This is the final Football Q & A for the 2004 season. Chico Harlan will return to answer you questions when the 2005 season begins in September.
Q: I realize that much of the blame for Penn State's failure must be placed on the head coach. His stubborn loyalty to poor players (Mills, Robinson) has caused much sorrow among the Penn State faithful for some time now. But why has there not been more focus on the play-calling? Penn State is one of the only schools in Div. I-A to have three coaches calling the shots on offense. Doesn't this concern anyone else out there? After all, there must be a reason why all of the other major programs have ONE play caller ? the offensive coordinator. This seems particularly odd given that one of these three "coaches" is Joe's son, Jay Paterno. Can we keep Joe and lose Jay? I guess I should ask Santa Claus. Was Fran Ganter fired simply because he had the common sense enough to see how inane this approach is? Did we hire Galen Hall as a "yes" man? By the way, is this the correct spelling of nepotism?
Jeff of Detroit
HARLAN: I don't know where you've been, Jeff. (Actually, I do know: Detroit.) But you get the point, Jeff, and I'm too simple-minded to preface my response to your question with anything by a trite phrase that makes little literal sense. I'll be honest, Jeff. I think the play-calling issue has been overblown, if anything. People have talked about it all season. Reporters have asked Paterno to explain the system. It's been reported and written about, both in print and on television. Paterno, as well as his coaching offspring Jay and his pal Galen, have been criticized for sticking with the absurd system. I don't know what more you want. If I had to put a number ? between 1 and 100 ? to rank the effect of the play-calling on the offense's failures, I'd say it's somewhere between a 5 and a 10. The offense has far bigger problems than its play-calling. Talent at wideout and on the offensive line is still the No. 1 issue. Can Jay leave, you ask? Doubtful. Was Galen hired as a "yes" man? No, but he's become one. I won't be surprised if Hall's next "yes" comes in response to this question: Would you like to leave after the season?
Q:
Chico, hey man. Think of this with some rhythm and groove to it when you say it. King is in the house, yeah-yeah, King is in the house!!! How huge is this for Penn State, really, in the grand scheme of things? PSU just landed one of the biggest blue chip recruits of the '05 recruiting season. Will this have a serious impact other recruits to follow King's lead?
John of Pittsburgh
HARLAN: Yes, it will. In fact, it already has. This week, following King, Penn State hauled in recruits Lydell Sargeant and, presumably, Sean Lee. Once King committed to the Lions, he set an interesting precedent, and suddenly, others will have an easier time buying into the Penn State program. It's always fascinating to watch people, especially teenagers, play follow-the-leader. In almost any social circumstance, one person can have a remarkable influence. Recruiting is no different. King has friendships with a raft of top recruits, and that will go a long way. These days, top high schoolers may come from all over the country, but they grow to know ? and sometimes even befriend ? one another. They attend the same football camps. They speak to the same network of college recruiters. They experience the same craziness of the recruiting process. Is it any wonder, then, that they gravitate to one another? Few 17-year-olds can imagine what it's like to be a top recruit under such constant attention and pressure. When one such player finds another person going through the same circumstances, the common ground can quickly breed a friendship. And that's how it begins. Players get to know one another. One commits to a school. The second thinks, "Wouldn't it be cool to play with him at the next level."
Q:
Chico, in a season full of questions concerning the coaching ability of Joe Paterno, the ability of Zach Mills, the talent of the wide receivers and the ineptitude of the play calling, why is it that the most glaring deficiency of the Penn State football program over the past several years never seems to be questioned. I am referring to the offensive line. This unit has been a disaster dating back to the late 90s. What has been the problem with this area over the past decade?
Tom of Pittsburgh
HARLAN: You seem to indicate the offensive line has escaped criticism this season, Tom, and I tend to disagree. At a few press conferences earlier this season, Paterno did a fine job verbally thrashing the unit. Truth is, I agree with his assessment. For most of the season, the line has been miserable ? it's been so bad, it's handcuffed the entire offense. In a typical game, Tony Hunt is lucky to average more than 3.5 yards per carry. Mills is thankful when he can complete a five-step drop without getting drilled from his blindside. Clearly, the installation of the zone-blocking scheme this season has made little difference in the effectiveness of the O-line. (The line had problems last season, too.) I haven't been covering the team long enough to know if the line has been a "disaster," as you state, going back to the 1990s. But I'll say this: coaching of PSU's current linemen has been suspect. Several players on the offensive front were highly recruited ? players like Tyler Reed, who's done little to demonstrate that high rating since arriving in State College. Granted, some players will flop, regardless of circumstances. But when an entire quintet of linemen struggles to develop, it's fair to lay some blame on the coaches.
