Q: Some comments from a Penn State fan of 40 years. Comment if you like.

1. Michael Robinson may be the best football player in the country as per Coach Paterno, but he does not excel at quarterback, tailback or receiver. Has anyone else noticed that the closest this offense came to being productive against a good team was the game in which Robinson did not play? The quarterback, tailbacks and receivers all got enough reps to get into the flow of the game. When they move him in and out of different positions, the rest of the offense suffers. He is a junior already and it seems like his talent is being wasted. Pick a position for him and let him perfect it.

2. If Tony Hunt is truly better than Austin Scott then they have no Division 1 running backs.

3. This offense is not "young". There are four seniors and one junior on the offensive line getting most of the playing time. If they don't have any sophomores or freshman linemen at least as good as these guys then winning is at least four more years away. That said, there are ways to compensate for a sub-par line. One- and three- step drops with quick slant-ins, square outs and buttonhooks will get any defense off the ball and back on their heels.

Advertise with us

4. All over the country teams have freshmen playing quarterback, receiver, tailback and line and performing. Yet here it is more than halfway through the season and PSU's freshman (read Anthony Morelli) is not ready yet? If he does not get some playing time, then next year he will become a Penn State sophomore who is not ready.

5. Last comment: If it's true that the whole coaching staff is contributing to the play calling, why was Galen Hall hired to be the offensive coordinator? Play calling by committee rarely seems to work at any level. It is certainly not working at PSU. A couple of years ago when Coach Paterno let Fran Gantner run the offense the play calling was imaginative, wide open and always had the defense guessing. From what I've read about Galen Hall, that's the type of offensive coach he was. Who is really in charge there?

Bruce Krivak of Hasbrouck Heights, N. J.

Have your own question?

Click here to submit your question

Advertise with us

HARLAN: We'll go number-by-number here, Bruce. First, I think Robinson would be best off sticking to wide receiver, with the occasional trick play mixed in. Right now, he splits practice time between receiver and quarterback, and though he claims that doesn't hinder his progress, it certainly must. No player can learn a position properly when he's devoting just half the usual time to it. Second, I think Hunt and Scott are not the problem. The offensive line can't block enough for either of them to have a fair shot. Third, indeed, the offense isn't young by a pure count of eligibility. The offense is inexperienced, though, based on a count of returning starters. Then again, after seven games, that no longer qualifies as a viable excuse. Fourth, the biggest mistake this season hasn't been the reluctance to play Morelli; it's been the decision to waste his redshirt season. Now that they've burned his redshirt, Morelli may see some playing time, but it seems unlikely. Coaches still insist he's not ready. Then again, the Steelers didn't necessarily think Ben Roethlisberger looked ready four games ago, either. Sometimes, a player can excel when you least expect it. Fifth, both Hall and Jay Paterno are in charge of the offense. Which means, in truth, that neither is in charge.

Q: Your headline caught my eye. "Penn State's offense hits rock bottom." I hope you're right, but every time I think this football team has finally hit "rock bottom," they begin digging! I've been scouring the Internet for answers, because I admit, I haven't been keeping up as much lately. But when I read that Jay Paterno is splitting time with Hall as offensive coordinator, that strikes me a pure nepotism. Don't get me wrong, that's fine if your name is Bowden. But is JoePa sticking around long enough to ensure his son can take over? If so, has Jay added anything of significance to the football program?

Halex Watson of Alexandria, Va.

HARLAN: Like the line about "digging," Halex. Clever. First, let me address misperception No. 1 about my job. I don't write the headlines. Never do. Most casual newspaper readers assume the hacks writing the stories also produce the big-fonted stuff above it. Au contraire, my friend. That said, I referenced "rock bottom" in my Monday article, so it's still fair game. Is this team at absolute rock bottom? I mean, complete, pit-of-the-Earth, dig-any-farther-and-come-out-in-China bottom? Well, I suppose not. A loss to Indiana might be a little worse. So might losing streak that extends to season's end. But let's be honest. A 6-4 football game is pretty pitiful. When you lose 6-4, it's tough to realistically imagine a more woebegone scenario. As for the JoePa and JayPa questions, I'll get to that later in the Q & A. Ad nausea. Promise.

