Have your own question?
Click here to submit your question
Q: At the end of Saturday's game, PSU had roughly 60 seconds left and no timeouts; 70 yards to go. Zack Mills threw two passes (if my memory serves me well) to the middle of the field and not beyond the first down marker, so precious time ticked away. In my mind, his play on that last drive was the dagger in the heart. A fourth-year quarterback should've known better to throw those passes and that it would be better to throw it away and try again. The worst part is that I've been unable to find a sports talking head who has referenced these critical mistakes (other than a brief mention by the ESPN announcers immediately afterward). Should I not expect a fourth-year quarterback to know better? Mills has shown limited improvement in his four years and while much of that can be blamed on his supporting cast, his critical mistakes at the end of the Purdue game suggest otherwise. It's getting harder and harder to remember Mill's heady first year, with comeback wins aplenty. C'mon, Chico, I need validation.
Kaliph of Monroe, N.C.
HARLAN: I agree, Kaliph -- the clock management at the end of the Purdue game was questionable. I understand some of it. The passes over the middle came only because Purdue's defense took away the far sides of the field. But here's the rub: if Mills is going to throw across the middle, those passes darn well better produce a first down. Otherwise, 15 seconds or so tick away instead of two or three. Though the odds of a Lions touchdown at the onset of that drive were slim, the odds slipped to absolute zero after those first few plays. Mills deserves part of the blame; he probably threw those passes because he feared taking a sack, which would have been a worse outcome than a short completion. But remember this, Kaliph. Mills was in a tough situation to begin with. To lead a team 70 yards with no timeouts in less than a minute is a task that would make even John Elway quiver. That Mills failed to lead PSU to a touchdown on that drive shouldn't detract from an otherwise excellent game.
Q: Ah, the bye week! A time to kick back and reflect on the glories of the first half of the season (about two seconds worth in Happy Valley). Of course, if we're to look at some mild positives, ever since the Boston College game, the defensive unit as a whole has shown steady improvement, and looks like it might be making strides to actually win a game or two by the season's end. Unfortunately, it also appears as if the offense remains in feet-dragging mode. That said, I'm curious how you would rate the '04 version of the Nittany Lions at the midway point. Who's stood out so far in your mind, and who should we keep our collective eyes on in the coming weeks? Any signs of life for the stretch run? Thanks, Chico!
Mark of Methuen, Mass.
HARLAN: I'll take your last question first. Any signs of life for the stretch run? Plenty, I say. Maybe this next statement will only reflect how far Penn State's standards have in fact fallen, but I think many aspects of this season have actually exceeded expectations. (Slightly.) Though it has built only a 2-4 record thus far, Penn State has convinced me it will be a pretty competitive team next year in the Big Ten. And I have a strange suspicion a sneak preview of that will come in the next five games. Maybe the Lions won't win four or five games -- which is what they need for a bowl berth -- but I foresee three wins before the season closes. Granted, a 5-6 season ain't much to get excited about (unless, of course, you happened to predict just that in the preseason), but it will paint a path for optimism next year. And maybe -- just maybe -- PSU can catch a few extra breaks and end up in the Music City Bowl. After all, I hear Nashville has a pretty good country music scene.
Anyway, you want individuals to watch, too. On defense, I'd say Tamba Hali. He hasn't gotten enough notice so far this season, but he's emerged into a playmaker on the defensive line. On offense -- provided you can bear watching it -- keep an eye on right tackle Andrew Richardson. He's playing for a job, both for this year and next year, and that alone should be enough to spice things up.
Q: If one really loves, then shouldn't one let go? I realize it must be very difficult, just like any love affair is; however if JoePa really loved Penn State, don't you think that someone who is close to JoePa would try to get the reality of JoePa to let go and step down? The changing of the times are upon us and obviously overdue. With all due respect, Penn State University should give a very prestigious title and position to Joe. Something on lines, like "director of player development" or some other position that saves face but removes him from the head coaching position. Do you think this is a realistic approach?
Allen Bills of Jacksonville, N.C.
HARLAN: Allen, I love the way you open your question; it's as if you're writing poetry, what with the love and the letting go and the heartbreak. How wondrously florid and imaginative! (A little overly dramatic, too, but what the heck, who cares.) You're an inspiration. Thankfully, because I have both plenty of time on my hands and a slight inclination to rhyming circumlocution, I will answer you in poetry-form. My apologies, in advance.
At the helm of the ballclub: a man named Paterno.
The hot seat, as he aged, felt like an inferno.
But the coach wasn't phased -- he incited a rage
By sticking around 'till he reached his old age.
Next question was, How will he go?
At least that's what a man named Bills wanted to know.
Director of Player Development? No way!
A lame job like that -- it's such a clich?.
Ol' Joe is a coach, and he's sticking around,
He lives for Penn State; to his team he is bound.
Maybe he'll leave when his wife says it's time,
But forcing him out: that's like a war crime.
In my humble eyes, Joe has one more year.
Then he should leave, and not interfere.
So if one really loves, then should he let go?
I'll leave that answer to a man like Thoreau.