If, in fact, you still think the linemen haven't been duly ripped, Tom, let me offer a theory. Linemen are hard to criticize because their play is, at times, difficult to quantify. Sure, if a D-lineman bolts right past Andrew Richardson and levels Mills for a sack (seems as if that happened a lot this year, too), then it's easy to trace blame to Richardson. But what about a bang-bang play where Hunt is tackled in the backfield? What about a screen pass where Paul Jefferson is tackled as soon as he catches the ball? Without knowing blocking schemes, it's impossible for an observer to note specifics about who didn't execute properly. Offensive line play is a challenge to pinpoint. It can also be fickle. Just look at the Steelers. Last season, their O-line was a weakness. This year ? without drastic personnel changes ? it's a strength. Penn State needs a similar turnaround for 2005.
Q:
A three-part question: First, will any of the fourth-year juniors decide not to come back next year, notably on defense? Second, is there any reason for Austin Scott to stay? What schools could he go to? Third, would Joe ever get rid of Jay? As a strong PSU supporter on the west side of the Mississippi it pains me to see how badly the Penn State image has been tarnished. Thanks for your thoughts.
Kevin B. of Denver
HARLAN: What juniors might not return for their final seasons? Too early to tell, and for the sake of those involved, I feel it's unfair to speculate without a firm base of knowledge. For a few, though, the writing is on the wall. (Just don't ask me what the writing says, or where this alleged wall might be located.) I've heard Chris Ganter will not be returning, and may transfer. You also have to wonder about Terrance Phillips. I know that several weeks ago I said that Phillips shouldn't be counted out as a potential contributor for next season. Perhaps I spoke too soon. In the last few weeks, Phillips has plummeted from a starter to a third-string wide receiver. He's dropping so fast, you almost hope he's equipped with a parachute. Right now, his Penn State career is headed in the wrong direction.
Second, Austin Scott. He was asked last week if he would considering transferring, and he offered some roundabout answer about not reading the newspapers. (As if publications from across the state are running headlines that scream: "TRANSFER, AUSTIN.") When asked if that meant he was staying at Penn State, he offered a very unconvincing "Yeah." He could well be back with the Lions next season, but I think he has yet to make up his mind. He seemed very uncomfortable committing to an answer when asked about the transfer possibility. But personally, I think his playing time has a chance to expand next season if he's actually around. He certainly looked like the better running back against Indiana. That's the first time all season I compared Scott favorably against Tony Hunt.
Third, will Joe ever get rid of Jay? To quote Shakespeare, "NO." (Shakespeare must have penned that word at least a couple times, right?) I think Jay is here as long as Joe is.
Q:
Hypothetically, if Penn State and Pitt were to play each other tomorrow, who do you think would win?
Rob York of Alexandria, Va.
HARLAN: I like questions such as this one, because I know that I'll never be proven wrong, and I find that very liberating. Gene Collier wrote a hilarious column about this exact scenario several weeks ago, so I'll avoid the temptation to plagiarize both his humor and his prediction. I'll settle on this: If Pitt were to play Penn State at a neutral site ? some venue, presumably, that's willing to put up with the puerile fan insults ? I think the Panthers would win handily. If I had to give numbers, I'd say 24-7, Pitt. Only way I'd change my pick: If Jay Paterno suddenly took a job as Tyler Palko's quarterback coach. Then, you never know what kind of regression plan JayPa might install for his newest prot?g?.
Q:
I have read many questions involving Paterno's immense loyalties to Zack Mills and Michael Robinson at quarterback, even when their play is mediocre at best. For instance, playing Mills the whole Northwestern game in hopes of a win (what would that have accomplished anyway)? So my question to you is whether this is not as much loyalty to them as admitting how terrible of a quarterback coach Jay is, considering both Mills and Robinson came into the program with such potential?