Q: Like most of the fans and fellow alumni, I get more frustrated and embarrassed with this program after every week. Although I understand that Joe is the main reason for the success of this program, everyone must realize that he could not have reached this success without the fans and alumni, supporting and more importantly, helping to fund the program. So I find myself continually wondering why he is allowed to make the decisions about his future with the program, especially after this lengthy period of futility and non-Penn State football. Where is Graham Spanier and what is this guy thinking? Could you give me a little insight into the ending of some other legendary coach's terms (Bo, Woody, Bear) and what were the circumstances and who had the major role in causing them to end their coaching careers.

Advertise with us

Chuck Seideneck of Manalapan, N.J.

HARLAN: Here's a little research about Bo, Woody and Bear. (Sounds like characters from a nursery rhyme, huh?) Schembechler retired after the 1989 season. His last game? The Rose Bowl, which capped Michigan's second consecutive Big Ten title. Wrote the Ann Arbor News at the time, "Schembechler will leave a very healthy football program." Hayes retired after the 1978 season, with a final record of 7-4-1. Though his last Ohio State team finished fourth in the Big Ten, his six immediately before that finished first or tied for first. Lastly, Bryant retired at 69, and died just weeks later. His last game was a Liberty Bowl victory at the end of 1982. In Bryant's last four seasons, his Alabama teams won 12, 10, 9 and 8 games, respectively. Makes for some interesting perspective.

Q: Chad Henne and Anthony Morelli were equally thought of coming out of high school. Henne is starting for a good Michigan team, yet Morelli can't get a snap for a putrid PSU offense? What does this say about Joe Paterno's age-old, outdated bias against freshmen?

Mike Adams of Madison, Wis.

HARLAN: I get the Morelli question so many times today, I'll disperse my wide-ranging thoughts from answer to answer. But here's one way to think of it, Mike. Yeah, Henne and Morelli have roughly the same physical tools. But let's not leap to the conclusion that Henne and Morelli are automatic equals. From what I've heard, Morelli has had an immense challenge grasping the plays at the college level. That might be why Paterno was insistent this week that Morelli wasn't ready for the job yet. Though Paterno deserves a lot of the heat he takes for not playing freshmen, what if once -- just once -- he's operating on sound reasoning?

Advertise with us

(That said, I will offer some contradictory points later in the Q & A.)

Q: Being a third-generation Buckeye and native of Pittsburgh, I have always admired Joe Paterno and his football program. Through the years I believe Joe has always operated in a manner that is a credit to Penn State. But, what has happened at Happy Valley? 6-4? Specifically, who is running the offense? Joe brings in Galen Hall, presumed to give the offense a fresh perspective, yet the Nits continue to operate under the same two-headed offensive monster that some believe helped drive Fran Ganter into retirement. Any truth to the rumor that Hall is frustrated and running out of patience with Joe's insistence in allowing son Jay to have a say in the play calling? I'm making my annual trek back to Columbus to see the Buckeyes this Saturday. I'm wondering if either team will score a touchdown. What's your take on the game?

Linda E. Moore of Laguna Niguel, Calif.

HARLAN: As for the offense, ugh, what a disaster. When Hall was brought in to guide the offense, I'm sure he came assuming he'd be given entire control over the play-calling. Even when Fran Ganter stepped aside in the offseason, he made some comments about how the next offensive coordinator would likely have more control. That seemed to make sense when the well-respected and experience Hall was brought it. Somehow, though, Penn State is still working with the same overly complex system of play calling. Perhaps part of it is nepotism; perhaps Joe just wants Jay to have an involvement with the offense, in helps of advancing his coaching career. Perhaps Joe actually thinks such a system is the best way to operate. In truth, I don't know how he thinks. He's been asked, too, and he's only offered vague answers about the play-calling. Especially with the way the offense has performed of late, it makes sense for the Lions to let Hall call all offensive plays. (Note: in that last sentence, I strung together three rhyming words in a row. Hall. Call. All. Certainly a literary high point for my Q&A writing!)

