Have your own question?
Click here to submit your question
Q: As you discussed in your article regarding the latest press conference, JoePa seemed to blame the Minnesota loss on the wide receivers. I came across some information on PSU wide receivers currently on the roster and noticed that not one was ranked in the nation's top 50 (or rated with three stars or higher) coming out of high school. In fact, Josh Hannum, who is no longer on the team, would have been the highest rated if he was still on the roster. Now, I know that the various scouting services that rate recruits do not have an exact science to hang their hat on, but it is apparent that PSU has not placed the necessary emphasis on the position come recruiting time, and/or, simply cannot attract talented wide receivers. The latter seems odd to me considering in 2001 a promising freshman by the name of Zack Mills came onto the scene and almost got that team to a bowl, despite an 0-4 start. Offensive success was through the passing game and it appeared that the offense was on its way to becoming more dynamic. However, any top recruits that were inspired by that style of offense in 2001 would be contributors on the team today and the playmakers are just not there. Therefore, do you think its fair to assume that the recruiting plans (those of which were JayPa's responsibility as coordinator up until this year) over the last several years have not adequately addressed the position? Other reasons?
John of Pittsburgh
HARLAN: Interestingly, Paterno was posed this exact question at his press conference this week, and he suggested that several of the current PSU wideouts were in fact highly recruited - they just haven't panned out. What would be a more accurate statement is this: Penn State has recruited some above-average high school receivers (three star players, in other words) but they haven't been able to grow into above-average college receivers. In some cases, they haven't even been able to grow into average college receivers. On the current Lions' roster, players like Mark Rubin - another three-star guy - look promising, but this is more about the players (like Gerald Smith, Terrance Phillips and Kinta Palmer) in the older generation. These are the players Penn State should be counting on right now. And they haven't produced this year. You make an interesting point about Mills, and the potential he might have had several years ago as a recruiting tool. I'd imagine you're right. What wide receiver wouldn't want to come to a school where he'd have the chance to develop alongside a promising quarterback? That said, I think Penn State's recruiting ability for wide receivers has been pretty sub-par. This is the second consecutive year in which dropped passes and a lacking playmaker has hurt the team. I doubt this black hole of current wideout talent resulted from a lack of recruiting effort. But indeed, I think the chance - whatever it might have been - to recruit one or two top-level receivers to play with Mills has certainly slipped away. For Mills' sake, that's a shame.
Q: I've about had it up to here (wherever that is !!!) with Coach Paterno blaming the receivers with dropping passes, so I have a question/comment/riddle about it and it goes like this: Coach Paterno complains about the receivers dropping passes. Who recruited the receivers and selected the receivers coach(es)? Coach Paterno. Duh !
Chuck of Huntington Beach, Calif.
HARLAN: Still, Chuck, a coach is never going to step back, mid-season, and look at things with such a big spectrum. Nor should he. If Paterno drew all lines back to himself, he could take credit after every win and every diving catch and every last-second field goal kick, simply by saying, 'I'm the man responsible for bringing this person here to play football.' Doesn't work like that. Perhaps the wide receiver talent at Penn State isn't perfect, but these are still bona fide Division I receivers. They shouldn't be dropping so many passes. At some point, credit and blame must be passed on to the person who is being given a scholarship in exchange for his football skills. I have no problem with Paterno criticizing his wide receivers. His dissatisfaction, I feel, is justified.
Q: Chico, Who do you think will be the next head coach at Penn State? Thanks.
Bob Hubert of Erie
HARLAN: Rumor mill question! But let me first note, Bob, for those who haven't been reading the fine print in Pennsylvania newspapers this year: Joe Paterno is still coaching the Penn State Nittany Lions. He could be here for another 50 years. The next PSU coach might still be an unborn child. Or JoePa's successor might be eating Gerber's and spitting on his bib right now. For the sake of interest, though, I've heard a few names mentioned as one-day candidates for a Penn State job. Kirk Ferentz, now at Iowa, is the most commonly mentioned name. He attended Upper St. Clair High School in Pittsburgh, so that makes the interest natural. Other possibilities: Al Golden, a current defensive coordinator at Virginia and a former PSU player. And perhaps Urban Meyer, now at Utah, whose stock is so high, he'd be a candidate for almost any high-level college opening. Then there's always the ol' ballcoach Steve Spurrier. So long as he remains unemployed, he is the most intriguing - and least likely - option. Too bad. I like any head coach who awards himself gameballs after big victories.
Q: As a fellow who has followed the game with the pointed ball since Ben Schwartzwalder roamed the sidelines at icy Alumni Stadium, I know the sport can be as perplexing as any... except maybe the contest in which those basket-tossers gallop around with the leather inflated air capsule. So I've found Penn State's offensive ineptitude quite curious. Seventeen points in three affairs against teams not named the Zips or UCF - or is it Cent. Fla. or Cen. Flori. or Ce. F.? Regardless, it seems the Nittany Lions need a change of pace at quarterback. How about Troy Nunes, a western Pennsylvania boy who's still very much a charm to be around? Or a youngster in the mold of Roger Staubach, who zipped and zagged and huzzahed atop the small green weeds in days of yore for Navy's squads? That said, what do you think of Purdue's defense?