Chris of Owasso, Okla.
HARLAN: Interesting thought, Chris, but I think that's a little far-fetched. If I understand your thinking, you suggest that Paterno, by steadfastly playing Mills over Morelli, is showing loyalty not just to Mills, but also to his son. It's a possibility, but a long shot. I believe that Paterno has some genuine loyalty to his veteran players ? and particularly Mills. Truth is, Mills deserves it. He's hung around the last three seasons through some very tough circumstances. Through it all, he's remained an admirable leader and a tough football player. His teammates love him. Want a good quote from a Penn State football player? Ask him about Zack Mills. Guys on both sides of the ball gush about him, and it doesn't sound like hollow praise ? the kind of stuff players say just to give an answer.
Paterno's feelings for Mills are similar. Of course, he has a tradition of showing loyalty to veteran players, which is another reason I think we can probably count out your clandestine JayPa theory. In Paterno's eyes, when a player sticks around in the Penn State program for four or five years, that player is showing desire and respect. Paterno believes it should be reciprocated. And I think he's right.
One other thing. For all these weeks, both fans and media, myself included, have chided Paterno for sticking with Mills and continually poo-poohing Morelli's progress. From what I saw of Morelli last Saturday against Indiana, it looks like Ol' JoePa was actually right. Morelli still looked a year away. Mills made plays ? especially the 33-yard touchdown pass to Michael Robinson ? that Morelli simply doesn't have the ability to make yet. Every once in a while, Paterno still shows he has an eye for evaluating players.
Q:
I was reading your responses this past week to those suggesting that PSU should look at Ron Zook as a possible replacement for Joe. Couldn't agree with you more. As a PSU alum and avid follower of the Gators here in "G'Ville," I can tell you that Coach Zook is the wrong choice for PSU. He's a great guy with strong personal standards of conduct (great for PSU), but he is a poor disciplinarian (which shows up in on- and off-the-field incidents), a mediocre X's and O's guy (Florida has been poor on both special teams and defense ? his specialties), and his lack of experience as a head coach prior to the UF job showed that he has a lot to learn as a manager of a major program.
However, Coach Zook's strength, recruiting, brings me to my question. In searching for a successor for Joe, much will be made of the importance of getting someone with experience in recruiting in the area. I've always thought that having a vast network of established recruiting contacts is helpful, but often overrated. I think that really good coaches can make up for initial shortcomings in this area by showing that they are smart, fair and energetic ? and then going out and winning some ballgames in the first couple of years. What's your take on the importance of hiring someone with local experience?
Gary of Gainesville, Fla.
HARLAN: Thanks for the support, Gary. I'm sure Zook will soon receive another head coaching offer ? provided the horror stories about permanent ink pens don't catch up to him ? but look at this general trend when considering where he might land: When fired coaches last for three seasons or less in a previous job, the next job is normally a step down, not a lateral move or a step up. I'd call Florida to Penn State a lateral move. Zook is unlikely to land such a prestigious job. Though Zook, as you note, is still widely respected, his performance with the Gators lowered his stock.
As for your question about the importance of local recruiting ties, here is my thinking: Recruiting skills are vitally important, and local ties do in fact make a difference. Tom Bradley, for instance, has the personality to be an effective recruiter no matter the region he's working in. But that effectiveness is multiplied when a recruiter forms strong bonds with high school coaches and other area mainstays. Think about the typical 17-year-old high school senior debating his college choice. He has so many people giving him advice. If a large portion of those people already know and feel comfortable with said recruiter ? say Bradley, for the sake of this hypothetical ? Bradley's and Penn State's credibility will instantly increase. Connections are always important, be it in the job market or the recruiting industry. And connections take a long time to form. People who've already formed them in this region are at an automatic advantage. So in short, I don't think recruiting contacts are overrated. Sure, winning football games is the best way to attract recruits, but winning, you must understand, is an X-factor. What happens if the wins don't come as desired? What do you fall back on? You need the stability of an excellent recruiter.
