Q:

I will not beat you up with the same questions that you get every week but I will hit you up with this one. Will an underclassman have to step up and be the vocal leader for this team? The senior captains are not answering the bell, so somebody else has to. Who? Posluszny, Connor, Shaw, Hunt, Hali?

Jarod of York, Pa.

Have your own question?

Advertise with us

Click here to submit your question

HARLAN: Jarod, your sentiment to avoid the repetitive question is much appreciated. However, your efforts -- as you will quickly see in this week's Q & A -- will be magnificently undone by many of the questions that follow. OK, enough prefacing. On with your question. I'll be somewhat of a contrarian, if you'll allow. I do, in fact, believe that both Zack Mills and Derek Wake have been strong captains this year. They are the leaders of this team, and not only by title. Mills stands tall against immense criticism; he takings physical beatings week after week, only to accept personal blame for the losses; he never complains about the lack of talent around him, and always encourages his teammates. Wake, meanwhile, has an easier task, because he has the benefit of strong players around him. Still, fellow linebackers credit Wake as a teacher and mentor. The problem with this year's team is not leadership. Throughout the losing, I've been impressed by the way this team has carried itself, and credit for that goes, in part, to players like Mills and Wake. Now performance is an entirely different issue. Mills has been plagued by mistakes this season; Wake is one of PSU's more pedestrian defenders. But since you ask about underclassmen leaders, I can tell that Posluszny already has many of the perfect leadership abilities. On offense, after Mills, underclassmen leaders are harder to come by. Levi Brown has shown some of the right qualities, but the ideal leader on offense is always a quarterback. I genuinely believe Mills has taken on that role admirably.

Q: First, a preface to my question. I have been the most loyal Paterno supporter, so for me to even begin to hope he soon steps aside, things must be getting pretty desperate.

Let's play the inevitable game of "what-if". What if Joe decides to hang up his black shoes after this season or next and hand the program over to someone? Who would be some of the choices to take over? Who would be logical and possible and who would be long-shots or only in our wildest dreams?

Todd of Murrieta, Calif.

Advertise with us

HARLAN: For the sake of my own sanity, I'll bunch all of the "What's happening with Paterno?" questions atop one another, then answer them together with one massive swing. Bear with me here.

Q: Having watched Penn State for many years and now seeing them fall apart recently, when will Coach Paterno step down and let someone else take over? This past weekend on ESPN, Mark May mentioned that he thought Ron Zook would be a great choice to replace Coach Paterno. I think this would be a good move. He wasn't given a chance at Florida. He can recruit. He has Ohio ties. And the way he has handled his dismissal has been amazing. What do you know?

Danny of Lakeland, Fla.

HARLAN: Yup, bear with me still.

Q: Since Penn State is going through another bad season, what do you think the chances are that Joe Paterno would call it quits after this season? I know he wants one more winning season but would he throw it in after this year? And, who would possibly succeed him as coach? Are they looking to hire within the system or are they looking to find the young up-and-coming coach like when Paterno was first hired?

Advertise with us

Chris Walmer of Lebanon, Pa.

HARLAN: OK, let's do it. I'm gonna squeeze out every ounce of Paterno talk I have within me. I'm a bit hesitant to do this -- and I'm sure Tunch Ilkin and Craig Wolfley can tell you why -- so let me first say, what will be provided in this answer segment is something like three parts rumor and one part reporting. There's a chance an official word from Penn State about Paterno's job could come within days or weeks. There's also a chance we might not hear anything for another year. Still, I agree -- questions and concerns about the PSU head coaching position are entirely fair game, so I'll take a crack at them.

First, what are the chances Paterno calls it quits at the end of the year? I'd guess about 25 percent. I've always had the belief that 2005 will be Paterno's last season. After all, he truly believes that the Lions will contend for a major bowl next year. We can debate whether that belief is well-founded, but Paterno certainly likes his chances in 2005. That's a strong incentive for him to return for one final season. Also, though he said recently that he's the type of person who'd need a farewell season, I tend to disagree. I think that if Paterno announced before next season that 2005 would be his last, many positive side-effects would result: First, both Paterno and his players would be freed of a question constantly lingering over their heads. Second, it would create a groundswell of support for Paterno and PSU, because fans would be relieved and proud to see Paterno finally make the right choice. Third, it would create a strong interest in the 2005 season; fans would fill Beaver Stadium to see the story lines of Paterno's final season unfold.

