out, kicking and screaming?
Ed of Pittsburgh
HARLAN: Paterno will not be dragged out by the fans. If indeed fans are disgusted with him - and frankly, I think a lot of the anger that built up against him last season has receded, at least temporarily - those voices of anger will never reach Paterno. Whenever he's been asked a question about his public perception, he immediately mentions that he has little care for the feelings of those who, by his perception, aren't closely involved with his football program.
Naturally, I don't say that to deter fans from sharing their ideas. Indeed, other Penn State administrators do take note when fans complain or gripe or call for the head of their 78-year-old coach. My point is, Paterno won't hear these complains directly. And most likely, he'll only leave his job when he wants to. No kicking and screaming.
Q: What is the status of offensive lineman Tyler Reed?
Rick of Pleasant Hills
HARLAN: Reed is currently working himself out of bad standing with Paterno. Here's the background: In January, two PSU players - E.Z. Smith and Mike Sothern - decided to shoot arrows at a wall in an apartment belonging to Reed and two teammates, Andrew Richardson and Scott Paxson. Though neither Smith nor Sothern lived at the damaged apartment, Reed and the others weren't immediately forthcoming about the damage. By the time spring ball rolled around, Reed was bouncing around in the wheels of the PSU judicial affairs system, as administrators tried to trace the problem back to the original perpetrators. Finally, Reed was cleared of involvement, but when he returned to the football team, he landed squarely in Paterno's doghouse. Seniors like Reed, Paterno figured, should know better. And therefore, Reed was dropped to fourth-string. That status carried through the summer, but in recent weeks, Reed rose. As of last week, he was working with the second-stringers at right guard. He started there for much of last season, and if Robert Price doesn't play well in the first few games, I wouldn't be surprised to see Reed finally reclaim his starting job.
Q: Do you believe Penn State has any shot at winning the Big Ten Title this year?
Brian Covol of Baltimore, Md.
HARLAN: No, I don't, Brian. The Big Ten might lack the top-to-bottom quality of the SEC, but its top teams - Ohio State, Michigan and Iowa - can compete with anybody. Penn State clearly lacks the talent of these three teams, which are stacked with veterans and lack PSU's numerous question marks. The main difference between the Lions and the aforementioned Big Three? Offense. Simple as that. As demonstrated last year, PSU owns a defense that can compete with - if not trump - any other in the conference. But this season, the Lions' offense will be responsible for some losses. Guarantee it. They still lack the balance seen in the conference's better teams. I can't totally discount Penn State's ability to win the Big Ten, simply because I've watched enough movies like "Miracle" to have a beginning-course level knowledge of upsets, but I feel pretty safe saying it's an enormous longshot.
Q: Ah, Chico, what a blessed day it is here in my little hamlet smack in the middle of Long Island, walking distance to Hofstra University and yet 1,411,819 feet, 2.4 inches from where my heart truly rests, State College, Pa., home of the fightin' Nittany Lions and that bastion of perhaps bygone brilliance, Joe Paterno. Anyway, as the readers of the Q&A know, I am quite fond of wordplay, and thusly onomastics, the study of names, intrigues me.
Which brings us to Penn State freshman Knowledge Timmons, a defensive back who runs a 4.35 40-yard dash. Now, I've seen some names in my day. I remember a baseball player named Wonderful Terrific Monds III, though, by the third generation, I figure it would've evolved to Wonderfullest. I have a son named Michael who goes by Garage, but where he was conceived is neither here nor there.
Point is, I want to know what you wish your parents named you. Obviously, you've adopted Chico (though I'm sure mom still wishes you were Aaron). I go by Ira, quite begrudgingly, instead wishing I were something normal, like James, or Kenneth, or Durango. What say you, Chico -- or should I henceforth call you Knowledge Harlan?
Ira Rothstein of East Meadow, N.Y.
HARLAN: Ahh, Ira, great to have you back. With one question in this young season, you've already disproved fears of your own sophomore slump, because clearly your pool of aimless and generally eccentric knowledge shows no visible limit. And for this, I am thankful. A Q&A season without Ira Rothstein just wouldn't work: it would be like a joke without a laugh, or an itch without a scratch, or perhaps a Joe Paterno press conference without a coughing spell. Whatever.
Anyway, you want to know about my name. Indeed, my parents named me Aaron. I took on my present nom de guerre - Chico - sometime in elementary school, when my Little League coach decided my baseball skills compared loosely to another Pittsburgh second baseman, Chico Lind. After that, I guess you could say "Chico" became my choice. Nobody ever forced me to keep it.
But what if I could start from scratch, you ask? Well that's a good - albeit inexplicable - question. Here are the names that I would rule out immediately, with little pause for reconsideration: Trevor, Kyle, Tucker, Tyler, Skyler, Connor, Ashton, Hunter and all other names that even subtly attempt coolness. Here are the names that I would rule out later, after brief deliberation: Maxwell, Ruben, Mason, Craig and Gary. Here are the names that I would probably dream of but rule out only reluctantly, under the provision that country stars should own sole rights to the greatness inherent in their names: Garth, Tim, Toby, Kenny, George, Kix, Tracy and Clint.
Where does that leave us? Well, with normal words - nouns and adjectives. Names that aren't even names. Knowledge, for instance. Or Intelligence. Or Ineptitude, So, in the final analysis, here are the final runners-up for preferred name, with a nod to the Timmons family: Intuition, Savvy, Moxie, Tedium, Devotion, Abject Cynicism, Misanthropic Disdain and Totalitarian Domination. (Friends would know him as "T.D.")
Oh, so now for the winner. Sorry about that. Almost forgot. I've got to switch gears again. I'm going in a new direction altogether.
How 'bout this? "QB Oilers."
Q: Chico, help me out here. I fear Paterno has lost control of this team. What's he thinking, letting Dan Connor make prank calls like this? Or a few of his linemen shoot arrows through a wall? Or a guy like Lavon Chisley, a senior who should know better, pull lousy summer grades and become ineligible? He's lost control of this team.
Tom from Zelienople
HARLAN: Thanks, Tom. Seriously. I'm pleased somebody brought up this issue. Reason being, I've heard numerous fans say this in recent weeks, that "Joe has lost control of the team." I'm hear to tell you that this is absolutely not the case. Here's why: When a coach truly loses control of the team, his command over the team erodes. He becomes a joke to the players. His words no longer frighten or motivate or provoke emotion. And Paterno, undoubtedly, still maintains this power. Not all Penn State players appreciate Paterno, but every player, to the man, respects his control and authority. That's because he never wavers on this issue - the power is his. When incidents such as Connor's or Chisley's arise, I put blame entirely on the player. Think about it this way - every year, millions of 19- and 20- and 21-year-olds attend college. Very few have a coach looking after them, policing them and disciplining them. Even so, most of these college students get by without problem. For members of a football team, it should be no different. Though a coach can remind each player that his off-the-field actions affect others on the team, it ultimately remains the player's obligation to stay out of trouble. Paterno can't possibly be expected to watch out for every action of every player.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.