Q:
Do you honestly think Coach Paterno can turn the program around? That, of course, begs the question of what "turning the program around" means. After four losing seasons in the last five, rhetorically, does it mean winning a conference game or two; does it mean beating a ranked team or two; does it mean crawling out of the conference cellar to the "middle of the pack"; does it mean having a winning record; or does it mean making a run at the conference title? Looking at the squad, I anticipate the same likely weaknesses: nobody to catch the football, nobody to throw the football, and nobody to block.
Chris of DuBois
Have your own question?
Click here to submit your question
HARLAN: I don't think Paterno will be around long enough to truly turn around the program, Chris. And if, for some inexplicable reason, JoePa ends up staying four or five more years -- No, I don't believe he can turn it around. That said, I think Penn State will be pretty respectable next season, with a legitimate chance for a seven- or eight-win season. That will give Paterno a decent way to exit, assuming he makes the proper decision and decides that 2005 will be his final season. But even if PSU does make a bowl game next year, that doesn't mean the program has turned around. It will be a surface success, as a deeper problem lurks below. In truth, the consequences Penn State is suffering right now -- i.e., recruiting struggles brought on by the losses and Paterno's advancing age -- will plague the program several years down the road. Penn State, I think, has long-term problems. Any new coach coming in will need several years to truly turn things around. Because that process starts at the bottom -- with recruiting. And the benefits of strong recruiting classes aren't immediate. If players like Anthony Morelli can blossom into elite college players, Penn State can be respectable even during this rebuilding process. But to give this process the best chance for success, I think it's best if Paterno leaves sooner than later.
Q: They play a little music jingle at Beaver Stadium over the loud speaker during the game and I would love to know what it is. The only way to explain it is it goes something like this: whoa oh oh oh, whoa oh oh oh, oh oh oh oh oh.
David of State College
HARLAN: Wait, Jim Malarky of Norco, Calif. -- give back your trophy! You no longer have the 2004 Weirdest Q&A Question Award. David, clear some space on your mantel place. The hardware is now yours. A few thoughts, before I offer a nonsensical answer to your entirely nonsensical question.
First, for future note, musical tones generally do not translate well into onomatopoeias. Second, because I am a member of the press -- and thus blocked from stadium noise by an unfortunate thick sheet of glass -- I am deterred from hearing most external stadium noises. That said, I'll offer a short list of songs that are either very likely or very unlikely to fit your description.
Likely -- Kernkraft 400, Zombie Nation
Unlikely -- anything from the "Fiddler on the Roof" soundtrack; Butthole Surfers, Pepper; any posthumous release from Tupac; any song played by a radio station that identifies itself as "Froggy" or "Wish"; Aaron Tippin, Where the Stars and Stripes and the Eagle Fly; any song by John Mayer.
Hope this narrows things down for you.
Q: Chico, with all the criticism by fans and the members of the media across the country regarding the state of the Penn State Football Program, does anyone out there have a pulse on what Tim Curley is thinking right now? Seems odd he gave a 4-year contract to a 77-year old legend who had three losing seasons in the previous four campaigns and it is going to be four out of five. Is there any language in that contract regarding performance on the field? Removing, or trying to coax a legend like JoePa to retire is very very tough. What is going through Curley's head right now regarding this? Thanks
John Gilger of Lexington, Ky.
HARLAN: Good question, John. I like it. Unfortunately for the sake of my answer here, trying to get into Curley's head is like trying to pry into a casino vault guarded by snipers and a retinal scanning device. When speaking publicly, Curley makes it his habit to put a hugely optimistic spin on all the not-so-positive happenings in Happy Valley. I've seen this first-hand. It's not that Curley is dishonest; he just dodges any question that could steer him toward criticism of his football program or his football coach. With Curley, you're not going to get straightforward opinions. That's fine, though, and I don't begrudge him for it -- I'm sure an intelligent man like Curley knows that Penn State is in trouble. I'm sure he sees the predicament, even if he's unwilling to publicly admit it. I'm also sure he's apprehensive about being too heavy-handed with the coaching legend in the office a quarter-mile down the road. In the final analysis, I'd be surprised if Curley has a large role in Paterno's ultimate decision. Perhaps the university president, Graham Spanier, has the power necessary for such a move. But I've long believed the decision will be Joe's. Maybe a few more losses -- or another losing season -- will change that sentiment, but not yet. For now, Curley is stuck in a tough situation.
Q: I disagree with the people who make the statement that Austin Scott has gotten a fair chance and hasn't done any better than Hunt. How is that when he is only getting two to three carries a game. You can't base his performance on that. Also, with that in mind, wouldn't you think if this keeps up any longer Austin should get out? Where do you think he could end up?