If Paterno steps away after this season, my guess is that he will have been pressured by the university. He won't do it on his own convictions. He indicated as much earlier this week.

Now, as for potential successors: Tom Bradley, currently the defensive coordinator, is one obvious possibility. His candidacy gained extra strength after this week's rumor that Bradley had been tabbed as Paterno's successor. Bradley, I believe, would be a fine choice. He's certainly not the big, national name that some Penn Staters want, but Bradley is a top-level recruiter with strong regional ties. He also knows his football. In past seasons, his defensive unit has come under criticism, but look what he's done this season. It's hard to argue with that.

Advertise with us

So who else? Ron Zook would be a bad choice, and I say this for several reasons. (I expand on one of those reasons in a later question.) Bringing Zook to Penn State would be like introducing one train wreck to another. PSU can't gamble by hiring somebody with a track record like Zook. At Florida, Zook took a major football program and caused it some definite problems, both with his actions and his coaching. No doubt, Zook is a proven recruiter, but I think his stint with the Gators is too much baggage.

Another name: the suddenly famous Urban Meyer. Who doesn't want to hire this guy these days? He came to Utah and transformed a team in one year, even though the Utes had little roster turnover. He could do the same with Penn State. In the "up-and-comers" category, Meyer's name comes first. Florida reportedly wants him, but Meyer, whose hometown is Ashtabula, Ohio, would have to at least consider PSU as well.

Then there's Steve Spurrier, who, so long as he's unemployed, will stick his visor into any coaching discussion. The Ol' Ballcoach is a long shot, and I'm certainly not making any news by suggesting this. When replacing a 77-year-old, though, no school should hire a man with "Ol'" prefixed to his name.

And don't forget about Kirk Ferentz, currently at Iowa, who'd strongly consider Penn State if given the chance. He's certainly qualified; he runs a strong program. And he has Pittsburgh roots.

One final name I've heard thrown around: Tom O'Brien, currently the head coach at Boston College.

Advertise with us

Q: What kind of impact has three disastrous seasons had on Penn State's recruiting? I would imagine that the once preference school status is now reduced to a last resort status for even marginal players after the past three seasons. I say that because Paterno seems to have no clue as to what is wrong and what can be done to fix it. After what has happened to Anthony Morelli this season, that must have scared off any possible quarterback prospects as well. Thanks.

Lan Villella of Aliquippa

HARLAN: Tough to tell right now, Lan, what exact effect the losing has had on recruiting. I'm sure it hurts to an extent. For instance, just think about all those recruits PSU was hosting last weekend. They saw a miserable football game. They saw empty seats. It was one of PSU's weaker gameday atmospheres. Then, after the game, they watched Paterno's press conference from a balcony overlooking the media room, and they heard question after question about the football team's shortcomings. Not the best way to impress recruits, huh? But there is a flip side to this. The losing can actually be looked at with a more optimistic eye. Right now, Penn State can be sold as a place where high schoolers can come in and make an immediate difference. They can commit to Penn State and help turn a program around. Granted, this may not be a realistic possibility, but athletes have egos, and any high school star worth his weight in scholarship money will come to a college believing he can be "the man." More than the losing, I think Penn State is hurt by at least two factors. (And I believe rival coaches use these following factors against PSU when going head-to-head with the Lions for recruits.) First, Paterno's age. That causes automatic questions about whether the head coach will be there for the duration of a player's career. Second, the recent mismanagement of players. Look at BranDon Snow. Look at Michael Robinson. Most recently, look at Morelli. Coaches can say, "If you go to PSU, you'll get jerked around just like those guys." The losing might be secondary to these factors.

Q: Apparently the anemic offense was not Franny Ganter's fault after all. I have watched two PSU games this year and it looked like same old three yards and a cloud of dust. It also appears that the quality of the players is not competitive with the rest of the Big Ten. Maybe it's because Joe cannot recruit a class that feels like he will be around for them to graduate. The question is, "How many losing years are required before it is acceptable to ask Joe to go back to the house?"

Blaine Hinds of Bonham, Texas

Advertise with us

HARLAN: Wait, didn't we already cover this? Enough with JoePa retirement and firing questions. I'm putting an end to them for the week. More to come in seven days.