Q: Against Purdue, with Tim Shaw, Paul Posluszny, and J.R. Zwierzynski out with injuries, Tom Bradley's best option a linebacker to play along side Dan Conner and Derek Wake was Nolan McCready, a 200-pound safety who never "repped" the position before. According to the box score, Pat Bedics and Mike Southern, both backup linebackers, dressed and played (and most definitely "repped" at the position) in the game. The third and long play in the fourth quarter when McCready missed a tackle and Purdue picked up a first down was huge because it led to a field goal and most importantly took an extra three minutes off the clock. I know hindsight is 20/20 but having someone in there that might have been in that situation before (i.e., during practice) may have made that play. Outside of Shaw, Conner, Wake, and Posluszny, where is the talent at Linebacker at Linebacker U?
Rob York of Alexandria, Va.
HARLAN: First off, I don't think it's so realistic to complain about a lack of talent behind Shaw, Conner, Wake and Posluszny. That's like saying, "Outside of Wood, Zambrano, Clement and Prior, where is the good, young starting pitching in Chicago?" Penn State has a fine trio of starting linebackers, and at least one solid backup. That's better than the Lions have at almost any other position. As for McCready's appearance in the game, obviously that's a worst-case scenario. Posluszny and Shaw were both out with injuries, and Connor was making his first career start. I think McCready was playing ahead of Southern and Bedics probably because McCready was more suited for passing situations, and Purdue runs a pass-first offense. And in truth, he did an admirable job. He made a few early mistakes (you reference one of them), but he learned on the fly. Hopefully, for the defense's sake, he won't be pressed into linebacker duty again this year.
Q: A long, long time ago -- 1940's vintage -- a young lad graduated from Slippery Rock as probably the or at least one of the greatest players ever at that school. I'm not sure what he did at first, but I do know that he became an assistant at Rochester to Rube Wrenchell. Rube had previously coached at Robinson Twp, where Bobby Phillips attended high school and was their quarterback. That's before Slippery Rock. Rube coached all three sports at Robinson and took the football team to new horizons. No championships, but winning records, which was really something for a school that seldom won more than two or three games. After he left it was back to losing for about the next 10 years. Enter Bob Phillips. Within three years the team was not only winning, but winning WPIAL championships. Then he went to Penn State as one of Paterno's assistants. Bob died a couple of years back shortly after retiring and it seemed that was just about the time when Paterno's teams started to go sour. I was wondering if you had any info as to when he started coaching at PSU and when he retired?
Jim Malarky of Norco, Calif.
HARLAN: Ding ding ding! We have a winner! Weirdest question all season, Jim. Thankfully, this is exactly why they manufacture media guides -- to forever preserve the obscure. Bob Phillips coached at Penn State from 1966 until 1986. Penn State didn't exactly "go sour" shortly after he left, though. Took about 1 ? decades. Anyway, hope this answers your question.
Q: Is it true that Penn State has signed Joe Paterno through 2008?
Robert Martin of Rochester, N.Y.
HARLAN: Yes.
Q: Mr. Answer Man aka Mr. Harlan, I'll try to hold these questions to a manageable length. Do you agree with me that Coach Paterno recruits an inordinate number of skill players (including linebackers) compared with offensive and defensive lineman? I think that is one of the reasons that PSU has little success in running (see 17 yards in 18 attempts vs. Purdue). Also, it appears that linemen are shifted between the offense and defense several times. Do you agree with me that quarterbacks who go to PSU don't develop in ability? Either the quarterbacks are not that talented or Jay Paterno is not a good quarterbacks coach. This may be why some noted high school quarterbacks, after flirting with PSU, have gone to other schools where they had success (e.g. Chris Simms and Chad Henne). Do you agree that Coach Paterno has lost the ability to close the deal with the top recruits and thus has a roster of mostly second-tier players? After all, what top drawer players want to go to a school that usually has losing seasons? Thanks.
Chuck of Huntington Beach, Calif.
HARLAN: Lots to cover here, Chuck. First, I don't agree Penn State recruits an "inordinate" number of skills players compared with linemen. No way. You use one rushing stat in one game to draw that conclusion, but I think you're only going to mislead yourself by suggesting that. If you look at Penn State's current distribution of talent, it's spotty everywhere. The Lions have a few very good D-linemen. They have several poor O-linemen. They have at least two talented running backs; their talent at wide receiver, though, is pretty pathetic. You can't make a definitive statement, in other words, that Penn State has done well recruiting one kind of player or position and poorly recruiting another kind of player or position. If PSU's recruiting has declined, it's not that cut and dried. Now I'll give you this: there's a good chance that the last few losing seasons have dissuaded some top recruits from coming here. When you're dealing with the best high schoolers in the nation -- the five-star players, guys who could play just about anywhere -- they can be more selective with the schools and criteria. If a player has offers from Tennessee, Oklahoma, Michigan and Penn State, the Lions will obviously suffer because they haven't been as successful in recent years. Maybe that was a factor in Henne's decision. Then again, if you ask 25 recruits why they chose a certain school, they'll give you 25 different reasons.
