Have your own question?
Click here to submit your question
Q: I'll start by saying that I believe playing Chris Ganter was the right thing to do immediately after Robinson went down in the second quarter. It's hard to pin the loss on Ganter, who is obviously the third-string quarterback for a reason. My problem with this loss was that Coach Paterno stuck with Ganter for the remainder of the game. What a perfect opportunity to give Anthony Morelli some snaps in a situation that required more than his typical mop-up role. Truth be told, I'd have rather they not played Morelli at all this year to let him redshirt, but since that opportunity is already shot, what were they waiting for? He's the future, and unfortunately (if Mills or Robinson are unable to go), the future is now. What do you think, Chico? This is not the typical plea from the "peanut gallery" to play the blue-chipper just because the starters have been ineffective. The team lost its top two quarterbacks, and it would seem that Morelli's potential rather than Ganter's experience now gives them the best chance for offensive success. Am I wrong?
Mark of Methuen, Mass.
HARLAN: Wow, Mark. I couldn't have summarized it any better. Much of my "A:" will sound like a paraphrase of your "Q:", simply because I agree with you 100 percent. When Mills and Robinson left the game against Wisconsin, nobody should have been surprised when Ganter got the first shot at stepping in. Just typical Paterno coaching. Play the older guy. Play the more experienced guy. But I thought it was both surprising and shameful that Morelli didn't start taking snaps by the fourth quarter or so. First, it became readily apparent that Ganter wasn't going to lead a comeback. Penn State could have played until midnight and not scored 16 points. Not with Ganter, at least. I know his teammates offered him support following the Wisconsin game, but c'mon. He completed 6 of 23 passes for a total of 32 yards. Thirty-two yards! It was the perfect time to play Morelli. He'd have entered in a no-lose situation. The team was already behind, so he could have been the hero, but surely not the goat. People who defend the decision to leave Morelli on the bench refer to the fact that freshmen shouldn't be thrust into such pressure-packed situations. Well, news flash -- Every game in the Big Ten has at least some modicum of pressure. Use that rationale, and Morelli will never see the field this season. Now that Penn State has decided against Morelli's redshirt, he has to play in such situations. Paterno, at his Tuesday press conference, explained the decision to keep Morelli by saying the freshman hadn't practiced enough in the preceding week. Well, I must wonder: Is there really such a difference in the snaps taken by a third-stringer and a fourth-stringer? I doubt it. Penn State should have played Morelli; coaches missed the perfect chance.
Q: A superficial scan of the Big Ten rosters shows a high percentage of players from those states where the respective school resides. For example, the predominance of Badgers (66%) is from that legendary football hotbed, Wisconsin. What conclusions or even observations can anybody reach from the high percentage of Pennsylvania lads on these dismal PSU teams of the last 5 years?
Willie of Philadelphia
HARLAN: First, a look at some numbers, just so we know what we're dealing with here. Thirty-seven Golden Gophers come from Minnesota. Sixty-three Fighting Illini players come from Illinois. Fifty-two Hawkeyes come from Iowa. A whopping 82 Buckeyes come from Ohio. And by my count, 43 current Lions come from Pennsylvania. In all of these cases, the big state schools draw primarily from players in their home states -- as it should be. It seems, from your question, you are trying to lead me to one of two conclusions: First, that the quality of football talent in Pennsylvania (the talent on which PSU so faithfully depends) has somehow decreased in recent years. Or second, that Penn State is still getting players from a traditionally strong football state, but its coaches aren't turning that talent into success. I look at it this way: Penn State will always draw a high number of recruits from Pennsylvania, but the bigger question is the quality of those recruits. We can all point to several blue-chippers who've left the state for schools like Michigan and Virginia Tech. My fear is that Penn State might now be getting the second level of talent from Pennsylvania.
It would be fallacious to believe that Penn State, simply by virtue of its proclivity for drawing recruits from a strong football state, ought to be able to beat schools (like Wisconsin) that draw on talent from a lesser football state. Here's why. If Wisconsin is getting the best layer of homegrown players and Penn State is getting the second-best layer of homegrown players, that can be a noticeable disparity.
Q: I was wondering what you think the chances are that Penn State will land Justin King. Also, from all that I have read, why haven't the Lions been recruiting the big defensive tackle from the Philly area, Callahan Bright, who is supposed to be one of if not the best talent in the nation for any position?