Q: I have watched every PSU football game in the past five years and I have seen the good and cheered through the bad. My question for you is in regard to the offense on Saturday verses Iowa. Where was Mark Rubin? Two weeks ago against Purdue, he stepped up as a solid receiver in Robinson's absence. Two weeks later, Robinson returns and Rubin is nowhere to be found. Clearly there is no one else that has played any better this year, so why not put Rubin and Robinson on each side and have two wideouts capable of playing. Can you shed any light on this?

Advertise with us

Pat Bernot of Butler

HARLAN: Yeah, Rubin's disappearance made no sense. Sometimes, Penn State focuses so much on Michael Robinson -- its self-advertised greatest weapon ever -- that it forgets about the other playmakers. And indeed, when Robinson missed two games, Rubin might well have been the Lions' best offensive player. A few passes were thrown his way Saturday, but he didn't really have a chance to catch any of them. I'd expect to see Rubin more involved this week, especially if Robinson is forced to play quarterback. So long as Robinson is under center, Rubin is the team's best receiver.

Q: Paterno said it wouldn't be fair to put Morelli in against Iowa - what's the big deal? Didn't Mills come in against Northwestern in a pressure situation and win in 2001!? What's Paterno's problem - neither Mills nor Robinson are getting it done, so what does he have to gain if he wastes this year of Morelli's eligibility? I don't even get excited about games anymore because I expect the Lions to lose.

Brent of Escondido, Calif.

HARLAN: As I see it, the problem isn't necessarily that Paterno is reluctant to play Morelli. The problem is that PSU burned his redshirt earlier in the year. Let's assume, just for a second, that Paterno is being truthful and correct when he says Morelli isn't ready to play. Let's assume he's not saying this out of loyalty to Mills. Let's assume he's not saying this just because he's hesitant to play a freshman. Why, then, did he decide to play Morelli way back on Sept. 4 in garbage time against Akron? If Morelli isn't ready now, surely he wasn't then. Two possibilities: Either Penn State made a horrible error in judgment. Or Morelli hasn't grasped the Penn State system as quickly as coaches might have hoped.

Advertise with us

Q: When is Penn State gonna get rid of Joe Paterno and his son??? The game has passed them by. Joe's age means he can't get good recruits. It's time he steps down. Thank you.

Jim of Fort Myers, Fla.

HARLAN: The recruiting issue might be the most well-founded criticism one can present against Paterno. No doubt, his age discourages recruits. Any top high school player with a pick of top football universities will want a school with stability. He'll want a school where, first, he knows and likes the head coach. And where, second, he's almost certain that coach will remain in place for four years. Right now, Paterno does not represent such stability. His age deters recruits. The losing deters recruits. And the failure to draw good recruits perpetuates the losing. Tough cycle, huh?

Q: I'm very concerned about the future of Anthony Morelli as a Lion. Given the fact the play of Mills and Robinson has been dreadful and the fact Joe hasn't given Morelli a chance to show his talents, I wonder if he does have a future at PSU. Joe had a great opportunity to get Morelli in there against Iowa, but said basically he couldn't put him into the fire like that. Well, when is the right time? The freshman couldn't have does any worse than Mills or Robinson. The fact is that Paterno has gone on record saying Robinson is the incumbent at quarterback in 2005 should worry every PSU fan. The Lions have already wasted Morelli in 2004 and him backing up Robinson would be a waste as well. Could he be having second thoughts about signing at PSU and could he be maybe thinking of transferring if he isn't given a shot this year?