Matt of Allentown
HARLAN: Well, Matt, I think we were starting to see a bit more Austin Scott in the Penn State offense before his injury last Saturday. It doesn't look like he'll be playing in this week's game, so another opportunity is lost. Scott is an interesting case. When people say he's not getting a chance, they forget that he is no doubt getting looks in practice. There is no question that coaches, especially of late, have given him a long look. The guess here is, Scott simply hasn't shown the coaches what they're looking for. With the way the Lions have run the football in the last month, they'd probably take any excuse possible to make a change. Elsewhere in the offense, reserves have been given great shots to usurp starters. (Just look at Scott Davis. Look at Mark Rubin. Look at John Wilson.) I think Scott's been given the same opportunities. He just hasn't taken advantage. Opportunities can extend far beyond playing time in a game, I think. There's a chance, obviously, that Scott will leave if things continue like this. But where he may end up, I have no guess.
Q: All things considered, how well do you think JoePa's son, Jay, would do as Penn State's head coach?
James Patrick Thompson of South Daytona, Fla.
HARLAN: With that question, James, you might as well be putting JayPa's head on a batting tee with the directions: "Go ahead, smack it." OK, so I will. Jay Paterno would be a horrible replacement at Penn State. Hiring him as Joe's successor would be the worst decision, hands down, in the history of the football program. He's shown little in his time at PSU to illustrate his coaching competence. Even more condemning, his so-called prot?g?, Zack Mills, has actually regressed in his four years under Paterno's watch. If Jay was hired, it would be a horrific display of nepotism -- and, I'm guessing, the decision would alienate a lot of fans. At this point, PSU can't afford that. Whenever Joe leaves as head coach, Penn State will have a laundry list of A-rate candidates hoping for the job. Jay has no business even being among the choices.
Q: This is not a question but a correction. Woody Hayes did not retire. He was fired for hitting a Clemson player who intercepted a pass to end OSU's last drive in the 1978 Gator Bowl.
Ray Blinn of Ostrander, Ohio
HARLAN: Thanks, Ray. Much appreciated. You should know, my personal fact-checker, Mr. Charles Phelan, has been given his unconditional release.
Q: Being both a graduate of Pitt (undergrad) and Penn State (grad school) I am a fan of both football teams -- although I'd root for Pitt if they ever play again.
I have a hypothetical question for you (I've asked Paul Zeise the same question): Assume at the end of the year both Walt Harris and Joe Paterno are no longer coaches at their respective schools -- for whatever reason. You are a top-notch, up-and-coming coach, and you want your next job to be your last job. Both schools offer you their head coaching job, same offer (pay, perks, etc.). Which job do you take?
Can you accomplish as much in the Big East as you can in the Big Ten? Do you want to follow Joe Paterno? Do you want to coach in front of 40K (whose loyalties may be with the Steelers) or 100K (with a cult like following). Do you want to start from "rock bottom" -- your term -- or do you want to start with a young, skilled team?
Matt Bachovchin of Naperville, Ill.
HARLAN: The Q's are on fire this week. Seriously. I'm lovin' the questions. As opposed to last week's episode -- "All Anthony Morelli, all the time!" -- we've got some variety this week. Good stuff.
Anyway, I think the choice, in your hypothetical situation, is Penn State. If I were this aforementioned "up-and-coming" coaching hotshot, and I had head coaching offers from Penn State and Pittsburgh, I wouldn't even waffle too much. I'd go with Penn State. Why? You already offer some of the obvious reasons. First, Penn State has a fantastic base of fans, who pack the stadium and create an irresistible game day atmosphere. In Pittsburgh, the Panthers are decidedly second-class citizens. The Steelers occupy most of the rooting attention. Second, I wouldn't be hesitant about following a legend like Paterno. Maybe five years ago, following Paterno would have been a potential landmine. Not anymore. Now, PSU fans are thirsty for change, and they'll be willing to offer support to Paterno's successor. The situation, for a new coach, would be a good one. He'd instantly be given a few years of patience to rebuild the program. Third, Penn State has fantastic facilities and tradition. It's been a college football powerhouse for a half-century. A final factor would be conference affiliation. The Big Ten provides stability and a built-in conference with top teams. The Big East provides nothing but uncertainty and question marks in football. When I look at Penn State, I see the chance to rebuild a great program and one day contend for a national championship. To borrow some footballspeak from Mel Kiper, I don't think an opportunity at Pitt would have the same "upside."
Q: Chico, in past Q&A sessions you said Zack Mills is the best solution at quarterback for Penn State. Given the team's mediocre showing, I believe it is time for Anthony Morelli to start and get some needed experience. His redshirt year is gone. Chad Henne, after some initial rough spots has proven to be a capable quarterback for Michigan. I know Henne's initial situation was different as the projected starter was injured, but since Morelli was rated equal or better than Henne, who's to say he cannot have the same level of success? Since neither Mills nor Robinson has shown much, I say bite the bullet and start Morelli. What do you think now?
Michael Yacura of Springfield, Va.
HARLAN: Tough call. My boy Mills deserves a better end. It would be just too sad to see him on the bench for his final three games. If I were Joe Pa, what would I do? I'd treat these last three games like NFL exhibition games. Mills would start. He'd take at least half of the snaps in every remaining game, provided he's healthy. But Morelli would get playing time -- a good chunk of it. (And he'd get snaps regardless of how the game progresses. Close game or blowout -- doesn't matter. He'd be in there.) Morelli would get about one or two quarters of playing time per game. Robinson, meanwhile, would be moved to wideout. Permanently.