Matt of Bedford
HARLAN: With King, it's still a bit early to tell. King (for those who don't know, he's a senior from Gateway High in suburban Pittsburgh, and one of the top high school players in the nation) is still waffling among several schools. Penn State is certainly on that list. So is Florida, USC and Michigan. King will decide on a school in the next 1 1/2 months; he's scheduled to take his official visit to Penn State on Nov. 6. As for the chances King will select Penn State? Let's wait until he makes his official visits to draw any conclusions, but the more games Penn State loses, the more PSU's chances have to suffer. The Lions have one thing going in their favor. King will be visiting State College close to the time he makes his decision, so a good impression -- provided that's what happens -- will still be fresh with him when he picks a school.
As for Bright, he is not considering Penn State. He might be the most sought-after defensive lineman in the country, having garnered more than 60 scholarship offers. He's still considering schools like Miami, Oklahoma and Florida State. So who can blame him if he's not interested in Penn State. Bottom line: that's why he's not being recruited by the Lions. His interest in PSU isn't there.
Q: It's that time of year, young Chico, when the leaves turn on Long Island and the wind whistles through the Sound and everyone with a salient and functional mind ponders the burning question that, still, after 55 seasons, no one answered: How much wood would a woodchuck chuck if a woodchuck was JoePa?
Ira Rothstein of East Meadow, N.Y.
HARLAN: You perplex me, Ira. This week, your question has reached a level of abstraction that leaves me speechless -- or, as I sit before my computer, typeless. So how much wood would a woodchuck chuck...? Well, I see it this way. Paterno possesses many rodent-like qualities -- both in his appearance and demeanor -- so I imagine him to be a very proficient wood-chucker. He would probably prefer some form of oak or maple. But I think it is unlikely that I can ever confirm this fact. Sometimes, Ira, your zaniness is too much. I pray for the sanity of your offspring.
Q: I wrote two weeks ago commenting on State's pathetic lines (offense & defense) to which you replied that I was being harsh. After yesterday's performance, I can say the defensive-line was okay and kept the offense in the game, except for the seven-plus minute drive to open the second half. If they were already tired at that point then they aren't in shape. However, it is now quite apparent that it is coaching that cost State its two most important players (Mills and Robinson). Obviously the coaches study film. How could they not see that they would need to double team Wisconsin's No. 90 and give help to right tackle Andrew Richardson?
Also, I thought the Big Ten instituted instant replay? Why wasn't it used when Smolko obviously caught the ball in the second quarter on that diving catch? Not that it would've made a difference in the outcome, but you never know.
Mick Fulton of Universal City, Texas
HARLAN: Wisconsin's defensive line presented too many problems, Mick, for coaches to concentrate on just one player. Erasmus James, for all he's done recently, isn't even the best player on Wisconsin's defensive line. That honor belongs to Anttaj Hawthorne, a potential All-American. When you have so many threats on one line, opponents can double-team one player, but that strategy is liable to open up problems elsewhere. Penn State could have double-teamed both Hawthorne and James on every play, but what does that leave the offense with? Three potential pass catchers on passing downs. In the end, Penn State needed its players to execute. That didn't happen, and it cost the Lions dearly. But the coaches can't take the blame for this one. No way.
Next, with the Smolko catch. The Big Ten should have reviewed that play, because it was indeed a catch. If plays like that aren't reviewed, I don't see the sense of the system. As you say, reversing that play wouldn't have made much of a difference in the game, but it would have been a nice example of the replay system at work. Penn State has a right to be disappointed that play wasn't reviewed.
Q: What are the chances of Penn State ever leaving the Big "Ten" and joining the Big East while Joe Paterno is still at the helm? I seem to remember that an all-sports Eastern conference was one of Paterno's lifelong dreams, until he grew impatient (or permanently miffed at Jackie Sherrill, take your pick). First of all, it would be a great boost in PSU's slowly-ebbing recruiting. Secondly, it would make more sense from a geographic standpoint. PSU would be more competitive in conference (sorry, but I only see two or three more wins on their schedule: Indiana and Northwestern, and maybe Michigan State in an upset). It would force Paterno to resume playing Pitt again. And finally, 10 + 1 does not equal 10.
Terry Smith of Littleton, Colo.
