Dearest readers: Sorry to bear bad news on this holiday weekend, but after today, the beloved Penn State Q&A -- taking a page from PSU's offense in the red zone -- will disappear. The Q&A will return in the late summer, as the Lions approach their first game of 2005. Thanks to all who offered their intelligent and often amusing questions.
You'll notice this week's Q&A is significantly shorter than normal, largely because, uh, I only received four questions this week. (Funny what will happen when every Penn State rumor -- JoePa leaving, Galen unhappy -- is shot down in one weekend.) Anyway, on with the merriment.
Q: On ESPN's PTI, Michael Wilbon and Tony Kornheiser were talking about a speech that JoePa gave during the past week. They stated that he made reference to retiring or leading up to announcing his retirement. They described it as thoughtful and eloquent and that he seemed to be leading up to what his immediate future plans are. What did I miss?
Ken Feigert of Hubbard, Ohio
HARLAN: Here's what you're talking about, Ken. On the Wednesday leading up to Penn State's season-finale, Paterno spoke in front of the State College Quarterback Club -- a collection of area boosters and businessmen. Paterno, in fact, speaks to this group every Wednesday during the season, but this week, a reporter from USA Today was granted admittance to the event. That's how Paterno's words from that particular day became public. At the end of his speech, Paterno told the group how pleased and delighted he was with their support. As they gave him a heartfelt ovation, he started getting a little teary-eyed. Though he never mentioned anything about an impending retirement, some interpreted Paterno's words as an indirect "goodbye." Obviously that was never his intention, but that particular week, Penn State followers were looking for signs of Paterno's departure even in places where they didn't exist.
Q: Chico, I think that I have discovered JoePa's plan for his son. By having Jay share play calling duties with Galen Hall, who is acknowledged to possess one of the top offensive coordinator minds, Jay can (should) learn from him. Then, when Tom Bradley becomes head coach and Hall leaves (he said recently that when Joe left, he'd be gone 10 minutes later), Jay will be the "obvious" choice to be named offensive coordinator. And, when Bradley gets fired or retires, Jay will become head coach. What do you think? Or, does (heaven forbid) Bradley get passed over and Jay become head coach when JoePa retires?
Chuck of Huntington Beach, Calif.
HARLAN: You're on to something, Chuck. Though such a plan seems a bit too clandestine, I don't think it's that far-flung. Let's be honest, here. Of course Paterno will look out for the best interests of Penn State when planning his departure, but he'll also emphasize the interests of his son, Jay. He might even emphasize them too much. I think we'd be foolish to think Paterno isn't at least keeping his son's interests in mind when plotting a so-called succession plan. Paterno has said for the record that he wants an in-house replacement after his retirement. Why? Because, as Paterno said, that's the way Penn State traditionally does it. But there's more to it, as you seem to understand. If a coach from the outside comes to State College, he's likely to revamp the staff -- and that certainly would lead to Jay's departure. If, say, Tom Bradley becomes the next PSU coach, Jay is far more likely to stay on the staff. (And yes, rise to offensive coordinator.) Does Joe someday want Jay to become the Lions' head coach? Who knows. In truth, that plan requires too much foresight, because if in fact Bradley is the next coach here, he could be in place for many years -- provided he does a good job. But indeed, to summarize, I do think Paterno is keeping at least one eye on his son's job prospects, which, for Penn State fans, is rightfully a cause for concern.
Q: Can you comment on the status of Jay Paterno? If I am correct he took over the quarterback coaching and offensive coordinator roles in 2000 and the offense has been downright terrible since (except for Larry Johnson in 2002). Might he leave, or is he here for a while? I personally feel he is absolutely horrible and the correlation with the struggles of the offense and him coming into power are hard to ignore. What do you think?
Jim of Pittsburgh
HARLAN: Jay is here for a while, Jim, so long as JoePa hangs around. As referenced in the previous question, I think if JoePa is followed with an in-house successor (such as Tom Bradley), then Jay will have a Penn State job even longer. For instance, I'd have a hard time picturing Bradley taking the head job largely because of his endorsement from Paterno, and then promptly going back and firing Paterno's son. So in short, I'll say this: get used to Jay.
There are two sides to Jay. In the several times I've dealt with him, I've found him to be a pleasant and entertaining guy. He's colorful and honest. That said, a lot of Penn Staters have made it their second job to besmirch this guy. As a coach, Jay hasn't done much worth the resume paper he'd print it on. Zack Mills, under Jay's tutelage, regressed from freshman phenom to senior disappointment. Since Jay arrived at Penn State in 2000, no Lions' quarterback has flourished. It's tougher to criticize Jay as a play-caller, because we really don't know how his role is defined. (He allegedly calls the passing plays, but who knows what kind of discussions he has with Galen Hall before every play.) I've heard grumblings from Penn State sources that Jay isn't exactly a top-shelf coach, and that's tough to ignore. But I think he'll be here for a while. Either he'll improve as an assistant or continue to be a problem.
Q: Now that Zack Mills is gone, is Fran Ganter going to be the new frontman? Who else does Penn State have in the quarterback hopper?
John Adams of Moon
HARLAN: Love the way you call the quarterback position a "frontman." As if taking snaps in Beaver Stadium is akin to standing on stage at a Metallica concert. Anyway, Ganter will decidedly not be PSU's frontman next year. In fact, he won't be on the team. Though he has one year of eligibility remaining, Ganter is leaving the Lions, presumably because he sees at least three quarterbacks -- Michael Robinson, Anthony Morelli and Paul Cianciolo -- ahead of him on next year's depth chart. He didn't see the point of coming back for a senior season that would be spent essentially on the scout team. So who will PSU's quarterback be next season? Either Robinson or Morelli. From my vantage point, Morelli is the logical choice -- that allows the Lions to keep Robinson at wideout, where he can considerably bolster the offense. (That is assuming he practices at WR full-time.) If Robinson plays quarterback, I think two positions -- both quarterback and wide receiver -- are weakened. Doesn't make sense for a team that needs all the help it can get on offense.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.