Q: If something would happen to Joe (say he would miss a game or two because of illness), who would be in charge of the team? Is there an assistant head coach?

Mike of Johnstown

HARLAN: No assistant head coach to speak of, Mike, but I can state with near-certainty that if Paterno ever missed a game, Tom Bradley -- currently the defensive coordinator -- would serve as the acting head coach. In those circumstances where Paterno has left the team (for instance, just minutes after the Wisconsin game, when Paterno rushed back to State College to be with his critically injured son-in-law) Bradley addressed the media and took Paterno's place. In the unofficial hierarchy of coaches behind Paterno, Bradley is at the top.

Q: In Big Ten play, PSU has scored 44 points through six games, or less than eight points per game. In your opinion, what is the reason why Morelli, Rodney Kinlaw, Austin Scott, and others have not played consistently (or at all)? Is PSU afraid that they will be shut out instead of scoring their fantastic eight points per game? Or is Paterno too attached to Mills, Robinson, et al to change when he knows the best they can be is 4-7 no matter who plays?

Advertise with us

Roger of Ephrata, Pa.

HARLAN: Your point is well-taken, Roger. I've thought the same thing at times this season. After the Northwestern game, for example, Paterno talked about not wanted to hurt his team's chances for a comeback by removing Zack Mills from the ballgame. I wondered: Why, exactly, did he like his team's chances WITH Mills in the game? Sometimes, it seems as if Paterno automatically favors the known over the unknown. Mills instead of Morelli. Hunt instead of Scott. Robinson over every other player in the country. In some cases, Paterno's assessments are no doubt correct -- for instance, I think Hunt has certainly given good reason to keep the starting halfback job -- but sometimes, his thinking simply looks too archaic. When a team is 2-7, loyalties to players should not run as thick as they seem to right now at Penn State. Paterno, talking about his well-documented love for playing veteran players, said this week at his press conference that "We have had a lot of good years with that philosophy." Problem is, PSU hasn't had a lot of good years lately. Paterno should be willing to revise his ideas.

Q: Chico -- Why should PSU brass relieve JoePa of his duties when, even while losing in the most embarrassing ways, PSU draws a full house at each and every home game? Don't you think that PSU fans just can't help themselves, even when playing the most pitiful football of their history? The fans just can't help themselves and must drive for hours in their Winebagos and fill Beaver Stadium. Money is being made hand over fist, even all the while the team is a sad sack display of what they used to be. So why dump JoePa?

Denny Guth of Port Matilda, Pa.

HARLAN: Good question, Denny. You're right -- at this time, Beaver Stadium is still relatively full on gameday. But if I were Tim Curley or Graham Spanier, I'd still be concerned. And removing Paterno, or at least developing a plan for his eventual retirement, would be something of a preemptive move. In the last months, I've spoken with many Penn State fans. And I've developed this definite sense: if changes aren't made soon -- very soon -- the disgust will quickly boil over into empty seats and near-revolt. If the same questions about Paterno are still hanging over Penn State next season (and if Penn State is having yet another disappointing season), I wouldn't be surprised to see 25,000 empty seats for some games. When that happens, the athletic department will be in high-gear disaster mode, and it will have to pay attention to the problems. Penn State cannot make the mistake of taking its fan base for granted. PSU fans are not automatons -- they won't blindly flock to Beaver Stadium every Saturday. The university has to make sure the gameday experience continues to be worthwhile, and that means providing a competitive football team.

Advertise with us

Q: The weekly question from the Commonwealth of Kentucky. I was shaking my head listening to several comments by Paterno in his press conference this past Tuesday. "Michael Robinson is the best quarterback of the bunch. (not your ringing endorsement for Morelli). We might have to 'bite the bullett' and play Morelli against Indiana. He compared PSU's program to Northwestern instead of the schools it should be compared to -- Ohio State, Michigan and Wisconsin. But, the thing that got me ... "If we can keep him, we are thinking about moving BranDon Snow to fullback." Obviously, Joe thinks Snow is thinking of transferring. I'm sure there are several other "future core" players with similar thoughts (Scott, Kinlaw, Farris ... even Morelli despite his father's comments a few weeks ago). This could be the first mass exodus that Paterno has suffered to transfers. Bottom line, if Paterno stays, can PSU fans expect a mass exodus? What have you heard? Thanks as always!