John of Lexington, Kent

Advertise with us

HARLAN: No way does Morelli transfer after this season. If nothing else, let's examine what Morelli likely expected when signing on at Penn State. He knew the Lions already had a fifth-year senior in place to start at quarterback. He knew how PSU is almost always hesitant to play freshmen. It can be said with almost absolute certainty that Morelli came to Penn State expecting to remain on the sidelines for a year. I'm sure he can live with it. If Morelli has a complaint, it's that coaches wasted his redshirt season just so he could be on the field for a few measly plays against MAC teams and a last-second Hail Mary. Nine passes, to be exact. Now that is a legitimate complaint. But nothing major enough to warrant a transfer.

Q: Don't you think Anthony Morelli would be better off transferring to another school? If they wouldn't play him in the Iowa game, there isn't much future for him at PSU. We all know Michael Robinson is not much of a passer and would have been better at receiver than quarterback.

John of Cyclone, Pa.

HARLAN: Read above and you'll see my opinions about the likelihood of Anthony Morelli transferring. But would he be better off elsewhere, you ask? Based on Penn State's recent history of developing quarterbacks, maybe he would be. But remember, if he transfers to another Division 1-A program, he's required to sit out another year. He wouldn't become eligible again until 2006 -- he'd be a player who last started regularly three seasons earlier. That is quite a deterrent. Maybe he should just pack his backs and head to Robert Morris. Then he could play next year without sitting out.

Q: It is obvious Joe Paterno is no longer able to coach winning football at Penn State. This will be the fourth losing season out of the past five, one conference win out the last 12 and yet he continues. In recent games he often angrily points his finger in the face of officials and even some players and last year he ran down an official to shout at him. I do not see this kind of behavior from other top 1-A coaches. This is not coaching or setting an example for his players. He is now doing what is best for Joe, not what is best for Penn State football and the University. Why is there no administration, alumni, fan or media effort to have him retire and bring on a new energetic, innovative coach? Is everyone afraid to talk about this sad state of affairs? What is the problem?

Advertise with us

Jerry Arnold of Austin, Texas

HARLAN: Why is there no media effort to make Paterno retire? Simple. Because we report the news, we don't cause it. (A few columnists this week, though, did write articles suggesting Paterno should step down.) Why no fan or alumni effort? I think that, contrary to what you suggest, there is an effort from this constituency. The letter-writing campaigns directed at athletic director Tim Curley and university president Graham Spanier have created a small wave of anti-Paterno sentiment. That's the kind of stuff that gets noticed. And what about an administrative effort? Not yet. For the longest time in Happy Valley, Paterno has been in complete control of his own affairs. Even now, as his program starts to crumble, the highest school officials seem hesitant to interfere. It's a tough situation for them. An understandable dilemma. I don't think people are hesitant to talk about this "sad state of affairs"; slowly, I think enough people are starting to admit to themselves that Paterno might not be able to turn this program around. Just based on my dealings with people, I've noticed a drastic change in the perception of Paterno over a very short period of time.

Q: In your opinion, are there any young, promising offensive lineman that could practice and play as a cohesive unit in the near or immediate future? The shuffling of linemen in and out is obviously detrimental to the timing and effectiveness of the offense. If they don't start to protect and produce, Anthony Morelli will be the last brave blue chip QB recruit to come to Penn State. They won't want to end up in the hospital each week like Mills and Robinson have.

Jim Post of Middlebury, Conn.

HARLAN: Here's the discouraging thing about the O-line, Jim. If you go back and dig up some articles written at the start of the season, players (on both offense and defense) as well as coaches were lauding the potential of the offensive line. To be sure, at least some base of talent is there. That's what makes the struggles on the line so perplexing. Penn State has absolutely failed to turn players who were above-average high school recruits into strong players. Take Tyler Reed, for instance. You can't tell me he doesn't have the ability. And yet last week, he sat on the bench in place of Scott Davis. Why do I mention this? Well, Jim, maybe it doesn't really matter if Penn State has any young, promising linemen on the bench. If the Lions can't develop those players, such promise will never amount to anything. That said, in recent weeks, you've seen a few younger players who certainly do have the chance to start next year. John Wilson is one of those players. And I wouldn't be surprised if Mark Farris is able to squeak out more playing time next year, too.