W.F. Whence of Quillstown, Mass.
HARLAN: Oh, the genesis of your thought-process leaves me very discombobulated, W.F. But I will make at least some attempt to cover a few of your references. First, the game with the pointed ball - or football, to the common rooting denizen - perplexes even the best of us, even old ballcoaches like Schwarzwalder and Pop Warner and Amos Alonzo Stagg. So are you befuddled by Penn State's offensive stagnation this year? Don't be. A quarterback change, W.F., won't make much of a difference. Mills is the best option, without question. Chris Ganter, currently the backup, so long as Michael Robinson remains injured, is a nice kid but a poor option at quarterback. And freshman Anthony Morelli has a great arm and fantastic raw skills, but he lacks the understanding of the offense - for now, at least - to capably lead the offense. This team will stick with Mills for good reason.
Q: Chico, this is getting very old - another Big Ten game for Penn State, and another loss. So, what's new, right? Well, what makes this latest loss particularly tough to swallow is the fact that even the lowly Northwestern football program seems to be more competitive in the Big Ten than Penn State is. On Saturday, while Zack Mills was "leading" his team to another hapless performance against Minnesota, not Miami, USC, or Oklahoma, but Minnesota (are you kidding?), Northwestern was doing something that Penn State teams now seem absolutely incapable of doing - beating Ohio State. How have we gotten to the point where the ugly purple of Northwestern is able to beat Ohio State in fairly convincing fashion, and Penn State is unable to beat anyone in the Big Ten? You can be honest wih me, Chico. Ha! I can take it! Will Penn State win at least one game in the Big Ten this year?
Jerry Moore of North Potomac, Md.
HARLAN: Yes, Penn State will win at least once in the Big Ten this year, Jerry. I can virtually guarantee it. Remember, you've only seen Penn State play two in-conference teams this season, and Minnesota and Wisconsin count as two of the four ranked teams in the Big Ten. Though it would have been nice to see PSU knock off one of those teams, it would have also been unexpected. On the road. Without a full offensive arsenal. That's tough to overcome. I don't think the Lions' first two Big Ten games cast a doomsday scenario on the rest of the season. The defense alone should be enough to give Penn State an edge over the bottom portion of the conference - and yes, I still think Penn State is probably the sixth- or seventh- best team in the league. A harsh schedule (Purdue, Iowa and Ohio State) finishes out October, but even against that competition, one upset isn't out of the question. I'd expect Penn State to make at least two of its next three games reasonably close; from there, one or two big plays could swing one of those games in PSU's favor. Stay out of panic mode for at least a few more games.
Q: Chico, my boy, I was perplexed at your perplexion over my question last week. Perhaps you'd like a question such as, "Why has the option died out?" But those types of flaccid questions do not challenge; rather, they allow for vapid, long-winded responses that don't stimulate the mind. So instead, I give you this week's query: Why has the run-and-shoot died out? My love for Penn State knows no bounds, however, I too have quite the football-crush on Jack Pardee, the innovator of the gun-slinging offense that, if implemented, could dredge the Nittanies out of their misery.
Ira Rothstein of East Meadow, N.Y.
HARLAN: As somebody who once made mincemeat out of opponents in Tecmo Bowl by expertly orchestrating the Warren Moon-Webster Slaughter-Haywood Jeffries-Ernest Givens-Drew Hill run-and-shoot offense, I, too, have fond memories of the Pardee era and all wacky philosophies that came with it. There is a reason, of course, why the run-and-shoot offense has gone the way of the dodo bird - no team ever won a Super Bowl by runnin' and shootin' - but that, actually, has nothing to do with why the offense would never work at Penn State. See, for a run-and-shoot offense, Ira, a team needs four reliable wide receivers. Penn State doesn't even have two. Earlier this year, a gentleman in this forum suggested that Penn State should experiment with the wishbone offense. Now you're suggesting the exact opposite. I think, for now, the run-and-shoot should remain, unbothered, in its current state of hibernation: preserved forever in the dusty Nintendo cartridge in my basement.
Q: Chico, in last week's column in response to one question you spoke about the coaching staff needing changes before PSU can return to national prominence. I assume you mean those changes have to start at the top. My question is, is there anyone at PSU who could possible persuade JoePa it's time to hang them up (other than Sue!)?
Ken Feigert of Hubbard, Ohio
HARLAN: Well, your question, Ken, points right to the drama that is Penn State football. Far too many lives and interests hang in the balance here for me to accurately answer this question. But I do find the whole situation fascinating. You have a coach, prideful and revered, who has survived - and flourished - for so many years by following his own principles and guidelines. You have a university that feels indebted to this coach for his service, and seems reluctant to push him aside with any force. And in the middle of this dynamic, you have a legion of fans who feel Paterno should gracefully retire, and who are growing frustrated with his reluctance to do so. And those desires go against the long-ingrained love they have for him. It's such a touchy situation, and frankly, I have no idea how Paterno's tenure at Penn State will end. He could be forced out, if the program continues to sink. (Though this, if not done with extreme caution, would likely generate a nightmarish sentiment against those who showed Paterno the door.) He could simply decide he's ready to retire. (But who can ever count on this happening.) Or, perhaps, Paterno could actually stick around to see one or two more successful Penn State seasons, and leave gracefully - with his legend furnished by a final season of great memories. I'm sure Sue will be heavily involved in the decision-making process - whatever the resolution. But could she persuade Paterno to step aside? Perhaps, but I'd guess her husband isn't easily persuaded.