HARLAN: In a word (or number, more appropriately), Zero. So long as Paterno stays at Penn State, the Lions are going nowhere. Nor should they. The Big Ten isn't the problem. PSU is the problem. Suggesting that Penn State should leave for the Big East, Terry, sounds a bit desperate. Just to remind you, the Big East -- though it doesn't miscalculate its numerical size in its conference title -- is a conference with uncertainty by the bucketload. By joining the Big East, there's no doubt that Penn State's football record would improve. But do you really want this? It would be a cheap solution. And "solution" is a kind word. It would be more like admitting defeat -- as in, Penn State can't return to its old form without lowering its standards. You're right: for now, PSU could be in for a long season, and wins won't come easily this year. But I disagree that joining the Big East would help recruiting. Most teams in the Big East are now complaining the their affiliation with the conference is actually hurting recruiting. Any player worth his salt doesn't just want to win; he wants to compete. Leaving the Big Ten, theoretically, only requires exiting teams to provide one year's notice. Also, the conference doesn't have an exit fee, as the Big East does. Still, don't hold your breath. Penn State is in the right place. Leaving would only compound its problems.
Q: Chico, I never thought I'd be asking this question, but is there any chance that Penn State will be able to rebuild the football program enough to be competitive with such emerging programs as the University of Maryland. I grew up a Penn State fan but attended Maryland. I support and cheer for both programs. When I was at Maryland, Penn State absolutely owned the Terrapins. Now, Maryland has emerged as a solid national program. The two programs appear to be headed in opposite directions. Maryland is on the rise, and Penn State is fast becoming a complete "has been;" a total non-factor in the Big Ten. Solid recruits like quarterback Jordan Steffy are now electing to go to Maryland, West Virginia, Virginia Tech, etc., rather than Penn State. Yes, the quarterback injuries were tough to deal with at Wisconsin. But it's hard to imagine the final outcome would have been any different even if the injuries hadn't occurred. Penn State simply seems unable to win in the Big Ten anymore. Clearly, Purdue, Minnesota, and Iowa have overtaken them; and Penn State simply isn't in the same league as Ohio State and Michigan anymore. I'll bet most Big Ten schools now relish playing Penn State on homecoming. It seems to me that Penn State is fortunate that they don't play Maryland anymore. I think Maryland would probably own Penn State now -- totally inconceivable just a few years ago, but perhaps reality today. It's unbelievable how far Penn State's glorious program has fallen. Arrgh!!! So, let me ask you again -- Do you think Penn State, without a complete overhaul, will ever be able to compete with Maryland again? (Wow, did I really ask that question?) Thanks for listening.
Jerry Moore of North Potomac, Md.
HARLAN: A worthy rant, Jerry -- well done. I will just tackle your last question, here: "Do you think Penn State, without a complete overhaul, will ever be able to compete with Maryland again?" Right now, Maryland is an above-average football team in a strong conference. The Terps' program has some good momentum. Penn State, meanwhile, is an average football team in a strong conference. And the Lions program has backward momentum. In truth, I don't think PSU and Maryland are all that far apart, aside from the general directions both programs have gone in during the past few seasons. If these two teams played tomorrow at a neutral site, it would be a pretty close game. But I think you're asking indirectly when Penn State will return to its old form. I don't think this will happen if PSU sticks with the status quo. The program has so much going for it -- excellent facilities, strong fan support, great tradition -- but changes must be made, especially with the coaching staff. So long as Joe Paterno is coaching Penn State, too many top recruits will be swayed away from coming to State College. But once the right changes are made, Jerry, I don't think it will take that much for Penn State to catch back up to a program like Maryland.
Q: Please tell me that Gerald Smith and Terrance Phillips will not start on Saturday. Is there any chance of Austin Scott or Rodney Kinlaw playing receiver? I've seen better receivers than Smith and Phillips in the Mt. Lebanon High School intramural flag football league.