Q: With the obvious lack of big-play ability in the Penn State offense, why is Rodney Kinlaw not being utilized in the passing game either out of the back field or in the slot to create mismatches with safeties and linebackers? All we heard in the preseason was how much of a gamebreaker he is because of his 4.3 speed, and they claim he has recovered 100% from his knee injury.
Carl of Pottstown
HARLAN: Word is, Kinlaw's not much of a pass-catcher. Yes, he has the speed you'd like to see in a wideout, but if he can't hang on to passes? well, that makes him just like most of his teammates. Still, I'm a bit surprised Penn State hasn't used Kinlaw more frequently in the offense -- even on reverses, quick passes, etc. From the times I've seen Kinlaw this season, he looks like a shifty runner who can provide an element this offense normally lacks.
Q: I thought Mark Farris was going to start against Purdue? John Wilson did a decent job pass protecting but his run blocking is why Levi Brown was converted from defense in the first place. Is Farris in the doghouse?
Mike Jones of Youngstown, Ohio
HARLAN: In the week leading up to the Purdue game, Mark Farris was indeed slated to start. Evidently, between Tuesday afternoon (when Paterno talked to the press) and Saturday evening (when Farris got placed on the bench), something happened in practice that told coaches Wilson would handle the starting job better than Farris. Even entering the Purdue game, Paterno was planning to sub Farris and Wilson, series by series. But Wilson's early play kept him in the lineup. I don't think Farris is in the doghouse -- only because when Paterno discusses a player actually in his doghouse, you can normally hear a layer of disgust in his voice. (See: Scott, Austin). You don't hear that with Farris. There is a chance we could see more of either Farris or Wilson next week, because Paterno seemed very close to removing right tackle Andrew Richardson from the starting lineup. He's had several poor games in a row, and Penn State could benefit from a change.
Q: Chico -- In lieu of your misspelling of Haywood Jeffires' last name, should I be worried that in my readings of the Post-Gazette online I'm going to start seeing "Joe Peterno" and "Zach Mills"? Now, if you were to flop a letter in the last name of former Oregon State receiver T.J. Houshmandzadeh, well, I'd understand. But my man Haywood was a mid-'90s luminary. Guy caught 100 balls in a season. And he was named Haywood! Considering my aversion to exclamation points, you know I'm serious, Cheeks, and with that comes a serious question that's bugged me for weeks: Why was JoePa's appearance on "Lou Dobbs Tonight" not syndicated nationally? I mean, the presidential debates are on NBC, ABC and CBS, and JoePa surely is smarter than both of those nincompoops.
Ira Rothstein of East Meadow, N.Y.
HARLAN: Oh, Ira. So much to learn. You may be proud of yourself for catching one of my errors, but I'm actually here to scold you. If you fancy yourself a watchdog on the accuracy of my mailbag -- i.e., Stat Boy on PTI -- let me explain that you missed a far more glaring error. Last week, I referenced Warren Moon's likeness in the early-'90s Tecmo Bowl video game. But in fact, there was no Warren Moon to be found; rather, it was a nebulous pixilated fellow named "QB Oilers" who delivered the ball to quartet of receivers. Readers everywhere, please accept my apologies. I regret the error. I also regret Ira didn't do a better job spotting it.
Now, onto your "serious" question, which is really quite the opposite of serious, as are all of your questions. You suggest our nation might have benefited had Joe Paterno's recent appearance on "Lou Dobbs Tonight" been syndicated on every major news network. Puh-lease, Ira. I'm guessing you didn't see the segment (if you did, you would surely not be paying tribute to the telecast), so let me fill you in on how the superficialities played out, as below I relay the entirety of Paterno's comments on the show:
First:
"I think it's a waste of time to come to college if you don't get something off it academically. I mean, football is a game."
Last:
"People say, what do you stand for? I don't know. I try to get up in the morning, try to be fair. I want to stand up in front of a team and say, this is what I expect of you, and not be a hypocrite."
Personally, I think watching two nincompoops is a lot more entertaining.
Q: The early emergence of Dan Conner illustrates the big problems at PSU. It "appears" to have been relatively easy for him to earn a starting position, but he clearly deserves the starting job and the praise for his play. He was a consensus five-star recruit, and he is competing primarily against three- and some four-star recruits at the linebacker position. It seems simple: as soon as the five-star and high four-star recruits start to consistently commit to PSU, the overall quality of the team will greatly improve and the wins will start to come in bunches! Also, how do they expect to win when they take an underachieving tight end, then convert him to a starting offensive tackle, when Michigan and OSU are recruiting five-star offensive tackles? Chico, you could probably beat Richardson around the corner and sack Mills!
Bob of Ponka City, Okla.
HARLAN: Basically, what you're saying seems pretty logical, Bob. Better recruits leads to better results. Seems easy enough, so I can't disagree with you. Problem is, there aren't enough players like Connor to fill a roster, even if (for the sake of making a point) Penn State was getting every single five-star recruit in the country. So what does that mean? Every team, including Penn State, must turn lesser-touted players into productive college players. That doesn't mean they have to be stars -- we can count on the occasional five-star players for that. But they have to become serviceable, hopefully above average. This, in my view, is a bigger failing for Penn State than struggling to land all of the top players.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.