Q: We all have heard the saying about "be careful what you wish for". As all loyal PSU fans will attest, we take great pride in way its athletes behave on the field and (in most instances) off the field and in the classroom. As it becomes more evident to even the most ardent Joe Paterno supporter, the program will not be turning around while he is still there. Today's athletes want to show off, to strut around and thump their chest and say look at me (eg. Florida State, Oklahoma, USC, etc.). Joe does not go for that. I think most of the fans don't go for that either. Do the PSU fans realize that those are the athletes that we will have to cheer for because the only way we will be able to compete is to attract those kinds of kids. Football has not passed Joe by, a way of life has passed him by and PSU fans as well. Living in Florida and watching FSU, UF and Miami and the way their "athletes" act is disgusting to someone who grew up in the era of sportmanship. Everything is about "me" and will I get to see myself on Sports Center. Sadly, in order to turn the program around we will have to accept the fact that the standards for our athletes will have to be lower. As I said, "be careful what you wish for". Comment?
Jeff Naret of Palm Harbor, Fla.
HARLAN: Interesting, Jeff, but I think our views differ a bit. First, I think the value that Penn State and Paterno have always like to associate with can still be carried on. PSU doesn't have to sell those traditional values in order to regain its status as a top football program. The characterization you make of this generation of college football players - pandering to SportsCenter; always thinking "me first" - is probably true to an extent, but there are still plenty of top athletes who don't fit this mold. But I think this point is even more important. It is a program's responsibility to recruit the top players (even if they are "me-first" athletes in high school) and turn them into something better. For a long time, I think Penn State has been able to do that. In other words, what you've always seen at Penn State does not result from the players they recruit, but rather, what happens to those recruits once they get to Happy Valley. If there is a turn in the program - in other words, if players lose the values that past PSU players have always embodied - I would actually put more blame on the program than on the kids or the generation. Players come to college to learn, and not just about football. In the past, Penn State has done a great job stressing that. If that changes - and hopefully it won't - it will be just much an indictment of the program as it will of the players.
Q: Although no one acknowledges it specifically, other than Justin Corson, Ken Caminiti and a few others, we know that steroids and human growth hormone are a big part of sports. So when I read comments about Penn State's smallish linemen who get blown off the ball by bigger opponents, I've got to wonder if that's happening because other teams are juicing their players and PSU is remaining inconveniently ethical. Any thoughts on that?
Rich Englehart of Newburyport, Mass.
HARLAN: I don't think steroid use exists on any widespread basis in college football, and if Penn State has any competitive disadvantage in the proverbial trenches, I can assure you it has nothing to do with opponents using performance-enhancing drugs. Please remember, Rich, most college football players will never play in the NFL. They aren't playing for a career; they aren't playing for money. I think performance-enhancing drugs become more of an issue at the professional levels, when the difference between success and failure becomes so slight, even a tiny edge can make a huge difference. At the college level, players have their scholarships regardless of production. That's not so say college football players are complacent - of course not. It's only to suggest that they don't have the perform-or-else pressure that might cause a pro athlete to experiment with risky behavior.
Q: I have to say, Chico, I've been honored to have several of my questions featured in your weekly Q & A section, and I appreciate your analysis of all things Penn State. That said, I'm already emotionally drained this season. What more is there to ask? Until something drastic changes in the "system," it appears mediocrity (or less) is the status quo in Happy Valley! So, with an impressive Purdue point-scoring machine coming into town this week, please just tell us all something...anything positive about the Penn State football team (even if you have to make something up)! Thanks again, Chico...keep up the good work!
Mark of Methuen, Mass.
HARLAN: Your question, Mark, reminds me of my Syracuse days, where, after every SU football loss - and there were many - a walrus-looking fellow from a neighboring paper made a habit of posing this question to Paul Pasqualoni: "Any positives, Coach?" So, with a nod to walrus-like scribe from up north, here is my list of all things positive for Penn State this season. First, though the team has suffered injuries to its first- and second-best offensive players, its third-best player remains healthy! (A notable positive!) Second, the fourth-best offensive player is healthy, too! Third, the team still has a game remaining against Indiana. Fourth, kicker Robbie Gould hasn't missed a field goal between 0 and 19 yards this season. Fifth, (and this is where I can start to approximate being serious) a few freshmen, like Dan Connor and Mark Rubin, look like they'll be great players. Sixth, the defense is growing, and will return all key components next year. Seventh, PSU has yet to lose 51-0 this season. Eighth, the team has stayed clear of legal trouble, financial trouble, visa trouble and/or all other scenarios that might be delivered on television news by a non-sports talking head. Ninth, the team likely has at least a few players who enjoy country music.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.