John Gilger of Lexington, Ky.

HARLAN: I'm not sure I'd call it a mass exodus, but I wouldn't be surprised if several Penn State players transfer following the season. Morelli won't be one of them -- unless, perhaps, Paterno sticks with the absurd assertion that Michael Robinson might play quarterback next season. As I see it, there's something of an informal equation that will lead to transferring. Because what keeps kids happy at a program? First, winning. Second, playing time. So when both of those factors are missing, you can certainly expect some transfers from kids who aren't seeing the field. If Austin Scott leaves, it wouldn't surprise me. Same with a guy like Snow, who was done a disservice when asked to switch to linebacker. The possible departures could make for an interesting off-season.

Q: OK, Chico, admit it -- during the past several years Penn State football has gotten so bad that all of this seems like a horrible nightmare. Doesn't it? It's now so bad -- zero wins in the conference (Are you kidding me?) -- that this can't possibly happen. Can it? How is it possible that the glorious Penn State football program that I've known practically my whole life as a solid winning program (from the days of Rip Engle and Richie Lucas) has become one of the worst football programs at any level in the entire country. I'm actually embarrassed to wear anything with PSU on it. We're a joke in the media, and the sad thing is Coach Paterno is a joke too. Every sports talk radio personality is now regularly taking shots at Coach Paterno and Penn State. He deserves better than that and so do we and Penn State. So, the question is simple. Who are the top five coaches in your mind who Penn State should actively pursue in the future to fill the head coach position that Coach Paterno will eventually vacate? (Personally, I like the current head coaches at Iowa, Cal, Utah, and Florida. Florida alums might not appreciate Coach Zook, but I think he's going to be a solid head coach in the future.)

Jerry Moore of N. Potomac, Md.

Advertise with us

HARLAN: Apologies, Jerry. I feel your question about the coaching situation was addressed earlier in this enlightening discourse, so I want to use your "Q" as a jump-off to avoid an "A" and provide a "T." As in, tangent. They say revenge is never as sweet as you imagine it, but heck, I'm gonna do this anyway. Revenge on Ron Zook! Long awaited! About seven or eight years ago, when I was growing up as a young, die-hard Steelers fan, I attended Steelers training camp one hot summer afternoon. I brought several items with me to camp: First, a mini-replica Steelers helmet, with plenty of space for autographs. Second, a gold pen -- permanent ink variety. After a long day of running around St. Vincent collecting autographs, I found, in a moment of great fortune, a little extra space on the helmet. (One final autograph!) I also found a little-known special teams coach walking off the field. His name? Ron Zook. I asked Zook if he could autograph my helmet, and he said OK. Only things soon proved to be anything but OK. As he gave the permanent ink pen its requisite shake, ink suddenly splattered out of the top in a geyser-like fit. And the ink just so happened to land in a mess all over my prized helmet. But Zook didn't seem too concerned. Without an apology, he handed the pen back to me and said, "Gotta run to a meeting." My helmet was ruined. So was my adoration for the headmaster of the Stillers' special teams. So that's the long-winded translation for this general thought, which I carry into the present: No, I don't think Ron Zook should be the next head coach at Penn State. He'll be too busy handling my oncoming lawsuit.

Q: One of the things I miss from the days of Penn State being an independent was playing a mix of teams from various conferences or other independents. It gave you a feel as to how you stacked up against teams from around the country. Is there a conference (1A) out there that this year's team could hold it's own in, as in a winning record? Could the defense hold its own against the speed in conferences like the ACC and SEC? With all that in mind, how do you think Big Ten teams will fair in the bowls?

Randy Hoffman of Bellefonte, Pa.

HARLAN: PSU's defense, Randy, could excel in any conference. PSU's offense would be miserable in any BCS-affiliated league, including the Big East. These two units are that polarized. If PSU was in the ACC or SEC, the team's record would certainly be equally poor. If the Lions were in the Big East, maybe the team could eek out a 4-7 or 5-6 season. So where could PSU actually look like a powerhouse? A buddy of mine just got a job in Pocatello, Idaho, where Idaho State University plays in the Big Sky Conference. Yeah, the Big Sky Conference. Penn State would probably finish in first place there.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.