Q:
Sorry I've not written in a while... doesn't mean I haven't been reading your wonderful insight these past few weeks. My questions are regarding the future of the program. What is your take on the continued success Penn State at least seems to be having in the recruiting wars? Does tradition alone make a kid like King choose the Blue and White, and if so, what is the statute of limitations such tradition has on keeping the talent coming in with continued 3-ish win seasons? Oh, and how much PT does Morelli get in the finale?
Mark of Methuen, Mass.
HARLAN: Thanks for the kind words, Mark. As for PSU's recent recruiting success, I gotta admit ? I'm surprised. I didn't think Penn State ? or Paterno, for that matter ? could do it. I believed Paterno's age and PSU's recent on-field failings would serve as deterrents too difficult to overcome. Guess I was wrong. King's decision shows just how unpredictable the recruiting process can be. There is no equation. Kids don't select schools based purely on record or coaches or playing time. Kids search for a feeling ? and that is an intangible quality that can be difficult, if not impossible, to predict. With King, he liked Penn State because the school's current players seemed to fit with King's personality. King also fell in love with Tom Bradley. And now that King jumped onto the PSU wagon, the Lions are suddenly en vogue again as a destination for big-time recruits. Tradition is a factor in all of that, but King's given Penn State's image a much-needed face lift. And as for the Morelli question, he'll certainly play, probably for about the same as he did last week.
Q:
The final score against Indiana was 22-18, with Penn State stepping out of the end zone and giving up two points on the final play of the game. My question is what is the ruling on that play? Why didn't Penn State have to kick the ball back to Indiana after the safety due to the safety?
John Postage of Greenville, S.C.
HARLAN: Easy. A game can end on a safety. Think of it like a touchdown. When a team scores a touchdown as time expires in a game, it isn't required to follow that with a kickoff. Safeties follow a similar principle. Clearly, the Lions wouldn't have opted for a safety against Indiana if they'd have been forced to kick the ball back as a result.
Q:
Ahhhh, young Chico. Your favorite spelunker into all things Penn State has returned from an extended road trip. Apologies. In reality, my name isn't Ira and I'm not from East Meadow. This has all been an elaborate ruse. I've spent the last three years in Columbus, Ohio, cashing paychecks in $100 increments and handing out the residuals to young men ranging in age from 18 to 27. (Hey, this is Ohio State, and sometimes it takes nine years to get a degree.) My name is actually Jim, my last name rhymes with vessel and, in truth, you knew everything about me when I professed my affinity for sweater-vests. How banally Rogersian.
Anyway, now that I've gotten in the obligatory dig at THE Ohio State University ? where THE stands for Truthfully Heinous Education ? we move on to more important things, namely that of the goings-on in the not-so-Happy Valley. Listen, Chico, sometimes I spend the day loping on my couch with thoughts of how Joe Paterno, football god he is, can leave this university gracefully, because while I'm thankful for that stunning victory against Indiana, it also speaks voluminously about a program when a win in Bloomington sends a town into a giddy tizzy ? or at least excites it.
Here's my latest thought: Announce a press conference for the Monday morning after the season ends. Make it opulent: a bejeweled dais, fancy spread for all you hacks and complimentary Cristal for all the boosters who will need to drink themselves silly to accept what's about to happen. JoePa walks up with Graham Spanier and Tim Curley. He takes a sip of water and a deep breath.
"I'm here today to announce ... to announce ... to ... "
And with that, he picks up his steel folding chair and bashes Spanier and Curley over the head!
"To announce that I'm going to coach Penn State until I die!"
Talk about a ruse, Chico. With that very move, Joe would not only endear himself to a testosterone-spiked pool of 17-year-olds he needs to tap for recruiting purposes, he would engender himself back to the fans who have turned on him and make everyone forget about the pathetic play that's plagued the team since its 9-0 start two years back and focus on the current JoePa, the new JoePa: The Hitman.
What say you?
Ira Rothstein of East Meadow, N.Y.
HARLAN: Your brilliance has never been this ebullient, Ira. Indeed, your mind is the high point of human evolution. I'm voting you MVP ? as in, Most Virtuous Pontificator ? of the Penn State season.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.