Brendan Shorts of Mt. Lebanon
HARLAN: Sorry to be the bearer of what you clearly consider bad news, but Yup, they're both starting tomorrow. Smith is a bit harder to knock than Phillips, who's turned into a target only slightly better than the de-limbed, blood-gushing knight in "Monty Python and the Holy Grail." Smith is OK -- he's a sometimes reliable, always adequate receiver. He could be a passable No. 2 receiver on most Division I teams. But Phillips drops way, way, way too many passes. Some of those drops have been very costly, too, leading to interceptions or halted drives. I know Paterno is not too enamored with the wideouts right now. That's why, starting with the Wisconsin game, we started seeing Mark Rubin. Teammates who watch Rubin every day in practice swear he's the real deal. And in limited playing time Saturday, he looked like it. As the season goes on, I'd expect to see a whole lot more of Rubin. I doubt Scott and Kinlaw will switch to receiver -- especially Scott, whose strength as a runner is too valuable to give up. Kinlaw could probably make the change if coaches asked him, because he's shifty and a good pass-catcher. Instead, I think PSU would be better off sticking with Smith and Rubin and, of course, Michael Robinson when he returns. We might also see a bit more of backups Brendan Perretta and Kinta Palmer -- who is, incidentally, just a two-letter rearrangement from becoming the embodiment of the Cincinnati Bengals' burgeoning quarterback controversy -- as the season progresses. As for the Mt. Lebanon High School comparison. Well, I'm a Lebo grad myself. And back in the day, I was a devoted flag football player. Funny, I never saw Tom Bradley scouting the talent up on the rock pile.
Q: I have a question that I can come up with no logical answer for. I have heard that PSU's training program concentrates on endurance rather than strength. Penn State is part of the Big 10. Big 10 football has always been about big men up front and big agile linebackers to combat against the big agile running backs. Why is Penn State trying to build up muscle endurance when we obviously have been oversized the last couple years? I am tired of seeing the front four get blown off the ball and the offensive linemen two yards in the backfield.
Point in case: You got a guy like Dan Connor (future big-time player and a great athlete), however, definitely not your prototypical Big Ten linebacker presently because of his size. Why is Penn State concentrating on endurance with a young guy like Connor, when what Connor actually needs is some meat to him so he does not get pancaked again by a wide recievers from Akron. I think PSU is used to not starting freshman -- they should change their "no freshmen starting philosophy" and change their weight-training program because it is obvious to me that PSU is a lot smaller than the other Big Ten powerhouses that PSU used to dominate. I'd like to hear your take. Thanks
George Ross of Sharon
HARLAN: George, I asked several Penn State players about it this week, and they all seemed to agree on this: Yes, the PSU strength program is different. But they think it is also very effective.
As you say, Penn State's program promotes endurance training over bulk-building. Several reasons: it's safer. It helps with speed. And, it's more mentally challenging, so it truly gives players both a mental and physical test. Players perform "max reps," meaning they essentially lift until they can do it no longer. But they don't lift massive amounts. Rather, they lift smaller weights for longer period of time. This program, as you seem to believe, has a drawback. Namely, players don't come in as freshman and automatically transform into behemoths. On the offensive and defensive lines, I'd imagine this tends to hurt Penn State. But clearly, the team has decided the aforementioned benefits outweigh the problems. Several NFL teams also employ this "high intensity training" philosophy, so Penn State isn't alone on sticking with it.
Q: Greetings from the Commonwealth of Kentucky. Maybe you can answer this for me. Early on, the Nits were high on the list of several highly-touted recruits, four star or better recruits. Do you think the way this program is at this time, sitting at 2-2 and getting ready to hit a huge stretch of games against heavy hitters, that several have backed off the Nits saying they aren't competitive against the big boys. Is it fair to say the Justin King's of the world are waiting for the Lions to beat a Ohio State or a Purdue before they think about committing? What have you heard with regards to recruiting and players backing off due to lack of success?
John of Lexington, Kent.
HARLAN: Interesting question, John. Before I elaborate on this, let me say definitively that Yes, a team's success plays a crucial role in recruiting. But I think that goes far beyond one game, or, as you put it, one win against a school like Ohio State or Purdue. If, for instance, PSU can knock off the Boilermakers in a few weeks, that victory will provide a nice jump-start for the season, but it will hardly create the lasting excitement and optimism needed to haul in recruits. I think high schoolers look at things with a wider scope. How has the team performed the past few seasons? What is expected of the team down the road? Moreover, there are factors that go far beyond simple wins and losses. Does the player feel comfortable dealing with the team's coaches? Will he have a chance to play immediately? There are so many variables, it's almost dizzying. That said, a school's on-field success is a tremendous factor, as it should be. But opinions about Penn State will change for the better after the Lions demonstrate some consistency. One or two big wins won't make such a difference in the long haul.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.