Advertise with us

Q: Now that it is apparent that we are done for the season, would it make sense to go ahead and play the offensive starters for next year. I would go ahead and make Robinson and Hunt the wide receivers, Scott the running back and the freshman quarterback the starters for the remaining of the year.

Warren Quinn of Pottsville, Pa.

HARLAN: No, I don't think it would make sense. And to be truthful, next year's starters won't be too much different from this year's starters. Just because Penn State likely won't make a bowl this season doesn't mean the Lions should scrap everything in midseason. It is their obligation, no matter the circumstances, to play the team that gives them the best chance to win for the game they're playing at that exact moment. Playing for next season is something that happens far more often in fans' fantasies than in real life.

Q: Mine is a two-part questrion: First, presuming he stays healthy, what odds do you give Paterno to be PSU's head coach thru 2008 to fulfill his contract? Two, barring his committing a felony, to what new lows do you think the University's 'Powers That Be' will allow the program to sink before finally stepping in to say "Enough already!" of this geriatric's delusions? PSU has not yet reached the bottom. Let's say JoePa has a 1- or 2-win season? Goes 0-11? Years ago, unthinkable, but with the downward trends of late, perhaps even likely. That trend is now many years old, and worsening.

Terry Smith of Littleton, Colo.

Advertise with us

HARLAN: If Paterno is Penn State's head coach in 2008, I'd be shocked. Absolutely floored. Stunned. Incredulous. You name it. That contract was only a fa?ade to suggest coaching stability at Penn State, especially for recruits, who need some tangible evident that their new D-1 head coach will be sticking around for the entirety of their playing careers. I'm still not sure, at this point, how much performance has to do with Paterno's last few years of coaching. He'll likely leave when he wants to leave. But I think he'll see a chance for a winning record next season and end it right there -- after 2005. If the "powers that be" must eventually step in and say "Enough already," that will truly be a last-case scenario. Yeah, maybe an 0-11 season would do it.

Q: Curious to know why if the running game is so inept, that we keep sticking with Tony Hunt? Sure, he looks like he's got some of the things that make a good back, but in the Purdue game he ran with little authority; not hitting holes, was very tentative, and very ineffective. The O-Line hasn't played very well on running plays that past three games, but Hunt hasn't done much to try and overcome that either. On several occasions vs. Purdue, when there was a slight hole, he was tentative to attack. I would think the coaching staff would realize this and make a change. Aside from the Austin Scott in the doghouse probability, any idea why they're not making a change?

EB of Richmond, Va.

HARLAN: I think Joe realizes that the O-line hasn't given Hunt a fair chance. Remember, we're starting to see a bit more of Scott now, too, and he hasn't been any more effective than Hunt. If Scott was routinely entering games in the second quarter and breaking off 20-yard runs, then yeah, maybe Scott would be able to overtake Hunt on the depth chart. But for now, both players have been equally ineffective. So why are they sticking with Tony Hunt? One of two reasons. Either Paterno doesn't think the running struggles are Hunt's fault. Or, he doesn't think the team has any running back more effective. I'd actually agree with both of those statements.

Q: Okay Chico, lay it on the line for us. It's a tough decision about a man that has meant so much more than football to his university, but there is more national speculation than ever that this season is it for JoePa (ESPN's "Around the Horn" and "Pardon the Interruption"). So, I put it to the one, single person who knows the real story -- what do you think, Mr. Harlan? When does the old man hang it up?

Advertise with us

Mark of Methuen, Mass.

HARLAN: After 2005, I think. That'll be his last year. We'll get the word from Joe sometime before next season.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.