Q: The only wide receivers on scholarship after this year will be Mark Rubin, Terrell Golden, Kinta Palmer, and Terrance Phillips. First, do you think Joe will encourage Palmer and/or Phillips to move on with their lives and not come back for their senior years? (Assuming Penn State gets one or two wide receiver recruits this year and possibly moves a player or two to the wide receiver position) Second, do you think Maurice Humphrey will play football at Penn State next year? There were reports that he was cited for trying to get into a bar with some else's ID, which may have violated his parole agreement. I haven't heard any comments from the team or university regarding his situation.
Robert York of Alexandria, Va.
HARLAN: I don't know if Humphrey will be back at Penn State next season, but I know it still hasn't been ruled out. Despite his recent fake ID trouble, he's still at Penn State-Altoona. And he still has a chance to be back with the team, depending on decisions made by the university and coaches. I'm not sure if his situation, though, will have any bearing on players like Phillips and Palmer. I see no reason why Paterno would tell a player like Phillips to leave the program. Just because a player hasn't been productive in one season doesn't mean he can't improve precipitously the following year. Unless Paterno sees absolutely no chance for such a player, he'd be unwise to show any wideout the door -- especially when it's a position with such poor depth. Palmer could end up being a non-factor next season, but don't count out Phillips so quickly.
Q: Why do you think Galen Hall has been so ineffective? We know he has a strong pedigree, with coaching stops at Oklahoma, Florida and the Dallas Cowboys. Which of the following applies?
A) His players are not of the same quality as before;
B) He is unable to run the offense he wants;
C) His system takes a long while to learn;
D) A little of each of the above and something else.
Comments, please.
Mark Wilson of Charleston, W.Va.
HARLAN: I'll just keep adding, rather than picking one. I think it's a combination of several factors.
E) He has not been given the proper power to install his own system at Penn State.
F) His play-calling has been hampered by an arcane system that forces him to call only a fraction of the plays.
G) The zone-blocking system taught this year to the O-linemen hasn't worked well.
Q: With all of the "great" investigative reporting in the media, why has nobody seemed to "crack" the real issues at Penn State and report the real facts? Why is Morelli not playing? Why is the offense so lame? The media uncovers many things in the political scene and sports scene, but they can't seem to find "anything" out about PSU. If I was a beat writer this would be my top story. Why?
Gary Ostrowski of Kingston, Mass.
HARLAN: I'm not sure I understand. What, exactly are you looking for, Gary? The so-called "issues" you're asking about have been dissected and analyzed all season. Morelli hasn't been playing because he's been slow to learn the Penn State offensive system. That, and Paterno is reluctant to play a freshman when he already has a fifth-year senior at the position. The offense is "lame" because the team lacks talent and uses an absurd power-sharing system for play-calling. I agree, there are some bigger issues with this team that are entirely worth pursuing for longer, investigative stories. But those are things that have been coming along all season. Penn State, as perhaps you know, guards access to its players and coaches like few other athletic teams -- pro or college -- in the nation. It's my hope, though, that with all the news outlets covering the PSU football team, some revealing and interesting information can come out from time to time. And as it accumulates, that will lead to a better understanding of a fascinating situation -- a legendary coach in decline, and a program following suit.
Q: Chico, long time fan of your columns and even longer fan of Penn State. I am an alumnus, one of the ones who stood beside the Paterno bashing over the past couple years. But now I find myself begging for Joe to let go, and to look for a new face to resurrect the program. My question is two-part: One, is Joe honestly ever going to let go on his own or will he have to be forced out? Second, Penn State looks to be very tough next year, I doubt they will allow more than a 10 points per game in '05. Do you think they have a legitimate shot at the Big Ten title with Joe there? Thanks, Chico.
John of Pittsburgh
HARLAN: I think the decision to leave will ultimately be Paterno's. He may be influenced by those close to him, but he will eventually have to decide it's time to go. As for 2005, I am reasonably optimistic. The defense will be fantastic. If the offense can improve even marginally, PSU will rise quickly to a mid-level Big Ten team. If the offense grows even more -- and becomes, say, average -- the Lions can contend for a second- or third-place finish. But this is looking way ahead. We still aren't exactly sure what changes will be made in the off-season, and what freshmen will be brought in. Those are all variables yet to be determined. In advance, though, I'd say that Penn State has a good shot for a bowl next season. But I think the Lions are a long shot for a Big Ten title.
Q: As a Penn State alumnus, I would like to know who the reporter was that asked Joe the question about "whether he deserved to coach at Penn State anymore?"
Nancy Ballard of Pittsburgh
HARLAN: That was Bob Flounders, the beat writer from the Harrisburg Patriot-News. I applaud Bob for asking the question. He had every right to ask it. Paterno's snippy answer was uncalled for. He ought to be scrutinized like any other head coach, regardless of his prior accomplishments.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.